Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
01 Nov 2005
Budget Process 2006-07
It is a delight to be here this afternoon to consider the transport elements of the draft budget for 2006-07. I have some brief comments to make, which I hope will be of assistance to the committee in its assessment of the transport portfolio.The draft budget document for 2006...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
12 Sep 2006
Transport and Works<br />(Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I am grateful to the committee for adjusting its timetable today. I am going to meet our colleagues on the Local Government and Transport Committee later this morning, which is why I have to move on. I welcome the opportunity to share my thoughts on the bill and on the Procedu...
Tavish Scott (Shetland) (LD): LD Chamber
14 Sep 2000
Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I am always grateful that Kenny MacAskill does not have to fly home to his constituency—the whining would carry on long after the plane engines had been switched off.The Liberal Democrats very much support the Transport (Scotland) Bill, which is a further step towards the Scot...
The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
16 Mar 2006
Public Transport Projects
When I took office as Minister for Transport and Telecommunications, I took responsibility for the greatest sustained investment in Scotland's transport system in decades. Transport spending has increased substantially since devolution. In 1999, transport spending was £345 mil...
The Deputy Minister for Finance and Public Service Reform (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
29 Jun 2005
Transport (Scotland) Bill
This devolved Government is committed to transforming transport delivery and transport infrastructure throughout Scotland. We believe that Scotland needs and deserves a transport infrastructure that is comparable with the best in Europe. We want a future where others look to u...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
19 Sep 2006
Subordinate Legislation
I am pleased to be here, and I hope that the ministerial colleague whom you mentioned earlier was opening the cheque book. I am happy to talk about the Shetland and the Dumfries and Galloway transfer orders together; it will be helpful to do so because they are similar in effe...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
06 Sep 2006
Bus Industry (Accountability)
This has been a useful debate that reflects the quite understandable concern about bus services that exists across the chamber and throughout Scotland. I acknowledge Pauline McNeill's leadership of the debate and the fact that members of all parties, except the one that collea...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
21 Mar 2007
Park-and-Ride Sites (South Edinburgh)
I welcome this evening's debate and thank Mike Pringle for raising the name of David Begg. David Begg taught me economics some years ago—and I will not take any intervention from Mr McLetchie on that. David Begg was always entertaining as a lecturer and I still find his contri...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
21 Feb 2006
Subordinate Legislation
I hope that I will not delay colleagues too long.I am pleased to lay before the committee this order, which will ensure the smooth transfer of the functions of Strathclyde Passenger Transport Authority and Strathclyde Passenger Transport Executive to the new west of Scotland t...
The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
01 Mar 2006
Tolled Bridges Review
I begin by dealing with the points that have just been raised. I regret that information was placed in the public domain and am as angry as anyone that Parliament has been shown such a discourtesy. I deprecate those leaks, if that is indeed what has happened. It is not in the ...
The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
26 Jan 2006
Thistle Travel Card Scheme
Parliament sometimes affords publicity to issues that need it; at times it affords publicity to issues that arguably do not need it. This debate is certainly a good example of our ability—in particular, Jackie Baillie's ability—to use Parliament to bring an important issue to ...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
10 Jan 2007
Bring Back our Buses Campaign
I was just thinking about how I could work in the interisland ferry home to Bressay. After Mr Ewing's speech, it is clear that I would have no difficulty in doing that.I will respond to the debate that Colin Fox has sponsored on the provision of local bus services. Members hav...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
25 Oct 2006
Freight Transport Inquiry
I welcome the opportunity to discuss and debate freight issues, which this country must confront. A range of views have been expressed by members of all parties. I acknowledge Bristow Muldoon's role as the convener of the Local Government and Transport Committee and that of Mi...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
03 Oct 2006
Transport and Works (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
It is important to recognise that there has been a positive response to the bill. We all recognise the benefits of removing transport projects from the private bills process, particularly those of us who have sat on private bill committees.One of the key considerations behind ...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
08 Feb 2007
Transport and Works (Scotland) Bill
Parliament recognises that transport is fundamental to our society and to having a socially just and economically vibrant Scotland. We have driven forward changes to transform transport delivery and transport infrastructure across the country. We have created regional transpor...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
