Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 49 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab Chamber
25 Apr 2002
International Workers Memorial Day
I, too, congratulate Cathy Peattie on securing another excellent debate, this time to mark international workers memorial day. It is appropriate that the debate is held on a motion in her name, given the sterling work that she does as convener of the Labour trade union group i...
The Convener: Lab Committee
19 Jun 2001
Current Petitions
The first set of petitions to which we have received a response includes PE31, PE34 and PE35. Members will remember that all those petitions asked the Parliament to review the legality of nuclear weapons in international law, consequent to the decision of Sheriff Gimblett at G...
Mr McAllion: Lab Chamber
13 Mar 2003
International Situation
It is because I feel compassion for the people of Iraq that I am opposed to the horrendous strike against them that the Governments of the United States and, unfortunately, the UK are planning.Those who are troubled by the United States and UK Governments' revisionism in relat...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
23 Jan 2002
Tobacco Advertising and Promotion (Scotland) Bill
I will clarify the point that Mary Scanlon made about the researchers in Parliament coming up with the data that she mentioned. In the section of the Scottish Parliament information centre research note that deals with international data, the researchers refer to a study that ...
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab Chamber
16 Jan 2003
International Situation
I begin by welcoming John Swinney's decision to lodge his motion and to make possible an excellent debate in the Parliament. In moving his motion, John Swinney spoke about the innate internationalism of the Scottish people, which is a source of pride to Scots of every politica...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
02 Oct 2001
Consultative Steering Group Principles
We do not verify e-petitions; that is done by the international teledemocracy centre at Napier University, which has introduced a system of grading in which seven is the highest grade and means utter reliability. The centre checks each signature on an electronic petition and t...
The Convener: Lab Committee
31 Aug 1999
Petitions
I agree. Everyone agrees that this is not a precedent, but a one-off that is happening because we are at an early stage in the committee's procedures and public guidance for petitioners has not yet been published.We will deal, as proposed, with Mr Frank's petition and then pro...
The Convener: Lab Committee
14 Dec 1999
Petitions
Petitions 31, 34 and 35 from Helen Mackenzie, Peter Norris and Marion Reynolds call on the Scottish Parliament to conduct a review of its obligations under international law regarding the presence of Trident nuclear weapons at Faslane nuclear submarine base, which are under Sc...
The Convener: Lab Committee
14 Dec 1999
Petitions
The next petition, PE40, is from the World Development Movement, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to debate the implications of the ministerial meeting of the World Trade Organisation—the petitioners refer to the recent, unsuccessful meeting of the WTO in Seattle. Intern...
The Convener (Mr John McAllion): Lab Committee
14 Mar 2000
Electronic Petitions
I call the meeting to order and welcome everyone to the fifth meeting this year of the Public Petitions Committee.We have a full agenda today. The first item is a paper that has been prepared by the clerks on electronic petitions. It has been issued beforehand to all members o...
The Convener: Lab Committee
06 Jun 2002
Electronic Petitions
The paper on electronic petitions describes the system as it operates through the partnership arrangement that we have with Napier University's international teledemocracy centre, whose e-petitioner system facilitates electronic petitioning in the Scottish Parliament. The pape...
The Convener: Lab Committee
08 Oct 2002
New Petitions
The next petition comes from Mr Allan J Bayle. It concerns the review of the Scottish Criminal Record Office. The petition calls for the Scottish Parliament to undertake an inquiry into the openness, transparency and admission of mistakes at the Scottish Criminal Record Office...
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab Chamber
13 Mar 2003
International Situation
No member of this Parliament is responsible for the fact that just seven weeks before a Scottish general election we find ourselves on the cusp of a major war and need to debate where the Parliament stands in relation to that war. Although it is naive to assume that the war wi...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
23 Jan 2002
Tobacco Advertising and Promotion (Scotland) Bill
Do you accept that action is needed at a level higher than the Scottish Parliament to make any ban on tobacco advertising effective in Scotland, given the recent internationalisation of sport? For example, tobacco companies sponsor snooker championships that are broadcast and ...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
23 Jan 2002
Tobacco Advertising and Promotion (Scotland) Bill
Is there an argument for saying that a ban should go beyond the British level? For example, during the summer, the world cup will be broadcast to Britain from Korea and Japan and I am sure that tobacco advertising will be to the fore. International events are broadcast by sate...
