Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Ash Regan Alba Chamber
18 Sep 2024
Creating a Modern, Diverse and Dynamic Scotland
In 2014, the royal family—including Will, Kate, Harry and Meghan—were in the news, the Commonwealth games were being held in Glasgow and the world was reporting on a possible Trump presidency. I am almost scared to turn around in case Bill Murray is in the gallery, rebooting “...
Ash Denham SNP Committee
23 Jan 2018
Preventative Agenda (Sexual Health, Blood-borne Viruses and HIV)
My question follows on from Ivan McKee’s question about cost benefit analysis. I will pull out a couple of comments from the written submissions that we received. John Dillon, you said in your submission that there is “limited health economic input available” and that “ th...
Ash Regan SNP Chamber
01 Jun 2022
Portfolio Question Time · Women’s Safety (Abortion Clinics)
I thank the member for that question. She raises some important points, and I am very sympathetic to the intention behind the question. On the recent incidents at the Sandyford clinic, I can confirm that Police Scotland was called on both occasions on which protests took plac...
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Committee
28 Mar 2017
Gender Pay Gap
I was going to ask you about innovative practices, but that subject was well covered in your answers to Gillian Martin’s question, so I will put another question to you. I do not know whether you saw it, but the insurance company Aviva recently wrote to all its supplier compan...
Ash Denham SNP Committee
25 Apr 2017
Gender Pay Gap
Following on from Richard Leonard’s question, the next question is whether you think that there is enough funding and support through the enterprise network in Scotland for women who own businesses, either starting up or progressing.
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Chamber
07 Jun 2017
First Minister’s Question Time · Cabinet (Meetings)
How has the First Minister’s Government protected Scotland’s budget in the face of Tory cuts? Interruption. It is a good question.
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Committee
27 Feb 2018
NHS Governance (Corporate)
I think that my question has been covered by the answer to Alison Johnson’s question.
Ash Denham SNP Committee
06 Nov 2018
Damages (Investment Returns and Periodical Payments) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
As you will have seen, the bill sets out a portfolio with asset classes and percentage holdings that are designed to meet the needs and characteristics of the hypothetical investor. Because they are laid out in the legislation, I will not go over them now. The hypothetical in...
Ash Denham SNP Committee
06 Nov 2018
Damages (Investment Returns and Periodical Payments) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
That is a good question. The answer is no, we do not think that it is a departure. By now, it will be clear to the committee that, as I have said, this area is not an exact science. For a range of reasons, there will always be to some degree the probability of undercompensatio...
Ash Denham SNP Committee
19 Feb 2019
Subordinate Legislation
To answer the first part of your question, our analysis, which is well backed up by the evidence, suggests that the biggest risk on our roads is people who are driving under the influence of alcohol. We prioritised lowering the drink-drive limit because we thought that that wa...
The Minister for Community Safety (Ash Denham) SNP Chamber
21 Feb 2019
General Question Time · Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court (Modernisation)
This question relates to operational matters that are the responsibility of the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service. The service is currently creating a two-court criminal annexe within Kirkcaldy police station to hear sheriff and jury cases and custody hearings, which is du...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
26 Feb 2019
Topical Question Time · Fatal Accident Inquiries (Legal Aid)
I can answer the member’s question. The average length of time to complete an inquiry has been gradually decreasing, which is obviously going in the direction that we would like. We are pleased that the figure is decreasing, although we would like further progress to be made. ...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
13 Mar 2019
Portfolio Question Time · Scottish Legal Aid Board (Project Funding)
The tackling child poverty delivery plan, which was published in March 2018, sets out action across Government to contribute towards reductions in the child poverty level. The plan, which covers the period 2018 to 2022, is backed by a multimillion pound package of investment, ...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
07 May 2019
Topical Question Time · Police Scotland (Deployment of Firearms Officers)
Liam Kerr will not be surprised to hear that I do not agree with that analysis. The change to the deployment model was a measured approach in order to use capacity appropriately. As I have already said, it is used in only a small number of cases in which speed of response is i...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
14 May 2019
Topical Question Time · Prison Officers (Industrial Action)
The first thing to be absolutely clear about is that the Prison Officers Association Scotland has put in a request for a negotiation around pay, and it has been quite clear that this is not to do with conditions and other factors: it is to do with pay. That is the first thing ...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2019
Topical Question Time · Prisoner Transport (Family Vehicles)
I thank the member for that question. I take on board the concerns that he has raised. The escorting contract has, of course, freed up front-line staff in both the Scottish Prison Service and Police Scotland and allowed them to undertake their core duties. Prior to the incepti...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2019
Topical Question Time · Prisoner Transport (Family Vehicles)
The member has raised an important point. I believe that contractors should be held accountable for their level of service. I do not have any further information on the point that the member has raised, so I undertake to write to him with a fuller answer to his question.
