Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
15 Nov 2016
Single Market and Trade (European Union Referendum)
I welcome this 11th debate on Brexit and the discussion on the implications for our trading relationships. I also welcome the speeches that members from across the chamber have made, although I highlight the irony of Mr Brown lecturing others on trade policy after a week in wh...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
15 Nov 2016
Single Market and Trade (European Union Referendum)
Asia accounts for two thirds of all global economic growth, but less than 2 per cent of Scotland’s exports go to China and just over 1 per cent go to Japan and India. There are significant opportunities there, so it is time for the SNP to move on from its post-Brexit denial, s...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
28 Feb 2017
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I am grateful to the convener of the Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee for setting out the parameters of the debate. I also mention the excellent work of the clerks and the Scottish Parliament information centre in helping to prepare the report. The inquiry’s remit was wi...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
03 Feb 2021
Brexit
I thank the cabinet secretary for an advance copy of his statement. The Scottish Government has received £200 million of Barnett consequentials to prepare Scottish business for Brexit but has refused to detail how that money is being spent. Will the cabinet secretary agree to...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
20 Sep 2016
Economy (EU Referendum)
That is understood. Thank you, Presiding Officer. I welcome Mr Russell to his new role. I also welcome the opportunity to be involved in a debate with Mr Brown, despite the fact that he never really answers the questions that we ask him. As expected, we have had a lively and...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
20 Sep 2016
Economy (EU Referendum)
The divergence of the Scottish economy from that of the UK has been shown to have been caused largely by uncertainty caused by the independence referendum. Business rates in Scotland, with the large business supplement, are twice the rates in England, as opposed to what Mr ...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
20 Sep 2016
Economy (EU Referendum)
We have said that that will be one of the priorities in our discussions with our European counterparts. I welcome the news about the member’s constituents; I thank her for that. Challenges arise from Brexit, but when we talk to businesses they tell us that they face challenge...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Committee
20 Sep 2016
Energy
I will do my best, convener. I refer to my entry in the register of members’ interests in respect of a shareholding in a smart meter company that operates in England, not Scotland. I would like to elaborate on the Brexit implications, because that is front and centre in a lo...
Dean Lockhart Con Committee
01 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
Professor Roy, in your submission, you rightly challenged policy makers to examine the policy opportunities that may open up as a result of Brexit. I have two questions for you. First, am I right in thinking that the report that you prepared for the then European and External ...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
15 Nov 2016
Single Market and Trade (European Union Referendum)
I will later. In contrast, as Jackie Baillie rightly highlighted, the SNP wants to turn its back on the UK single market and is clearly using Brexit as a political football to agitate for a second independence referendum. Another key difference between our approach to Brexit...
Dean Lockhart Con Committee
21 Dec 2016
Draft Budget 2017-18
On your point about Brexit, I take it that Brexit would impact on ESA10 but not on IFRS because, notwithstanding Brexit, IFRS will still apply within the UK to the ONS for accounting purposes.
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
01 Nov 2017
Portfolio Question Time · Economic Growth
Figures that were released last week showed that the United Kingdom economy expanded by 1.5 per cent compared with growth of only 0.5 per cent in Scotland under the Scottish National Party. The SNP is clearly trying to blame Brexit for Scotland’s economic underperformance, bu...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
13 Mar 2018
UK Withdrawal from the European Union (Legal Continuity) (Scotland) Bill
This legislation is complex and far reaching, and a number of genuine concerns have rightly been raised during today’s debate. I will address three of those concerns. First, on the new powers coming to this Parliament after Brexit, it is important to remember the two very dif...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
09 Jan 2019
Life Sciences Sector
I thank the minister for that intervention, but I believe that the original target that was set in 2011 was for £6.2 billion by 2020, and that we are still quite a way behind that. However, I recognise the progress that has been made and the contribution that is made by everyo...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
14 Nov 2019
Scottish Products (United States Tariffs)
I will give way in a second—let me just make a bit of progress. By mentioning Brexit in the context of US tariffs being imposed on Scotch whisky, the minister undermines his own policy on Brexit. The only reason that Scotch whisky and other sectors are being hit by US tariffs...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
23 Dec 2020
Brexit
I thank the cabinet secretary for an advance copy of his statement. The cabinet secretary continues to suggest that the disruption at Dover is a precursor to Brexit. The disruption has nothing to do with Brexit—it is the result of a unilateral decision taken by French author...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
30 Dec 2020
Trade and Co-operation Agreement between the United Kingdom and the European Union
The UK Government has announced a comprehensive scheme to replace that scheme—the Turing scheme, which will be directed at students from disadvantaged backgrounds and will cover a comprehensive range of institutions, with around 35,000 students being able to participate. The ...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
20 Sep 2016
Economy (EU Referendum)
We have made our position quite clear. Interruption. Yes, we have. The real issue—if SNP members will allow me to answer—is the level of access to the single market and terms on which that access is negotiated. That can be a bespoke agreement. The United Kingdom is the second-...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
27 Sep 2016
Rural Economy (European Union Referendum)
Mr Lochhead talked about further powers being transferred to the Scottish Parliament but we are waiting with bated breath to see how the SNP will use its existing powers. Our amendment to the Government motion stresses the importance of securing jobs, incomes, businesses, inv...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
27 Sep 2016
Rural Economy (European Union Referendum)
I suggest that that success is despite and not because of Government policy. Interruption. Let me just conclude. Audit Scotland also highlighted the widespread confusion over the full range of public sector support and funding that is available to businesses in rural Scotla...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Committee
27 Sep 2016
Big Business
I have some follow-up questions for our guests, whom I thank for coming this morning. My first question is for Erik Geddes and concerns what is happening post-Brexit with inward-bound tourism to Scotland. We have heard from different bodies that they have seen an increase par...
