Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
13 Dec 2018
Demonstrating Leadership in Human Rights
I can heartily give a commitment that all stakeholders who have an interest will take part in that consultation. I will certainly encourage them to do so, and I hope that Mr Sarwar will do so, too. Given all his networks and connections, I would be keen for that to happen. Th...
Christina McKelvie SNP Committee
10 Sep 2015
Committee Reform
I agree with you on that. One of the parliamentary constraints that we have is that a stage 3 debate that includes consideration of amendments is obviously a no-go area in terms of having other business at the same time. However, a debate that requires no decision by Parliamen...
The Convener SNP Committee
10 May 2018
Human Rights and the Scottish Parliament
Thank you. You have touched on a lot of points that are similar to previous evidence that we have heard. I reassure you that the committee has gone out to events in the north, south, east and west, including those in Leith and Highland. This coming week, on Friday and Monday, ...
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
21 Mar 2019
General Question Time · Elder Abuse
My answer to David Stewart’s question ties in to my answer to the previous question. Vulnerability is a clear theme that we are working on through Lord Bracadale’s recommendations. Lord Bracadale recognised that older people could be targeted by perpetrators due to their age a...
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2020
Portfolio Question Time · Older People (Easing of Lockdown Measures)
Alexander Burnett may have heard my response to part of Maureen Watt’s question about the work that we are doing now to make sure that the shielding advice for older people is informed by people who are shielding. We also need to balance protecting older people who are more at...
Christina McKelvie SNP Committee
29 Mar 2022
Ministerial Portfolio: Equalities and Older People
I thank everyone for all their good wishes. I am glad to be back, too. It is good to be here. I hope that you are feeling better, Pam. Three great reports were published last week, including the Inclusion Scotland report and the UN’s guide report. With all the reports, we ar...
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
06 Dec 2023
Portfolio Question Time · Historic Environment Scotland (Reopening of Sites)
I am very concerned to hear about the antisocial behaviour issue, and I will take that up with colleagues after portfolio question time today. However, I am pleased to confirm that there is now full or partial access to a number of sites in Roz McCall’s region. I am also plea...
Christina McKelvie: SNP Chamber
28 Feb 2008
Graduate Endowment Abolition (Scotland) Bill
I think that Margo MacDonald knows the answer to that question. The matter is already being examined.The Coalition of Higher Education Students in Scotland is also clear about the effect of the removal of this barrier. CHESS says that"for a working class family it"—"it" is att...
Christina McKelvie: SNP Chamber
11 Dec 2008
Kinship Care
Sorry, I have only four minutes.Labour members will need to decide for themselves whether they are content to remain members of a party that would do such a thing.The SNP Government, on the other hand, is delivering. In response to a parliamentary question in April from Elaine...
Christina McKelvie: SNP Chamber
05 Feb 2009
Early Years Framework
I will not take any interventions, because the misinformation that the Labour Party has doled out today in the Parliament should not be continued.The figures that have been released under the SNP have removed those 200 ghosts, because peripatetic teachers are now counted separ...
Christina McKelvie SNP Committee
01 Dec 2010
Draft Budget Scrutiny 2011-12
You have pre-empted and answered my second question. I was going to ask you about capital pressures, but you have covered that issue. However, I have another question. Where there is an expectation that the national collections and the national companies will work together, ho...
Christina McKelvie (Central Scotland) (SNP) SNP Committee
26 Jan 2011
Review of Teacher Education in Scotland
That leads on quite nicely to my question, because Kenny Gibson’s question on the role of the teacher in leading their own learning is where I want to go. You make a number of recommendations in the report about mentoring, continuous professional development and teachers havin...
Christina McKelvie SNP Committee
23 Feb 2011
The Future of Schools Management in Scotland
At the round-table meeting, Professor Mongon said:“According to all the international evidence, the structural question is a second-order question.”—Official Report, Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee, 2 February 2011; c 4618.I agree with him. If you have been ...
