Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Fulton MacGregor SNP Chamber
26 Feb 2020
Police Scotland (Draft Budget 2020-21)
A very good deal was put forward in the budget and it was increased today. Liam Kerr came to the chamber with a pre-prepared speech—he admitted that he got that information 14 minutes before he spoke. He has no answer to the fact that there is £10 million more in the budget th...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
09 Nov 2022
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2023-24
I was not sure whether you were going to bring me back in, convener, given that Wendy Sinclair-Gieben has already touched on this issue in response to earlier questions. Throughout the pre-budget scrutiny process, I have been asking other panellists about the interplay with o...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Chamber
29 Oct 2024
Fiscal Sustainability
I apologise for missing the final opening speech. It was unavoidable, but I want the Parliament to know that it was not Willie Rennie’s speech that I was avoiding—absolutely not. Today we have debated the fiscal health of Scotland, and one thing has been made abundantly clear...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Oct 2020
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2021-22
On that last point, the Equalities and Human Rights Commission said in evidence that it is not overly clear about, or has—should I say?—put some question marks around how the equality and fairer Scotland budget statement influences budget decisions. Can you take this opportuni...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
24 Oct 2023
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2024-25
I have a follow-up question to the discussions that we have been having. The response to the equality and human rights budget advisory group makes it clear that the Scottish Government does not intend to greatly increase direct engagement with the public on the budget process ...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
13 Sep 2023
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2024-25
It is very important that we help you to reflect that accurately. Thank you. I have a couple of questions on the fire services—I will be quick, convener. The first question is for Ross Haggart. I did a bit of work with my local fire station at Coatdyke—it was not too long ago...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
06 Nov 2024
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2025-26
I am the convener of the cross-party group on adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse. The convictions that you have spoken about have been welcomed by survivors in that community. If that trend is going to increase, what is the answer? Sticking to the pre-budget scrutiny p...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
13 Nov 2024
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2025-26
Good morning, cabinet secretary. I have a quick supplementary that relates to the area of the Crown Office and prosecution, and it comes ahead of a question from John Mason that you will answer at question time later today. It relates to the amount of time and cost that is inv...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
03 Nov 2021
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2022-23
My colleague Collette Stevenson has probably covered my question because it is in the same area. If 20 people in that age group were moved into secure care, it strikes me that there would be a budget implication—in a positive sense—for the prison service. It would also be pos...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Nov 2023
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2024-25
Is there any plan in this budget for how we might pick up the pace? For example, in the previous session, I asked the Scottish Prison Service about throughcare. The previous throughcare service was very highly respected, but it has been pulled, what with the growth in the pris...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
06 Oct 2021
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2022-23
Thank you, convener. I thought that I had been forgotten about there. This is probably a reasonable enough area for the last question. It has been touched on in all the answers when looking at the budget overall. Where does local policing sit as a priority in the budget? I ca...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
06 Oct 2021
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2022-23
Anything that improves access to justice and legal aid is crucial, so I welcome what you have said. However, the meeting is about budget scrutiny, so might the result of streamlining the process be that, once things are working more fully and better, more people will get legal...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
13 Sep 2023
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2024-25
I hope that my first question will link this session with the previous one. My colleague John Swinney’s line of questioning in the previous session was about joined-up thinking in the justice sector. It will come as no surprise to the witnesses—the point has probably been rais...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
09 Sep 2025
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2026-27
That is excellent. Good morning to the witnesses. Almost all of you have mentioned the budget gap that local authorities across Scotland face this year. How does your local authority ensure that communities are involved in decisions about how to address those gaps? Please coul...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Chamber
05 Feb 2019
Vulnerable Witnesses (Criminal Evidence) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
It is a great pleasure to speak in the debate. I will not be met with much objection from colleagues across the chamber when I say that it is legislation such as that proposed in the bill that we all came into politics for. The proposed legislation will have a positive effect ...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Chamber
01 May 2019
Nursery Funding (Deferred Entry to Primary School)
