Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 20 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
04 Feb 2003
Retail Pharmacies (Report)
I, too, have been lobbied, but not on a train.There are local pharmacies in cities, so the issue is important not just for rural areas but for the survival of many local pharmacies in towns. They, too, are concerned.The clerk's note says that it is for Scottish ministers to de...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
30 Jan 2002
Tobacco Advertising and Promotion (Scotland) Bill
We have heard evidence this morning that suggests that tobacco advertising is targeted at deprived neighbourhoods. Is the society satisfied that there is an adequate network of local pharmacies in deprived neighbourhoods to provide advice and therapy and so on? Is it not the c...
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
You admitted that your director general and the DTI have driven the deregulation agenda. In Scotland since 1999, successive ministers with responsibility for health have made it clear that they want to rid the NHS of the market mechanism and to dismantle completely the interna...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
It sounds as if it is. This afternoon, you have talked consistently about customers, markets and deregulation. It sounds as though you are pursuing completely the opposite agenda to that which the Parliament is pursuing. Indeed, if we took you at your word and said that the se...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
04 Feb 2003
Retail Pharmacies (Report)
We cannot just let the matter slip through. We need a briefing about the full implications of such a statutory instrument so that we know what we are voting on. Would it be possible for us to block such a statutory instrument?
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Retail Pharmacies
I will try to make Bill Butler even happier by pushing the issue further.The control of entry regulations were introduced in 1987 as a means of planning the provision of pharmaceutical services to make them match the needs of defined communities. The OFT report recommends scra...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Retail Pharmacies
Is that the planned approach or the free market approach?
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Retail Pharmacies
If there is a third way, it would be worse than the free market approach.
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Retail Pharmacies
It has been a long time since that happened.
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
When you met Scottish ministers, was it made clear to you that the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Executive had rejected market models for the delivery of NHS services?
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
I can think of monopolies, or near-monopolies, in all sectors of the economy, with huge multinationals and national chains predominating and small retail outlets getting knocked out of the picture. If we listened to you, why would not that happen in this case?
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
You are now agreeing with us. You are now saying that the sector is not appropriate for market deregulation, which your report calls for.
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
We, as a Scottish committee, have a problem because in an earlier answer to Bill Butler one of you accepted that your conclusions and recommendations were a judgment call based on little Scottish evidence. The Scottish NHS is distinctive—it has distinctive policies—but you are...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
So is the New Economics Foundation's report.
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
What was your evidence base in Scotland? It was minimal. Why should Scotland follow a model that is based on what is going on south of the border?
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
You are saying that Scotland is calling out for deregulation and the introduction of the market.
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
That is what your report calls for.
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
So there is no support for the conclusions at which you have arrived.
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Retail Pharmacies<br />(Office of Fair Trading Report)
Was that use of the Barnett formula?
The Convener: Lab Committee
18 Mar 2003
New Petitions
Although there are only two petitions on this issue before the committee, we have received petitions from all over Scotland—especially from pharmacies—that support the line that is set out in PE613 and PE614.
← Back to list
Committee

Health and Community Care Committee, 04 Feb 2003

04 Feb 2003 · S1 · Health and Community Care Committee
Item of business
Retail Pharmacies (Report)
I, too, have been lobbied, but not on a train.There are local pharmacies in cities, so the issue is important not just for rural areas but for the survival of many local pharmacies in towns. They, too, are concerned.The clerk's note says that it is for Scottish ministers to determine what action, if any, should be taken regarding the statutory arrangements for control of entry to NHS lists. Does that mean that before any change could happen, a statutory instrument would have to come before the committee?

In the same item of business

The Deputy Convener: Lab
The next item, on the Office of Fair Trading report on retail pharmacies, will be taken in public, as agreed.
Mary Scanlon: Con
Last week, on my train journey to Inverness, I sat beside a pharmacist. He had three and a half hours in which to lobby me on the issue.The report has far-re...
The Deputy Convener: Lab
The 90 days that you are talking about is the 90-day period within which responses have to be sent to the OFT.
Mary Scanlon: Con
That period ends on 17 April.
The Deputy Convener: Lab
The OFT is required to consult the devolved health departments and the Scottish Executive health department has come up with 28 February for the end of its c...
Mary Scanlon: Con
So pharmacists and anyone else in Scotland who has concerns must get their responses to Frank McAveety by 28 February, so that those views can be fed into th...
The Deputy Convener: Lab
Yes. It is a staged process. I have spoken to pharmacists in my constituency. If they miss the 28 February deadline, there is nothing to prevent them from se...
Mary Scanlon: Con
I would be concerned if there was only one opinion from Scotland—if all the views go to the minister and only one view is sent to Westminster. I hope that th...
The Deputy Convener: Lab
You seem to be saying that, given the amount of work that the committee has to do on the Mental Health (Scotland) Bill, we need to ask the minister what his ...
Nicola Sturgeon: SNP
I am concerned about the implications of the OFT report. I understand the time scale and the consultation process; the Scottish Executive will seek views unt...
The Deputy Convener: Lab
It is difficult to extricate all the information from the OFT report. From what I have seen of it so far, the OFT has not considered the issue of dispensing ...
Mr McAllion: Lab
I, too, have been lobbied, but not on a train.There are local pharmacies in cities, so the issue is important not just for rural areas but for the survival o...
The Deputy Convener: Lab
Yes.
Mr McAllion: Lab
We cannot just let the matter slip through. We need a briefing about the full implications of such a statutory instrument so that we know what we are voting ...
The Deputy Convener: Lab
Yes. Could we agree that we should ask for extra information before we decide what we are going to do? Is it agreed that we give the committee clerks two wee...
Members indicated agreement.
Janis Hughes (Glasgow Rutherglen) (Lab): Lab
Given that Executive responses are not always expeditious, can we emphasise in the letter the time scale and the committee's concerns?
The Deputy Convener: Lab
Yes.I will see you all tomorrow morning at 9.30.
Meeting closed at 11:49.