Mr McAllion: Lab Committee
30 Jan 2002
Tobacco Advertising and Promotion (Scotland) Bill
The two examples that you gave—formula 1 racing and cricket—are international sports that are broadcast globally by satellite television. Is it difficult to ban advertising on such globally delivered products?
Mr John McAllion (Convener, Public Petitions Committee): Lab Committee
02 Oct 2001
Consultative Steering Group Principles
Thank you for inviting me and the Public Petitions Committee to give evidence to the inquiry. The Public Petitions Committee has submitted a paper as its formal response, but I would like to take this opportunity to add a few comments of my own.Citizens' ability to petition th...
The Convener: Lab Committee
02 Nov 1999
Petitions
Is it agreed that the clerks should write to the petitioner, explaining that the European Court of Human Rights relates to international relations and is therefore a reserved matter, and that neither our committee nor the Justice and Home Affairs Committee want to take a view ...
The Convener: Lab Committee
14 Mar 2000
Electronic Petitions
People are already allowed to petition the Scottish Parliament electronically. This is simply about the method by which people do that. At the moment, they have to do it through the Scottish Parliament website. We are suggesting that for a year we will accept as a host site to...
The Convener: Lab Committee
14 Mar 2000
Electronic Petitions
Is it also agreed that for one year we should enter into a pilot scheme with the international teledemocracy centre, and that at the end of the year we should review the position?Members indicated agreement.
The Convener: Lab Committee
12 Sep 2000
Current Petitions
The last petition, PE242, is from Action of Churches Together in Scotland, the Scottish Refugee Council and Amnesty International, on the care of asylum seekers and refugees in Scotland. We have received a response from Iain Gray, the Deputy Minister for Community Care, which ...
The Convener: Lab Committee
21 Nov 2000
New Petitions
I welcome you again.PE291 has been running on the international teledemocracy centre e-petitioner website for the past four and a half months. The centre has provided the committee with a very useful briefing on the background to the petition, which is not usually available wi...
The Convener: Lab Committee
19 Dec 2000
New Petitions
Petition PE320, from John Watson on behalf of the World Development Movement, concerns the implications of the liberalisation of trade and services. It calls on the Health and Community Care Committee to examine the possible implications for health policy in Scotland of the Wo...
The Convener: Lab Committee
23 Jan 2001
Inadmissible Petitions
The next item is inadmissible petitions. This is a departure for the committee—we have never had this item before—and we agreed to it only recently. We have received a number of petitions that, in all honesty, are not admissible under the criteria for submitting petitions to t...
The Convener: Lab Committee
27 Mar 2001
New Petitions
The next petition is PE347 from Mr Kenneth Mitchell. It calls on the Scottish Parliament to investigate the practice of couping Clydesdale horses and to introduce legislation to make such a style of shoeing illegal unless it is sanctioned for medical reasons by a veterinary su...
The Convener: Lab Committee
08 May 2001
Inadmissible Petitions
We received a petition from Mr Norrie McVicar calling for the Parliament to support the campaign of the UK maritime unions for the extension of the UK immigration and work permit regime to the offshore oil and gas sector and the International Transport Workers Federation's cam...
The Convener: Lab Committee
22 May 2001
New Petitions
The final new petition this morning is PE366 from Dr Andy McDonald, on behalf of Craigmillar Community Information Service. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to support its digital inclusion charter and asks the Scottish Executive to take a range of steps to tackle...
The Convener: Lab Committee
19 Jun 2001
New Petitions
That is a clear exposition of the case for the petition. I should point out that the petition was first submitted as an e-petition via the International Teledemocracy Centre. The documentation supplied with the petition goes far beyond what usually accompanies petitions and de...
The Convener: Lab Committee
19 Jun 2001
New Petitions
PE380 is from Mr David Macnab of the East of Scotland Supporters Association. It calls on the Education, Culture and Sport Committee to initiate an inquiry into how fans' participation in the decision-making process in senior Scottish football might be promoted. The petitioner...
The Convener: Lab Committee
06 Nov 2001
New Petitions
Thank you. Just for the record, I again emphasise that almost 2,500 signatures to the petition were submitted electronically. Furthermore, committee members have a full brief on the electronic petition, including an account of various comments about the petition from people wh...
The Convener: Lab Committee
23 Apr 2002
New Petitions
The next petition, which calls for a debate on the treatment of Afghan prisoners in the USA, is from Mr Ivor Birnie and has 36 signatures. The petition is presented on behalf of the Edinburgh stop the war coalition and was prompted by the coalition's concerns about the impriso...
The Convener: Lab Committee
14 Jan 2003
New Petitions
