Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 47 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
However, I believe that there are many members of other parties who would wish away tax credits being restricted to the first two children, and I point them towards the legislative powers of this Parliament. For my part, I will continue to monitor how the policy works on the ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
I refer again to the third-party model and the fact that it already exists in relation to domestic violence. It is the third-party model that is being used to fill out the pages of the form. Let me come back to the point that the First Minister raised in her speech about work...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
I agreed with her then, and I still do. The First Minister gave monetary examples, so let me put them in context. A one-parent family with two children where the parent works 16 hours a week on the minimum wage can claim monetary benefits of just under £19,000 a year. Added t...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
Inevitably, that means examining many budgets, including the welfare budget. It has meant, for example, removing child benefit from higher earners. The issue that we are debating today revolves around further decisions that have been taken by the UK Government to limit child t...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
21 May 2015
First Minister’s Question Time · Prime Minister (Meetings)
Among that litany of exam results, we did not get an acknowledgement that the biannual literacy testing this year shows that standards in literacy are down, and that the biannual numeracy testing last year shows that standards are down. Since the First Minister came into pos...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
23 Mar 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Prime Minister (Meetings)
The First Minister now claims that the scheme, which is due to start in August, is somehow “not mandatory” or “not compulsory” and that parents can choose “not to have anything to do with it”. Will she make it absolutely clear whether parents who do not agree with that schem...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
25 May 2016
Taking Scotland Forward
I thank the First Minister for advance notice of her speech. In today’s meeting, Parliament begins the real work of holding the Government to account for the next five years. That task has never been more important. We get down to business today in the knowledge that decisio...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
22 Sep 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Engagements
I thank the First Minister for that response but, although she recognises that 93 per cent of sentences in rape cases are custodial, that leaves 7 per cent that are not. This morning, we read once again of more evidence where that is the case and where these types of crimes ar...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
First, let me say that I welcome this debate today, not because it is about an issue that is easy to discuss in public—something so appalling never is—but because it is only right that issues of difficulty and passion like this are debated in our Parliament here in Edinburgh. ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
I accept that, for many MSPs, the change is far from welcome. These are difficult judgment calls. When, in 2015, the UK Government initially proposed cutting tax credits, I spoke out against it. I did not think that ministers had got the balance right. Those measures were scra...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
It is important that we do not wilfully misrepresent the process, causing fear and alarm. Let me outline the process to members again. The woman writes her name and a third-party professional who is helping her sets out the rest. The third-party model already exists in the ben...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
05 Oct 2017
First Minister’s Question Time · Carrying of Weapons (Children)
Schools are also supposed to monitor and record every time a child is searched. The guidance specifically requires that any incident where a decision is made to search a child or young person, or where a weapon is suspected of being carried or is found, must be recorded. Can t...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
01 Dec 2011
First Minister’s Question Time · Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings)
The First Minister likes to claim the credit when he thinks that something is better in Scotland than it is elsewhere in the United Kingdom, but will he step up to the mark when Scotland is falling behind? Families who have young children in England receive 20 per cent more fr...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
04 Oct 2012
First Minister’s Question Time · Secretary of State for Scotland
Classic SNP playbook: attack the messenger, ignore the message, do not acknowledge responsibility and, for goodness’ sake, do not even think about answering the question.Perhaps the First Minister has spent too much time lolling on the greens in America to pay any attention to...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
20 Mar 2013
Trident
No thank you, not at this time.The other argument that we hear is the money argument, which is that Trident is expensive and the money could be better spent elsewhere. We can quibble about the sums, but the yes Scotland campaign put a notice on its website last week saying tha...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