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
13 Nov 2019
Portfolio Question Time · Fireworks Review Group (Veterans)
Yes. I thank Bill Bowman for raising that issue. That theme certainly came through in the consultation. I am aware that there are a number of groups, including veterans, people with underlying mental health concerns and people who have pets, as well as pets themselves, that su...
Ash Denham SNP Committee
25 Feb 2020
Children (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Okay—I see what you are saying. I did not quite understand where you were going with your question. There is a question about whether it is better to put that in the bill, as you have suggested, or whether a more general, signposting approach might be a better option. There i...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
27 Feb 2020
General Question Time · Antisocial Behaviour (Off-road Vehicles)
I would be happy to meet the member to discuss some elements of her question, although parts of it may have strayed into a colleague’s portfolio. The Scottish Government fully supports the police, our local authorities and court services to take appropriate and proportionate a...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
03 Nov 2020
Fireworks
That is an important question, as we know that fireworks can cause a lot of distress to animals. The ultimate responsibility for the welfare of an animal rests with the animal’s keeper, but many will take steps to protect their animals from that distress. Recommendations that ...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
05 Nov 2020
Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I thank members for their contribution to this afternoon’s helpful debate. I am pleased that there is support across the chamber for the general principles of the bill. The Scottish Law Commission’s reform project was the first significant look at defamation law here in Scotl...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
16 Dec 2020
Portfolio Question Time · Antisocial Behaviour
I agree with much of the gist of the member’s question. There has been quite a degree of success in Fife with the delivery of the Levenmouth together programme. I have written to the member on that, and my officials have shared examples of the good practice in tackling the ill...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
22 Jun 2021
Topical Question Time · Female Prisoners (Remand)
There were a number of points in that question. I am not sure that I will be able to cover them all in my reply, but I will follow up with the member if I miss any out. We absolutely take the issue seriously, but I remind the member that decisions on bail are made by the inde...
Ash Regan SNP Chamber
26 Jan 2022
Portfolio Question Time · Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Repairs Backlog)
I thank the member for raising that important point. I stress that the draft budget, as with budgets in previous years, includes an uplift for the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service. In the draft budget, there is £9.5 million of additional spending available to the service. That...
Ash Regan SNP Chamber
26 Jan 2022
Portfolio Question Time · Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Repairs Backlog)
I did answer the question, because I said that the fire service is perfectly aware that maintenance needs to be carried out on a number of fire stations. Much of the capital backlog, which that is part of, was inherited from local authorities when the national service was form...
Ash Regan SNP Chamber
08 Feb 2022
Justice Services
I am probably about to answer the question that the member will ask. We have reforms planned in a number of areas, including the management of sexual offences. Lady Dorrian’s review suggests a number of proposals for modernisation, with which we are moving forward. If that do...
Ash Regan SNP Committee
30 Mar 2022
Fireworks and Pyrotechnic Articles (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I feel that we have already answered that question; it is very similar to the question that Russell Findlay asked about enforcement and statistics. In fact, Elinor Findlay has already read out those statistics, and we have said—
Ash Regan SNP Committee
30 Mar 2022
Fireworks and Pyrotechnic Articles (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Another piece of evidence is national health service injury data, which includes firework-related diagnosis. I will say—if I do not, my officials will get very cross with me—that we have to be a bit cautious about that data but, nonetheless, broadly, it tells us that such inju...