The Convener SNP Committee
15 Nov 2011
Horizon 2020
Thank you. I open the discussion by throwing out a question to everyone round the table. The overall question that we are looking at is how framework programme 7 has worked and how you see FP8 working, or horizon 2020 as it has been renamed. What is your organisation’s involve...
The Convener SNP Committee
15 Nov 2011
“Brussels Bulletin”
I have a question that is linked to that. I see that there is huge emphasis on transparency in the initiative. The “Brussels Bulletin” says:“The intention with the review is also to prevent investors from secretly building up controlling stakes in listed companies (‘hidden own...
The Convener SNP Committee
31 Jan 2012
International Representation and Scottish Government Country Plans
Item 2 is a round-table discussion on Scottish representation abroad and the Scottish Government’s country plans. I welcome all our guests. I hope that we can make the discussion as informal as possible, but I ask people to channel their points through me—if people catch my ey...
The Convener SNP Committee
20 Mar 2012
European Union Structural Funds
I am not. Your question is a valid question, but I think that it might be better directed at the cabinet secretary.
The Convener SNP Committee
20 Mar 2012
Euro Zone Developments
Aileen McLeod has a final question to put to you. I promise you that it will be the final question.
The Convener SNP Committee
15 Nov 2012
Work Programme
I thank members for those frank comments. I fear that there is no consensus in the committee, so I will go straight to a question. The question is, that the committee should undertake an inquiry into the Scottish Government’s handling of the issue of EU legal advice.
The Convener SNP Committee
07 Feb 2013
Foreign Language Learning in Primary Schools Inquiry
Jenny Goldsmith has just reminded me that, at our next meeting, we will hear from the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities; perhaps that is a question that we should ask of the local authorities. On 18 April, we will have the minister, so we can direct a question on resour...
The Convener SNP Committee
05 Dec 2013
Independence White Paper
Dr Fleming, before I ask you to comment on the general question of the Edinburgh agreement, I point out that, on page 10 of our briefing papers, there is a paragraph referring to what would happen “at the midnight hour”. I think that it was David Edward who said this, but one ...
The Convener SNP Committee
20 Mar 2014
Independence: European Union Membership Inquiry
Okay. We will ask the question as a committee, then.We have time for a final question from Willie Coffey. I am sorry, Mr Carmichael—I know that you have to run.
The Convener SNP Committee
06 Feb 2014
Independence: European Union Membership Inquiry
Hanzala Malik has a quick supplementary question on that point. We will then finish off with a question from Rod Campbell.
Christina McKelvie (Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse) (SNP) SNP Chamber
28 Oct 2014
Smith Commission
We have heard many ideas about what powers should come to this Parliament, and the consensus term of the day seems to be “powers for a purpose”. This country of ours is going through the most amazing transformation. From fantastic debates in communities, in schools, on buses a...
The Convener SNP Committee
03 Oct 2013
European Structural Funds
I have a very quick final question. I know that we are slightly overrunning, and we are grateful to you for persevering with us. I have the perennial question that we have been faced with from stakeholders for years. We always say that we will make audit and compliance much mo...
Christina McKelvie (Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse) (SNP) SNP Chamber
13 Jan 2015
Protecting Public Services
It should come as no great surprise that David Cameron’s coalition Government policy is austerity for all, but especially for women. It is certainly no surprise that Labour supports that policy, even in the corridors of power at Westminster today. The public schoolboy network ...
Christina McKelvie (Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse) (SNP) SNP Chamber
30 Apr 2015
Living Wage
The living wage is about dignity and security—on that I agree with Neil Findlay. I thank him for bringing this debate to the chamber, because it gives us another opportunity to expose Labour’s position on the living wage. I will follow that up in a minute. Only action that is...
Christina McKelvie SNP Committee
02 Jun 2015
Women and Welfare
Kevin Stewart touched on the question that I raised with the previous panel about human rights and related issues. I thank One Parent Families Scotland for drawing my attention to the information in its submission—I was looking for those details last night and I could not find...