02 May 2013
First Minister’s Question Time · Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings)
I have the ICAS report here. It raises a number of questions—12 of them, in fact—none of which seemed to be answered by the First Minister’s finance spokesman on Sunday, when he took to the airwaves to try to protect the Government. The question that I liked most was whether t...
Ruth Davidson (Glasgow) (Con) Con Chamber
23 May 2013
Mary Barbour Commemoration
I congratulate Anne McTaggart on securing the debate. As participants in it are acutely aware, Glasgow has an honourable tradition of electing gobby women. I think that Mary Barbour is at the root of that tradition, but her contribution to the lives of the people of Glasgow ha...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
07 Jan 2014
Scotland’s Future
The position is that the best way out of poverty is to increase employment, which is what the coalition Government has done. Can the member square what he says with the fact that, after enacting coalition policies for several years, we now have the lowest level of child povert...
Ruth Davidson (Glasgow) (Con) Con Chamber
19 Nov 2014
First Minister
I stand today as others have done before me—Alex Salmond, Robin Harper, John Swinney, Dennis Canavan and half a dozen others besides—knowing that I do not lead the largest party in the Parliament and realistic about my prospects of becoming First Minister, at least for now. H...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
23 Apr 2015
First Minister’s Question Time · Prime Minister (Meetings)
Those who raised concerns had sound motivations, too, and they were publicly traduced in this chamber by an SNP minister. The First Minister’s problem is that this is not an isolated case. There is a pattern of a majority SNP Government steamrollering through its plans without...
Ruth Davidson (Glasgow) (Con) Con Chamber
08 Nov 2012
Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games
I congratulate John Mason on bringing the debate to the chamber. I am delighted to be given the opportunity to speak about an exciting event that can bring the nation together in a positive way, behind a common purpose, in 2014. It is an event that will give Scots across the n...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
01 Sep 2015
Programme for Government 2015-16
I am in my first minute. No doubt the omission of a welcome for the new living wage in the First Minister’s speech was simply accidental. However, we in this Parliament must turn our attention to the powers over which we exercise full control—from the education of our childr...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
21 Jan 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Prime Minister (Meetings)
This morning we learned that the number of school inspections has fallen from 491 in 2004-05 to just 137 last year, a drop of more than 70 per cent. Inspections are a vital means of providing parents with the necessary information to make decisions about their children’s schoo...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
23 Mar 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Prime Minister (Meetings)
The Scottish National Party Government wants to impose a named person on every child in Scotland over the heads of parents, against the wishes of the majority of this country, and against the concerns of many, including the police, who believe that that will take resource away...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
23 Mar 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Prime Minister (Meetings)
That was anything but clear. I remind members that the Scottish Conservatives lodged specific amendments to the Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill to allow parents to opt out of the named person scheme and that those amendments were voted down by the First Minister’s pa...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
23 Mar 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Prime Minister (Meetings)
That named person will have access to private and sensitive information, all of which will be recorded on a database and will be accessible without the consent—or, in some cases, even the knowledge—of the parents. Named person legislation is so sweeping and so unpopular that ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
09 Jun 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Engagements
I know that the First Minister is off to London tonight for a debate, but we are talking about the Scottish NHS, which her Government has been in charge of for nine years. She is right to point out that the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health is about to publish a re...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
06 Sep 2016
Programme for Government 2016-17
Thank you for remembering my name, Presiding Officer. I was a bit worried for a second. I also thank the First Minister for early sight of her statement today. Last week, I had the pleasure of visiting the Southside general practice in my constituency of Edinburgh Central. I ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
26 Jan 2017
First Minister’s Question Time · Engagements
We want to grow the tax base to fund our public services. The First Minister is damaging our economy. I simply ask her: if staffing is all fine, why are theatres lying empty and patients not getting the operations that they need? This week, the First Minister asked what kind ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
09 Feb 2017