I thank my fellow members across all parties who signed the motion. I also thank the give them time campaign, some of whose supporters are in the gallery, for their tenacity in highlighting the issue of deferment for children who are four at the start of the school year and fo...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Chamber
09 May 2019
Vulnerable Witnesses (Criminal Evidence) (Scotland) Bill
It is a great pleasure to speak in the debate—as it was at stage 1—as we stand, at stage 3, on the verge of making the bill law. I hear what others have said about its being just a start, and I agree with that, especially on the back of the main theme of Jackie Baillie’s speec...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
03 Dec 2019
Subordinate Legislation
I have some comments, although they do not relate specifically to the instruments that are in front of us. I have been dealing with a constituency case involving firefighter pensions. It is about pre-1992 pensions which, unlike later pensions, are not given to partners who are...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Chamber
12 Jan 2022
Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service
It is a great privilege to lead this debate on the Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service. As with so many scientific breakthroughs, it was in Scotland that the first successful blood transfusion was carried out, by James Blundell in the early 19th century. A century late...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
23 Oct 2018
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2019-20
Following on from the points that were raised by Rona Mackay and Liam McArthur, cabinet secretary, do you have any plans to implement guidance for local authorities around specific agencies? The local authority in the area that I represent is running some innovative work on ju...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
12 Sep 2019
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2020-21
I want to go back to the issue of sectarianism and the events at the weekend and the previous weekend. We have had a couple of isolated incidents, and Glasgow City Council has banned certain marches from taking place this weekend. However, that is only a temporary solution. I ...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Chamber
18 Sep 2019
Criminal Sentencing
I would, normally, because I have mentioned Liam Kerr, but this is a four-minute speech. I advise the Tories to look again at splitting their debating time as they have done today, because that gives us only four minutes each. What is happening with sentencing just now works....
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
08 Oct 2019
Pre-Budget Scrutiny
Good morning, panel. Like Shona Robison, I want to thank your staff team, who are clearly working in very difficult circumstances. They are always working in difficult circumstances, but from what we have heard, they are perhaps more difficult at the moment. You will be aware...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Oct 2019
Pre-Budget Scrutiny
Do you expect it to be a one-off and then for you to be able to work within the budget next year, or do you expect to hold similar conversations next year?
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Oct 2019
Pre-Budget Scrutiny
In our session with Colin McConnell, I asked him about the Auditor General’s report and the issue of the Scottish Prison Service writing to the Scottish Government to say that it would not be able to deliver a balanced budget in 2019-20. Mr McConnell said that he had a product...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Oct 2019
Pre-Budget Scrutiny
We had a fairly positive response on that from not just Colin McConnell but Melanie Allan, who is the SPS’s head of financial policy and services. In general terms, do you feel that there is an issue with the financial sustainability of the prison budget, or is it simply a ca...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
08 Oct 2020
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2021-22
Will you sum up your thoughts about the recovery plan for us? I appreciate that you have already addressed much of that in your answers, but what do you think the main principles behind a recovery plan should be and who should be involved? As we build back better—to use that p...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Oct 2020
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2021-22
Thank you, convener, and good morning, minister You will be aware that Engender said to the committee in evidence: “Although the introduction of the Equality Budget Statement in 2009 was a welcome step, our European work tells us that Scotland is slipping behind compared wit...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Oct 2020
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2021-22
I had another question about the Scottish Government’s recently announced measures to make equalities and human rights central to budget decisions, but they have been referred to in the minister’s opening statement and throughout the evidence, so with the convener’s permission...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Mar 2021
Budget (Scotland) (No 5) Bill: Stage 2
The decisions that you have made will be welcome to businesses. Earlier, you spoke about the grants that were put in place, and, as I have said in a previous committee meeting, I thank the North Lanarkshire Council’s grant team for the way that it has dealt with those—it has...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
05 Oct 2021
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2022-23
I have a few questions that follow on from the earlier session this morning—I do not know whether you had a chance to see that—and from the last line of questioning, about the funding streams that are open to voluntary organisations. We heard quite clearly from Paul Bradley t...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
03 Nov 2021
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2022-23
Good morning. I welcome the Lord Advocate to her new position. I know that post mortems have been a topical issue for you, with issues with the toxicology departments causing significant delays. There has also been a more recent surge, because of an increase in deaths. Have t...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
25 Oct 2022