Christina McKelvie SNP Committee
10 Sep 2015
Committee Reform
I have an add-on to my point about committees meeting during parliamentary sitting time. We recently met, via videoconference, the Houses of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on European Union Affairs. We were told that the committees there meet during parliamentary sitting time....
The Convener SNP Committee
03 Dec 2015
European Union Reform and Referendum
Thanks. I have a question for Helen Martin. I come from a trade union background and I realise that the social union part of the EU has created the working time directive and workplace rights on, for example, non-discrimination, equal pay, maternity leave and pension entitleme...
The Convener SNP Committee
04 Feb 2016
Human Rights
In gathering evidence, the committee has heard few, if any, dissenting voices when it comes to supporting the Human Rights Act 1998, but it has heard lots of evidence as to how the act should and could be extended. That is an interesting debate, although I fear that the same d...
The Convener SNP Committee
03 Mar 2016
Human Rights
Thank you, cabinet secretary. You took the words out of my mouth for my first question, because I have just seen some of the stuff from the Jimmy Reid Foundation. It reflects a lot of evidence that we have taken over the past few months, in as much as people are seeking to ext...
Christina McKelvie (Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse) (SNP) SNP Chamber
26 May 2016
Scotland’s Future in the European Union
Thank you, Presiding Officer. I welcome you to your new role in the chair. There is much about the EU debate that reminds me of Alice in “Through the Looking Glass” by Lewis Carroll: up is down and in is out. The two right-wing factions of one party fighting over who is more ...
The Convener SNP Committee
22 Sep 2016
Work Programme
As we can see, there are a lot of interesting and interested people around the table to hear from, and we are very keen to hear from you. Before I kick off with the first question, I should say that we had an informal breakfast this morning with some of the witnesses, who very...
The Convener SNP Committee
01 Jun 2017
Gypsy Traveller Community in Scotland
That is where I want to go with my question. The National Centre for Social Research briefing that we had with Professor John Curtice showed dramatic drops in prejudice towards lots of groups with protected characteristics, apart from those with mental health problems and Gyps...
The Convener SNP Committee
15 Jun 2017
Bullying and Harassment of Children and Young People in Schools
We are almost out of time for this panel, as we have a second panel to question. I have a quick question about the Girlguiding girls’ attitudes survey on an issue that I hope will be included in future scout surveys. What impact does bullying have on the mental or physical hea...
The Convener SNP Committee
28 Sep 2017
Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
What with Jamie Greene exercising his right to independence this morning and asking a different question from planned, we have one question outstanding.
The Convener SNP Committee
26 Oct 2017
Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
With the cabinet secretary are Eileen Flanagan, who is the equality policy manager at the Scottish Government; Lesley Cunningham, who is the gender equality policy officer; and Lucy Galloway, who is a solicitor. Good morning, and thank you for coming along to this final eviden...
The Convener SNP Committee
21 Dec 2017
Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
Agenda item 2 is the first of our two substantive items this morning: the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Bill. I welcome the Cabinet Secretary for Communities, Social Security and Equalities, Angela Constance, who is the minister in charge of the bill. Our a...
The Convener SNP Committee
08 Feb 2018
Historical Sexual Offences (Pardons and Disregards) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
That clears up that question in my head. My other question is for Police Scotland. In the conclusion to its submission, at paragraph 6.1, Police Scotland uses the term “victims”. I will read it so that the witnesses understand what I mean: “These processes, gathering and com...
The Convener SNP Committee
08 Mar 2018
UK Withdrawal from the European Union (Legal Continuity) (Scotland) Bill
I have a quick question, and then Alex Cole-Hamilton will have the final question. I know that you need to get to the other committee, Tobias. It is my understanding that losing the charter of fundamental rights will create significant gaps in human rights law, because it goe...
The Convener SNP Committee
19 Apr 2018
Human Rights and the Scottish Parliament
As a follow-up to that question, we should put the question to Judith Robertson about the powers that she has. I saw you nodding vigorously when Marie Anderson said that we could legislate, too, and I suspect that you meant “Please do it.” Will you give us a bit of insight int...
