Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
The Convener Lab Committee
26 Mar 2025
Skills Delivery
Our second item of business is the first of a series of evidence sessions on skills delivery. The purpose of the sessions is to consider how the current skills system is or is not working and to identify the actions that are needed to support businesses and improve the skills ...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
20 Mar 2024
Bankruptcy and Diligence (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
I take on board that amendments 13 and 14 would allow the use of, for example, electronic means as a way of serving arrestment schedules. That is understandable and a better use of technology, but I ask the minister to say more about how he intends to tackle the unintended con...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
25 Aug 2020
Ferguson Marine
I thank the cabinet secretary for advance sight of her statement. The ferry fiasco strikes at the very heart of this Government’s incompetence. Contracts for the two ferries were signed in 2015, and the First Minister told us then that there was a fixed price of £97 million f...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
28 Jun 2023
Royal Mail
Something that does appear to be in your business plan is reported changes to the pipeline for getting mail to delivery offices. Perhaps I can use my own area as an illustration. I represent South Scotland, and I am based in Dumfries and Galloway; currently, the mail comes nor...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
28 Jun 2023
Royal Mail
Let me be clear that I am not disputing the importance of moving from planes to trains. Frankly, I support that, but I want to know what you are doing to mitigate the impact on those areas that are further away from the hubs, because their mail will now arrive at the delivery ...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
29 May 2024
Scottish Government Priorities
So there is not only a productivity gap but a delivery gap from the Government. We have not made a lot of progress. Your comment earlier that we have too many strategies and plans was right. There are around 60 plans and strategies relating to the economy, and quite a few we...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
12 Jan 2017
Inequities in Palliative Care
I refer members to my entry in the register of members’ interests, which states that I was employed by Parkinson’s UK when I was elected to Parliament. That employment has ceased. I thank members from across Parliament for supporting my motion, allowing a timely debate on pal...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
18 Apr 2017
Preventative Health Agenda
It is a privilege to open on behalf of the Labour Party on an issue that I know is very important to all members of the Health and Sport Committee. When Labour created the NHS in 1948, life expectancy in Scotland was 64 years for men and 69 years for women. Today, it is now a...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
31 Oct 2018
Ferry Services
I do not think that that would go down particularly well with the people who would be looking at the prospect of higher fares. The issue is that the RET, which is welcome, has increased demand, so we need to increase capacity to meet demand in order to follow the policy throug...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
15 May 2019
South of Scotland Enterprise Bill: Stage 2
As a starting point, I believe that there is a requirement to have something in the legislation to achieve this aim. The cabinet secretary used the interesting phrase that he hopes that the current “culture of co-operation” in SOSEP will continue. Hope is something that we all...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
12 Jun 2019
Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
Jamie Greene makes a valid point, and it is covered in amendment 303 in his name, which effectively seeks to remove the 20-minute time period from the bill. When the committee discussed the issue, we considered that to be unenforceable, and stakeholders expressed concern that ...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
03 Mar 2021
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
To be clear, Mr Hair, when you gave the update in August, you said: “The delivery of 801 is now planned for the range April 2022 to June 2022 The delivery of 802 is now planned for December 2022 to February 2023. 802 launch will occur in early May 2022.” Are you saying that...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
22 Dec 2022
Climate Change Committee Reports
I thank the cabinet secretary for advance sight of his statement. Listening to him, we could be forgiven for thinking that the Climate Change Committee’s review is not utterly scathing about the Government’s failure. However, it is utterly scathing—the cabinet secretary is cl...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
29 Feb 2024
National Care Service (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
At the height of the Covid pandemic, rarely a day passed without constituents raising with me their heartbreaking experiences of not being able to visit loved ones in care homes, because we did not get our act together on testing; social care packages being removed; people fee...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
13 Nov 2024
Rural Roads
That budget of £30 million extra was supported by every group on the council. However, with regard to Dumfries and Galloway Council, we have had Conservative administrations for an awful lot longer than we have had Labour, or other party, administrations. The consequence of th...
