Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green Chamber
11 Dec 2008
Climate Change (Communities)
That should be just long enough for the dulcet tones of Lord Foulkes to disappear from the back of the chamber.I thank the members who have stayed to participate in the debate and I thank those who supported the motion. I ask members to welcome to the public gallery the repres...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
14 Jan 2014
Draft Climate Change Adaptation Programme
It is probably fair to say that climate change adaptation often plays second fiddle to the mitigation agenda and the urgent need to reduce our emissions. That is true in relation to public perception, media coverage, political debate and institutional knowledge. To be fair, it...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie): Green Committee
11 Nov 2008
Climate Change Bill (Consultation)
Good afternoon, everybody, and welcome to the 21st meeting in 2008 of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee. We have received apologies from Shirley-Anne Somerville and Alison McInnes, and Alex Johnstone has notified us that he will be late for the meeting...
Patrick Harvie Green Committee
03 Mar 2026
Infrastructure Delivery Pipeline 2026
:I would like to ask the witnesses to reflect on a slightly different perspective. I think that you were here during the earlier part of the meeting and may have heard my questions to the Scottish Fiscal Commission about the economic and security risks that come from ecosystem...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
12 Jan 2011
“Report on Low Carbon Scotland: The Draft Report on Proposals and Policies”
I am happy to open the debate on behalf of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee and to discuss the report that the committee has published on the Government’s draft report on proposals and policies to reach the targets outlined in the Climate Change (Scot...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
14 May 2025
Oil and Gas Industry
When this Parliament passed its first piece of climate legislation, the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009, I warned that we had consensus on the destination but not on the actions that were necessary, and I have continued to say that. However, in recent months, it has become ...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green Chamber
17 Dec 2008
Budget Process 2009-10
I acknowledge the work that the Finance Committee's members and its team have put into the budget scrutiny process and I thank them for their report.Andrew Welsh talked about the two changes in economic context, to which we should all expect the Government to be able to respon...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
05 Jun 2024
Oil and Gas Industry
We are at a critical point in the transition—halfway to net zero—but that is largely as a result of the easy wins, especially the decarbonisation of electricity. Anyone with any credibility at all accepts the reality that change is needed. Outright climate denial is largely a...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
10 Oct 2024
Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I echo the thanks that other members have put on record to the committee, its clerks and others who have supported a rapid scrutiny process. However, across political parties, there has been a recognition that nobody really wants to be here. Nobody should be proud of the fact ...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
05 Nov 2024
Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I am glad that everyone is logged in in time for this last group—although, on this occasion, I do not think that it will do me much good. I want to take members back to the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009. In the passage of the bill that became that first climate act, 15 y...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green Chamber
13 Nov 2008
Energy Efficiency
Members of all parties have united in recognition of the contribution that Sarah Boyack has made over a long period to the debate on energy efficiency. She began her speech by calling for cross-party unity. If her motion remains unamended, I will certainly back it and I hope t...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
05 Nov 2024
Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill
First, I pay genuine tribute to Monica Lennon for making the choice to open her speech by recognising what we mean when we use jargon phrases such as “the climate emergency”. This is here and now, and it is life and death. Monica Lennon was quite right to remind us of that. T...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie): Green Committee
27 Jan 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Good afternoon. Welcome to the fourth meeting this year of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee. I remind everyone present that all mobile devices—phones, BlackBerrys, pagers and so on—should be switched off.There is just one item on the agenda for today'...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie): Green Committee
03 Mar 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Good afternoon and welcome to the eighth meeting in 2009 of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee. I remind members and everybody else present that all mobile devices should be switched off. We have received apologies from Alex Johnstone and from Shirley-A...
The Convener: Green Committee
10 Mar 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
This is the final evidence session in our stage 1 inquiry. We have heard from a large number of witnesses during the past six meetings. Today, we have the opportunity to put questions that have emerged from those discussions to the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Cl...
Patrick Harvie: Green Chamber
10 Dec 2009
Climate Change
I agree that that is possible, but I do not agree that it is guaranteed. Rob Gibson will remember that, in the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee, we have heard voices calling for, "More of everything, thank you." Some people have wanted more aviation, more...
Patrick Harvie: Green Chamber
10 Dec 2009
Climate Change
Perhaps it has been that kind of debate, but even though Des McNulty said that he would disagree with me, he then said things that I do not really disagree with. I welcome all the speeches that we have heard in the debate. Many have stressed the importance of the consensus, to...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
27 May 2010
Parliamentary Bureau Motions
Thank you, Presiding Officer.However, instead of acknowledging the consensus that is growing in the UK Government and other agencies, the Scottish Government is asking us to approve a multiplier of 1. Anyone who has as basic a grasp of arithmetic as I have knows that a multipl...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
01 Mar 2012
Climate Justice
When the Parliament united to pass the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009—a good piece of legislation that brought together all sides of the political debate to vote yes when it came to the moment—we did something that very few other jurisdictions had been able to do. “We—poli...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie): Green Committee
26 May 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
Good afternoon, everybody, and welcome to the 14th meeting this year of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee. I remind members, witnesses and everyone else present that all mobile phones and other devices should be switched off.We have no apologies to rec...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie): Green Committee
