Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Gil Paterson SNP Chamber
23 Feb 2017
Budget (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
That might well be the case, but the point is that, locally, Labour councillors and Jackie Baillie in particular have berated the freezing of the council tax, yet Labour has continued that freeze. That is what we are talking about. We have the business bonus, but we also have...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
30 May 2019
A Trading Nation
I refer the public to my entry in the register of interests. “A Trading Nation” is a substantial piece of work in a comprehensive format that is easily understood and which points the way forward for Scotland to improve its economic future through increased exports. The docu...
The Convener: SNP Committee
19 May 2009
Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament Act 2006
Item 2 relates to proposed amendments to the Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament Act 2006, which will result from the implementation of the Companies Act 2006. The proposed amendments are set out in a letter to the Minister for Parliamentary Business from Ian Pears...
Gil Paterson SNP Chamber
20 May 2010
High-speed Rail
We have to talk about it before we can develop it. Give us the commitment and the money, and I am sure that it will happen overnight. Despite the experts suggesting that the link should start in Scotland, the project will start in the south of England. Should history repeat it...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
13 Sep 2012
Electricity Market Reform
The debate comes at an important time and is welcome. When we discuss energy matters, there tends to be a focus on how the energy is produced and distributed, rather than on how it impacts on ordinary persons. I will attempt to focus on the production of electricity and on how...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
30 Sep 2015
Employment
I thank the Labour Party for bringing this debate to the chamber today. Scotland, like the rest of the UK, felt the effects of the recession, and this is a welcome opportunity to discuss the progress of Scotland and its Government in improving employment. As it stands, Scotla...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
01 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
My experience is in the automotive industry in Scotland, not the UK—I am not talking about big plants manufacturing cars in England. The number of EU nationals in that industry now in Scotland is quite substantial and they are very highly qualified. My question also relates...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
28 Feb 2017
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I declare an interest: I own a business that relies heavily on imports from the EU. Ever since the Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee was formed in this session, there have been concerns that the statistics, particularly in regard to the Scottish economy, are not particul...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
03 Oct 2017
Economic Data
How do you see the Digital Economy Act 2017 improving the quality and timeliness of economic statistics in the UK, and what can Scotland learn from that?
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
03 Oct 2017
Economic Data
How easy is it to get access to key economic statistical information?
Mr Gil Paterson (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
25 Nov 1999
Law and Order
I have no doubt that this Tory-initiated debate is intended to centre on the Conservatives' supposedly impeccable record on law and order, as against the fact that Labour has allowed the country to go to rack and ruin. I have no intention of getting involved in the shouting ma...
Mr Gil Paterson (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
07 Feb 2001
Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2001
Local authorities are meant to work in partnership with Government to deliver local services and address local needs. However, the details that have emerged from the spending review show a lack of resources and a lack of flexibility in the relationship between local and centra...
Mr Gil Paterson (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
05 Sep 2001
Education Curriculum (1820 Martyrs)
On a bright summer's afternoon, on 30 August 1820, a crowd of 20,000 people gathered on Glasgow green to watch the execution of a Strathaven weaver, James Wilson.After taking part in a simple religious service and drinking the customary glass of wine, Wilson, dressed in white,...
Gil Paterson (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
04 Nov 2009
National Parks
Presiding Officer, I apologise to you and other members for the fact that I need to leave a bit early, unfortunately. I hope that members forgive me—I have a prior engagement. I am delighted to participate in this important debate about some of Scotland's greatest assets—our n...
Gil Paterson (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
21 Jan 2010
Prescription Charges
Many people who are ill and cannot work face a financial penalty through having their wages docked by their employer. That means a treble whammy—people worry about their health, their job and the cost of getting better. Of course, people who are in employment have already paid...
Gil Paterson (West of Scotland) (SNP) SNP Committee
05 Oct 2010
Palliative Care (Scotland) Bill: Financial Memorandum
I am grateful to the committee for inviting me to give evidence on the Palliative Care (Scotland) Bill. Given the committee’s affection for figures, I thought that it would be best to start by quoting a few that set out the context of the bill. More than 55,000 people in Scotl...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
10 Jan 2012
Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
There is intercourse between the industry and supermarkets in particular. If we take cheap alcohol away from the place in which the industry makes its money, namely floor space in supermarkets, we might shift alcohol sales to the internet. Do you agree that the effect of that ...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
10 Jan 2012
Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Mr Williamson, I want not to put you on the spot but to ask you to utilise your experience. Drew Smith mentioned the possibility of on-sales benefiting from the introduction of minimum pricing, in that clubs would be able to sell alcohol more cheaply, on the basis of market fo...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
20 Feb 2013
High-speed Rail
A couple of years ago, the Parliament visited America for tartan day. I was there and I was struck by the fact that American plans for developing a high-speed rail link relied on a route into Canada and on close co-operation. Do you have comments on or knowledge of how two eco...