The Convener SNP Committee
19 Apr 2018
Human Rights and the Scottish Parliament
We will continue with our first agenda item, which is our inquiry into human rights and the Scottish Parliament. Our second panel this morning is larger than the first. We have a huge panel in a round-table format. To give a few rules of the round-table format, panel members s...
The Convener SNP Committee
10 May 2018
Human Rights and the Scottish Parliament
We will go on to Mary Fee’s other question. Are Dylan and Hannah ready with ideas on what to ask the cabinet secretary if they could ask her one question?
The Convener SNP Committee
17 May 2018
Historical Sexual Offences (Pardons and Disregards) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
We move on to stage 2 consideration of the Historical Sexual Offences (Pardons and Disregards) (Scotland) Bill. I welcome Michael Matheson, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, who joins us today as the minister in charge of the bill. I also welcome Stewart Stevenson, who is her...
The Convener SNP Committee
14 Jun 2018
Destitution, Asylum and Insecure Immigration Status
Eloise Nutbrown wanted to respond to Gail Ross’s question, but maybe she will address Alex Cole-Hamilton’s question, too.
The Convener SNP Committee
21 Jun 2018
Bullying and Harassment of Children and Young People in Schools
I am the convener of the committee. I thank all of you who have come back to see us; it is good to see you again. I welcome Katherine Botterill and Daniela Sime, as it is their first time at the committee. They have looked at prejudice-based bullying of minorities and other i...
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
26 Jun 2018
Scottish Parliament (Powers)
If Oliver Mundell were to look at the functioning of the Treaty on European Union he would know that all 27 nations are independent and have the choice to do whatever they like. They do not give sovereignty back to Brussels. We had 105 years of stuttering progress, but what ...
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
26 Jun 2019
Portfolio Question Time · Older People’s Services (Dumfries and Galloway Council)
That is a really interesting question, which, as Minister for Older People and Equalities, I take a huge interest in. We have an ageing population that will demand more services as we move through the next few years. On the specifics of Dumfries and Galloway and the progress ...
The Minister for Older People and Equalities (Christina McKelvie) SNP Chamber
14 Nov 2019
General Question Time · Survival Sex
It is absolutely disgraceful that women should have to resort to survival sex, as it is sometimes known—even the term makes my blood run cold—for their most basic needs such as food and shelter. It is a very complex issue; however, it is clear that already vulnerable women are...
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
14 Nov 2019
General Question Time · Survival Sex
It would have been nice if Maurice Golden had actually been in the chamber for the first question and understood how serious the issue is, instead of sitting there laughing like a child. Interruption. He is still rattling on. It is imperative that all powers that relate to so...
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
30 Jan 2020
Portfolio Question Time · Social Isolation and Loneliness (Highland)
I thank Edward Mountain for that follow-up question. He is absolutely right about the share what you love campaign and the importance of spending time with people. Members might have noticed this week that PG Tips, in co-ordination with Age UK, has a great social media campaig...
Christina McKelvie SNP Committee
20 Feb 2020
Budget Scrutiny 2020-21
You have touched on the crux of why I cannot sit in a silo. The work that I need to undertake with Ms Campbell around the work on the third sector that she does, as the budget holder for that bigger pot of money, is on how to bring about additionality and greater inclusion. Y...
The Minister for Older People and Equalities (Christina McKelvie) SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2020
Portfolio Question Time · Older People (Easing of Lockdown Measures)
That is another very important question, and I thank the member for it. The route map that was published by the First Minister on 21 May set out a phased approach to lifting lockdown measures, based on a balanced assessment of all the available evidence, with a clear emphasis ...
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
25 Jun 2020
Portfolio Question Time · Older People (Covid-19 Support and Guidance)
I thank Dean Lockhart for that multifaceted question. Some of the language can be confusing and hard to understand. We took early action to consult, and stakeholders have been involved in the production of many pieces of information that have gone out, whether in social media,...
