Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP Chamber
05 Oct 2017
City Region Deals
Strengthening Scotland’s economy so that it benefits all is the very definition of inclusive growth and is front and centre of what the Government is all about. We are using all the levers at our disposal. Recent data shows that the economy is growing, though we want it to gro...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
Thank you, convener. I have a fairly brief opening statement. I am disappointed that we have not been joined by the UK Government. I think that the last time that it appeared before this committee was the first time in the history of the Scottish Parliament that we had two min...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP Chamber
27 Mar 2018
City Region Deals
Bob Doris has covered a range of the important recommendations made by the committee in its report on the inquiry that was conducted into city region deals in Scotland. It is worth mentioning that that committee investigation also included the first time that United Kingdom an...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
22 Feb 2018
General Question Time · Stirling and Clackmannanshire City Region Deal
The scale of Government investment in the deal and the projects included in it will of course be subject to negotiation between Governments and between the city region partners. The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Constitution made provision in the budget for around £120...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
22 Nov 2017
City Region Deals
The first lesson is that, if you are going to have a deal involving the Scottish Government, you should talk to the Scottish Government first. I think that agreeing a deal and then coming to the Scottish Government with a demand for money is not the best way to get the best de...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
22 Nov 2017
City Region Deals
I think that the Sheriffhall junction will have been a priority for a number of the local authorities involved. To be honest, I do not think that it is the way to go for local authorities that freely and happily signed that city deal agreement to start picking it apart. As yo...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
22 Nov 2017
City Region Deals
The Scottish Government has made a commitment that every area and every community in Scotland should benefit from a deal. To put it diplomatically, we are still working through that process. It will be interesting to hear Ian Duncan’s view on the issue. We have areas such as M...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
07 Dec 2016
Enterprise and Skills Review
You are correct about the unique nature of the city deal framework that is emerging. That initiative began in the Glasgow region with a proposal from us, the United Kingdom Government and the relevant local authorities. You are right to say that city deals do not fit readily i...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
Yes. First, we are aware of the fact that the public authorities that are involved in the city deals have obligations on the equality impact assessment and we expect them to follow through on those obligations. I will quickly return to your previous question and the reasonabl...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
You will find that the difference is even greater if you examine the projects that have been supported. For example, in the most recent deal—the Stirling and Clackmannanshire deal—one of the projects that the UK Government supported was the establishment of a national tartan c...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
22 Nov 2017
City Region Deals
On the first part of your question, the Glasgow city region deal is unlike the other deals. The Scottish Government was asked, at the very last minute, to contribute £0.5 billion to it. There was no prior discussion, so our ability to emphasise or prioritise such things as inc...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
15 Sep 2016
General Question Time · City Deals
It is worth outlining exactly the nature of the city deal. As asked for by the local authorities concerned, the city deal was to pass over the resources and powers for the partners to take forward work themselves—not the Scottish Government or the UK Government. We are fully s...
Keith Brown (Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work) SNP Committee
22 Nov 2017
City Region Deals
Thank you very much, convener. Ian Duncan and I appear together on many platforms, including the Scottish business growth scheme and various conferences, not least of which are those on city deals. We are delighted to be here. Ian Duncan reminded me that I danced at his weddin...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
27 Mar 2018
City Region Deals
I understand the point that Brian Whittle makes but, just to explain, the way that the deals have been put together up to now is that, when the Governments and the local partners agree, they all agree. It is a bit like Brexit: nothing is agreed until everything is agreed. If w...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
28 Mar 2018
Portfolio Question Time · Glasgow City Region Deal (Impact on Motherwell and Wishaw)
Clarity and transparency are always a good thing but, as the member knows full well, it is not really for either this Government or the United Kingdom Government to dictate to the Glasgow city deal partners how to conduct their business. As long as the deal complies with the c...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
