Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
15 May 2002
Autism Awareness Week
I am delighted again to be afforded the opportunity to raise awareness of autistic spectrum disorders in the chamber, even if it is slightly due to the hand of fate and the interference of our esteemed legal establishment. Nonetheless, as I look around the chamber, I see many ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
19 Jun 2001
Consultative Steering Group Principles
We are being asked for a report on what we believe the committee is doing correctly or incorrectly in relation to the principles in the CSG report. That has nothing to do with a decision made in the Parliament or by the bureau. We have been asked to refer back to the Procedure...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
17 May 2001
Special Educational Needs
First, I congratulate the Education, Culture and Sport Committee on its hard work and all the organisations and individuals who were consulted in this review of current service provision.I have spoken about autistic spectrum disorder on many occasions and I wish to reiterate t...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
14 Nov 2000
Convener's Report
On that point, under item 3 of the convener's report, I note that we are seeking "a mutually acceptable date" to meet Jack McConnell. I am led to believe that the minister is going to Europe at the beginning of next month. I am not sure what other members think, but I would li...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Feb 2002
Convener's Report
Some of the wording with which we seriously disagreed was not changed in the final draft, but that is another matter. We chose not to produce a minority report or to press matters to a vote but that does not mean that we agreed with everything in the report.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
24 Sep 2002
Convener's Report
I understand that, but at what point did the First Minister, as rapporteur, ask for the opinion of this committee or the Parliament so that he could report as the First Minister of Scotland? Are we, on the other hand, not having a report from Scotland?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
24 Sep 2002
Convener's Report
That is not the point that I was trying to make. Where in Jack McConnell's report is the opinion of the Scottish Parliament or of the European Committee of the Scottish Parliament? If that is not included, the report is incomplete.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Jun 2000
Housing Stock Transfer (Report)
I again wish to put on record that, last week, when concerns about the source of some of the amendments to the committee report were expressed, that concept was rejected by the convener. At that point, Ms Whitefield intervened to tell us that some of the amendments in the conv...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
27 Nov 2002
Lifelong Learning
I thank the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee and its advisers and clerks for a very fine report and for the fact that they have addressed disability issues—specifically those that affect people with autistic spectrum disorder and Asperger's syndrome.People with ASD a...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
20 Mar 2001
“The New Scottish Parliament Building”
I accept what Paul Martin is saying. We cannot consider competing for a slot in the chamber, as the issue also affects the Finance Committee. You are proposing that the issue be taken to the conveners group with the suggestion that there might be a debate on it. The informatio...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Apr 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
Mr Jones, the ministerial task force identified an absence of health leadership, corporate working and governance and a lack of effective communication as important factors contributing to financial and other problems in the NHS in Tayside. Paragraph 8.12 of the Auditor Genera...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Apr 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
Thank you, Mr Bates. That makes things clear for us—although inferences may be drawn from a comparison of what you said with what Mr Brett said.My final question is to Mr Brett. Paragraph 8.11 of the Auditor General's report refers to the "Recovery through Modernisation and In...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
26 Nov 2002
“Measuring Up? A follow-up report on performance measurement in the Scottish Environment Protection Agency”
Both exhibit 12 and paragraph 2.15 of the Auditor General's report note that SEPA intends to introduce guidance on the frequency of inspections. That appears to be basic information for a regulatory authority. How did you manage without such guidance until now?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Nov 2002
“Measuring Up? A follow-up report on performance measurement in the Scottish Environment Protection Agency”
The Auditor General's report says: "Managers will be expected to record decisions taken where the frequency of inspection and sampling differs from those recommended in the manual."You just made reference to the previous structure, wherein individual officers' perceptions were...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Nov 2002
“How government works in Scotland”
It is clear that performance management and performance reporting provide essential information on the achievements of public bodies. More important, they properly support the accountability process. Without performance management and reporting, accountability could be undermi...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Nov 2002
“How government works in Scotland”
No. I am still seeking an answer to the question why we cannot have a report of an analysis, rather than the lodging of parliamentary questions in order to publish the same information, which is a huge waste of public money. The newspapers regularly make an issue out of that. ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
14 Nov 2000
Convener's Report
The idea of a pre and post-council briefing is excellent as far as the December meeting is concerned. I am slightly concerned, however, that there is a meeting this week, on 17 November, that will cover matters that are pertinent to the committee such as changes in fleet manag...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
19 Jun 2001
Convener's Report
I agree with Dennis Canavan, but we cannot confine the protocol that we are asking for to the meetings that the Minister for Education, Europe and External Affairs attends with representatives from devolved or autonomous Parliaments. If he is the minister who is responsible fo...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Sep 2001
Common Fisheries Policy