Ash Regan SNP Committee
30 Mar 2022
Fireworks and Pyrotechnic Articles (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
In answer to your first question, we have seen the industry’s 10-point plan. Some of it does not relate specifically to the Scottish Government—I think that it contains action points for the United Kingdom Government—but there are some interesting things in there. I met repre...
Ash Regan SNP Chamber
20 Apr 2022
Portfolio Question Time · Water Safety Action Plan
The member raises a pertinent question given the tragedies that have occurred in that national park in recent years. The national park authority has developed a water safety policy and an accompanying risk assessment procedure, which formalises its approach on its owned and ma...
Ash Regan SNP Chamber
26 Apr 2022
Topical Question Time · Solicitors (Domestic Abuse Cases)
The only person in this chamber who is in a parallel reality at the moment is the member. He was not listening to my extensive answers detailing the very regular consultation that the Government has with representatives of the legal profession. Instead of repeating my earlier ...
Ash Regan SNP Chamber
17 May 2022
Topical Question Time · Police Scotland (Compensation Payments)
I thank Daniel Johnson for raising his personal experience with Police Scotland in reporting an incident such as this. I would expect the chief constable to reflect carefully on what Daniel Johnson has said in the chamber today. On the substance of the question, in the days a...
Ash Regan SNP Chamber
25 Oct 2022
Topical Question Time · Legal Aid Fees
No—I do not accept that at all. I have set out some of the actions that this Government has taken, including the 3 per cent overall rise in fees in 2019, which was followed by the 5 per cent overall rise in fees in 2021, another overall rise in fees in 2022 and—as I set out i...
Ash Regan (Edinburgh Eastern) (Alba) Alba Chamber
14 Jan 2025
Topical Question Time · Safer Drug Consumption Facility (Assessment)
I know that the minister has already been asked this question, but he did not put any specifics on the record. Specifically, what metrics will be used to assess the success of the Thistle? In addition, what lessons will the Government draw from global examples such as analysis...
Ash Regan Alba Chamber
28 Jan 2025
Urgent Question · Child Safeguarding in Scotland
Yet again, catastrophic system failures have been brought to light by brave survivors and interveners. That shows that there is a problem in the system. A child’s background, behaviour and perceived social status must never impact on how they are protected in a civilised socie...
Ash Regan (Edinburgh Eastern) (Alba) Alba Chamber
06 Mar 2025
First Minister’s Question Time · International Women’s Day
Despite the First Minister’s warm words during the answer to the question, I feel that he is woefully out of touch on the situation of women’s rights across Scotland. Therefore, it is utterly impossible to accelerate action towards gender equality when women’s human rights are...
Ash Regan (Edinburgh Eastern) (Alba) Alba Committee
08 Oct 2025
Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Thank you, convener, and good morning to the witnesses. Thank you for attending. It often seems that a voice is missing from the debate, and for me, that voice is that of the buyers. We know that sex buyers are around 99 per cent male, so it is the voices of the men who pay t...
Ash Regan Ind Chamber
28 Oct 2025
Urgent Question · Exploitation Networks (Children and Vulnerable Adults)
The Dundee grooming gang case proves that Scotland is not immune to organised grooming gang sexual exploitation, but I agree that Police Scotland deserves real credit for bringing the perpetrators in Dundee, and in Glasgow’s beastie house case, to justice. To truly protect the...
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
15 Jun 2016
Portfolio Question Time · Attainment Gap (Role of Breakfast Clubs)
Does the minister agree that there are a range of ways in which schools can use programmes beyond the classroom—breakfast clubs, after-school clubs and other support—that will not only provide real help to children and make it easier for parents to work but, crucially, help to...
13. Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Chamber
15 Jun 2016
Portfolio Question Time · Attainment Gap (Role of Breakfast Clubs)
To ask the Scottish Government what role breakfast clubs play in closing the attainment gap, and what support it provides to them. (S5O-00043)
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
15 Jun 2016
Economy
In talking about the wider context, we need to talk about what Westminster is doing, as it clearly has more levers than the Scottish Government. The Labour Party will recall that it accepted the £30 billion of cuts that the Tories proposed. George Osborne said that those cuts...
Ash Denham SNP Committee
28 Jul 2016
Implications of Brexit
I want to turn to aviation, so my question is for Mr Dewar. Changes to how aviation operates could have a big impact on Scotland. They could affect tourism and the economy—we know that transport and air routes are quite important for foreign direct investment and so on. The I...
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Chamber
14 Sep 2016
Portfolio Question Time · Urban Broadband
Can the cabinet secretary advise how much the Scottish Government has already invested in fibre broadband and how many premises in Scotland now have access to it?
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Chamber
02 Nov 2016
Portfolio Question Time · Small Businesses (Taxation Policy and Insolvency)
What steps are being taken to give Scottish businesses a competitive advantage over their counterparts in other parts of the UK?
Ash Denham SNP Committee
01 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
My question may have been partially covered, but I want to highlight a couple of points. The Fraser of Allander institute has focused on short-term considerations, and we will all no doubt have seen newspaper headlines in the past few weeks crowing about the fact that the pred...
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Committee
02 Nov 2016
Public Finances and Economic Performance
I suppose that my question is more on the idea of reality versus perception in relation to the short-term impacts that we have seen following the announcement of Brexit. I am sure that everyone has seen the recent headlines crowing that the predictions of economic meltdown ha...
Ash Denham SNP Committee
08 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
Yes—my question is specifically for the universities sector. I visited the University of Edinburgh last week and I know that it is very concerned about a number of issues. My colleague Gillian Martin wants to ask about funding, so I will confine myself to free movement and sta...
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Chamber
16 Nov 2016
Portfolio Question Time · European Union Referendum
The minister will be aware of the leaked memorandum that suggests that there is no UK Government plan for Brexit and that it will be another six months before the UK Government agrees its priorities, in stark contrast to the Scottish Government’s approach. Will the minister ou...
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Committee
22 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
That is my question. Laughter.
Ash Denham SNP Committee
22 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I will not ask the same question again, but it would be good if you could paint a picture for us. If you were not able to recruit from other EU countries, how would that affect your business?
Ash Denham SNP Committee
22 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
Unfortunately, my question is for the same witness. The submission from Thompsons explained the viewpoint that if the powers return to the UK Government, there may be a deterioration in some of the employment laws, equality laws and so on. It cited some evidence, and personall...
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Committee
14 Dec 2016
Draft Budget 2017-18
Good morning. My question covers some of the same ground as Murdo Fraser covered. I would like us to talk a little bit more about the failure to identify some Scottish taxpayers, because that is clearly the most important part of the process. You have to know who Scottish taxp...
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Committee
20 Dec 2016
Draft Budget Scrutiny 2017-18
I want to take the opportunity to raise with you the quality of Scottish export statistics, which has come up a number of times during our recent inquiry. Export Statistics Scotland says that its “estimates only capture the first point of export.” In my view, that could lead...
Ash Denham SNP Committee
20 Dec 2016
Draft Budget Scrutiny 2017-18
Okay. I will move on to my other question. The submission that we received from FSB Scotland, which you might have seen, highlights “the importance of getting the maximum economic impact from public spending”. Its point is that if we are about to embark on a large amount of ...
Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Committee
11 Jan 2017
Draft Budget 2017-18
You have partly answered my question, which is about the assumptions around productivity growth. You say in your report that that is the most important uncertainty. I saw a tweet by Danny Blanchflower in which he said that the OBR really must explain its assumptions around why...