27 Mar 2018
City Region Deals
It has been an interesting debate, with a number of points of view. I thank the committee for pressing to have the debate and for its report and recommendations. It is clear from the contributions to the debate how ambitious everyone is for the achievement of faster inclusive ...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP Chamber
09 Jun 2016
General Question Time · Aberdeen City Region Deal
The Scottish Government has demonstrated strong support for Aberdeen and the north-east by committing over the next 10 years up to £125 million, alongside £125 million from the United Kingdom Government, for an Aberdeen city region deal. Alongside that, we have committed to an...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
15 Sep 2016
General Question Time · City Deals
As Lewis Macdonald said, that was not part of the city deal. We wanted to make it so, but the United Kingdom Government would not go further than the city deal that was eventually agreed. We went substantially further. The UK contribution and the Scottish contribution to the A...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
09 Jan 2018
Topical Question Time · City Region Deals
We have, of course, made substantial commitments in relation to the establishment of a new agency for the south of Scotland, and the Borders has been part of a city deal already, so I do not accept the idea that we have not been proactive in ensuring that there is a deal for t...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
28 Jun 2016
Scottish Government Policy Update
You said that there was no timetable or timescale for the £254 million investment. It is important to be clear about the position, so I should repeat how it came about. We entered into a conversation with Aberdeen Council, Aberdeenshire Council and the UK Government on the cit...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP Chamber
09 Jan 2018
Topical Question Time · City Region Deals
I thank Kenneth Gibson and his fellow members of the Local Government and Communities Committee for their report, which is to be welcomed. The Scottish Government and I want to see all parts of Scotland thrive, and city region deals are contributing to that aim. It is importa...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
09 Jun 2016
General Question Time · Aberdeen City Region Deal
I am not sure whether Ross Thomson listened to the answer that I gave. He talked about reannouncements. Last week, his colleague reannounced to this Parliament that the city deal—£125 million from the UK Government and £125 million from the Scottish Government—was in fact a £2...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
22 May 2013
Haudagain Roundabout
I think that I have just said what is being done. We have employed design consultants to work on the design at this early stage in order that we can be ready to go immediately.We can of course revisit all the arguments. For example, I have had a letter from somebody in the Abe...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
05 Oct 2017
City Region Deals
It might have been a pity, but it was not a surprise. In relation to the Stirling and Clackmannanshire city region deal, we have constructive relationships with the two councils involved. Some welcome flexibility has been shown. As I mentioned, the UK Government now seeks to...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
Perhaps I am being diplomatic, but it depends on the basis of the city region deals. If we start off from the position that it is to be 50:50 funding, which is where we started off on the Glasgow city region deal, the answer is that it has not been that way. In the Aberdeen, ...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
07 Feb 2018
Portfolio Question Time · Cupar North Relief Road (Funding)
Willie Rennie asked why we are considering that proposal. I said in my first response that we are considering it because it is a project and proposal that has come from the relevant local partner—the local authority—and that is the basis of city deals. Neither we nor the Unite...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
09 Jan 2018
Topical Question Time · City Region Deals
I do not know about that—the member would have to ask the council whether the projects that they have submitted are being kept secret. On the point about rural areas, first of all, it is worth saying that the agreed city deals and those in prospect also include areas, such as...
Keith Brown (Clackmannanshire and Dunblane) (SNP) SNP Committee
04 Nov 2020
City Region Deals
I want to take up the deputy convener’s theme on accountability and transparency. The deal in my local area is the Stirling and Clackmannanshire city region deal. I point out to Alexander Stewart that the partner is the county of Clackmannanshire rather than the town of Clackm...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP Chamber
15 Sep 2016
General Question Time · City Deals
Cities and their regions are the engines of our economy, which is why we are committed to working with all our cities to unlock investment and stimulate growth. The Scottish Government is a full partner in the Glasgow city region city deal, supporting all three strands and con...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
We are learning lessons all the time. The confusion that seems to have arisen about university projects in the Edinburgh city region deal is perhaps best avoided by being clearer about the basis on which support is being provided. That situation is being resolved now, so we ha...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