29 Jun 2005
Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I never split hairs over Mr Ewing's arguments—I just pick large holes in them.I thank Mr Ewing for explaining his amendment. We fully support the principle that the transport agency should consider sustainable economic growth while carrying out its functions, but we think that...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
03 Oct 2006
Transport and Works (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I am sorry; I should not mislead the committee. It is not the reporter's job to do what I expect Transport Scotland to do on the capital transport programme, which it will do whoever is minister for transport. It is Transport Scotland's job to ensure that the business case on ...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
08 Feb 2007
School Transport Safety
I welcome the chance to make a brief speech in the debate. I acknowledge the cross-party support for the motion that was initiated by Maureen Watt on the importance of school transport safety and give the assurance that many members have requested that we will stress to the De...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
21 Feb 2007
Subordinate Legislation
Convener, thank you for arranging today's meeting. I apologise that I was unable to be present yesterday. I appreciate that that was an inconvenience to the committee and probably a darn pest, but I had to be in Shetland for the funeral of the neighbouring farmer on the island...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
28 Mar 2007
Railways
Given that I have no stations in my constituency I, unlike others in this end-of-season debate, cannot be parochial about rail, which is probably just as well. I accept members' concerns and their desire to do more on rail and to see more improvements and a better rail network...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
13 Jun 2006
Subordinate Legislation
The Public Transport Users' Committee for Scotland Order 2006 (SSI 2006/250) is to establish the public transport users committee for Scotland, while the Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc (Scotland) Act 2003 (Treatment of Public Transport Users' Committee for Scotland ...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
21 Feb 2007
Transport (North-east Scotland)
I am delighted to respond to the debate, which has been secured by Nora Radcliffe, on transport in the north-east. Participants in transport debates tend to be divided into those of us who believe that there is much that we can do that is positive and those who believe that we...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
24 Oct 2006
Budget Process 2007-08
In opening proceedings, I will reflect on several transport issues, but I note at the outset that only two substantial changes have been made to the budget, both of which relate to transfers. If that is of interest, we can deal with it.The Government's transport policies have ...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
21 Jun 2006
Highland Transport Links
I am grateful that Mr Ewing is adopting my approach to the matter, which is to have a national transport strategy. If the Scottish National Party is doing that as well, I applaud that. We are objectively considering the important priorities for transport links throughout Scotl...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
27 Sep 2006
Glasgow Crossrail
All I can remember about 1973 is that it was the year in which Scotland qualified for the football world cup in West Germany.I am from the Charlie Gordon school of politics. I am not in the same party as him, but I am from the school of politics that says that we are here to m...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
09 May 2006
Freight Transport Inquiry
That is not an unfair question.The national transport strategy—the consultation on the strategy is currently going on—will represent the blueprint and all other documents will sit below it. I am sure that you accept that a national transport strategy has component parts. Freig...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
21 Sep 2006
Elgin Bypass
I thank Maureen Macmillan for the thoughtful way in which she introduced this evening's debate. I also thank Richard Lochhead, David Petrie and Eleanor Scott for their speeches, much of which I agreed with. I have one or two thoughts on them that I would like to share.I drove ...
The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
15 Nov 2005
Subordinate Legislation
Thank you. I will do my best to hurtle through my remarks.I am very pleased to be able to bring the draft order before the committee. Parliament gave a clear welcome to the Executive's proposals for regional transport partnerships when it voted through the Transport (Scotland)...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
15 Nov 2005
Subordinate Legislation
This is the final legislative stage of delivering our commitment in the 2004 white paper on transport to transfer the relevant rail powers of SPT to Scottish ministers. In late 2004, Parliament approved the Scotland Act 1998 section 30 order, which provided the required legisl...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
29 Mar 2006
Edinburgh Tram (Line One) Bill
As I made absolutely clear in my statement on major public transport projects, we will fund what is now in front of us—that is, the tram network between Leith and the airport—but that is dependent on the business case. That is our position.Parliament is aware of the importance...