The Convener Lab Committee
26 Mar 2025
Skills Delivery
That is an interesting point. There was a lot of positive feedback on the delivery of apprenticeships, and there was a desire for there to be more of them, given that the level is still below what it was before Covid. One of the key messages that we got from our visits was th...
The Convener Lab Committee
02 Apr 2025
Skills Delivery
Our next item of business is the second of a series of evidence sessions on the skills delivery landscape. The purpose of the sessions is to consider how the current skills system is working and to identify the actions that are needed to support businesses and improve the skil...
The Convener (Colin Smyth) Lab Committee
23 Apr 2025
Skills Delivery
Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the 12th meeting in 2025 of the Economy and Fair Work Committee. Our first item of business is our third evidence session on the skills delivery landscape. The purpose of the sessions is to consider how the current skills system is work...
The Convener Lab Committee
23 Apr 2025
Skills Delivery
I would like to ask a final question. You will be aware that an independent review of the skills delivery landscape in Scotland was recently carried out by James Withers. Do any of our witnesses have any reflections on that review? Is what the review has proposed the right dir...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
29 Apr 2025
Supporting Scottish Industry
There is no doubt that these are turbulent economic times. Global instability, shifting trade policy and the urgent need to respond to the climate crisis are reshaping the way in which industry must operate. The question today is not about recognising challenges, but about ris...
The Convener (Colin Smyth) Lab Committee
30 Apr 2025
Skills Delivery
Good morning, and welcome to the 13th meeting in 2025 of the Economy and Fair Work Committee. Our first item of business is the fourth in our series of evidence sessions on Scotland’s skills delivery and development landscape. The purpose of these sessions is to consider how...
The Convener (Colin Smyth) Lab Committee
07 May 2025
Skills Delivery
Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the 14th meeting in 2025 of the Economy and Fair Work Committee. The first item of business is an evidence session on the skills delivery landscape. The purpose of these sessions is to consider how the current skills system is working, ...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
26 Oct 2016
Enterprise and Skills Support
I refer members to my entry in the register of members’ interests and to the fact that I am a councillor in Dumfries and Galloway, where I chair the economy committee. I am also the chair of the south of Scotland alliance. As the cabinet secretary said in his opening speech, ...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
18 Jan 2017
Health
I declare an interest as a councillor in Dumfries and Galloway. When Labour created the NHS in 1948, life expectancy in Scotland was 64 years for men and 69 for women. Today, it is about 77 for men and 81 for women. That shows the success of Britain’s greatest achievement: ou...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
08 Mar 2017
Marie Curie Great Daffodil Appeal
I refer members to the register of members’ interests, which states that I was employed by Parkinson’s UK when I was elected to Parliament, although that employment has ceased. I echo the comments of other members in thanking Linda Fabiani, who is, I know, a long-standing sup...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
14 Sep 2017
Borders Talking Newspapers
I echo the comments of Christine Grahame and congratulate Rachael Hamilton on lodging her motion and providing members with the opportunity to wish Borders Talking Newspapers a very happy 25th birthday. I add to the welcome to the Scottish Parliament that has been given to the...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
14 Nov 2017
World Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Day
I echo other members’ thanks to Emma Harper for lodging her motion and providing members with the opportunity to raise awareness of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease ahead of COPD day tomorrow. I also thank Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland, the British Lung Foundation and...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
24 Jan 2018
Railway Policing
When the Railway Policing (Scotland) Bill came before Parliament, Labour shared the universal concerns about it that were raised by stakeholders including the trade unions—the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers; the Associated Society of Locomotive Engineer...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
31 Jan 2018
Bus Services
I thank Ross Greer for lodging his motion, which is on an issue that has greatly concerned members in Glasgow and West Scotland, including my colleague Johann Lamont and others. They have campaigned vociferously on behalf of their constituents against First Bus’s unacceptable ...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
27 Feb 2018
Topical Question Time · Railways (Edinburgh to Glasgow Peak Services)
The recent BBC documentary “Mind the Gap” revealed instances of passengers collapsing on increasingly overcrowded trains. Unions such as the Transport Salaried Staffs’ Association are concerned over staffing cuts by ScotRail, which have left stations without a health and safet...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
30 May 2018
Islands (Scotland) Bill