We do not want to be seen to be going behind what the partners have proposed. Councils and other partners collectively come to both Governments and say what deal they are looking for; we will never be, and have never been, able to fund every project in a proposal. However, we ...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
Yes. I will make the point again that we do not say to particular councils, “You should band together to get a deal.” We do not prescribe how a deal happens. If we want to take an equitable approach, everybody should have the opportunity. Falkirk could conceivably partner with...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
23 Mar 2016
General Question Time · City Deal (Dundee)
I confirm that, contrary to what Jenny Marra has said, Dundee City Council has written to me and to the UK Government on the issue. I also confirm that, on yesterday’s Inverness city deal announcement, the UK Government’s contribution of £53 million was substantially less than...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
05 Oct 2017
City Region Deals
It is astonishing that the Tories have crept back to their position of pretending that the UK Government has no role in the Scottish economy. It defies belief that people who are meant to have a level of intelligence about economic debate still cling to that position. Dean Loc...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
We have had some progress on that. After many months of asking, the UK Government has now publicly stated that it will support an Ayrshire growth deal. The Ayrshire growth deal has been discussed for a long time now and what seems to have happened is that a lot of the focus ha...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP Chamber
14 Dec 2016
Portfolio Question Time · Aberdeen City Region Deal
The Scottish Government, the United Kingdom Government and regional partners signed the Aberdeen city region deal on 21 November. The signing of the Aberdeen city region deal and the release of funding allow the deal to move on to the delivery stage and make proposals a realit...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP Chamber
27 Apr 2017
General Question Time · Glasgow City Deal (Motherwell and Wishaw)
The Scottish Government is a full partner in the Glasgow city region deal, which is now in its delivery stage, and the Government is contributing up to £500 million over 20 years into the £1.13 billion Glasgow city region deal infrastructure fund. The deal empowers Glasgow and...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
22 Nov 2017
City Region Deals
We now have a board that includes the UK and Scottish Governments to do oversight. What was called an assurance framework was put in place for the Glasgow deal. As the convener rightly said, it was not for us to go in and say that we did not think a project would offer value f...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
No, and this refers back to the basis on which the deals were originally agreed. I mentioned the Glasgow city deal. This is perhaps the reason why, as you mentioned, Glasgow and its partners said that they want to pursue inclusive economic growth in the city deal. In the most ...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2015
General Question Time · Aberdeen City Region Deal Bid
I have made that support clear to Aberdeen City Council by writing directly to its leader, who had written to us previously. I also met the leader of Aberdeen City Council yesterday at the Scottish cities alliance. We have made it clear that we are more than happy to work with...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
07 Dec 2016
Enterprise and Skills Review
On the cities review, it is worth bearing in mind that, if you were to look at the deals that are likely to emerge for Scotland’s seven cities, you would find that the area covered by the non-city authorities vastly exceeds the area covered by the city ones, given how the deal...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
27 Apr 2017
General Question Time · Ayrshire Growth Deal
The process that we follow is similar to the city deal process. We take the proposals that come in, which in the case of the Ayrshire growth deal are from the councils and their partners. We analyse the proposals to see which are most susceptible to support and will generate e...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
27 Mar 2018
City Region Deals
As I recall, we were ready to do a deal on 3 July but we could not get the UK Government to agree. We wanted to put in more money than the UK Government wanted to put in, and we asked whether it would match that. It was not until 18 July that the UK Government, knowing that th...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
That question can be answered only by the UK Government. The example that you have given represents quite an extraordinary development—as, I am sure, you would agree—and the figure of £8 million has changed two or three times during the past two or three days. The committee is...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
15 Sep 2016
General Question Time · City Deals
In my first answer I mentioned the Stirling city deal. It was open to areas around Stirling to come together on that, but, as Alison Harris says, it looks as though Falkirk is not part of that deal. We have said to parts of Scotland that are not part of city deals that we are,...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
14 Dec 2016