Tavish Scott (Shetland) (LD): LD Chamber
11 May 2000
Telecommunications
I am grateful to Nick Johnston for clarifying the Conservative front-bench situation. For a terrible moment, those of us who enjoy transport and the environment debates thought Murray Tosh had been demoted to the back benches. We are gratified to hear that this is just a tempo...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
19 Jan 2006
Air Route Development Fund
Members from across the parties have made good speeches in this positive and thoroughly enjoyable debate. A debate in which Fergus Ewing and Phil Gallie agree on so much is rare. I enjoyed several speeches, particularly Kenny MacAskill's withering demolition of the Greens, whi...
Tavish Scott (Shetland) (LD): LD Chamber
24 May 2000
National Parks (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
In October this year I will have been married for 10 years, but I will not be asking Fergus Ewing to remind me of that fact.I broadly welcome this bill and the remarks that all members, particularly those on the front benches of all parties, have made, which were constructive....
The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
09 May 2006
Disability Inquiry
Yes. First, I apologise for being late. Various modes of transport held me up this morning, as did the fact that our capital city's airport was about as busy as it gets at 10 to 9 on the average weekday morning.With your agreement, I will announce some positions that are relev...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
23 Nov 2006
Airdrie-Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill: Preliminary Stage
Mr Purvis has made an important point. I understand that he recently met the Deputy Minister for Communities to discuss that matter with respect to this and other capital transport projects. We are considering the appropriate level of home-loss payments for Scotland and will c...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
12 Dec 2006
Transport and Works (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
I will speak first to my amendments in the group. I will then speak to Donald Gorrie's amendments.Amendments 21 and 24 are technical amendments. Amendment 21 seeks to clarify, for the avoidance of doubt, that the Parliament will be informed of all orders that are made under pa...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
09 May 2006
Freight Transport Inquiry
Because ports are so essential to the development of Scotland plc, ports policy should be part of our national transport strategy. My officials sometimes get a bit fed up with me about this, but if I have one concern, it is that we have too much strategy and not enough action ...
The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
15 Mar 2006
Community Transport<br />(Banff and Buchan)
I met officials of the concessionary scheme today, so I can assure Christine Grahame that as long as the application for her card has been received, she should receive the card by the end of next week. I will personally look into where her card is and ensure that it is taken c...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
28 Mar 2007
Airdrie-Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill
Such a young Parliament, so many historic events. I pay tribute to Phil Gallie's years of public service. I understand that he was with Cunninghame District Council for four years, during which time—my good friend and colleague Cathy Jamieson tells me—he was affectionately kno...
Tavish Scott (Shetland Islands) (LD) LD Chamber
13 Nov 2013
Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure
I make the point to Alex Johnstone that when Sarah Boyack became the first transport minister under devolution, she did not inherit a transport policy, but a roads policy. Such was the nature of policy at the time; previous London Governments with responsibility for transport ...
Tavish Scott (Shetland) (LD): LD Chamber
01 Jun 2000
Borders Rail Link
That was a good fundamentalist speech from Alex Neil. It contrasted with Mike Russell's gradualist speech, which is presumably why he has gone. I thought Mike Russell had gone to sort out whether this is priority No 1, No 2 or No 3, but it is now obvious that he left because h...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
29 Jun 2005
Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
We made it clear during stage 2 that staff relations are critical to the success of any organisation and that we should do everything possible to ensure that staff employment rights are protected during a period of change. That is what section 13 is all about; it ensures that ...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
26 Oct 2006
Climate Change (Road Traffic)
The Greens are again crying, moaning, whingeing and groaning. When we do something positive, they still do that.The challenge is to investigate new fuel-production technologies—clean fuels and hydrogen, for example, must be investigated. The north-east Scotland transport partn...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
15 Mar 2006
Community Transport<br />(Banff and Buchan)
I understand Mr Robson's point about schemes such as Berwickshire Wheels. We need to encourage such schemes and think about how we can expand them. We must look to the methods and mechanisms that have worked in particular parts of Scotland, such as Mr Robson's constituency, to...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
15 Mar 2006
Community Transport<br />(Banff and Buchan)
I recognise the point that Mr Stevenson is making and, in a moment, I will deal with what we can do in the future. However, no minister or taxpayer can ignore the financial consequences of the national concessionary travel scheme. In the next financial year, this Government is...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
15 Nov 2005
Subordinate Legislation
We will do that through the different bodies. There are capital transport investment projects under way—we have discussed them with the committee before and will do so again—that are clearly strategic and, in many ways, of pan-Scotland significance. At the moment, the voluntar...