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2023-24
Good afternoon. As we have heard, the Scottish Government has a human rights goal or policy but it is not reflected in what people are finding is happening on the ground. I would like the witnesses to talk about how this committee, the Government and Parliament could perhaps m...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
26 Oct 2022
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2023-24
Good morning. I have been a member of this committee and its predecessor for six years, along with Rona Mackay—I think that we are the only two members who are in that position—and I have to say that this budget scrutiny is the starkest that I have heard. During previous sessi...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
26 Oct 2022
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2023-24
I welcome all that. The blue-light collaboration, which you and the police have spoken about, is a fantastic piece of work and should be happening. It might be that you are not able to look at this, but in relation to budget scrutiny, is part of your analysis and assessment ...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
26 Oct 2022
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2023-24
So it is a work in progress. Thanks very much for that. I have one other quick supplementary question, about the impact of climate change. It came to me as we have been speaking through the course of the committee meeting. 12:30 I am asking about it because, throughout the...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
02 Nov 2022
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2022-23
You said that the service will continue to prioritise criminal cases, and particularly the most serious ones. I think that everybody would agree with that and there would be no argument about it. That implies that the civil stuff might take more of a back seat, for want of a b...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
02 Nov 2022
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2022-23
My other question is about the interplay between different parts of the justice sector. I have asked previous panels about that, and we will hear later from the Scottish Prison Service, which is another key player. When you make budget decisions and consider ideas, do you tak...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
02 Nov 2022
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2022-23
The final question that I want to ask is one that I asked the previous panel and the panels last week. It is about your interlinking with the other justice agencies. You heard this morning’s evidence, and I assume that you tuned into the police’s and the fire service’s evidenc...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
09 Nov 2022
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2023-24
My question goes back to Katy Clark’s line of questioning a wee while ago about reform and how some upcoming reforms, which the committee will consider, could link into the budget process that we are here to talk about. We will very soon be starting work on the Bail and Rele...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
09 Nov 2022
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2023-24
The Government seems to be moving in that direction; we will scrutinise and vote on the bill as it comes through Parliament shortly. Has the flat cash settlement come too early for that bill’s operation, or is there a hope that it could, inevitably, reduce the budget, which is...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
13 Sep 2023
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2024-25
You mentioned sporting events, so you must have read my mind about my next question. At last night’s Scotland match, there was a significant increase in police numbers compared to previous games—I have been at all the games recently as part of the five game package. Even my we...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
13 Sep 2023
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2024-25
Thanks very much for that answer. My final question is on an issue that we have done a bit of work on in the Parliament: water safety. I have to say the SFRS does a fantastic job with us on water safety. Accessing wild waters is becoming more popular as a result of the pandemi...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Nov 2023
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2024-25
Are the Community Justice Scotland throughcare services still offered through the Wise Group and Sacro? Do the costs of providing throughcare services not come out of your budget at all?
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
08 Nov 2023
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2024-25
Good morning, cabinet secretary and officials. You might have seen last week’s evidence session with witnesses from Community Justice Scotland, during which we heard quite a strong case about a disconnect of some sort between the Scottish Government’s policy intention with re...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
01 Oct 2024
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2025-26
I thank the witnesses for those answers. Professor Heald, you said in your written submission that the equalisation methods that are used to distribute funding mean that Scotland is not realising the full benefit of the funds. Will you expand a wee bit on that, and say what c...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
09 Oct 2024
Pre-Budget Scrutiny 2025-26
It is probably a good point for me to ask my first question. Much of our discussion has been about where community justice sits with other services. We have been talking about drug and alcohol services, which are in the health space, and there has been quite a lot of talk abou...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
06 Nov 2024
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2025-26
I want to ask about changes in the population of the prison estate. That has had more news coverage recently, particularly in relation to the complex health concerns and needs that are arising. I have asked about that in the chamber. A wee while ago, one of the governors—I thi...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
19 Nov 2025