The next petition, PE589, is from Mr George McAuley, on behalf of the UK Men's Movement. It calls on the Parliament to take the necessary steps to recognise parental alienation syndrome and to develop early intervention strategies to prevent it. Members will be aware that we h...
The Convener: Lab Committee
11 Feb 2003
New Petitions
Petition PE594 is from Thomas Ross on the subject of amateur boxing in Scotland. The petition calls on the Parliament to ask the Scottish Executive to fund the medical requirement of the AIBA—the international amateur boxing association—to eliminate abuse of amateur boxers in ...
The Convener: Lab Committee
11 Feb 2003
New Petitions
They are not meeting the international standards laid down by law.
The Convener: Lab Committee
11 Feb 2003
New Petitions
So international standards are being ignored in Scotland.
The Convener: Lab Committee
11 Feb 2003
New Petitions
You would say that they are in breach of their legal requirements under international law.
The Convener: Lab Committee
11 Feb 2003
New Petitions
Basically, you argue that international standards are not being met by those involved in boxing in Scotland and that it is time that the Parliament did something about that.
The Convener: Lab Committee
11 Mar 2003
Current Petitions
The next petition is PE534, from Mr Duncan Shields on behalf of Fathers Fighting Injustice and the International Men's Organisation, which concerns doctors' reports in court actions. Mr Shields submitted an earlier petition—PE532—on the same issue and was unhappy when the comm...
The Convener: Lab Committee
25 Mar 2003
New Petitions
A further new petition was received too late to be issued with the committee papers, but I thought that we had better deal with it. I think that members have all received it.PE619, from Professor Eric Clive and 62 other lawyers and academics, is on the subject of the legality ...
The Convener: Lab Committee
25 Mar 2003
Current Petitions
Petition PE594, from Mr Thomas C S Ross, is on amateur boxing in Scotland. Members will recall that we agreed to raise his concerns with both Scottish Amateur Boxing Ltd and the international amateur boxing association. We have now received responses from both groups.Although ...
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab Committee
08 Nov 2000
Petition
I am convener of the Public Petitions Committee, which dealt with the petition and referred it to the Social Inclusion, Housing and Voluntary Sector Committee for its information. At the time, Sandra White, I think, pointed out that many of the issues that are raised in the pe...
Mr McAllion: Lab Chamber
07 Oct 1999
Memorandum of Understanding and Concordats
I do not have time. Ms White can see me outside later on if she wants to deal with the matter. As for Scotland being shackled by the concordats, that is a laughable suggestion. The SNP is arguing as if the concordats could be regarded as international treaties that are binding...
Mr McAllion: Lab Chamber
18 Nov 1999
Scottish Economy
I was trying to be complimentary, but obviously I have not made myself clear. The thought that we need more Brian Souters and Ann Gloags in Scotland does not necessarily appeal to me. I do not know anything about those two people, other than that they are multimillionaires. If...
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab Chamber
25 Oct 2001
International Situation
The way in which the debate has been conducted this morning has, for the most part, justified holding a debate in the first place. We have heard many excellent and thoughtful speeches. I sense that the Parliament is reflecting the confusion and lack of certainty about this war...
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab Chamber
27 Mar 2002
Hamish Henderson
I congratulate Cathy Peattie on securing the debate, and on the moving and fitting way in which she opened it. I particularly congratulate her on her singing. I once heard Willie McKelvie sing "Road to the Isles" in the House of Commons, and I can assure Cathy that he came now...
Mr McAllion: Lab Chamber
13 Mar 2003
International Situation
The tragedy for Johann Lamont and me is that our party supports the Americans, who use those vetoes against the interests of the Palestinian people. That is the point that I am trying to make. Britain has been one of the closest allies of Israel and America in the United Natio...
Mr McAllion: Lab Chamber
13 Mar 2003
International Situation
It should be challenged inside the United Nations. If we abandon the United Nations completely, what else will there be to get some sort of discipline? The reality is that under the UN charter, there are simply no grounds for any pre-emptive attack against the people of Iraq. ...
Mr McAllion: Lab Chamber
13 Mar 2003
International Situation
I endorse everything that the member said. I want to concentrate on this issue, because it sometimes angers me to the point of distraction when I hear spokesmen from the United States of America speak about their concern for the humanitarian suffering of the people of Iraq. Th...
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab Chamber
19 Mar 2003
International Situation (Contingency Planning)
Does the First Minister accept that in a democracy such as ours the real betrayal of our armed forces would have been not to challenge and go on challenging the political decisions that are forcing them to lay their lives on the line? If so, will he assure me that our democrac...
← Back to list
Chamber