The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
09 May 2006
Freight Transport Inquiry
l am delighted to be here today in this lovely, cool committee room that I can see you are all basking in. It is slightly warmer in Edinburgh than it was in Glasgow an hour ago. I am happy to be here, having experienced a little freight traffic on the way through.I strongly we...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
22 Nov 2006
Transport and Works (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
"Ho, ho, ho" is the obvious answer to that.I thank the members who have spoken in the debate, who have been thoughtful and constructive in bringing a degree of consensus to our deliberations. We have been open about the reason for our proposals and our purpose of improving our...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
15 Nov 2004
Budget Process 2005-06
I have a couple of observations to make on what Mr Brocklebank has said. First, the forthcoming Transport (Scotland) Bill, which will undergo financial scrutiny by the committee as well as the normal process of parliamentary scrutiny, will create transport partnerships. It str...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
30 Jun 1999
Remit
As a councillor, I was on the transport committee in Shetland, and I spend rather a lot of time on a variety of means of transport, getting to the central belt. I endorse what Helen said about a rail link to Edinburgh airport as I have a vested interest in that.We need to brea...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
14 Sep 2000
Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I accept Euan Robson's points about the need for a Borders rail link, its integration with other forms of transport and how that should be tackled by the different local authorities in the areas through which the railway would go. There is also a difficulty with integration in...
The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications (Tavish Scott): LD Chamber
15 Dec 2005
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Regional Transport Partnerships
The four voluntary regional transport partnerships have been delivering public transport improvements in their regions over the past few years. We are building on their success by developing the seven statutory regional transport partnerships that were established on 1 Decembe...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
17 May 2006
Aberdeen Crossrail
I will do that once I have dealt with the issue that members raised—one of them was the member who raised the point of order. I know that she does not want to hear this, but she will just have to sit there and take it.Road Sense is a campaign body that should admit that its re...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
22 Nov 2006
Transport and Works (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I certainly recognise the concerns that Nora Radcliffe has expressed. It is important to recognise—as, in fairness, members did during stage 1—that the introduction of such railways can potentially have the same impact on people in a locality and that, therefore, such people s...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
13 Dec 2007
Local Government Finance Settlement 2008 to 2011
Over the years, many Liberal Democrats and Liberals have studied land value taxation. It is a shame that Donald Gorrie is no longer a member of the Parliament because he could have delivered an eight-minute speech on that without repetition, deviation or hesitation. I must ask...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
15 Nov 2004
Budget Process 2005-06
I will make a couple of financial points at the outset. We now have three-year budgeting, of course, which those of us who were in local government before we were elected to the Parliament and who sat through a number of years of having settlements imposed on us at the last po...
Tavish Scott: LD Chamber
21 Mar 2007
Park-and-Ride Sites (South Edinburgh)
I am interested in and will closely consider any proposal from the private sector to assist us with heavy rail, light rail or transport investment in general. I have no ideological objection to considering such proposals.Dublin's light rail tram system, Luas, is washing its fa...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
12 Sep 2006
Transport and Works<br />(Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Yes. There will be stronger scrutiny of Government proposals for road and harbour developments. Most of us have been here for seven years and we know how the process of scrutiny has operated. I argue strongly that we are enhancing Parliament's ability to monitor proposals for ...
The Minister for Transport (Tavish Scott): LD Committee
11 Sep 2006
Airdrie-Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill: Preliminary Stage
First, convener, it is a delight to be here. We have just been discussing who Sir John Wilson was and the origins of this hall, which is named after him. We talked to some local people and gathered that he was a famous man in these parts. All that has given me two seconds to t...