Portfolio Question Time · Aberdeen City Region Deal
I am happy to do so. However, I should say that the projects that Mairi Evans mentioned are not part of the city deal. The Scottish Government wanted them to be part of it, but the UK Government baulked at the size of the contribution that it would have to make to additional e...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
05 Oct 2017
City Region Deals
I can give a couple of examples; if the member wants more detail, I can write to him with that. The biggest example would be the contribution that is made through the Aberdeen Harbour trust of around £400 million. We and the UK Government have supported that through some of t...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
It is just as you confirmed, convener, and I think that we discussed the matter when I was before the committee previously. You are right to say that the Glasgow deal was the first deal. It happened before Brexit was on the horizon and I think that Mr Simpson raised some issue...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
21 Nov 2013
General Question Time · Aberdeen City Council (Transport)
As I said in my response to Maureen Watt, I think that this is purely an Aberdeen City Council initiative but I have gone so far as to say that Transport Scotland officials will discuss the council proposals with the city council officials. That is as far as I would want to go...
Keith Brown (Clackmannanshire and Dunblane) (SNP) SNP Chamber
05 Mar 2019
European Union Withdrawal Negotiations
I support the motion in the name of the First Minister, but I will consider in some detail the amendment that is proposed by the Conservative Party and that party’s actions and record, given its leading role in supporting, introducing and implementing—if that is the right word...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
22 Nov 2017
City Region Deals
You mentioned the process that led up to the deal, in which Government officials were involved. I was with Councillor Ross at the signing of the deal, and I have no recollection of any objections being raised to the deal that was proposed. I can absolutely guarantee that it is...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
22 Nov 2017
City Region Deals
For Glasgow, I think that the estimated contribution from the private sector is £3.3 billion. However, it is probably too early to say what it will be. In relation to the Aberdeen city deal, there is £400 million of investment just in Aberdeen harbour, and that is following a ...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
24 Feb 2015
Building Scotland’s Infrastructure
The funding for the new City of Glasgow College has been allocated for quite some time: in fact, it dates back to when I was Minister for Skills and Lifelong Learning in 2010-11. The two things are not related. As I said, there has been a significant level of international in...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
20 Jan 2016
Portfolio Question Time · City Deals Programme
The nature of city deals has changed over the period, both in Scotland, where we have one already and others are being discussed, and in England and Wales, where there has been a very large one recently in Cardiff. Some of those have involved asks for additional powers, as the...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP Committee
14 Nov 2017
Economic Data
Thank you for allowing me the time to access some caffeine, convener. I also thank the committee for the opportunity to contribute to its inquiry into economic data for Scotland. The need for robust and timely economic statistics for Scotland is well recognised, not least by ...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
13 Jun 2018
City Region Deals
I understand that you were not involved in the inquiry. On the genesis of city region deals, the first of those was the Glasgow city region deal. Unfortunately, the Scottish Government was not involved in its development. It was developed with the UK Government and local autho...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
27 Feb 2024
Budget (Scotland) (No 3) Bill
I will not. Jackie Baillie would not take an intervention from me and I will not be taking one from her. What Labour did in 2009-10 is exactly what it did in 1979: it facilitated a long-term Tory Government that was committed to austerity, and Scotland continues to suffer the...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
27 Apr 2017
General Question Time · Ayrshire Growth Deal
In writing and face to face with members of the UK Government, I have consistently expressed my desire to have discussions with the UK Government to support the deal. It is unfortunate that we have not had explicit support from the UK Government for the growth deal, along the ...
Keith Brown SNP Committee
22 Nov 2017
City Region Deals
That is not the case with Ayrshire, because the Ayrshire councils had quite a lot of discussion with us and the UK Government about the things that they wanted to be developed. The earliest discussion of a growth deal included the HALO project, so that is not being imposed. Ho...
Keith Brown SNP Chamber
22 Feb 2018
General Question Time · Stirling and Clackmannanshire City Region Deal
Mark Ruskell makes a good point. We have helped not least by providing, for the first time, additional support to the council—given the council’s size and the fact that it came to the deal later—through the Scottish Futures Trust, and Scottish Government officials to help the ...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 05 October 2017