First, at the heart of many of our discussions in producing the report was regional management and the structure of the zonal management committees. The sentence"The Executive envisages that the regional bodies should take an advisory role in the first instance but that their ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
29 Jan 2002
Convener's Report
We can hear back from members about the work of the Committee of the Regions. As we discussed when we put our report together, we are well aware that the Committee of the Regions will not necessarily exist in a couple of years.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Feb 2002
Petition
The fact that the Health and Community Care Committee has not yet agreed the paper does not mean that having read it we cannot have opinions about it. I agree with Dennis Canavan. I also think that it is a dangerous precedent for us to drop the draft report and give it to the ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Feb 2002
Convener's Report
Obviously, the SNP will be taking part in the debate, but you cannot expect Colin Campbell and me to endorse the entire findings of the report, although we were very kind and—
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
24 Sep 2002
Convener's Report
I am not asking about the quality or the content of the opinion; I am asking at what stage the Scottish Parliament, through its structures, makes a contribution to that report?
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
29 May 2001
Minutes (Publication)
My letter is fairly self-explanatory. To me, this is an issue of principle and an issue of best practice in a new structure. My fear, which a number of members share, is that the practice of behind-closed-doors meetings, specifically those of the Parliamentary Bureau and the h...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
18 Mar 2003
New Petitions
If members have been to their desks this morning, they will have seen a copy of the report on the first seminar of the consultation on the establishment of a human rights commission, which I attended and to which Mr Slaven referred in his presentation. When they read that repo...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
02 Sep 1999
National Cultural Strategy
The one issue that slightly concerns me about this debate is that there has been little or no discussion about practitioners of the arts or artists. There has been an awful lot of talk about meaningful, to-be-desired initiatives and consultations, yet no mention of the Broadca...
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Housing Stock Transfer
Michael McMahon should buy some eardrops. I made no reference to independence—perhaps he did not notice. We must look to modern structures and take on our proper responsibility as a Parliament, which is to run finance and local government properly. I am on the edge of being si...
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
14 Dec 2000
Question Time · Secretary of State for Health (Meetings)
I thank Mr Chisholm for that very comprehensive report on the meetings that have taken place with the Secretary of State for Health. In the light of the recent report on autism in the greater Glasgow area by the National Autistic Society, will the Executive implement some join...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
22 Mar 2001
Drug Misuse and Deprived Communities
There is no question but that we have moved this debate on since the beginning of the Scottish Parliament. We must, together as a Parliament, commend the Social Inclusion, Housing and Voluntary Sector Committee's report and, to a point, the Executive's response, while recognis...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
06 Sep 2001
Erskine Bridge Tolls Bill
For Mr Tosh and other members' information, I will make it clear that West Dunbartonshire Council's policy, under its previous administration and its current coalition administration, is for the Erskine bridge tolls to be removed. That council believes that the tolls damage se...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
08 Jan 2003
Local Government in Scotland Bill: Stage 3
Given that the idea of repeal appears to have arisen after the publication of the Bain report, can the minister tell the chamber whether there is a reference to repeal of section 19 in the pathfinder report that the Executive has consistently suppressed?
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
29 Jan 2003
Firefighters' Dispute
If and when the negotiations begin, will the Deputy First Minister bring to the table the pathfinder report and base the negotiations on it, rather than the cobbled-together Bain report?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
20 Mar 2001
“The New Scottish Parliament Building”
It is a response to the report, which was based on evidence.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Apr 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
I refer Mr White to paragraph 8.6 of the Auditor General's report, which makes it clear that the results of the acute services review are an essential component of achieving financial balance and eliminating the trust's financial deficit. Can you explain how you expect the rev...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Apr 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
I understand that. I refer you to the last sentence of paragraph 8.6 of the Auditor General's report, which says:"Until the findings of the Review are finalised and the impact of any changes to the delivery of acute health care is quantified, it will not be clear when TUHT wil...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Apr 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
Thank you.My next question is for Mr Jones. Paragraph 7.14 of the Auditor General's report tells us that, as a result of comments made by the task force about the monitoring arrangements, you advised the Minister for Health and Community Care that your department would take a ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Apr 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
My final question is for Mr Brett.Paragraphs 8.7 and 8.8 of the Auditor General's report start with the fairly encouraging news that the trusts are on target to achieve planned savings in 2000-01, but go on to highlight emerging difficulties. Can you explain what those difficu...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Apr 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
I will direct my next question to Mr Brett. Paragraph 8.9 of the Auditor General's report summarises the new protocols that have been introduced to control the approval of service developments. Do those protocols overcome the previous weaknesses?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Apr 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
That is an interesting reply, given the reference that is made in paragraph 8.9 on page 35 of the report to the protocols that would "help control the approval and use of additional resources for service developments." Those protocols created major problems in the past. Do you...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