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2026-27
I should declare an interest in that my wife works at the state hospital, which is a high-security facility as well as a health-based one. Could other aspects of prisoner care move to that basis? That question is more about policy than about the budget, but how could such a mo...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
19 Nov 2025
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2026-27
I move on to my more substantive question. In your submission, you said that a resource increase is needed to meet “Additional costs to support the implementation of the FAI Taskforce recommendations.” Will you set out what that resource requirement is and what it covers, an...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
20 Feb 2020
Budget Scrutiny 2020-21
Yes, it is specifically about the budget. I am glad that the issue of immigration was raised. I find the situation that we face quite frightening, and I think that it will have a massive impact on the budget. Obviously, the UK Government’s announcement was made only yesterday...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Chamber
26 Feb 2020
Police Scotland (Draft Budget 2020-21)
No, I do not have time. My apologies, Mr Kelly. The fact is that Police Scotland’s capital budget has been more than doubled between 2016-17 and 2020-21. As other members have said, it includes, for example, £5 million of extra funding to allow Police Scotland to accelerate i...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
24 Jan 2023
Budget Scrutiny 2023-24
I thank the panel for giving us their views—you have covered quite a bit. I have a short question about the emergency budget review, which some of you touched on. Do you feel that equalities and human rights concerns have risen specifically out of the emergency budget review? ...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
09 Nov 2016
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2017-18 (Skills Development Scotland)
I was going to ask about the consistency of careers advice, but I think that Danny Logue has more or less covered that. To follow up on what Tavish Scott said, is there a careers adviser in each school, or is there an adviser for an area? Is careers advice provided on a needs-...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
09 Nov 2016
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2017-18 (Skills Development Scotland)
I would be happy to speak to you outwith the meeting to set up a date to visit one of the schools in Coatbridge and Chryston and meet some of the staff.
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP Committee
23 Nov 2016
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2017-18 (Scottish Qualifications Authority)
Thank you for having us over to the SQA last week. It was a very worthwhile and interesting visit. It was good to see the scale of the work that you are involved in. I reflected after the meeting that I had learned a lot about what you do, which is a lot more than I had initia...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
23 Nov 2016
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2017-18 (Scottish Qualifications Authority)
I am glad that you have picked up on that. After reading the submissions and hearing about the group of teachers who met the convener and Mr Greer, I took the opportunity last night to send a quick text to some teachers I know—like everybody, I have many friends who are teache...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
23 Nov 2016
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2017-18 (Scottish Qualifications Authority)
This has been a very challenging evidence session for our witnesses. I hope that you respect that it has to be that way because the committee’s job is to scrutinise and ensure that things are as good as they can be. However, I wanted to come back in to say that, following las...
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
02 Oct 2018
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2019-20
My question carries on nicely from Tom Halpin’s point. Most of the submissions welcomed the Scottish Government’s funding initiatives for community justice, but how can we better use third sector organisations alongside statutory resources?
Fulton MacGregor SNP Committee
02 Oct 2018
Pre-budget Scrutiny 2019-20
Thank you very much for those answers, which go some way towards explaining the national scheme and what is happening at local authority level. To the extent that it is appropriate for your organisations, can you tell us how you can have an impact at the level of the individu...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 26 February 2020

26 Feb 2020 · S5 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Police Scotland (Draft Budget 2020-21)
MacGregor, Fulton SNP Coatbridge and Chryston Watch on SPTV

A very good deal was put forward in the budget and it was increased today. Liam Kerr came to the chamber with a pre-prepared speech—he admitted that he got that information 14 minutes before he spoke. He has no answer to the fact that there is £10 million more in the budget than the Tories asked for as a minimum. They keep saying that that is a minimum. I hope that Mr Kerr and his party will support the budget.

Despite the austerity that has been imposed on us, which has led to our resource budget from the UK Government for 2020-21 being around 2.8 per cent lower than it was in 2010, policing services in Scotland have been maintained and improved.

As Rona Mackay rightly said, there has been an increase of 1,025 police officers from the position that was inherited in 2007. That contrasts with cuts of up to 20,000 officers in England and Wales. Even in a scenario in which forces in England and Wales replace the officers who have been cut, there would be around 24 officers per 10,000 of population, which is still well below the rate in Scotland of 32 officers per 10,000 of population.

Our commitment is supported by the decision of the Government in the draft budget to invest £60 million in Police Scotland’s annual budget. More than £9 billion has been invested in policing since 2013, and Police Scotland’s budget has been increased in every one of the past five years, which clearly shows the Scottish Government’s position on the matter.