02 Jun 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
Good afternoon. If everybody is settled, we can proceed. Welcome to the 15th meeting this year of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee. I remind members and everybody else present that mobile devices should be switched off. We have received no apologies. ...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie): Green Committee
09 Jun 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
Good afternoon and welcome to the 16th meeting this year of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee. I remind members and everyone else that all mobile devices should be switched off. We have no apologies to record. I welcome Iain Smith, Sarah Boyack and Lew...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green Chamber
24 Jun 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill
What can I say to Cathy Peattie, other than "Congratulations"?John Swinney began his remarks by offering thanks to those who have well earned them, and it would be wrong for me to begin in any other way. I thank my fellow members of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Ch...
The Minister for Zero Carbon Buildings, Active Travel and Tenants’ Rights (Patrick Harvie) Green Chamber
07 Oct 2021
Heat in Buildings Strategy
Today, we publish Scotland’s heat in buildings strategy and, with it, we mark a significant step towards bringing to an end the contribution that heating our homes and buildings makes to climate change. The ambition that is set out in the strategy is significant, and rightly s...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
27 Feb 2020
Budget (Scotland) (No 4) Bill: Stage 1
No, thank you. It needs to be a climate emergency budget, and the ground-breaking proposal for free bus travel for everyone aged 18 and younger will make a massive difference. Some students in Scotland are paying upwards of £1,000 a year just to get to college. A student trav...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green Chamber
10 Dec 2009
Climate Change
I am sure that the Parliament will, as the minister has called on us to do, endorse the motion that he has moved. I do not disagree with a word of it, and I agree with and welcome much of what he said in his speech.However, I lodged my amendment because there is an important q...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
24 Nov 2011
United Nations Climate Summit
It is clear that the political significance attached to climate change has come a very long way since previous decades when the Greens, who had been campaigning on such issues for many years, were dismissed as eccentrics. Now only those who live in denial, who indulge in consp...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
01 Mar 2012
Climate Justice
Ah, consensual debates. Don’t you love them, Presiding Officer? Maybe sometimes. We should probably admit that we have a bit more fun with a good old-fashioned argument in the chamber, but the debates in which we unite on a piece of text, and in which we all agree consensually...
The Minister for Zero Carbon Buildings, Active Travel and Tenants’ Rights (Patrick Harvie) Green Chamber
28 Nov 2023
Heat in Buildings
The climate crisis is, of course, the greatest challenge of our age. Scotland has halved its emissions since 1990, but the most challenging part of the journey lies ahead. The First Minister and the Cabinet Secretary for Transport, Net Zero and Just Transition will be at the 2...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
26 Nov 2025
Oil and Gas
No. I do not have time. My real worry at the moment is that the Tory and Labour position—the new antagonism to any kind of credible climate policy—not only is bad in its own right and harmful in indulging the interests of the fossil fuel industry and rebooting climate denial,...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green Chamber
14 Jun 2007
Carbon Offsetting
We initiated the debate as the beginning of a discussion about this complex issue and I am grateful to all members who have engaged constructively in that conversation, not least Nigel Don. I am sorry that he has just left the chamber, because he made a thought-provoking speec...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
12 Jan 2011
“Report on Low Carbon Scotland: The Draft Report on Proposals and Policies”
I am sorry that I will not have time to respond to all the members who made points in the debate.The minister began her opening speech by emphasising the social and economic benefits that can be achieved as we reduce our emissions. She was quite right about that, and what she ...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Committee
29 Oct 2024
Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
Good morning. As a non-member of the committee, I will speak to my own amendment and leave members of the committee to comment on the other amendments in the group. Amendment 60 is not grouped with amendment 17, which will come up later, but it touches on a similar issue, and...
The Convener: Green Committee
20 Jan 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Item 2 is an evidence session on the Climate Change (Scotland) Bill. This is the first of many evidence sessions. We will be hearing today from Scottish Government officials and the bill team. It is expected that we will continue to take evidence until some time in March, at w...
The Convener Green Committee
22 Feb 2011
“Public Bodies Climate Change Duties: Putting Them Into Practice” and “A Low Carbon Economic Strategy for Scotland”
The next item gives us an opportunity to take evidence from the Minister for Environment and Climate Change, Roseanna Cunningham, on two documents: “Public Bodies Climate Change Duties: Putting Them Into Practice” and “A Low Carbon Economic Strategy for Scotland”. I welcome th...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie): Green Committee
06 Jan 2009
National Planning Framework
Good afternoon, everybody. I welcome you all to the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee's first meeting this year and I wish everybody a happy new year. I remind members and everybody else that all mobile phones and other mobile devices should be switched of...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
09 Jun 2010
Active Travel
Clearly, the time indication that I was given was purely informal and I should be more careful in future.I thank my fellow committee members, the clerks and colleagues from the Scottish Parliament information centre who contributed to the production of the report, as well as t...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green Chamber
24 Jun 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
After working on the Climate Change (Scotland) Bill for so many months, I am gratified that, throughout the process, the debate has been characterised by an almost universal acceptance that our approach to climate change must be science led and based on an acceptance of the ur...
Patrick Harvie: Green Chamber
24 Jun 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
During stage 1, the committee heard clear evidence—albeit that there was a range of views, there was broad agreement on the principle—that aviation and shipping emissions should be included in the bill. It was also agreed that aviation emissions have a disproportionate impact ...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie): Green Committee
05 Feb 2008
Climate Change
Good afternoon. I welcome everyone to the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee's third meeting this year. We have apologies from Charlie Gordon. As usual, I remind everyone that mobile phones and other mobile devices should be switched off.We have just one ag...