01 May 2001
Financial Reporting Advisory Board
My question was whether the FRAB annual report is sent to the finance committees of the National Assembly for Wales and the Northern Ireland Assembly.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
15 May 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
Both of you have described how 200 staff were recruited by Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust during the last quarter of 1998-99. Mr Brett, you said that those people were recruited "in the mistaken belief that there was funding for them"—Official Report, Audit Committee, 2 A...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
15 May 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
You can find it in column 604 of the Official Report of the Audit Committee meeting of 2 April.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
15 May 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
I am referring to your comments, Mr Brett, not to the Auditor General's report. What made you believe that someone—unnamed in your remarks—was under the mistaken belief that they could recruit 200 people and that there would be a budget for that? What makes you believe that th...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
15 May 2001
National Health Service (Tayside)
It is column 597 of the Official Report of the Audit Committee of 2 April.
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
18 Sep 2001
“Public audit in Scotland”
I thank the Auditor General for his presentation and for this report. Three aspects of it are especially important. The first of those is the new forms of accountability, particularly in view of the development of the use of public-private partnerships. Will your greater invol...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Oct 2001
Moray College
I am surprised that Professor Sizer, Mr Frizzell and Dr Logan have referred to avaricious people, financial impropriety and such practices. I did not find that in your report, Dr Logan. That gives me the impression that there was something going on and that you know something ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Oct 2001
Moray College
I was referring to Dr Logan's report.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Oct 2001
Moray College
I think that the witnesses will know what my attitude is before I ask any questions.My question is for Dr Logan. The report says that between July 1999, when Professor Sizer was in position, and January 2001, SFEFC produced reports that highlighted "significant weaknesses" in ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
02 Oct 2001
Moray College
Okay—for how many colleges have you felt the need to produce a report on such issues?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
27 Nov 2001
“Overview of further education colleges in Scotland 1999/2000”
Paragraphs 4.19 to 4.24 of the Auditor General's report explain how the funding council developed its approach to monitoring financial performance and reviewing financial health at individual colleges. Despite that, the number of colleges with an operating deficit continues to...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
27 Nov 2001
“Overview of further education colleges in Scotland 1999/2000”
Both answers lead rather well to my next question. Unfortunately, as identified in paragraph 4.9 of the report, 31 colleges—or three quarters of the sector—are returning 1999-2000 operating deficits that total £18 million. Why do you think that colleges are in such poor financ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
27 Nov 2001
“Overview of further education colleges in Scotland 1999/2000”
I have a final question for Mr Frizzell. Exhibit 11 on page 27 of the report indicates that the number of colleges recording an operating deficit has increased between 1993-94 and 1998-99. What more could have been done—and by whom—to avoid that?
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
22 Jan 2002
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2000/01”
I apologise to the committee for my late arrival.Rather than begin with the question that I had prepared, I will ask about something that Mr Jones mentioned, although I am not sure whether he is able to answer my question or whether the Auditor General should answer it. Mr Jon...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
22 Jan 2002
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2000/01”
I refer you to paragraphs 4.5 and 4.6 of the Auditor General's report, which clearly show that eight trusts failed to break even in 2000-01—in fact, those trusts had deficits that totalled £54 million. I accept that one trust had a technical deficit and is therefore excluded, ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
22 Jan 2002
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2000/01”
Again, I refer you to exhibit 5 in the Auditor General's report, which shows the trusts that did not break even. Which of those trusts, in your opinion, face the greatest problems in achieving break-even in the future, particularly in light of the discussion that we have just ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
05 Feb 2002
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2000/01”
However, as such factors clearly affect service delivery, they have to be brought into the equation to ensure that you address the financial pressures. For example, I have asked about the geography of your health board area. Those factors are all aspects of how the committee a...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
05 Feb 2002
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2000/01”
The broader demographic picture shows that we have an aging population. There are a number of issues that can create pressures that have not arisen, but of which I am aware through my involvement in a report by another committee. For example, pressures are created by high leve...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Nov 2002
“Measuring Up? A follow-up report on performance measurement in the Scottish Environment Protection Agency”
Field officers' perceptions can be positive and they can be dangerous if they do not move with the times. Will the key to the structure be monitoring and the development of training for field officers?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Nov 2002
“Measuring Up? A follow-up report on performance measurement in the Scottish Environment Protection Agency”
Is that in-built?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
26 Nov 2002
“Measuring Up? A follow-up report on performance measurement in the Scottish Environment Protection Agency”
Will further funds be made available for HR to put in place a proper structure for professional development?
← Back to list
Chamber