Dean Lockhart Con Committee
01 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
Earlier this week, in your blog, you mentioned that we should not let Brexit overcloud everything else and that some of the challenges that the Scottish economy faces have been there for years. I welcome that. Do you agree that, although Brexit is a possible headwind, there ar...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
03 Nov 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Brexit and the Scottish Financial Services Sector
The financial services sector in Scotland is indeed vital to our economy, accounting for approximately 10 per cent of our onshore gross domestic product. That is exactly why I am asking the First Minister to follow the report’s guidance, which concludes that Brexit “does not ...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
15 Nov 2016
Single Market and Trade (European Union Referendum)
I am sorry—Ms Denham has now asked me to give way a couple of times. Let me just make a bit of progress and then I will. The final area in which we take a different approach from the SNP is that we want to highlight the global trade opportunities that will arise from Brexit. ...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
17 Jan 2017
Scotland’s Future Relationship with Europe
I believe that we are now on our 15th debate on Brexit. If the SNP focused on domestic issues such as productivity, it could improve the Scottish economy by £45 billion, according to Scottish Enterprise. That is a multiple of the amount that we are talking about as a result of...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
22 Feb 2017
Industrial Strategy
As are we. The cabinet secretary seems to be blaming Brexit for all the economic woes. Can I remind him that the underperformance of the Scottish economy dates back 10 years to when this Government took control, and that, for every year bar two, the Scottish economy has under...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
28 Feb 2017
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
That would be a matter for negotiation. I am impressed by the minister’s crystal ball in anticipating what the issues might be. However, India is the fastest-growing market for Scotch whisky and that is why a free-trade agreement with India will be very valuable. The report i...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
19 Apr 2017
Scotland’s Economy
We called today’s debate because Scotland’s economy is facing a crisis. As we have heard, the economy contracted by 0.2 per cent in the final quarter of last year, there was zero growth in the 12 months up to that period and all sectors of the active economy are in decline. Al...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
19 Apr 2017
Scotland’s Economy
The Scottish Government’s own chief economist confirmed to the Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee last year that “all levers that impact on the underlying competitiveness of the economy”—Official Report, Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee, 29 November 2016; c 14. now l...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
11 Jan 2018
General Question Time · Scottish Fiscal Commission Forecasts
I remind the cabinet secretary that the Scottish Fiscal Commission is forecasting that the economy will grow by less than 1 per cent for each of the next four years, which is a fraction of the growth that is expected for the rest of the UK. The Fraser of Allander institute has...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
16 Jan 2019
Scotland’s Future Economy
Brexit applies to all of the UK, and the economy of the rest of the UK is growing at a far stronger rate than Scotland’s economy. The cabinet secretary should not try to blame Brexit for the Scottish economy’s underperformance for the past 11 years under the SNP.