Yes, I agree—although the issue is slightly outwith the remit of the bill. The bill is a step forward. It could have been more radical and given islands more powers. However, there is much in it that we support. For example, the national islands plan has the potential to be t...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
31 Oct 2018
Ferry Services
Overall, the Government does not seem to recognise that ferries—as all public transport does—provide a vital public service. That lack of recognition is summed up by its ambivalence towards public ownership, as seen in its failure to take the northern isles contract in-house p...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
06 Nov 2018
Maybole Bypass
There has been significant investment, going back many years, from Glasgow right down to Kilmarnock, where Willie Coffey lives. There has been no investment in Dumfries and Galloway—not a single project from the SNP Government to upgrade major roads in the area. That is shamef...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
22 Jan 2019
City Deals and Regional Economic Partnerships
At a time of relentless centralisation in much of Government policy, a focus on city and regional growth deals and regional economic partnerships is welcome. Labour believes that if the right investment choices are made in growth deals, they can be a catalyst for economic grow...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
04 Apr 2019
Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I ask members to imagine a transport system in which our transport agencies have the powers properly to regulate public transport in their areas and to deliver a genuinely integrated system; in which local communities can establish municipal bus companies without restrictions,...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
04 Apr 2019
Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Transport impacts on many aspects of our constituents’ lives, from their health to the environment to poverty. It accounts for more than a third of all greenhouse gas emissions, with levels currently the same as they were in 1990. It is a key cause of air pollution, which last...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
16 May 2019
Brexit (Impact on Food and Drink)
I was under the impression that we are not allowed to advocate how people should vote, but if it is part of the debate today, I ask people to vote Labour next Thursday. As we have heard, the food and drink sector is vital to our economy and to the people of Scotland. It accou...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
05 Jun 2019
South of Scotland Enterprise Bill: Stage 3
Amendment 18 requires the agency’s annual report to include an assessment of progress against the agency’s aims, as set out in the bill, and its action plan. As it stands, the bill does not require the annual report to include performance monitoring; it requires the agency to ...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
12 Jun 2019
Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
Amendment 96 serves the same purpose as my amendments that have already been debated in previous groups but with regard to the BSIP. It would require consultation with those who live in poverty and those with relevant protected characteristics as part of the delivery of the fr...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
18 Jun 2019
Topical Question Time · Caledonian Sleeper Service
The sleeper service has been plagued by the late delivery of rolling stock. Almost a third of new services have been late or cancelled and workers are on the verge of strike action because of rising stress levels. Does the cabinet secretary accept that it is another example of...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
09 Oct 2019
Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. During the debate on group 16, Mike Rumbles got to his feet and in effect accused me of misleading Parliament over a recommendation that was made by the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee at stage 1 of the bill. That recommendation...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Committee
30 Oct 2019
Digital Connectivity
When R100 was first announced, the Government said that the contracts would be awarded by the end of 2018. That was delayed to early 2019 and then delayed further to September 2019. Today, we are told that it is being delayed further still, to the end of 2019. Given the fact t...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
06 Nov 2019
Ferries
We cannot overstate the importance of Scotland’s ferry network to our island communities. Last year, the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee carried out budget scrutiny of investment to support the Clyde and Hebrides ferry services. In its evidence to the committee, Weste...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
06 Nov 2019
Ferries
That is 30 seconds gone already. Laughter. The debate has, at least in some contributions, recognised the frustrations of our island communities about the impact of the lack of capacity and resilience in Scotland’s ageing ferry fleet. It has highlighted the desperate need fo...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
05 Feb 2020
Transport Strategy
I thank the cabinet secretary for advance notice of his statement. Few will have any dispute with a vision of a more sustainable and inclusive transport system, or with the four priorities set out in the strategy, which Labour very much welcomes. The problem is with delivery ...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
04 Mar 2020
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