The Minister for Older People and Equalities (Christina McKelvie) SNP Chamber
25 Jun 2020
Portfolio Question Time · Older People (Support)
I think that that might be Beatrice Wishart’s supplementary, rather than her main question.
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
25 Jun 2020
Portfolio Question Time · Covid-19 (Impact on Women)
That is an incredibly important question. As the recovery process progresses, equalities, fair work and wellbeing will remain at the heart of our approach. All our focus remains on controlling and suppressing the virus during phase 2 and into phase 3. There is a role for both ...
Christina McKelvie SNP Committee
25 Jun 2020
Covid-19: Impact on Equalities and Human Rights
It is a question of how we keep the balance right and how we maintain a public health response in relation to the fundamental right to life, keep people safe and have the powers and the measures to do that while understanding that they are a pretty blunt instrument to use in s...
Christina McKelvie SNP Committee
25 Jun 2020
Covid-19: Impact on Equalities and Human Rights
That is a really important question. Part of the work that we have done in Government has been through the public services hub—there are also hubs for economy and health. The public services hub is chaired by the Deputy First Minister. It includes me, Shirley-Anne Somerville, ...
Christina McKelvie SNP Chamber
03 Sep 2020
Portfolio Question Time · Race Equality Framework
That is an important question to kick off with. The programme with the John Smith Institute will be open to people from all minority ethnic backgrounds and all walks of life. It will provide opportunities for up to 50 participants to take up living-wage placements. The placeme...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 13 December 2018

13 Dec 2018 · S5 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Demonstrating Leadership in Human Rights
McKelvie, Christina SNP Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse Watch on SPTV

I can heartily give a commitment that all stakeholders who have an interest will take part in that consultation. I will certainly encourage them to do so, and I hope that Mr Sarwar will do so, too. Given all his networks and connections, I would be keen for that to happen.

The advisory group’s recommendations overlap with the findings of the Equalities and Human Rights Committee. There is an interest in how we can work closely with that committee. I am delighted that it is being steered with such capable hands, by Ruth Maguire. The human rights takeover, which happened in the chamber on Monday, was not just inspirational but motivational, and it has motivated me to do more.

It is clear that the landscape in Scotland is shifting. As we heard from Daniel Johnson, across the world, the landscape is shifting, although sometimes not in a positive way. People want to take hold of their human rights and see them increasingly realised in their lives rather than undermined. The Scottish Government is fully behind that shift. We will therefore work with the advisory group, the committee, the Parliament and wider society—anybody who should be making a contribution—on that. Gail Ross spoke about the commitment that the First Minister made to engage constructively with the recommendations in the reports from the advisory group and the committee.

In 1940, eight years before the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was adopted and while the world was still in the grip of war, HG Wells wrote the book “The Rights of Man”, in which he posed the question:

“What are we fighting for?”

Anas Sarwar reminded us what we are fighting for. He reminded us that racism, Islamophobia and other types of discrimination are prevalent in the world. There is also a gendered issue, so maybe the rights of women merit some attention, too. HG Wells’s question was aimed at drawing forth ideas from society about what kind of world should emerge and what is worth fighting for. As we debate human rights in Scotland today, it is useful to ask ourselves the same question. What are we fighting for? What is the vision of Scotland that we are working to bring about? Anas Sarwar gave us clear ideas about how we can end racism and discrimination. He said that there should be dialogue and not division, which was an absolutely perfect response to the question.

To respond to Jeremy Balfour, children educating their parents is very welcome, especially when it is daughters educating their fathers—I am sure that we all welcome that.

I am grateful for the contribution of Professor Alan Miller and the advisory group, and of the Equalities and Human Rights Committee through its human rights inquiry, in taking us forward and identifying practical steps that we need to take. I look forward to working with members from across the chamber to make that practical effort and to make it work.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Linda Fabiani) SNP
The next item of business is a debate on motion S5M-15126, in the name of Christina McKelvie, on demonstrating leadership in human rights. 14:38
The Minister for Older People and Equalities (Christina McKelvie) SNP
It gives me great pleasure to open this debate. As 2018 draws to a close, it is appropriate for the Parliament to reflect on the state of human rights not ju...