Ash Denham SNP Committee
16 Jan 2017
Draft Budget 2017-18
The next question is from Bernard Harkins in Musselburgh, who is a PCS trade union representative and a community councillor. He asks: “Some PCS members need to use food banks. How will you use your new tax powers to tackle poverty?”
1. Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Chamber
19 Jan 2017
General Question Time · Green Investment Bank
To ask the Scottish Government what discussions it has had with the United Kingdom Government regarding reports of potential asset stripping when the Edinburgh-based Green Investment Bank is transferred to the private sector. (S5O-00569)
Ash Denham SNP Chamber
19 Jan 2017
General Question Time · Green Investment Bank
I welcome the Scottish Government’s action in relaying those concerns, which I am sure are shared by many members on all sides of the chamber. It is disappointing that the Tory Government has not continued to help the Green Investment Bank to flourish. As an Edinburgh MSP, ho...
2. Ash Denham (Edinburgh Eastern) (SNP) SNP Chamber
25 Jan 2017
Portfolio Question Time · Health Inequalities (Pregnancy and Postnatal Period)
To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to reduce health inequalities during pregnancy and in the postnatal period. (S5O-00580)
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 18 September 2024

18 Sep 2024 · S6 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Creating a Modern, Diverse and Dynamic Scotland
Regan, Ash Alba Edinburgh Eastern Watch on SPTV

In 2014, the royal family—including Will, Kate, Harry and Meghan—were in the news, the Commonwealth games were being held in Glasgow and the world was reporting on a possible Trump presidency. I am almost scared to turn around in case Bill Murray is in the gallery, rebooting “Groundhog Day”, because, 10 years later, a new generation of the royal family is in the news, the Commonwealth games are returning to Glasgow and an older, if not wiser, Donald Trump is campaigning to be the US President again. The only thing not to be repeated is a democratic event that would allow Scots to choose independence.

It is time to break out of that repeating “Groundhog Day” cycle of ask-the-British-Government-and-get-refused, and to put the question back to the people of Scotland by using what has been staring us in the face for 10 years—the ballot box. Let us hold the constitutional convention, assemble the independence commission and put democracy back in top gear in 2026 by putting the question of independence to the people on the ballot. Self-determination is the path to the beginning of our empowered future. A simple majority of pro-independence votes on the Scottish parliamentary list vote will trigger the clear instruction from the people that is needed to demonstrate that democratic authority for Scottish independence.

I cannot say that this has been a very enlightening debate, but at least we found out that Alex Cole-Hamilton is in a buoyant mood after a recent visit to Brighton. However, I caution him that using words such as “fanatic” and “fanaticism” lets him down. There is nothing strange or unusual about believing strongly in the human right to self-determination.

If I understood Richard Leonard correctly, he said that using the 2026 list vote would be an insult to the people of Scotland. I do not agree with that, and the people of Scotland do not agree with that. Just last week, a poll showed that 57 per cent of the Scottish public think that we should have another referendum. The Labour Party and the Conservative Party must say why they are willing to prevent Scots from having their say.

That brings me on to the Greens. I do not say this often, but Ross Greer hit the nail on the head when he spoke of denying Scots’ democratic wishes. That is where we have a deep issue, because not one of the Labour, Tory or Liberal Democrat speakers addressed themselves to this fundamental question: if SNP mandate after SNP mandate did not secure a second referendum, how can Scotland express its choice? What is the democratic route that is open to Scotland? I am still waiting to hear it. Perhaps I will hear an answer to that question in the summing up from the unionist parties.

It is time to say goodbye to this non-functional union and embrace the untapped potential of an independent Scotland. We know that the union’s greatest fear is us firing on all cylinders, with the Scottish Parliament’s full powers and the backing of the Scottish people.

Column inches have been padded out in recent years by how vicious, detailed and incisive our fury with each other has been. I hope that they have seen nothing like what is about to be unleashed by the union, if we can all work together. We are a resource-rich nation and our people deserve so much better than surviving through this UK managed decline. We have in abundance the resources and the talent that we need to thrive under self-determination. No individual can change Scotland; only a collective effort will deliver the Scotland for all of us that we want to see. I urge that we all set aside our differences and work together towards a common goal—our nation’s independence.