What are the barriers that have prevented a standardised approach from being taken previously? Why are we talking about it now? You have indicated that you guys are not round the table when it comes to those matters—your job is purely to deliver a service during the short-term...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
19 May 2020
Care Homes
Does the cabinet secretary accept that simply adding new categories to the list of those who can be tested is, in itself, not enough? We know from our communities that many people who are already eligible—such as carers and residents in homes with an outbreak, and carers who a...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
17 Jun 2020
Animals and Wildlife (Penalties, Protections and Powers) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
The lack of information sharing around animal welfare and wildlife offences is a significant issue, and the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee, along with many stakeholders over a long period of time, have agreed that it needs to be addressed. I am mindfu...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
05 May 2020
Agriculture (Retained EU Law and Data) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
The bill is important and I recognise the need for it to be passed swiftly in order to provide certainty on future payments for farmers and crofters. I am happy to support the bill at stage 1. However, our constituents may be asking why, in the current crisis, the Government h...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
26 Aug 2020
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
When did ministers first become aware of problems during the early stages of the contract’s delivery? When were ministers given specific evidence that there would be delays and potential increased costs? Which ministers were made aware of the delays and increased costs? What s...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
26 Aug 2020
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
I will stick with the issue of the loans. Cabinet secretary, you accepted that CMAL was unaware that the loans were being provided to FMEL. CMAL told the committee that, despite the work that was done by Luke van Beek, the loan instalments were released to FMEL even though del...
6. Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
03 Sep 2020
Portfolio Question Time · Covid-19 (Local Government Services)
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the impact of the cost of the Covid-19 response and recovery measures for local government on the delivery of other council services. (S5O-04538)
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
21 Jan 2021
Portfolio Question Time · Covid-19 (Support for Food and Drink Businesses)
Last year, ahead of stage 3 of the Agriculture (Retained EU Law and Data) (Scotland) Bill, the cabinet secretary announced that he was “beginning a process of developing a non-statutory statement of policy on food”.—Written Answers, 17 August 2020; S5W-31244. His argument wa...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Committee
27 Jan 2021
Climate Change Plan
I am pleased that Jillian Anable and Derek Halden bravely tried to move the discussion on to prevention rather than cure, and reducing the need to travel, rather than just talking about the punishments or carrots that we can use on those who are forced to travel into congested...
Colin Smyth Lab Chamber
02 Feb 2021
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
Mr McMillan ignored that point in his speech. It is absolutely vital that we do not look only at the structures for how contracts are procured. Ferry building should be properly aligned with wider policy, including our ambitious carbon reduction targets. The Scottish Governme...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
03 Mar 2021
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
You have just mentioned vessels 801 and 802. On 21 August last year, the committee received an update on the construction of the two ferries. How much further has the timescale slipped since that update last year? Can any slippage be recovered, or will the estimated delivery d...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
10 Nov 2021
National Planning Framework
NPF3 had a commitment to the town centre first principle, but I am sure that the minister will accept that the decline of our high streets has continued. In fact, it has, I am sad to say, accelerated in recent years. Does he accept that, whatever commitments are made in NPF4 o...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber
10 Mar 2022
Climate Emergency
It is more than 100 days since Scotland welcomed the world to COP26. The generation-defining decisions that were made there barely keep alive the goal of limiting global warming to 1.5°C that was agreed in Paris a decade ago. The task for the Glasgow summit was to set out c...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
16 Mar 2022
National Strategy for Economic Transformation
We should go much further with conditionality in areas such as trade union access. You mentioned one big issue that trade unions are deeply concerned about, which is jobs in the supply chain. You highlighted offshore wind. The former First Minister, Alex Salmond, said that Sc...
Colin Smyth Lab Committee
16 Mar 2022
National Strategy for Economic Transformation
It would certainly take a leap to go from 20,500 to 130,000 jobs just by changing the definition. I would be keen to hear what the Government’s target actually is, however you define it. I will briefly raise a final issue. I have previously raised the issue of the cluttered l...
← Back to list
Committee