First Minister’s Question Time · Engagements
As always, the First Minister has her long list of excuses ready, but the answer to the question that I asked lies at the door of a Scottish National Party that has failed utterly over 10 years of government to set Scottish education on the right course. The First Minister fai...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
23 Feb 2017
First Minister’s Question Time · Engagements
I thank the First Minister for her response. She is absolutely right to point out that we should all uphold the independence of the judiciary. It is also right to say that Parliament makes the law and the Government sets the framework in which our judges operate. The Conservat...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
02 Mar 2017
First Minister’s Question Time · Engagements
If this is so important to the First Minister, why does she keep kicking the can down the road? The Hometown Foundation said in its letter to Mr Swinney: “This is really not a great demonstration of meaningful engagement with stakeholders or a good start in trying to empower ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
16 Mar 2017
First Minister’s Question Time · Engagements
I thank the First Minister for her answer to my question, but I wonder whether it would have been delivered in quite the same tone had she known that the question was not actually mine but was a question that was put to one of my MSPs earlier this week by a parent who contacte...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
20 Apr 2017
First Minister’s Question Time · Engagements
I will answer the question in the same way that I answered it in the press this morning: if the First Minister does not like the two-child tax policy, she can change it. But the truth is— Members: Shame!
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
I am sorry, but I have a lot to get through and I will not be taking any interventions. Members: Oh!
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
I do not think that this issue should be subject to the knockabout that we see here in the chamber daily. Of course, there is a political judgment, which any Government has to take. Labour and the SNP would not seek to curtail the growth in spending as we would, and that is t...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
In other words, parents of three or more children who are currently claiming tax credits will still continue to do so.
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
It adds that “women are not placed in the position of having to give details about the rape to DWP or HMRC officials”.
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
There is absolutely no requirement to report rape as a crime, to provide proof of rape or to provide proof of conviction. A woman writes her name and a third-party professional who is helping the mother is asked to set out the rest.
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
That third-party model already exists in the benefit system to support victims of domestic violence. Members: Give way—go on.
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Apr 2017
Child Tax Credit Cuts
The third-party professionals— Members: Give way!
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 May 2017
First Minister’s Question Time · Engagements
Along with the concerns that were raised by the Scottish Youth Parliament, the Scottish Association for Mental Health launched a campaign this week that highlights the mental health needs of young people. The “Going to Be” campaign points out that three children in every class...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
03 May 2018
First Minister’s Question Time · Police Officer Numbers
That is great—it would be unacceptable. The fall will not be 1,200. What we need to know now is how many it will be. Will it be 600? Will be 800? Police Scotland is facing a £30 million black hole, so we know that the cuts are coming, and people outside Parliament have a right...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
04 Sep 2018
Programme for Government 2018-19
This is the 12th Scottish National Party programme for government and it is the third under the current First Minister. It comes a year after last year’s programme for government when, following the general election, the First Minister declared a radical relaunch of her Admini...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
04 Sep 2018
Programme for Government 2018-19
I love the idea that the First Minister thinks that the people of Scotland are mugs enough to believe what she says. Having stood here 12 months ago saying that we needed a radical bill for the “most radical change” to our schools to make them better—when, under her watch, the...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
13 Sep 2018
First Minister’s Question Time
The First Minister says that she wants more information, but she is not even making sure that the information that this Parliament requires of schools is being put in the public realm. Seven per cent is shameful. Here is why that matters. The Government says that we need pa...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
16 May 2019
First Minister’s Question Time · Numeracy Attainment
What the First Minister does not get is that the mum of a seven-year-old now will not know whether this country is getting any better at teaching maths until her child is a teenager. Interruption. It is true. The reason for that is that the old national survey—Interruption. Me...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 25 April 2017

