Chamber
Plenary, 12 Dec 2007
12 Dec 2007 · S3 · Plenary
Item of business
Woodland and Green Spaces
I agree with the minister that the environment plays an important role in ensuring good health among our constituents. That is equally true in rural and urban constituencies. Members will not be surprised that, as I am an MSP for an urban constituency, I think that green space and woodland are most valued in urban areas.
I grew up on the Dundee housing estate of Whitfield, which is in the constituency of my colleague Shona Robison. It was known in the citizens band radio community as the concrete jungle—a place where green space had been given little, if any, regard in early planning. I am pleased that we have learned much from the mistakes of the past and that describing Whitfield as a concrete jungle now would be wrong. We have a much greener new Whitfield.
The importance to health of access to good-quality green space cannot be overestimated. Not just physical health, but mental health can benefit from green space. Green space is of great benefit to people who live in cities such as Dundee. Evidence is emerging that access to high-quality green space can reduce stress, provide an opportunity for physical activity and build community spirit.
Deryck Irving, who is the senior development officer for Greenspace Scotland, has said:
"Research has shown that access to appropriate, good quality greenspace can have a positive impact on both mental and physical health. Equally, a lack of access to such greenspace can have a negative impact on mental and physical health and well-being."
In 1980, 12 per cent of Scotland was covered by woodland. By 2006, that figure had risen to 17 per cent. The aim is to increase that to 25 per cent, which will result in an additional 650,000 hectares of woodland throughout Scotland. I am sure that we all agree that we should aim to travel in that direction, but the placement of our new woodland must be well thought out.
RSPB Scotland has expressed concerns about that and has stressed the importance of developing new woodland, because inappropriately locating new woodland can damage wildlife. I seek reassurance from the minister that careful planning will be involved in aiming to achieve the target of increasing forestation so that it covers 25 per cent of Scotland.
A number of green space projects in Dundee have enjoyed success. The Baxter park restoration project, for example, revamped and cleaned up that park and installed urban rangers to engage with the public, and the Middleton community woodland project in my old ward has created a community woodland on an area of land adjacent to the Whitfield housing estate. That project has been successful in engaging young people from Braeview academy, local youth groups and community organisations.
One of the most successful projects in my constituency of Dundee West has been in Ardler—I refer to the Ardler in bloom project and the Ardler Environmental Group. In 2004, when the Ardler estate was newly finished, a local gardening competition was set up to encourage residents to grow their own plants and take pride in the environment. Many residents of the new village of Ardler had moved from multistorey flats that were demolished, so they had no experience of owning their own garden. The project supported those residents in their new gardens, and it has continued. The Ardler Environmental Group, which has also been supported by the urban ranger project, was established with the aim of making the area more attractive to wildlife and local communities. The people involved in such projects played a large part in Ardler estate winning a British Urban Regeneration Association award for best practice in regeneration in 2006 and the Queen's award for voluntary service this year.
Good-quality green space can be the cornerstone of the economy. Last month, I spoke about Camperdown country park, which is Dundee's top attraction. It has 400,000 visitors every year and is home to the Camperdown elm and Scotland's last city-based red squirrel population. It is a huge asset to the people of Dundee. In 2006, it managed to play host to Radio 1's big weekend festival. It has been estimated that that festival boosted the local economy to the tune of around £10 million.
All our constituents would benefit much from improved access to green space and woodland. There should be an holistic approach to community regeneration, as there has been in Dundee, with green spaces properly planned.
I urge members to support the motion.
I grew up on the Dundee housing estate of Whitfield, which is in the constituency of my colleague Shona Robison. It was known in the citizens band radio community as the concrete jungle—a place where green space had been given little, if any, regard in early planning. I am pleased that we have learned much from the mistakes of the past and that describing Whitfield as a concrete jungle now would be wrong. We have a much greener new Whitfield.
The importance to health of access to good-quality green space cannot be overestimated. Not just physical health, but mental health can benefit from green space. Green space is of great benefit to people who live in cities such as Dundee. Evidence is emerging that access to high-quality green space can reduce stress, provide an opportunity for physical activity and build community spirit.
Deryck Irving, who is the senior development officer for Greenspace Scotland, has said:
"Research has shown that access to appropriate, good quality greenspace can have a positive impact on both mental and physical health. Equally, a lack of access to such greenspace can have a negative impact on mental and physical health and well-being."
In 1980, 12 per cent of Scotland was covered by woodland. By 2006, that figure had risen to 17 per cent. The aim is to increase that to 25 per cent, which will result in an additional 650,000 hectares of woodland throughout Scotland. I am sure that we all agree that we should aim to travel in that direction, but the placement of our new woodland must be well thought out.
RSPB Scotland has expressed concerns about that and has stressed the importance of developing new woodland, because inappropriately locating new woodland can damage wildlife. I seek reassurance from the minister that careful planning will be involved in aiming to achieve the target of increasing forestation so that it covers 25 per cent of Scotland.
A number of green space projects in Dundee have enjoyed success. The Baxter park restoration project, for example, revamped and cleaned up that park and installed urban rangers to engage with the public, and the Middleton community woodland project in my old ward has created a community woodland on an area of land adjacent to the Whitfield housing estate. That project has been successful in engaging young people from Braeview academy, local youth groups and community organisations.