05 Oct 2017 · S5 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
City Region Deals
Brown, Keith SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane Watch on SPTV

Strengthening Scotland’s economy so that it benefits all is the very definition of inclusive growth and is front and centre of what the Government is all about. We are using all the levers at our disposal. Recent data shows that the economy is growing, though we want it to grow at a higher rate. The number of people in employment is at a record high and unemployment is at a joint record low.

Cities and their regions are the engines of our economy. Increasing jobs, investment and employment in our city regions will drive up national economic growth. City region deals are one of our key economic levers. Eighty-three per cent of Scotland’s population—4.5 million people—live in the areas that are covered by existing or planned city region deals. According to the latest figures, which are from 2015, those same areas account for 86 per cent of Scotland’s gross value added and 2.2 million jobs, which is 85 per cent of the total number of Scottish jobs.

The investments that we have made in city region deals can be transformational. They will benefit Scotland as a whole, creating tens of thousands of jobs and upskilling labour markets. However, deals can do much more than that. They galvanise key partners to come together to drive regional economies in ways that go well beyond the investments that they deliver.

So far, the Scottish Government has committed over £1 billion over the next 10 to 20 years for city region deals in Glasgow, Aberdeen, Inverness and Edinburgh. Our investment exceeds the United Kingdom Government investment in the deals. Indeed, the Scottish Government is the biggest funder of city region deals in Scotland.

The deals are based on proposals developed by cities and their partners, harnessing local intelligence to identify what is needed to unlock inclusive growth. City deals are important investments and they can attract significant private sector leverage, but we must see them in context. Over the past five years, local government in Scotland has received more than £3.5 billion capital funding through the local government settlement. This Government has made significant investment to transform Scotland’s infrastructure. In 2017-18 alone, we have committed more than £4 billion for projects such as the Queensferry crossing, the Aberdeen western peripheral route, the A9 dualling programme and rail improvements between Edinburgh and Glasgow. To cap that list, over three years we have seen four deals. That is solid progress.

Today I express our commitment to deals for all our cities and confirm to Parliament that the Scottish Government will support city deals for Stirling and Clackmannanshire and for the Tay cities, which will be the first two-city deal in Scotland. In addition, I want to seek clarity and achieve consensus where possible with other partners on how all Scotland can benefit from the deals that we strike.

The first deal was, of course, Glasgow. That deal is in its delivery stage. Along with the UK Government, we are supporting £1.13 billion of investment in Scotland’s largest city and region, which is levering in about £3.3 billion of private sector investment.

In Aberdeen, we are investing £125 million over the next 10 years, with match funding from the UK Government, to deliver projects including a new oil and gas technology centre and harbour infrastructure. When we struck that deal, we were clear that more was needed for the north-east, so the Scottish Government alone committed to investing an additional £254 million in transport, digital and housing.

In January, I signed the Inverness and Highland city region deal, committing up to £135 million over 10 years as part of a £315 million package. That investment will deliver jobs, drive innovation, attract greater private sector investment and—crucially for the Highlands—help to retain the young people who are the lifeblood of the region’s future.

In Edinburgh, after some hard negotiations with the UK Government to encourage it to match our ambitions, we signed heads of terms in July to invest £300 million over the next 15 years in the Edinburgh and south-east Scotland city region deal as part of a £1.1 billion package.

That is where we are, and we plan to go further.

We have discussed in the chamber on a number of occasions the enterprise and skills review. In our review report, which we published in June, we set out our commitment to support the creation of regional partnerships across the country.

Our national economic development agencies have been challenged to align regionally to support regional partnerships, and they have been proactive in doing that. We are very clear that future city and regional deals will be expected to use our inclusive growth model to prioritise their investments and monitor their progress. We are also clear that private sector involvement in the partnerships is crucial and that the Scottish Government—I think that this is also true for the UK Government—will make its funding contingent on the involvement of the private sector.