Plenary, 15 May 2002

15 May 2002 · S1 · Plenary
Item of business
Autism Awareness Week
I am delighted again to be afforded the opportunity to raise awareness of autistic spectrum disorders in the chamber, even if it is slightly due to the hand of fate and the interference of our esteemed legal establishment. Nonetheless, as I look around the chamber, I see many faces from the many debates that have been held on the issue over the past two or three years and we must congratulate ourselves and the business managers on putting ASD regularly and firmly on the Parliament's agenda. That has gone a long way to increasing awareness and understanding of the condition throughout the country, which is marvellous.

I have stated many times that my knowledge of the condition has been gained by the sheer determination and continuous campaigning of parents, carers and professionals, some of whom are in the public gallery. I thank them and commend their efforts.

There is little point in my raking over old ground by citing statistics and explaining the condition to members. It will suffice to say that the number of those who are diagnosed is growing rapidly every day. That increase includes not only children but adults. We cannot afford to waste any more time in debating how to address the situation. The time has come for action.

I am an active campaigner for the rights of those on the spectrum and am the convener of the cross-party group in the Scottish Parliament on autistic spectrum disorder. I stress the importance of implementing the recommendations of the Public Health Institute of Scotland's needs assessment report. Many members have received notes of concern—as I have—from many organisations as to the scope of the consultation process that led to the report. We must take those concerns on board, but the report is a basis for the best way forward, if only because it is at least a step in the right direction. I am sure that the positive feedback of carers, sufferers and organisations can add to and strengthen the report's recommendations as they are implemented.

I draw attention to some of the report's recommendations. First, it recommends early identification and appropriate early interventions. We in Scotland are well positioned to use means of early identification, new means of identification and new forms of diagnosis on a biomedical level. Much work in that area has been done in Scotland and it would be foolish of us not to take advantage of that work and our expertise and thereby allow a full life-term plan to be laid out for all sufferers.

Secondly, the range of services that are delivered must be seamlessly delivered and planned and developed in a multi-agency way. I have frequently talked about the necessity for a national strategy that is focused on the individual and that uses multi-agency methods and many members have agreed with me.

Thirdly, the report recommends the planned and sensitive management of the transition between childhood and adulthood, which must be carried out between agencies. At the moment, the transition period is the most difficult period for parents, carers and professionals but, most important, it is the most damaging period for sufferers. Continuity is the key to treatment of people with ASD. It is vital that there should be continuity of provision, teaching and treatment. The terrible break between school and adulthood is allowing people to fall into wrong areas of support.

Fourthly, all planning should be carried out with the person at the centre of the services to ensure that individual needs are assessed. The only thing that I will say about the condition itself is that it is different in each sufferer and therefore treatment must be individualised for each sufferer. If we do not understand that simple and basic principle, we will fail. However, I genuinely believe that we do understand it. Finance is required. The simple fact is that our society will be denied the abilities of many people with ASD if the required finances are not made available.

What should our approach be? As I have said, we need joint policies, strategies and operational arrangements among agencies, skilled and experienced professionals and targeted funding. We have some skilled, trained and experienced professionals, but we do not have enough of them. This is a great opportunity for this country to become a centre of excellence in training. We can provide not only for our own sufferers but for sufferers throughout the UK and Europe, if not the world. As I said, the expertise exists in Scotland. Let us make something of that. It would be a positive contribution to the world and, more important, a positive contribution to our own economy.