The Convener: Green Committee
09 Jun 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
I welcome the amendments from Iain Smith and the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. The emphasis on energy efficiency in recent years has increased slowly but steadily to the point at which broad agreement has been reached—as it was in the Transport, Infrastructure and Cli...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie) Green Committee
07 Dec 2010
Decision on Taking Business in Private
Welcome to the 25th meeting in 2010 of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee. Mobile devices should be switched off. Apologies have been received from Jackson Carlaw, Alison McInnes and Cathy Peattie. Alasdair Allan expects to be here but has let us know t...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
27 May 2025
Community-owned Energy
What a pleasure to follow that. This has been an interesting balance of constructive debate, consensus and some disagreement. Alex Rowley, Michael Matheson and Emma Harper were among the many members who very clearly expressed the connection between the infrastructure challe...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
29 Jun 2011
Taking Scotland Forward: Infrastructure and Capital Investment
I realised that this would be a depressing debate for a Green to take part in. Thankfully, my pain will last for only three minutes instead of four.I welcome the cabinet secretary to his new role much more enthusiastically than I welcome his transgression yesterday. I point ou...
Patrick Harvie Green Committee
03 Mar 2026
Infrastructure Delivery Pipeline 2026
:We will not get into a philosophical debate now about the definition of or what counts as infrastructure, but I suggest that, around the world, we are continuing to effectively wipe out the pollinators that we depend on for our food system. If a tech bro came along saying, “I...
The Convener: Green Committee
03 Feb 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Item 2 is continuation of our scrutiny at stage 1 of the Climate Change (Scotland) Bill. This is our third evidence-taking session on the bill. Today, we will hear from two panels of representatives of the Stop Climate Chaos Coalition. We expect to continue taking evidence on ...
The Convener (Patrick Harvie): Green Committee
06 Oct 2009
Climate Change (Employment and Workplaces Impact)
Good afternoon. I welcome everyone to the 22nd meeting this year of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee. I record that we have apologies from Alex Johnstone and that Lewis Macdonald MSP has joined us as an observer at today's meeting. I remind everyone p...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green Chamber
14 Jan 2009
Budget (Scotland) (No 2) Bill: Stage 1
There are many reasons why Greens might choose to criticise and oppose the budget as it stands. As the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee discovered, this is a business-as-usual budget. At a time when we face economic crisis, climate crisis and impending en...
The Convener: Green Committee
27 Jan 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Will the witnesses say a little more about the contribution that aviation emissions make to climate change? Beyond the volume of greenhouse gases that are emitted from aviation, a number of different multipliers are used to determine the impact of aviation on the climate and o...
The Convener: Green Committee
03 Feb 2009
Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I will begin with a couple of questions about the science. The scientific basis for the Climate Change (Scotland) Bill is the reports of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and the United Kingdom Committee on Climate Change. Is the Scottish Government using the most ...
The Convener Green Committee
30 Nov 2010
Draft Budget Scrutiny 2011-12
As there are no further comments on the question of fares versus public funding, we will move on to talk about the wider climate change aspects of the budget. Obviously, the transport questions include a climate change element and climate change, as a topic, will include some ...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Committee
12 Mar 2014
Procurement Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
I would first like to address the more general point that Alex Johnstone made about the previous group of amendments in respect of issues that he perceives as seeking to hijack the bill and make it“act as a proxy for ... other political priorities”,as Mr Johnstone put it. I in...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
27 May 2010
Climate Change (Annual Targets) (Scotland) Order 2010 (Draft)
Since we passed the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009 almost a year ago, the First Minister and others have been very happy to strut the world’s stage, casting themselves as the world leaders on climate change and talking about the consensus that was built up on the 42 per ce...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
13 Sep 2012
Electricity Market Reform
I understand the minister’s desire for a motion that would give rise to a consensual approach to renewables, and I am grateful to him for agreeing to some minor changes to his motion, particularly for removing explicit support for the principles of EMR and a reference to inves...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
19 Dec 2013
Draft Budget 2014-15
I extend my thanks to the Finance Committee for its work in producing the report and bringing it to the chamber. First, I will say a few words on the national performance framework. Members of the Scottish Green Party have probably been boring members over the years with spee...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green Chamber
16 Sep 2020
Sustainable Aviation beyond Covid-19
Thank you, Presiding Officer; I am happy to accept any apology for that comment. I also thank you for your recognition that working from home, where we can do so, remains the default. I am happy to take part in the debate on those terms. I am grateful to Colin Smyth for bringi...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
26 Sep 2023
Climate Emergency
No, thank you. The Prime Minister spoke about being honest with the public, then proceeded to knock down straw men in his hunger to generate a climate culture war. As I was listening to that speech, I lost count of the number of entirely non-existent policies that he reeled...
Patrick Harvie Green Chamber
26 Sep 2023
Climate Emergency
Completely. The language and the anti-environment rhetoric that the UK Government uses is undermining people’s belief that we can move forward on this together. We also do not control large-scale insulation programmes such as ECO4 and the warm homes discount, which has now be...
Patrick Harvie Green Committee
29 Oct 2024
Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
We are coming to the end of stage 2, so I promise not to keep the committee very long, but I would like to go back to the debates in 2009 on the first climate change legislation. As it happens, the amendment sessions took place in this room and I was sitting where you are, con...
Patrick Harvie Green Committee
10 Jun 2025
Food Standards Scotland
Good morning to the witnesses. Heather Kelman was just talking about the issues that will be included in the consultation on the development of the new strategy, and I was very pleased to hear the commitment that there will be greater emphasis on climate and sustainability. Th...
← Back to list
Chamber