In each of the deals that I have talked about, we have leveraged private investment to support regional development. I am delighted with that, and I am sure that we can do even more. The private sector has to be an engaged partner, providing drive and direction to our regional economies. In parallel, and very importantly, the Equality and Human Rights Commission is working with us to maximise equality of opportunity within city region deals.

As I have said, we intend to achieve city region deals for Stirling and Clackmannanshire and for the Tay cities of Dundee and Perth, alongside their partners in Angus and the north of Fife. Officials are working with both sets of regional partners and with the UK Government, so that we can reach agreement on heads of terms as soon as possible. I will continue to press the UK Government to match our commitment to transform those regional economies.

Our policy approach should not just be about cities and their regions, extremely important though they are. For our economy and all our people to flourish, we need inclusive economic growth in all of Scotland, especially outside the traditional growth areas.

As I said at the start of my statement, inclusive growth is about opportunities for everybody. To that end, we have said that we are supportive of a growth deal for the three Ayrshire councils, which would be the first regional deal in Scotland. Ayrshire’s economy has lagged behind national growth for too long and it is time to take decisive action. We are determined to deliver a deal that will bring jobs and investment to the area, reduce unemployment and reinvigorate the local economy.

We are also committed to tackling the economic challenges faced in the south of Scotland, so as well as our commitment to establish a new south of Scotland enterprise agency—we are the first Government to do that—we are looking at a border lands inclusive growth deal. We are entering into detailed discussions with Dumfries and Galloway and Scottish Borders to explore a deal that supports their aspirations.

We have had discussions with Moray, Falkirk and Argyll and Bute. Each has growth proposals, while Orkney, Shetland and the Western Isles seek an islands deal.

I am willing to play my part and to work closely with the UK Government to agree the next phase of deals. We have had good co-operation, to this juncture at least. We had good co-operation with Andrew Dunlop when he was in post, but I call on the UK Government to play its part, match our commitment to support inclusive economic growth for all Scotland and, crucially, develop a coherent and planned programme. By that I mean that it is not clear to me what role the UK Government wants to play in different parts of Scotland and it would be useful for us to know that before we proceed with any further deals.

I have given a clear picture of our plans. Our existing deals are delivering jobs and investment for Scotland. The £1 billion committed so far to city region deals is a clear signal that we respect the knowledge of regional partners, who are best placed to identify what is needed to unlock inclusive growth in their regions. The point is that the cities and their partners produce the proposals. Of necessity, we and the UK Government have to prioritise which of those we accept and support, but the cities come up with them in the first place; the proposals are not made by either of the two Governments.

We are also expanding our regional economic policy to go beyond city deals and we will support the creation of regional partnerships across the country. However, I want a clear commitment from the UK Government that it will work in partnership with us to deliver transformational city region deals for Stirling and Clackmannanshire, the Tay cities and the other areas that I have mentioned.

I have said repeatedly that I am willing to work with the relevant UK ministers to help to achieve the aspirations of the industrial strategy. To achieve that, I call on the UK Government to help to develop a co-ordinated approach to all of Scotland, including working with us in relation to all areas, including the Ayrshire regions, Argyll and Bute, Moray, Falkirk, the border lands and the islands. For my part and on behalf of the Scottish Government, I commit to working collaboratively with all our partners to ensure that we get the best deal for cities, regions and the whole of Scotland.