Plenary, 25 Apr 2002

25 Apr 2002 · S1 · Plenary
Item of business
International Workers Memorial Day
I, too, congratulate Cathy Peattie on securing another excellent debate, this time to mark international workers memorial day. It is appropriate that the debate is held on a motion in her name, given the sterling work that she does as convener of the Labour trade union group in the Parliament. I am not at all jealous that she secures so many debates and I secure none.

It is important that democratic Parliaments around the world take time to consider those workers who have died, suffered injuries or suffer serious ill health because of being forced to work in poor and dangerous conditions. That is not given the prominence that it should, not only in Scotland but around the world. That has particularly been the case in recent years, in which the focus has been very much on the new partnership between Government and business. Although many may welcome that new focus, it creates a danger of forgetting that the most important partnership, certainly for any Labour Government, is the partnership with the workers—the people whom the Labour party was brought into existence to represent.

We should never allow ourselves to forget that fact. It is not forgotten in Dundee, where the council has taken the excellent initiative of establishing an annual lecture on international workers memorial day. I think that Jaquie Roberts, the chief executive of the Scottish Commission for the Regulation of Care, is giving the lecture in Dundee tomorrow on health and safety in the area for which she is responsible. Dundee is very much a trade unionist's city. I was delighted to hear that Phil Gallie had been a trade unionist. I hope that he is still a trade unionist, because he is still working—well, he is supposed to be working. In Dundee, there has always been an emphasis on looking after the interests of workers. Among many other outstanding trade union leaders, the late Harry McLevy came from the city.

I take the opportunity to mention the 167 men who died in the Piper Alpha disaster. The discovery of oil in the North sea is often regarded as a great boon in Scotland. It was certainly good for the Treasury and the oil companies, which profited handsomely from it. It has been good for the United Kingdom economy, which has been given a great boost. Indeed, it has been good for releasing the pressure on public spending in our country over many years. However, that has all been achieved at a price—a high price indeed for those men who lost their lives in that terrible disaster.

I know that some good came out of the Piper Alpha disaster. I know that a public inquiry was held and that health and safety rules in the North sea have been tightened up. I also know that trade unions there are better organised than they ever were before. Even with all that, as Cathy Peattie pointed out, 68 men have died in the years since the Piper Alpha disaster.

As Tommy Sheridan pointed out, there has never been an inquiry into the actions of those whose negligence was criminally responsible for the loss of those 167 lives on Piper Alpha. The remit of the original public inquiry deliberately did not include consideration of who was responsible for the disaster. That injustice remains and it must be put right.

I pay tribute to Gavin Cleland, who has campaigned ceaselessly over the years to have such an inquiry into Piper Alpha. I do not think that anyone could have attended any political gathering in Scotland in the past 10 or 15 years without knowing who Gavin Cleland is. He is always there with his big banner, making sure that we never forget the men of Piper Alpha. He is right to do that.

I lodged a motion on the issue, but I was unsuccessful in securing a debate on it. However, I have lodged a new motion—S1M-2906—on criminal responsibility and the Piper Alpha disaster. Five members have signed the motion so far, and I plead for as many other members as possible to do so, in order that we may secure the debate that we want to have.