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
04 Jun 2019
Realising Scotland’s Potential
The Scottish Conservatives will use our time today to set out a new direction in economic policy and a comprehensive new approach to skills and training. The need for a new economic model has never been greater. Last week, the Scottish Fiscal Commission forecast that Scotland...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
19 Sep 2019
Pre-release Access to Economic Statistics (Committee Bill Proposal)
Part of the debate, which I will come on to, is about aligning the Scottish Government’s approach to pre-release access with the best practice that is followed by the UK Government. That is the whole point of having the debate. The SNP Government says that it has “the most o...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
14 Nov 2019
Scottish Products (United States Tariffs)
Thank you, Presiding Officer. In the motion, the Scottish Government highlights its concerns about a no-deal Brexit. If the SNP is so concerned about a no-deal Brexit, why has it voted four times against a deal, which the SWA has said “stands up well against the priorities o...
Dean Lockhart Con Committee
02 Jun 2020
Covid-19 (Impact on Businesses, Workers and the Economy)
I was not making a political point; it was more of a financial and economic question. You said earlier that some modelling has been done on the potential impact of Brexit in different scenarios. My question was whether any modelling, similar to the modelling that has been done...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
07 Oct 2020
United Kingdom Internal Market Bill
There has been a lot of noise surrounding the UK internal market proposals, but when further restrictions on economic activity have just been announced, surely the priority must be to protect the 550,000 jobs and livelihoods and the 60 per cent of trade that depend on barrier-...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
08 Dec 2020
Brexit Readiness
I thank the cabinet secretary for the advance copy of his statement. Negotiations continue with the EU, and I remain hopeful that a deal can be reached. In the past few hours, it has been announced that agreement has been reached on the protocol governing Ireland and Northern...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
22 Dec 2020
UK Withdrawal from the European Union (Continuity) (Scotland) Bill
The bill is an exceptional piece of legislation. It gives the Scottish ministers exceptional powers to keep pace with EU legislation over a period of a decade. Let us be clear: we are talking about laws made by a supranational body of which we will no longer be a member and la...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
30 Dec 2020
Trade and Co-operation Agreement between the United Kingdom and the European Union
The SNP’s approach to the debate has been to avoid the fundamental question whether we want to leave the European Union with the benefits of a comprehensive deal or to leave without a deal. There is no third option here, at Westminster or in the European Union. It is deal or n...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Committee
30 Dec 2020
European Union (Future Relationship) Bill
Good morning, cabinet secretary, and thank you for joining us. In recent weeks, you have said that any deal would be better than no deal, and the First Minister has said that no deal would be “catastrophic”. However, we have just heard from you that the Scottish National Party...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
27 Sep 2016
Rural Economy (European Union Referendum)
That is a very specific question and I do not have that information to hand, as I am sure that the member would expect. This Government must change its policies on the rural economy. First, the Government’s lack of detail in economic policy and the confusion over the financia...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
26 Oct 2016
Enterprise and Skills Support
The SNP has had its hands on the levers of the economy for almost a decade. It had a review of the enterprise agencies when it first came to power, in 2007, and it has now had another end-to-end review. It has had enough time to establish its economic credentials, and the econ...
5. Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
03 Nov 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Brexit and the Scottish Financial Services Sector
To ask the First Minister what the Scottish Government’s response is to the University of Strathclyde paper, “Brexit and the Scottish Financial Services Sector”. (S5F-00429)
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
15 Nov 2016
Single Market and Trade (European Union Referendum)
Last week, the Irish Government made it clear that it would deal only with the UK Government, as the member state, in respect of Brexit negotiations. Will Keith Brown not listen to the constitutional lesson given by the Irish Government and recognise that the member state is t...
Dean Lockhart Con Committee
22 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I have a few questions. First, on workers’ rights inside or outside the EU, does Stephen Boyd agree with Trades Union Congress general secretary Frances O’Grady, who said that workers in Scotland would be better off in the UK, even outside the EU, than they would be in an inde...
Dean Lockhart Con Committee
22 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I am sorry; the question was whether, in your three-page written submission to the committee, you have given any hard legal advice in relation to the implications of Brexit.
Dean Lockhart Con Committee
06 Dec 2016
Draft Budget Scrutiny 2017-18
Your paper highlights opportunities in tourism, food and drink and other areas. Can you talk us through the steps that HIE is taking to explore the impact of Brexit and the opportunities that might arise from that and to help the companies that you assist to capture those oppo...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
14 Dec 2016
Portfolio Question Time · UK Brexit Strategy (Economic Impact)
What specific actions is the Scottish Government taking to capitalise on the opportunities arising from Brexit? How much money has been provided to Scottish business from the £500 million growth fund that was announced by the Scottish Government over three months ago?
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
14 Dec 2016
Taxation
We called for this debate on taxation because tomorrow’s budget will set the future direction of tax and fiscal policy in Scotland. Let me remind members who today call us devolution deniers that those powers were delivered to this Parliament by a Conservative Government. Unde...