Tavish Scott: LD Committee
09 May 2006
Freight Transport Inquiry
I accept that encouraging individuals to make a better choice about using public transport is advantageous to movement on our highways and to tackling the strategic congestion pinchpoints in the network. As Minister for Transport and Telecommunications, I have always said that...
← Back to list
Committee

Local Government and Transport Committee, 01 Nov 2005

01 Nov 2005 · S2 · Local Government and Transport Committee
Item of business
Budget Process 2006-07
It is a delight to be here this afternoon to consider the transport elements of the draft budget for 2006-07. I have some brief comments to make, which I hope will be of assistance to the committee in its assessment of the transport portfolio.The draft budget document for 2006-07 has been presented with some minor changes. The rationale behind most of those changes has been to highlight the key programme spending plans that will become the responsibility of the new transport agency. We have sought to provide as much clarity around that as we can. We have also taken into consideration some of the recommendations that the committee noted when the then Minister for Transport appeared before the committee to discuss stage 2 of last year's draft budget. Efficient government savings have been identified in the transport portfolio, and my team has been working with delivery partners to ensure that those savings are realised and delivered during the 2004 spending review period.The spending review process will enable us to look forward to future years of spending and to focus on priorities and key spending areas in transport. In simplistic terms, I want to ensure that I get everything that I can from the use of public money. Therefore, our priorities for delivery during the 2006-07 financial year are as follows. We wish to invest to maintain the momentum of our 10-year transport investment plan and our commitment to spend around £3 billion on transport capital infrastructure projects and service improvements over that period. As you know, I will also complete a review of transport capital projects in the next few weeks.We wish to maintain and improve Scotland's existing rail and trunk road networks. We wish to invest in public transport service improvements by, for example, promoting integrated ticketing, delivering a better deal for rail passengers in the new franchise and introducing a new bus route development fund—all better outputs for passengers across Scotland. We wish to extend the benefits of concessionary travel by introducing national schemes—one for older and disabled people, the other for younger people—and we need to ensure the delivery of our partnership agreement commitments to create the new transport agency for Scotland and a network of new regional transport partnerships.We want to ensure that, as one of the cross-cutting themes in Government, sustainable development and the environment are considered as part of transport spending. There is, in short, a two-part process. The first part is the work that my department is currently undertaking in relation to the national transport strategy. A draft strategy will be ready shortly, and a formal consultation on it will then take place. Within that will be a strategic environmental assessment of transport and the choices that are available to us, and to Parliament in scrutinising us, in that regard. The second element of the process is the Scottish transport appraisal guidance—STAG—which provides advice to planners and decision makers on the appraisal of transport projects where our support is necessary for those spends. The key criterion of STAG is the impact of the proposed transport interventions on the environment. The national transport strategy provides an opportunity—and will provide an opportunity during 2006—to launch a wider debate on the issues, to which I attach considerable importance.I also bring to the committee's attention some of the changes that we have introduced in the transport budget. The changes were raised by committee members in previous Local Government and Transport Committee discussions. Some of the changes are fairly technical.I want to raise four specific issues. First, table 8.01 in the draft budget for 2006-07 has been presented to reflect the level 2 spending plans that will be the responsibility of the new transport agency. I suspect that colleagues would expect us to provide that clarity, and I hope that the table goes some way towards helping you with that. The transport agency will be directly accountable for level 2 spending plans for rail services, concessionary fares, motorways and trunk roads. Some further level 3 programme expenditure within the other public transport line will also be the agency's responsibility.The second point is on the integrated transport fund. Its budget line in the draft budget for 2006-07 has been unbundled to reflect the expenditure for which the transport agency will be accountable and that for which the Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning Department will be accountable. That is intended to give the committee as much clarity as we can.The third point relates to other public transport funding, which will increase by £7.5 million in 2006-07 and in 2007-08, to reflect the transfer from the Department for Transport of additional resources to undertake the new rail functions.The fourth and final point is on the additional funding of about £330 million for the additional rail powers for which the Scottish ministers have taken responsibility. That is not reflected in the draft budget but will be included in the budget bill for 2006-07 when it is introduced in January next year.All those aspects are part of the start of our major programme of structural reform. We are developing a new transport agency along with a new network of regional transport partnerships. I am confident that those structures will enable the right people, skills and experience to be brought to bear on our undoubtedly ambitious programme of infrastructure projects and service improvements that lie ahead of the department in the coming financial year.With those brief points, I hope that I have given a flavour of where we are. I am happy to answer questions.