25 Apr 2017 · S5 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Child Tax Credit Cuts
Davidson, Ruth Con Edinburgh Central Watch on SPTV

However, I believe that there are many members of other parties who would wish away tax credits being restricted to the first two children, and I point them towards the legislative powers of this Parliament.

For my part, I will continue to monitor how the policy works on the ground. The First Minister and her ministers use strong words such as “shameful”. She has the power to act, and if she chooses strong words but chooses not to act, that would indeed be shameful. We will continue to monitor the policy.

I move amendment S5M-05282.4, to leave out from “is fundamentally” to end and insert:

“notes that the UK Government has a duty to manage public finances carefully for future generations; considers that the UK Government has sought to curb increasing welfare spending by reducing benefits to those on higher incomes, such as child benefit; notes that the two-child limit on child tax credits will not apply to current recipients; considers that the Scottish Government has the power to reverse the two-child limit on tax credits by using newly devolved powers if it so chooses; further considers that exemptions to the two-child policy, such as that given to women who are victims of rape, must be implemented as compassionately as possible and monitored closely, and believes that more must be done to help women in Scotland in these circumstances by, for example, increasing the number of sexual assault referral centres that are available.”

14:45  
References in this contribution

Motions, questions or amendments mentioned by their reference code.

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Ken Macintosh) NPA
The next item of business is a debate on motion S5M-05282, in the name of Nicola Sturgeon, on child tax credit cuts. I call the First Minister to speak to an...
The First Minister (Nicola Sturgeon) SNP
Last Thursday, together with Kezia Dugdale, Willie Rennie, Patrick Harvie and many MSPs from across the chamber, I attended the demonstration against the rap...
Alex Cole-Hamilton (Edinburgh Western) (LD) LD
Is the First Minister surprised to learn that this is, in fact, the second time that the Conservatives have sought to introduce this policy, after they were ...
The First Minister SNP
No, I am not surprised to hear that, because I know that. While I oppose many of the benefit cuts, I think that this one—particularly the rape clause that fl...
The Presiding Officer NPA
I call on Ruth Davidson to speak to and move the amendment in her name. 14:32
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con
First, let me say that I welcome this debate today, not because it is about an issue that is easy to discuss in public—something so appalling never is—but be...
Gillian Martin (Aberdeenshire East) (SNP) SNP
Will the member give way?
Kezia Dugdale (Lothian) (Lab) Lab
Will the member give way?
Ruth Davidson Con
I am sorry, but I have a lot to get through and I will not be taking any interventions. Members: Oh!
Ruth Davidson Con
I do not think that this issue should be subject to the knockabout that we see here in the chamber daily. Of course, there is a political judgment, which an...
Kezia Dugdale Lab
Will the member give way on that point?
Ruth Davidson Con
Inevitably, that means examining many budgets, including the welfare budget. It has meant, for example, removing child benefit from higher earners. The issue...
Neil Findlay (Lothian) (Lab) Lab
Will the member take an intervention?
Ruth Davidson Con
In other words, parents of three or more children who are currently claiming tax credits will still continue to do so.
Neil Findlay Lab
Will you not defend your own policy?
Ruth Davidson Con
I accept that, for many MSPs, the change is far from welcome. These are difficult judgment calls. When, in 2015, the UK Government initially proposed cutting...
The Minister for Childcare and Early Years (Mark McDonald) SNP
Will the member give way?
Ruth Davidson Con
I agreed with her then, and I still do. The First Minister gave monetary examples, so let me put them in context. A one-parent family with two children wher...
Neil Findlay Lab
On a point of order, Presiding Officer.
Ruth Davidson Con
It adds that “women are not placed in the position of having to give details about the rape to DWP or HMRC officials”.
The Presiding Officer NPA
I am sorry, Ms Davidson, but there is a point of order from Mr Findlay.
Neil Findlay Lab
Presiding Officer, I was under the impression that this was a debating chamber. Is it not appalling that the leader of the Opposition in the Parliament is un...
The Presiding Officer NPA
That is not a point of order. All members know that it is entirely at their own discretion whether to take an intervention or not.
Ruth Davidson Con
There is absolutely no requirement to report rape as a crime, to provide proof of rape or to provide proof of conviction. A woman writes her name and a third...
The First Minister SNP
Will Ruth Davidson take an intervention?
Ruth Davidson Con
That third-party model already exists in the benefit system to support victims of domestic violence. Members: Give way—go on.
Ruth Davidson Con
The third-party professionals— Members: Give way!
The Presiding Officer NPA
Order. The member is not taking an intervention.
Ruth Davidson Con
It is important that we do not wilfully misrepresent the process, causing fear and alarm. Let me outline the process to members again. The woman writes her n...
The Presiding Officer NPA
There is another point of order.