Plenary, 11 Dec 2008

11 Dec 2008 · S3 · Plenary
Item of business
Climate Change (Communities)
That should be just long enough for the dulcet tones of Lord Foulkes to disappear from the back of the chamber.

I thank the members who have stayed to participate in the debate and I thank those who supported the motion. I ask members to welcome to the public gallery the representatives of projects that have successfully bid for money from the climate challenge fund.

I am often given to comment on the status that climate change has achieved on the political agenda over the years. When I was a lad, I was taken along by my mum to various environmental demonstrations. I am pleased to say that she still goes to environmental demonstrations. It is fair to say that, in those days, climate change and other issues that were being raised by the environment movement were sometimes portrayed as being on the fringes of the political agenda.

However, over not only the short span of my life, but the decades since the concept of climate change first came to the awareness of scientists, we have reached the point at which the few who deny the issue, who deny the reality of the problem and who deny the serious impact that it will have on lives and economies around the planet are now portrayed as the fringe eccentrics on the edges of the issue. It has taken a long time to reach that point and it has taken a lot of work, not only by politicians but by communities and activists at community level. We are now at the point when ministers are asked questions about climate change every week in this Parliament; they have to respond and take the issue seriously.

We have reached the point at which the secretary-general of the United Nations, Ban Ki-moon, today addressed the delegates at Poznan and called for a new climate revolution—in fact, for "a new Copernican revolution". That is how profound the issue is. Global solidarity is needed on climate change, which is the defining challenge of our era. Mr Ban argues that if banks are too big to fail, so is the climate. That is something on which we can all now agree, although there might not have been such agreement even a few short years ago.