I am glad that there is an international aspect to the motion that we are debating this evening. Scottish manufacturing industry has been in decline for many years, but that is not the result of a lack of demand for our manufactured products. Companies are switching production away from places such as Scotland where trade unions are well organised and where there are health and safety regulations to parts of the world where there are no or very weak trade unions and where Governments turn a blind eye to health and safety regulations. In those countries, companies can profit from putting workers' lives at risk. That is the international situation that we confront as we debate this issue in the Scottish Parliament.

I hope that the Parliament will take a stand and that ministers will indicate that they intend to do something about the situation that I have described. It is a disgrace that the likes of Nike can be seen as respectable companies in this country and can appear on television sponsoring football matches and so on, when at the same time they are exploiting workers around the world in sweatshops where there are no trade unions, colluding with right-wing Governments to murder and kidnap people, and giving workers a very hard time. It is time that we confronted such companies and stopped working in partnership with them, because they do not deserve it.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Mr Murray Tosh): Con
The final item of business today is a members' business debate on motion S1M-2615, in the name of Cathy Peattie, on international workers memorial day—28 Apr...
Motion debated,
That the Parliament notes that 28 April 2002 is International Workers' Memorial Day, a commemoration of those who have died or suffered accidents or ill heal...
Cathy Peattie (Falkirk East) (Lab): Lab
"Mourn for the Dead, Fight for the Living" is stated on a poster, produced by the American Federation of Labor-Congress of Industrial Organizations, which sh...
The Deputy Presiding Officer: Con
Quite a few members wish to speak. If we have four-minute speeches, we might be able to fit everyone in. We might need a short extension later, but we will s...
Linda Fabiani (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP
I will be brief. I thank Cathy Peattie for securing this debate. International workers memorial day is certainly worthy of discussion. When Cathy mentioned t...
Elaine Smith (Coatbridge and Chryston) (Lab): Lab
I also congratulate Cathy Peattie on securing this evening's debate. I am a member of the Transport and General Workers Union and have declared that interest...
Phil Gallie (South of Scotland) (Con): Con
I, too, offer congratulations to Cathy Peattie on securing this debate. Perhaps my line on this issue is slightly different from that of other members. I was...
Mr Duncan McNeil (Greenock and Inverclyde) (Lab): Lab
I thank Cathy Peattie for giving us the opportunity of having this debate. International workers memorial day will be a time for reflection for people throug...
Tommy Sheridan (Glasgow) (SSP): SSP
I associate myself with the comments congratulating Cathy Peattie on securing tonight's debate.Although health and safety at work is a reserved matter, I hop...
Pauline McNeill (Glasgow Kelvin) (Lab): Lab
I thank Cathy Peattie for giving us all the opportunity to say something on this important subject. I am a trade unionist and a member of the GMB.In our deal...
Shona Robison (North-East Scotland) (SNP): SNP
I join other members in thanking Cathy Peattie for securing this debate on her motion.I want to say a few words about my father's experience as a pipe fitter...
Brian Fitzpatrick (Strathkelvin and Bearsden) (Lab): Lab
I make reference to my entry in the Register of Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament, which shows that I am a member of Amicus Amalgamated Enginee...
Mr John McAllion (Dundee East) (Lab): Lab
I, too, congratulate Cathy Peattie on securing another excellent debate, this time to mark international workers memorial day. It is appropriate that the deb...
The Deputy Presiding Officer: Con
To fit in all members who would like to speak, we need to extend the debate until 5 past 6. I would be happy to accept a motion without notice to that effect.
Motion moved,
That, under Rule 8.14.3, the debate be extended until 6.05 pm.—Mr Duncan McNeil.
Motion agreed to.
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab): Lab
My interest in speaking in this debate is the fact that hundreds of families in my constituency are affected by industrial injury. Long after the shipyards h...
The Deputy Minister for Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning (Lewis Macdonald): Lab
I thank Cathy Peattie for lodging her motion, which has stimulated a positive and constructive debate. Many useful contributions have been made from around t...
Phil Gallie: Con
In the past, alcohol was acknowledged as a danger in the workplace. Does the minister have any thoughts on the problems that are caused by drugs in the workp...
Lewis Macdonald: Lab
My colleagues in the health department will address those issues and Mary Mulligan will respond on that in more detail at an appropriate time.Duncan McNeil m...
Meeting closed at 18:06.