The Conservatives may like to make out that the Scottish Government underfunds the police, but as others have said, that does not reflect the facts.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Linda Fabiani) SNP
The next item of business is a debate on motion S5M-20979, in the name of Liam Kerr, on Police Scotland underfunded in the draft budget. I call Liam Kerr to ...
Liam Kerr (North East Scotland) (Con) Con
I have 13 minutes to address a matter that is too grave and serious for anything other than a cold and blunt analysis. I hope that that will not be sidetrack...
The Cabinet Secretary for Justice (Humza Yousaf) SNP
Will the member take an intervention?
Liam Kerr Con
Of course.
Humza Yousaf SNP
The member asked for £50 million in the budget for policing. He might have seen that we have reached a deal with the Greens, which includes an extra £60 mill...
Liam Kerr Con
I thank the cabinet secretary for that information. I was aware of it, because the answer to the Government initiated question came out 14 minutes ago. Howev...
Fulton MacGregor (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP) SNP
Will the member take an intervention?
Liam Kerr Con
Let me make some progress, please. The starting point must first be understood. Audit Scotland and the chief constable were clear that a significant uplift ...
Maureen Watt (Aberdeen South and North Kincardine) (SNP) SNP
Does the member recognise that the Government’s distressed brief intervention programme deals precisely with that, including in his own patch in Aberdeen?
Liam Kerr Con
I recognise that—it is exactly the point that I am making. Waiting lists for mental health services are at an all-time high. The police are having to deal wi...
Humza Yousaf SNP
I am sure that Labour will speak to its amendment, but the member surely cannot ignore the fact that the discretionary budget has been cut by £800 million si...
Liam Kerr Con
The cabinet secretary needs to accept that the Scottish budget is up in real terms from when the SNP came to power. As I have outlined, £1 billion is coming ...
The Cabinet Secretary for Justice (Humza Yousaf) SNP
I am delighted to speak in the debate on police funding. I am pleased to say that, as a result of the on-going budget discussions that have been taking place...
James Kelly (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab
How, in any way, can the cabinet secretary describe the capital budget allocation as adequate when the police told us that it was £56 million short? An addit...
Humza Yousaf SNP
There is an increase of almost 30 per cent on the capital budget for the current year, and in the current year there was an increase of almost 52 per cent. I...
Liam Kerr Con
The cabinet secretary perhaps should not quote selectively because, in the same letter, Police Scotland slammed the overall funding settlement. Does the cabi...
Humza Yousaf SNP
As I said, we have increased the capital budget by almost 30 per cent. From a baseline of £20 million in 2017-18, we now have a capital budget of £45 million...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
You are just closing, cabinet secretary.
Humza Yousaf SNP
I am not surprised that nobody from the Conservative benches chose to stand up when I asked them to stand up for Scotland; instead, they chose to remain seat...
Humza Yousaf SNP
I am more than happy to take an intervention in my final minute.
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
I will allow that.
Liam Kerr Con
On that point, will the cabinet secretary recognise that, despite the new deal, he has still short-changed the police, given that he has an extra £96 million...
Humza Yousaf SNP
That was a waste of time. I should not have accepted the intervention, because Liam Kerr was not able to confirm that he agrees that the UK Government should...
Liam Kerr Con
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. The cabinet secretary refers to money being stolen. The word “stolen” implies impropriety, dishonesty and criminal ac...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
That is not a point of order. What individuals say in the chamber is up to them, but there are means by which complaints can be made about that. I say to all...
Humza Yousaf SNP
I did not realise that Liam Kerr was such a sensitive soul when it comes to minding one’s language. If he is so sensitive about language, I would have though...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
I call James Kelly to speak to and move amendment S5M-20979.2. 15:39
James Kelly (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab
I welcome the opportunity to take part in the debate, which the Scottish Conservative Party has brought to the chamber. At the outset of my remarks, I pay tr...
Humza Yousaf SNP
In the spirit of coming to the budget negotiations with credible plans, I ask where James Kelly would have taken capital from and where he would invest capit...
James Kelly Lab
You are the cabinet secretary, so you are responsible.