In the same item of business

The Convener: Lab
We shall hear evidence from both ministers with responsibility for our remit. The first is the Deputy Minister for Finance, Public Service Reform and Parliam...
The Deputy Minister for Finance, Public Service Reform and Parliamentary Business (George Lyon): LD
It is a great pleasure to be with you this afternoon. I find myself in a similar situation to that of Mr McCabe when he attended the committee last year and ...
The Convener: Lab
Before inviting questions from members, I should tell the committee that we have been advised by the broadcasters that there has been a difficulty with the b...
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
The Convener: Lab
I am advised that the broadcasting system is now ready to be used again. I will start off our questions on the pressures on local government and the potentia...
George Lyon: LD
Allowance has been made for general pay and price inflation in the settlement. We look to local government to play its part in offsetting some costs through ...
The Convener: Lab
There is still a bit of time in which to respond to the proposals for 2007-08, as next year's budget could make further adjustments to what is proposed. Howe...
George Lyon: LD
Ultimately, as you know, those decisions are for local government, but it is clear that the Executive has been encouraging local government to be as conserva...
The Convener: Lab
Does the Executive have any figures showing how far above 2.5 per cent the current indications suggest the average rise would be?
Graham Owenson (Scottish Executive Finance and Central Services Department):
We have some indicative figures for 2006-07, but they are not complete; we cannot give an overall number for the whole of Scotland because not all councils h...
The Convener: Lab
How many local authorities do you have figures for? What is the range?
Graham Owenson:
I do not have those details to hand.
The Convener: Lab
Would it be possible to supply those figures to the committee in writing?
George Lyon: LD
We can certainly write to you. As soon as we have all the information in from local authorities, we shall respond to you on that point. There are certainly i...
The Convener: Lab
You said that you want increases in the council tax collection rates—I am sure that everyone agrees with you on that. As you will be aware, council tax benef...
George Lyon: LD
The Executive, working with local authorities, clearly wishes to see that figure improved. It is essential that everyone who is entitled to housing benefit m...
The Convener: Lab
You mean council tax benefit, I think.
George Lyon: LD
Yes, I mean council tax benefit. Sorry.
Bruce Crawford (Mid Scotland and Fife) (SNP): SNP
I do not envy the minister's job in trying to deal with some of the obvious tensions in the system. The Finance Committee's budget adviser had confirmation f...
George Lyon: LD
I should address your initial point that the impact of the efficiency savings on local government will be disproportionate. Local government has been asked t...
Bruce Crawford: SNP
I understand what you are saying, but I have to point out that those words did not come from my mouth; I am simply using the terminology that the Finance Com...
George Lyon: LD
I am quoting the actual figures. The adviser might well have been comparing the local government proposals with the original proposal that the Health Departm...
Bruce Crawford: SNP
I have the information that was given to us by the Finance Committee—
George Lyon: LD
I understand that, but I simply have to put on record the position with regard to efficiency savings and dispel the notion that you have expressed.
Bruce Crawford: SNP
I realise that the equal pay issue has to be resolved between COSLA as the employer and the employees. However, local government did not introduce the legisl...
George Lyon: LD
I make it clear that once we get a full picture of costs throughout Scotland—and we will not know them until most of the agreements have been hammered out—we...
Bruce Crawford: SNP
I have other questions, but I will let other members ask theirs first.
Mr David Davidson (North East Scotland) (Con): Con
Can I assume that the figures that you quoted were not real-terms figures? What you were handing out sounded very optimistic.
George Lyon: LD
The figures in my opening speech were cash figures.