In my opinion, targeted funding can be delivered through a central base—that is the national strategy that I keep talking about. However, we also need a centre of excellence that can set out the strategy and policies nationally and that can be used as a resource for training, information and research. That is not a new idea. As many members know, we have the potential for that centre of excellence in Struan House and in the Scottish Society for Autism's planned facility in Alloa. Again—I cannot restate it often enough—that would enable us to make our contribution to the world, not just to our own society.

I have stated in the chamber and in the cross-party group that the benefits for the autistic community of the creation of a centre of excellence would be huge. It could ensure that special skills and quality of life are nurtured and not ignored, as many of those needs are today.

The Scottish Society for Autism runs an excellent school and the National Autistic Society runs a complementary facility at Daldorch. Those are very special places, where children and adults can be cared for and educated and where, most important—this is why they work—the environment is geared towards continuity of provision, education and treatment.

Struan House is an exceptional centre, but it is far too small to cater for demand. That is why the SSA has set out its appeal for a new school and centre for training research and assessment. I understand that both Nicol Stephen and Hugh Henry have visited the school—I hope that Frank McAveety will do so too—and have seen the benefits that it provides for the Scottish autistic population and the international community.

I urge Frank McAveety in his reply—I accept that he is new to the brief—to commit the Government to the changes for which I have asked. We know what is happening out there. We need action. Further consultations could be useful, but only in terms of the action that is required. I ask the minister to implement at the earliest opportunity the recommendations from the PHIS needs assessment report. More important, I ask him to recognise the report's limitations, listen to carers and professionals and, most important, recognise the needs of each individual sufferer.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Mr Murray Tosh): Con
The final item of business is a members' business debate on motion S1M-2988, in the name of Lloyd Quinan, on autism awareness week. The debate will be conclu...
Motion debated,
That the Parliament acknowledges Autism Awareness Week 2002 and the forthcoming Autism Awareness Week 2003 by supporting both the Scottish Society for Autism...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP
I am delighted again to be afforded the opportunity to raise awareness of autistic spectrum disorders in the chamber, even if it is slightly due to the hand ...
Elaine Smith (Coatbridge and Chryston) (Lab): Lab
I would like to make a brief speech as vice-convener of the cross-party group on autistic spectrum disorder.I congratulate Lloyd Quinan on securing the debat...
Mr Keith Raffan (Mid Scotland and Fife) (LD): LD
I congratulate Lloyd Quinan on securing this debate about increasing awareness of autism. It is now nearly a quarter of a century since Struan House was esta...
Christine Grahame (South of Scotland) (SNP): SNP
I want to touch on two issues. The first is inclusivity for young people with autism; the second is adults with ASD. We start from the premise that the Stand...
Mary Scanlon (Highlands and Islands) (Con): Con
Christine Grahame raised a good point. I have heard anecdotally that many marriages do not survive the bringing up of an autistic child. It has also come to ...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab): Lab
I commend Lloyd Quinan and Elaine Smith for their excellent work on autism and on the speeches that they made at the start of tonight's debate. I also place ...
Donald Gorrie (Central Scotland) (LD): LD
Lloyd Quinan and Elaine Smith deserve great credit for pursuing the issue of autism and for making the tone of the debate very constructive. Some people have...
The Deputy Presiding Officer: Con
I must cut the time allocated to speeches to three minutes. I apologise to members who have yet to speak.
Fergus Ewing (Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber) (SNP): SNP
I warmly congratulate Lloyd Quinan on bringing his motion before the Parliament at short notice, and on the work that he, Elaine Smith, Christine Grahame and...
Mr Kenneth Macintosh (Eastwood) (Lab): Lab
I congratulate Lloyd Quinan on introducing the debate, despite the unfortunate circumstances around it. I state for the record that this is the first debate ...
The Deputy Presiding Officer: Con
I have great pleasure in calling Frank McAveety to testify to the effectiveness of the Executive's recycling policy and to respond to the debate.
Mr Raffan: LD
Surely you mean resurrection, Presiding Officer?
The Deputy Minister for Health and Community Care (Mr Frank McAveety): Lab
That would be a sound theological position for me to adopt.I congratulate Lloyd Quinan on securing the debate, albeit in unusual circumstances. It is interes...
Meeting closed at 17:55.