Dean Lockhart Con Committee
20 Dec 2016
Draft Budget Scrutiny 2017-18
Given the need to stimulate the economy and some of the concerns expressed over Brexit, should we be significantly increasing the budget for Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise? For every £1 invested, Scottish Enterprise tells us that £9 is generated for t...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
17 Jan 2017
Scotland’s Future Relationship with Europe
Thank you, Presiding Officer. I start by recognising the contribution to the EU debate that the Scottish Government’s paper, “Scotland’s Place in Europe”, has provided. I also highlight the powerful speech that the Prime Minister delivered this morning, which provides us with ...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
17 Jan 2017
Scotland’s Future Relationship with Europe
There are various ways of achieving it. For example, the UK could accede to arrangements that are already in place. All of that will form part of the negotiation. Unlike some others, I am very confident that we have a strong position. I want to return to the point about the p...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
17 Jan 2017
Scotland’s Future Relationship with Europe
No, thank you—I have taken enough. Reflecting that constitutional background, the head of the Norwegian delegation to EFTA has made it clear that “To enter the EEA agreements, a nation has to be either a member of the EU or EFTA. To become a member of EFTA, Scotland would fi...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
08 Feb 2017
Portfolio Question Time · Export Statistics
In yesterday’s debate, the Scottish Government told us that there will be a hard Brexit, resulting in a customs border between the UK and the EU. If that is true, what side of that customs border does Mr Brown want Scotland to be on? Does he want to be on the UK domestic marke...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
28 Feb 2017
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I will later. The SCDI said that, post-Brexit, there is a good chance to create new free-trade agreements with international markets such as China and India. We would encourage that.
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
28 Feb 2017
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
There are 70,000 young people in Scotland aged between 16 and 24 who are not in employment. Does the member agree with Keith Brown that we should be looking to reskill those people to address any gaps in employment post-Brexit?
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
29 Mar 2017
Portfolio Question Time · Consumer Confidence
The cabinet secretary asked about the union dividend. I point him to the Scottish Government’s own Government expenditure and revenue Scotland numbers that last year showed a £15 billion union dividend. The Fraser of Allander institute highlights that, since the SNP came to p...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
29 Mar 2017
SinoFortone and China Railway No 3 Engineering Group Memorandum of Understanding
Perhaps I will give way later. Chinese companies have experience of investing across the world. In progressing this potential investment in Scotland they would, quite rightly, have expected a degree of competence from the SNP Government. Instead, after a few months of dealing...
Dean Lockhart Con Chamber
19 Apr 2017
Scotland’s Economy
All that we need look at is the large business supplement. I could go on, but I do not have time. In addition to a budget that is bad for the economy, we have seen punitive increases in business rates throughout Scotland. Murdo Fraser highlighted the crippling impact of the r...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con Chamber
14 Jun 2017
Scotland’s Economy (Opportunities for Growth)
The Government has today presented a wide-ranging motion on the economy, which is a subject that it was curiously silent on before the election. Nonetheless, I will start with some areas of consensus. We agree that there are opportunities for growth in Scotland’s economy. We ...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 15 November 2016

15 Nov 2016 · S5 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Single Market and Trade (European Union Referendum)
Lockhart, Dean Con Mid Scotland and Fife Watch on SPTV

I welcome this 11th debate on Brexit and the discussion on the implications for our trading relationships. I also welcome the speeches that members from across the chamber have made, although I highlight the irony of Mr Brown lecturing others on trade policy after a week in which the SNP has been called “the Scottish shambles” by senior Chinese trade officials. It looks as though Mr Brown’s policy of internationalisation is finally paying off—previously, only people in Scotland referred to the SNP as a shambles; now the rest of the world is joining in.

Not only has the SNP upset global investors in Asia; it has suddenly found itself in the position of having a deeply damaged relationship with the newly elected President of the US—a new President that the SNP recently sacked as a trade ambassador and even wanted to ban from entering this country. Following a week in which the SNP has managed to damage our trading relationships with the largest and second largest economies in the world, its lectures on trade policy are wearing a bit thin.

After 11 debates on Brexit, the differences between our approach to Brexit and the approach that is taken by the SNP are clear. First, we respect and will follow the democratic vote that was taken by the UK electorate to leave the EU. Unlike the SNP, we respect the outcome of referendums. As Graham Simpson highlighted, the UK is the member state and the UK voted to leave. It is now time for the SNP to recognise that as well and to work positively with the UK Government to secure the best possible trade deal for Scotland. Last week, the Irish Government made that very point when it said that it would discuss Brexit only with the UK Government and not with the SNP.