We Greens have played our part constructively, not just here but around the world, although we certainly do not pretend that we are the only people to have done so. Other people in other political movements have done so, and people have played their parts in their own communities. We will continue to challenge the Government sometimes, issuing our criticisms as we did yesterday when we considered the strategic transport projects review. Criticism on its own is not enough, however, even when Governments fall short. It is necessary also to promote positive ideas about what can be achieved. That is the approach that we took to last year's budget negotiations, when we asked for the establishment of the climate challenge fund, which has presented an opportunity for communities to bid and to set their own agendas.

Although consensus has developed on climate change, something has fallen between the cracks. We have spoken about the relationship between Government, business and individuals. Who needs to play their part? Where does the balance of responsibility for climate change lie? It has been forgotten for a long time that, between Government, individuals and business, communities can collectively play a far more powerful role than any of us can individually. Cutting emissions directly is one thing, but communities can also set their own agendas and priorities. Different solutions will be appropriate in different towns and villages and in different parts of a city. The issues might be around food production, transport, buildings or lifestyle. People have a host of choices and opportunities.

If the Government simply comes along, wags the finger and tells communities how things are going to be, however, it risks its approach being rejected. The Government allowing communities to set their own agendas, and providing a little bit of extra financial support can help to create a can-do spirit. That is what communities can do, which individual action—however important—cannot do on its own. With that can-do spirit, relationships can be built at community level, which can generate all sorts of spin-off benefits, whether in social justice or in economic wellbeing—which means so much more than mere growth, of course.

In many ways, we face a pretty frightening time with the so-called triple crunch. We are facing an economic crisis, a climate crisis and an impending energy crisis—all three at once. Those are the consequences of generations of unsustainable politics and economics. They might be unprecedented challenges, but there are unprecedented opportunities, too. Creative solutions are available, not just for tackling climate change, but for working towards the concept of a sustainable community.

The Transition Network Ltd is one of the organisations that have benefited from the climate challenge fund. It is the inheritor of a set of ideas—a holistic sense—about what sustainable communities are. Over the years, we are going to have to build in concepts not just of low-carbon living but of resilience and self-reliance. If the climate crisis, the energy crisis and the economic crisis play out as some of us fear, the communities that will prosper and thrive, and which will be able to maintain wellbeing, will be those that can meet their needs locally. That might mean local food production, which the Toryglen gardening club is exploring. Other projects have benefited from the climate challenge fund.

I asked ministers recently whether they are aware of the land share concept: the idea that those who have spare land that is not being used can turn it into something productive and an asset for a community. That is very much what the folk in Toryglen are doing. They are working with churches, housing schemes and a host of people who can provide a little bit of land. That land can be the catalyst not just for producing food locally and cutting carbon emissions, but for bringing people together with their common interests—despite the frightening economic crisis.

I hope that members will refer to various projects around the country that are benefiting from the scheme and that are creating benefits for the communities that they serve. I have circulated to all members a map that shows where projects are around the country. There are many more of them in the pipeline.

In closing, I will mention Des McNulty's members' business debate next week, on the subject of eco-congregations. I am aware that the eco-congregations network is now a huge network of projects around the country. I hope that the network is positively considering the opportunities that the climate challenge fund offers.

I again thank members and the many activists from around Scotland who are making things happen. Without that, policies are worth very little.

I invite anyone who wishes to join us to committee room 4 for a little drink at the end of the debate.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Trish Godman): Lab
The final item of business today is a members' business debate on motion S3M-2991, in the name of Patrick Harvie, on communities leading on climate change. T...
Motion debated,
That the Parliament congratulates the community groups around Scotland, such as the Toryglen Gardening Club in Glasgow, that have made successful application...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green
That should be just long enough for the dulcet tones of Lord Foulkes to disappear from the back of the chamber.I thank the members who have stayed to partici...
Shirley-Anne Somerville (Lothians) (SNP): SNP
I thank Patrick Harvie for securing this debate on community action on climate change, which provides a timely reminder of the important role that communitie...
Alex Johnstone (North East Scotland) (Con): Con
I thank Patrick Harvie for bringing to my attention the work of the Toryglen gardening club, of which I was unaware. However, I have been concerned about the...
Robin Harper (Lothians) (Green): Green
I congratulate Patrick Harvie on bringing the motion to the chamber. At the outset, I say to Alex Johnstone that he spoke of the Tory gardening club, rather ...
Margaret Curran (Glasgow Baillieston) (Lab): Lab
I, too, thank Patrick Harvie for bringing the matter to the chamber for debate. I congratulate all those who are with us this evening who have participated i...
The Minister for Environment (Michael Russell): SNP
I suppose that, in the spirit of the debate, I should thank Patrick Harvie's mother for creating the circumstances in which this debate has come about. I als...
Meeting closed at 17:36.