Oliver Mundell (Dumfriesshire) (Con) Con
Will the minister commit today to addressing all the issues that the UN rapporteur set out for the Scottish Government in relation to the social security sys...
Christina McKelvie SNP
Absolutely. We have taken seriously all the recommendations in Professor Alston’s report and we are looking at how we can give effect to them. We have also ...
Daniel Johnson (Edinburgh Southern) (Lab) Lab
I agree with the minister that fair work is very much a human right. Does she think that zero-hours contracts are compatible with that human rights-based vie...
Christina McKelvie SNP
The Scottish Government has a clear view on exploitative zero-hours contracts, so I think that the member and I would be in agreement on that point. The Gov...
Clare Adamson (Motherwell and Wishaw) (SNP) SNP
Section 2(e) of article 24 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child says that states parties should “ensure that all segments of society,...
Christina McKelvie SNP
I thank the member for her intervention and for her tireless work on the cross-party group. Promoting and ensuring the safety and wellbeing of children and y...
Christina McKelvie SNP
—and we are happy to support their amendment today. Laughter. It seems that I might have pre-empted Mr Cole-Hamilton. If he lets me finish, I might just make...
Annie Wells (Glasgow) (Con) Con
Monday 10 December was human rights day—the anniversary of the day in 1948 when the United Nations General Assembly adopted the Universal Declaration of Huma...
Daniel Johnson Lab
I agree with what Annie Wells said about the declaration. Does she agree that other international institutions are also important—for example, the European C...
Annie Wells Con
I absolutely agree, and the Scottish Conservatives are committed to the country remaining a signatory to the European convention on human rights. In 1950, t...
Mary Fee (West Scotland) (Lab) Lab
I am grateful for the opportunity to open this important debate for Scottish Labour. Scottish Labour is happy to support the Government motion and the Libera...
Oliver Mundell Con
I thank Mary Fee for giving that shout out to Lockerbie. Will she join me in welcoming the new changing places toilet at Johnstonebridge service station and ...
Mary Fee Lab
I absolutely welcome the progress that has been made in the provision of changing places toilets, and I congratulate the service station that Oliver Mundell ...
Alex Cole-Hamilton (Edinburgh Western) (LD) LD
I move the amendment in my name. I remind members of my entry in the register of members’ interests, which shows that I am a former convener of Together, the...
Daniel Johnson Lab
Does the member agree that honouring human rights and international institutions sometimes means doing what is uncomfortable but that it is always the right ...
Alex Cole-Hamilton LD
I absolutely agree with that. Doing the right thing is sometimes out of step with public opinion, but it is incumbent on us as legislators to lead public opi...
The Minister for Children and Young People (Maree Todd) SNP
I am pleased to reiterate, as I did earlier, that the Scottish Government recognises and respects the significance of the UN committee’s general comments as ...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
I remind the minister that interventions are not statements. Please wind up.
Maree Todd SNP
I am asking the member to agree that, particularly in the area of offending and criminal justice, we need to fully and carefully consider the implications—
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
Minister, please finish.
Alex Cole-Hamilton LD
I take the intervention in the spirit in which it is offered. It is an important point, and I agree with it. That is why I was delighted that, this morning, ...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
Please move your amendment, Mr Cole-Hamilton.
Alex Cole-Hamilton LD
I moved it at the start of my speech, Presiding Officer.
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
Do you want to argue?
Alex Cole-Hamilton LD
No. I move amendment S5M-15126.2, to insert at end: “, and welcomes the Scottish Government’s commitment to incorporate the UN Convention on the Rights of ...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
Thank you very much. 15:11
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green
I am delighted to speak in the debate. Largely, it is a consensual debate, and I align myself with many of the comments that have been made thus far. The min...
Gordon Lindhurst (Lothian) (Con) Con
I did not notice any Conservative member looking away at that point. The situation in Gaza is not that simple. What about the north of Israel, which is under...