One of the most successful projects in my constituency of Dundee West has been in Ardler—I refer to the Ardler in bloom project and the Ardler Environmental Group. In 2004, when the Ardler estate was newly finished, a local gardening competition was set up to encourage residents to grow their own plants and take pride in the environment. Many residents of the new village of Ardler had moved from multistorey flats that were demolished, so they had no experience of owning their own garden. The project supported those residents in their new gardens, and it has continued. The Ardler Environmental Group, which has also been supported by the urban ranger project, was established with the aim of making the area more attractive to wildlife and local communities. The people involved in such projects played a large part in Ardler estate winning a British Urban Regeneration Association award for best practice in regeneration in 2006 and the Queen's award for voluntary service this year.
Good-quality green space can be the cornerstone of the economy. Last month, I spoke about Camperdown country park, which is Dundee's top attraction. It has 400,000 visitors every year and is home to the Camperdown elm and Scotland's last city-based red squirrel population. It is a huge asset to the people of Dundee. In 2006, it managed to play host to Radio 1's big weekend festival. It has been estimated that that festival boosted the local economy to the tune of around £10 million.
All our constituents would benefit much from improved access to green space and woodland. There should be an holistic approach to community regeneration, as there has been in Dundee, with green spaces properly planned.
I urge members to support the motion.
In the same item of business
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Alasdair Morgan):
SNP
The next item of business is a debate on motion S3M-1008, in the name of Michael Russell, on the benefits of woodland and green spaces.
The Minister for Environment (Michael Russell):
SNP
In October, I had the privilege of speaking at the Central Scotland Forest Trust's conference, at which one of the big issues was the link between a high-qua...
Johann Lamont (Glasgow Pollok) (Lab):
Lab
Our amendment is moderate with regard to the issue about consultation. Will the minister explain why it was decided to circulate the revised version of Scott...
Michael Russell:
SNP
I am sorry that I am not able to give that explanation, but I am happy to find out and write to the member about why that was done. However, I do not think t...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab):
Lab
I welcome the terms of the motion in the name of Michael Russell, and I agree with what he said about the importance of accessible green space, from both the...
Michael Russell:
SNP
Given the spirit of trying to be co-operative, I think that the word "shirking" is a little strong. I hope that the member accepts that there is a triple loc...
Des McNulty:
Lab
One has to consider the practical implications. There is a view among my constituents that open space protection is now significantly weaker than the protect...
Nanette Milne (North East Scotland) (Con):
Con
This is a welcome debate, which focuses on the health benefits to be derived from the woodland and green space in our communities; I will concentrate on that...
Jim Hume (South of Scotland) (LD):
LD
I am pleased to speak on behalf of the Liberal Democrats in the debate. It is difficult to disagree with today's motion, which is neither new nor substantial...
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Trish Godman):
Lab
We now move to the debate. I remind members that speeches are to be four minutes long.
Rob Gibson (Highlands and Islands) (SNP):
SNP
The old forester in Scotland said, "Aye be sticking in a tree, because while you're sleeping, it's growing." People can plant trees in their gardens, as they...
Johann Lamont (Glasgow Pollok) (Lab):
Lab
I welcome the opportunity to contribute to what I perhaps uncharitably described—when I first heard what was to be debated—as a tree-hugging debate. Those of...
Robin Harper (Lothians) (Green):
Green
It is about time that we started to treasure and give real value to our woodland, countryside and informal urban green spaces, rather than selling them off t...
Joe FitzPatrick (Dundee West) (SNP):
SNP
I agree with the minister that the environment plays an important role in ensuring good health among our constituents. That is equally true in rural and urba...
David Whitton (Strathkelvin and Bearsden) (Lab):
Lab
I support the amendment in the name of Des McNulty. I want to deal specifically with how our woodland can be used to benefit tourism.The Piranha Trail Builde...
Michael Russell:
SNP
I know that the member has a strong interest in the matter. In the light of his recent inquiries, I give an assurance that the Forestry Commission is keen to...
David Whitton:
Lab
I thank the minister for that good news, which I am sure the Piranhas and others will welcome.I remind Mr Russell that it was the Labour-Liberal coalition th...
Shirley-Anne Somerville (Lothians) (SNP):
SNP
Green spaces in our towns and cities do not just offer desirable respite from an urban concrete wilderness, and we do not maintain them merely out of a sense...
Johann Lamont:
Lab
Does the member acknowledge that, particularly in a city such as Edinburgh, green spaces that are improved will come under pressure, so the proposal for a st...
Shirley-Anne Somerville:
SNP
As the minister explained earlier, there is a triple lock to protect green spaces in the urban environment.Another space that is important in Scottish cities...
The Deputy Presiding Officer:
Lab
We move to wind-up speeches.
Mike Rumbles (West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD):
LD
I would have thought that in a debate on the benefits of woodland and green spaces, it would have been a given that MSPs from all sides of the chamber would ...
Michael Russell:
SNP
I always am.
Mike Rumbles:
LD
—and I thought that, in that spirit, he would accept amendments to his motion.
Michael Russell:
SNP
I am not that consensual.
Mike Rumbles:
LD
As the minister has just said, he is not that consensual. He rejected the Labour and Liberal Democrat amendments. What does he object to specifically in our ...
Michael Russell:
SNP
First, the amendment's call for "management contract incentives" is, as Mr Harper pointed out, quite contrary to what the motion is about. That issue is alre...
Mike Rumbles:
LD
Again, the minister completely misunderstands what our amendment is about. It is not about land management contracts. As the minister knows, that is not in t...
Michael Russell:
SNP
Yes, it is.
Mike Rumbles:
LD
Let us ignore the minister's misunderstanding for the moment. There is nothing in any of the three amendments that MSPs from all parties should not feel able...