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Ken Macintosh) NPA
The next item of business is a debate on motion S5M-02488, in the name of Keith Brown, on the single market and trade and the European Union referendum. I a...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP
This is the fourth in a series of debates that focus on the challenges that Scotland faces as a result of the recent European Union referendum. Following Sco...
Murdo Fraser (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con
This morning, the BBC reported that the Scottish Government’s preferred option is membership of the European Economic Area. In June, the First Minister publi...
Keith Brown SNP
I am able to confirm that, just because the BBC says that that is the Scottish Government’s position, that does not make it so. We have made it clear all alo...
Neil Findlay (Lothian) (Lab) Lab
On export destinations, does Scotland have a greater export field into the EU or to the rest of the UK?
Keith Brown SNP
The UK market for our exports is currently substantially larger than the EU market. However, it is also true to say that many of the goods that we export to ...
Mike Rumbles (North East Scotland) (LD) LD
I seek an explanation of the Government’s motion. It says that if “the UK Government ... will not secure that option” the Parliament “calls for Scotland’s...
Keith Brown SNP
As I said in response to an earlier question, we will put to the UK Government a set of proposals whereby we can maintain and protect that position. We are u...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con
Will the member take an intervention?
Keith Brown SNP
I am sorry, but I must make progress. If I have time towards the end, I will take the intervention. Leaving the single market could mean the introduction of...
Dean Lockhart Con
Last week, the Irish Government made it clear that it would deal only with the UK Government, as the member state, in respect of Brexit negotiations. Will Ke...
Keith Brown SNP
There is an element of self-loathing here, which says that Scotland cannot be active in the international arena, although it is. The Cabinet Secretary for Cu...
Murdo Fraser (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con
It is an interesting tactic from the cabinet secretary to say that he wants the support of members across the chamber when he spent most of his speech attack...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green
Murdo Fraser can be assured that I will never stand up to represent the SNP. Has he not noticed that the debate is about the single market? Does he have a si...
Murdo Fraser Con
I am simply putting into context the debate on the single market. It is just a few days since we heard SNP MP Mhairi Black say that she voted remain only whi...
Murdo Fraser Con
Let me make some progress. Nearly five months on from the Brexit vote, after all the attention that has been paid to the issue by the First Minister, the Sco...
Willie Rennie (North East Fife) (LD) LD
Murdo Fraser talked about giving absolute clarity and set out a range of possible options. How far is he prepared to go? What is he prepared to accept for ou...
Murdo Fraser Con
I will expand on that point in great detail in the next few minutes. The BBC suggested this morning that the Scottish Government’s preferred option is EEA m...
Murdo Fraser Con
I need to make progress. Conservative members understand that we cannot be members of the EU single market unless we are members of the EU, but we can hav...
The Minister for UK Negotiations on Scotland’s Place in Europe (Michael Russell) SNP
I respect Professor Keating’s point of view, but how does that position square with the Prime Minister’s commitment to ensure that there is no hard border be...
Murdo Fraser Con
Mr Russell will be well aware of the different historical arrangements between the north and the south of Ireland. I am simply quoting the opinion of a well-...
Michael Russell SNP
Will the member give way?
Murdo Fraser Con
No—I have taken three or four interventions and I need to make progress. Bodies such as the Scotch Whisky Association are already looking to opportunities t...
Jackie Baillie (Dumbarton) (Lab) Lab
Presiding Officer, whatever way we voted in the referendum—I voted to remain in the European Union—there is little doubt in my mind that we will be leaving. ...
Keith Brown SNP
Will the member take an intervention?
Jackie Baillie Lab
I will in a second. Even I, committed as I am to membership of the EU, would want us to pause and think about the terms of any such entry. For a start, we wo...
Keith Brown SNP
The member says that we have broken the consensus. I remind Jackie Baillie that in September, when Jeremy Corbyn indicated that he did not favour single mark...
Jackie Baillie Lab
I will say how wonderful it is that the cabinet secretary spends so much time looking at our tweets. I will tweet more regularly in order for him to do so. ...
Michael Russell SNP
Will the member take another intervention?
Jackie Baillie Lab
No, I need to make some headway. Our response to Brexit must be clear and straightforward and not a thinly veiled attempt to pursue the only thing that unite...