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Ken Macintosh) NPA
The next item of business is a statement by Keith Brown, on Scottish city region deals—next steps. The cabinet secretary will take questions at the end of hi...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (Keith Brown) SNP
Strengthening Scotland’s economy so that it benefits all is the very definition of inclusive growth and is front and centre of what the Government is all abo...
Dean Lockhart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con
I thank the cabinet secretary for the advance copy of his statement. We welcome the continuing collaboration between the UK Government and the Scottish Gover...
Keith Brown SNP
It is astonishing that the Tories have crept back to their position of pretending that the UK Government has no role in the Scottish economy. It defies belie...
Jackie Baillie (Dumbarton) (Lab) Lab
I thank the cabinet secretary for providing an advance copy of his statement. There is much on which we can agree. Scottish Labour believes that cities and r...
Keith Brown SNP
In response to Jackie Baillie’s final question, if the money were allocated on an equitable basis, of course it would be a positive example, but given that t...
Jackie Baillie Lab
Growth in Scotland has increased by 0.5 per cent over the year.
Keith Brown SNP
If Jackie Baillie would care to listen to what I am saying, she will find out that she was also wrong in what she said about part-time workers. In Scotland, ...
Bruce Crawford (Stirling) (SNP) SNP
I very much welcome the cabinet secretary’s statement and the Scottish Government’s clear commitment to ensuring a successful outcome for the Stirling and Cl...
Keith Brown SNP
It might have been a pity, but it was not a surprise. In relation to the Stirling and Clackmannanshire city region deal, we have constructive relationships...
Murdo Fraser (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con
In his statement, the cabinet secretary mentioned that private investment had been leveraged into the various city deals. Is he able to give us any figures f...
Keith Brown SNP
I can give a couple of examples; if the member wants more detail, I can write to him with that. The biggest example would be the contribution that is made t...
The Presiding Officer NPA
There are 10 minutes left for 10 questions so I urge the cabinet secretary to be slightly briefer in his answers.
Mark Ruskell (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green) Green
City deals can be a strong driver for investment in low-carbon infrastructure and in the inclusive economic growth opportunities that come alongside that. Un...
Keith Brown SNP
I will try to be brief, but I reiterate the point that we have to look at the deals that are proposed to us and decide which ones we will support. If the cou...
Liam McArthur (Orkney Islands) (LD) LD
I thank the cabinet secretary for early sight of his statement and welcome the confirmation of the on-going discussions with the island authorities about a p...
Keith Brown SNP
I can say yes to both of those questions. The SFT engages with all local authorities when they express a need for support in relation to estate and other fin...
Gail Ross (Caithness, Sutherland and Ross) (SNP) SNP
My constituents in Caithness, Sutherland and Ross have a perception that the Inverness city region deal is largely being used in Inverness, as opposed to sup...
Keith Brown SNP
I give Gail Ross the same caveat that I have given to other members. We look at the projects that the local authorities and their partners bring forward. We ...
Pauline McNeill (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab
Will the cabinet secretary confirm that the access link to Glasgow airport will be state of the art and that it will be delivered by 2025? Will he confirm wh...
Keith Brown SNP
It might be helpful for Pauline McNeill if I lay out the basis on which the deals are made. They are made with support from the UK and Scottish Governments, ...
Kenneth Gibson (Cunninghame North) (SNP) SNP
I welcome the cabinet secretary’s commitment to Ayrshire in his statement. Will he advise members what progress has been made in discussions with the UK Gove...
Keith Brown SNP
At the request of the three Ayrshire authorities— because they could not get a response—we asked the UK Government whether it wanted to be a co-partner in an...
Brian Whittle (South Scotland) (Con) Con
I thank the Scottish Government for following the UK Government lead and matching its £3.5 million investment in the HALO project in Kilmarnock, which was in...
Keith Brown SNP
I notice that there was no quantification of the deal that the UK Government is apparently on the verge of agreeing. If members were to ask the councils that...
The Presiding Officer NPA
Will members behave, please? Colin Smyth—
Bruce Crawford SNP
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. I am sorry—I thought that we had reached the end of the questions.
The Presiding Officer NPA
Not quite yet. We will be a few more minutes. Colin Smyth, to be followed by Ben Macpherson.
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab
The cabinet secretary will be aware that local councils in the border lands—Dumfries and Galloway and the Scottish Borders in Scotland, and Carlisle, Cumbria...
Keith Brown SNP
First, we have to see those proposals and have the chance to consider them. That is the only responsible thing that a Government can do. We have said that w...