The independence phoenix can rise from the ashes, and it will burn brighter and stronger than the fuel of our collective experience. We are taking this fight up a notch to match our rising ambition. We are discussing big ideas and bold promises. I believe that the people’s voice and their votes matter. The people of Scotland are sovereign, and only they will decide when it is time to reject Westminster’s decline and chart a new course into the safety of independence.

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Alison Johnstone) NPA
The next item of business is a debate on motion S6M-14524, in the name of John Swinney, on creating a modern, diverse and dynamic Scotland. I invite members ...
The First Minister (John Swinney) SNP
From my experience of taking part in every year of this Parliament since it was reconvened 25 years ago, one thing is clear—no matter where any of us sit in ...
Douglas Ross (Highlands and Islands) (Con) Con
As the First Minister is speaking about powers, will he outline how many powers he has been offered by the UK Government but has returned to it because the S...
The First Minister SNP
It is clear from what I have set out so far, and from my comments earlier today, that, since the independence referendum in 2014, there has been a strengthen...
Douglas Ross Con
It is the powers that—
The First Minister SNP
The powers that I am concerned about are the powers of this Parliament that the people of Scotland voted for in a democratic referendum in 1997. Those powers...
Douglas Ross Con
I will try a different question, then. Will the First Minister tell this Parliament one power that the UK Government has taken away from the Scottish Governm...
The First Minister SNP
The use of the internal market—
Douglas Ross Con
One power that has been taken away.
The Presiding Officer NPA
Mr Ross.
The First Minister SNP
I will explain to Mr Ross exactly what has happened, if he is not familiar with what he has voted for. This Parliament had exclusive power over a range of co...
The Presiding Officer NPA
I call Douglas Ross to speak to and to move amendment S6M-14524.4. 15:11
Douglas Ross (Highlands and Islands) (Con) Con
I want to start by imagining a different decade to the one that we have had—not a different outcome on 18 September 2014, because the people of Scotland vote...
The Presiding Officer NPA
Let us hear Mr Ross.
Douglas Ross Con
I believe that Scotland is a modern, dynamic and diverse country—that is set out in my amendment. However, the SNP does not believe that; that is clear from ...
The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic (Kate Forbes) SNP
I am a big fan of being true to your word. What would have happened if the Conservatives had been true to their word, when they said, “Vote no to stay in the...
Douglas Ross Con
I am sorry, but the Deputy First Minister cannot pick and choose. “One choice” is what the nationalists told us in 2014. They said that it was a “once-in-a-g...
The Presiding Officer NPA
Always speak through the chair, please.
Douglas Ross Con
I cannot believe that the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Social Care does not believe that our health service is in crisis. I am happy to give way if he ca...
The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Social Care (Neil Gray) SNP
I refuse to talk down the work of the incredible staff and committed workforce in our health service. The First Minister provided a list of the Government’s ...
Douglas Ross Con
Can the health secretary not understand that we have the highest number of drug deaths not just in the United Kingdom but across Europe and that one in six p...
The First Minister SNP
Will Mr Ross give way?
Douglas Ross Con
Is there extra time for an intervention?
The Presiding Officer NPA
There is no extra time.
Douglas Ross Con
I am sorry, but I have given way twice to members on the SNP front bench. In his motion, John Swinney claims that independence is “normal”, but a democracy ...
The First Minister SNP
Will Mr Ross give way?
Douglas Ross Con
I am sorry, but I am very tight for time. If there was an opportunity for me to get more time, I would give way.
The Presiding Officer NPA
Taking interventions, within members’ allocated time, is a matter for members.
Douglas Ross Con
I am sorry, but I have already taken two interventions from members on the Government front bench. As historians look back over the past 10 years, they will...
The Presiding Officer NPA
I call Anas Sarwar to speak to and move amendment S6M-14524.5. 15:20