Economy and Fair Work Committee 26 March 2025

26 Mar 2025 · S6 · Economy and Fair Work Committee
Item of business
Skills Delivery

Our second item of business is the first of a series of evidence sessions on skills delivery. The purpose of the sessions is to consider how the current skills system is or is not working and to identify the actions that are needed to support businesses and improve the skills supply chain, including green skills.

On behalf of the committee, a number of members recently visited Lothian Buses and Ashleigh Building in order to meet apprentices and staff. Many members will also have carried out individual constituency visits during apprenticeship week—in my case, I visited Dumfries and Galloway College. The visits gave us invaluable insight into the experience of skills delivery and a chance to meet some inspiring apprentices. I give a big thank you to Ashleigh Building, Lothian Buses and all the colleges and employers for welcoming us on our visits, and I thank Skills Development Scotland for organising visits during apprenticeship awareness week.

We have two evidence sessions this morning. First, I welcome James Withers, the author of the independent review of the skills delivery landscape, which was published in June 2023.

Time is tight today, so I ask members to keep their questions as concise as possible—I will fail miserably in that regard—and I ask the same of our witnesses with their answers.

I will kick off the questions. I mentioned apprentices in my opening comments. Before you reviewed the skills delivery landscape, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development carried out an extensive review of apprenticeships in Scotland. How did that review influence your thinking and the work that you carried out on apprenticeships?

In the same item of business

The Convener Lab
Our second item of business is the first of a series of evidence sessions on skills delivery. The purpose of the sessions is to consider how the current skil...
James Withers (JR Withers Advisory Ltd)
Good morning, everyone. Thank you for having me along today. I spent nine months inside the skills system, and it struck me that a lot of reviews were takin...
The Convener Lab
You mentioned economies that have a much higher level of apprenticeships. As well as Switzerland and Germany, there are the Scandinavian countries and others...
James Withers
Yes. I felt that Scotland should aspire to having the culture that exists in those countries. I spent time with pupils in the senior phase of high school acr...
The Convener Lab
That is an interesting point. There was a lot of positive feedback on the delivery of apprenticeships, and there was a desire for there to be more of them, g...
James Withers
My view is that SAAB has done a very good job in threading the views of employers into the apprenticeship system, but nobody I met in any sector viewed the a...
The Convener Lab
That sounds very much like an industry-led approach, but you do not seem to be proposing industry-led expansion across other areas. You seem to be talking ab...
James Withers
The principle behind regional employers boards and a national employers board is about doing just that—stitching business views into the heart of the system ...
The Convener Lab
I will bring in Murdo Fraser to follow up on some of the points on apprenticeships.
Murdo Fraser (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con
Good morning, James. It is nice to see you again. One thing that has struck me, both from the visits that the committee has made and from our wider engageme...
James Withers
I agree with that analysis, and I am happy to touch on funding. I think that we should be spending more on apprenticeships. My point, more broadly, was that ...
Murdo Fraser Con
Thank you. That is helpful. The Government is taking forward a bill that is about shifting funding to the Scottish Funding Council, which will then be respo...
James Withers
It is a risk. How do you mitigate that risk? You build into the culture of the SFC and the provisions in the bill—it is already there—the importance of appre...
Murdo Fraser Con
Thank you. I have one more question, which is on the apprenticeship levy. The issue keeps being raised with us by employers who are frustrated that they put ...
James Withers
To be honest, on transparency, the only way is up. The way that the apprenticeship levy has worked in Scotland has damaged faith and trust in the system amon...
Murdo Fraser Con
Okay. Thanks.
Lorna Slater (Lothian) (Green) Green
I have two slightly smaller questions—Murdo Fraser has been asking bigger questions. I was an electromechanical engineer in my former life, and one of my ab...
James Withers
As I said, Lorna, I was not supposed to spend much time in schools, but I got drawn in. I had to really, and I maybe abused my remit slightly by spending a l...
Lorna Slater Green
Did you look at careers advice or anything like that? One of the challenges, anecdotally, is that everybody says that careers advice is terrible. When you sp...
James Withers
Yes, I would. That bias is ingrained in parents, too. That presents a challenging issue, because kids are then fighting the system in school and also, probab...
Lorna Slater Green
My final question goes back to apprenticeships. How do we achieve parity of esteem between apprenticeships and the highers and university route? One suggesti...
James Withers
Foundation apprenticeships are already higher equivalent. However, if you asked 100 young people and 100 parents whether they thought that they are higher eq...
Lorna Slater Green
Thank you very much.
The Convener Lab
My apologies to Daniel Johnson, whom I was going to bring in for a brief supplementary question after Murdo Fraser. We may jump back.
Daniel Johnson (Edinburgh Southern) (Lab) Lab
I am amused by that last comment, given some of our discussions about whether we should call them SCQF qualifications or highers. It is a good point. I want...
James Withers
That is where political and ministerial leadership comes in. That leadership has been absent in the skills system, and I was very clear in my review that the...
Daniel Johnson Lab
Thank you.
Michelle Thomson (Falkirk East) (SNP) SNP
Good morning. Thanks for joining us. My question arguably follows on from Daniel Johnson’s question. Recommendation 1 in your report is that there should be...
James Withers
It is about taking baby steps. I remain concerned about the lack of courage towards wider education reform, which really matters in schools. I spent time wit...
Michelle Thomson SNP
Classic. Absolutely. Thank you very much for that.