Gil Paterson (West of Scotland) (SNP) SNP Chamber
03 Mar 2010
Fairtrade Fortnight
The Scottish Parliament has an excellent record of bringing fair trade issues to the public’s attention. The topic of tonight’s debate—Fairtrade fortnight—continues this fine record. Bill Butler should be congratulated on securing the debate. It gives the chamber the chance, o...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
05 Feb 2013
Human Rights
I welcome the opportunity to speak in the debate and highlight our country’s role in the world in defending human rights.In Scotland, we have a proud tradition and history of protecting and promoting human rights, not only for our citizens but internationally. The principle of...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
01 May 2013
Voluntary Sector (Funding)
I have carefully read Gavin Brown’s motion on voluntary sector funding and I cannot find a single word that I disagree with, which is probably a first in my parliamentary career. John Swinney’s amendment certainly finishes it off properly.I have great respect for the third sec...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
30 Oct 2014
Supported Business
I am pleased to be speaking in this important debate. Before beginning my speech, though, I must declare a constituency interest, in that a business has recently—and significantly—opened in the town of Clydebank, in the factory that was formerly used by Remploy. That is a very...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
28 Jan 2015
Women Offenders
I am pleased to speak in this debate on women offenders and how we can best deal with that problem. This is my first speech as a member of the Justice Committee, but I have been involved with and have paid close attention to the issue for a good number of years. My starting p...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
11 Mar 2015
Scotland’s Economy
There are so many things in the Labour Party motion that are questionable that it is difficult to make up one’s mind just where to start. However, the overall comment that best describes its major message is clear. It is another talking-down-Scotland exercise by Labour—a rubbi...
Gil Paterson SNP Chamber
10 Nov 2015
Trade Union Bill
No union has ever approached me. If they approach me, they will be welcome. I run something closer to a co-operative than a business. That is only possible if we work with and trust people as equals. The bill is therefore madness, and will cause division where none exists. In...
Gil Paterson SNP Chamber
08 Sep 2016
First Minister’s Question Time · Brexit (Business Support)
Does the First Minister agree that it is high time that the United Kingdom Government followed our lead and announced its own economic stimulus package rather than continuing to brush off all concerns about the future of our economy by repeating its meaningless mantra “Brexit ...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Committee
25 Oct 2016
“Supporting Scotland’s economic growth”
First I have a general question, and then I will move on to a couple of specific questions. An issue that has bedevilled this new committee in its short existence, and which has come up at every single meeting in this parliamentary session, concerns statistics that are partic...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
25 Oct 2016
“Supporting Scotland’s economic growth”
That would be useful; I would like to see the data. There is a conundrum that the committee has somehow to solve with regard to why we cannot get the information. I will refer in particular to exhibit 1 on page 9, following the point that Jackie Baillie made. The figure for p...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
25 Oct 2016
“Supporting Scotland’s economic growth”
The substance of my question concerns the fact that we are comparing Scotland with the United Kingdom. We know the black hole in the United Kingdom—London is the black hole that disturbs everything that surrounds it, including the whole of England. There are difficulties with ...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
25 Oct 2016
“Supporting Scotland’s economic growth”
To go back to my original question, my main point is that if we do not have for Scotland discernible figures that we can interrogate, how can we possibly say that the figures are categoric? I am not blaming you for that, but it is a serious question—particularly at the junctur...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
25 Oct 2016
“Supporting Scotland’s economic growth”
I appreciate that. Thank you.
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
01 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I am looking at the long term, but there might be quite a sharp cut-off. How do we square that circle? How long does it take to train people in those highly skilled jobs and how will that impact on the economy?
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
01 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I do not know whether anyone else has an opinion. I referred to the automotive industry, but other people might be more familiar with the health service and the impact on it—it is just that I know all about the motor industry, I am sorry to say.
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
01 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I hope that you will indulge me if I comment quickly on the previous subject, convener. I understand that the tariff for automobile parts is substantially lower than that for the finished articles. That is a worldwide phenomenon. My main question is about the statistics on ex...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Committee
08 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I was going to put this question to the next panel of witnesses, but I will ask it now in case this panel has some answers. I should declare an interest: I am in the automotive industry, and my business imports quite a substantial amount. We deal not in parts but in coatings—v...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
08 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
That is fine. Does anyone else want to comment?
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
08 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I have a quick question on building new markets. The door has been prised open by the High Court judgment on article 50, so nobody knows exactly where things will land. My question is twofold. Should the Parliament focus on expanding markets in a particular area? That quest...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
08 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
It is a fundamental question about Scottish and UK exports. There is evidence to suggest that some Scottish exports are counted as English exports because they go through English ports, I think because when the deal is done and the contract is signed, it specifies that an Engl...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Committee
15 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
Good morning, everybody. I have a general question that will leave the witnesses free to come in on any particular area that they are interested in. The committee has been out and about. We have just started taking evidence from different sectors out in the field throughout S...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
15 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
On planning, whom should we be aiming at? Who is really calling the shots? Is it the UK Government or the European Union? I know how important the financial sector is to Scotland—although I gather that the Scottish interest and the London interest are perhaps slightly differe...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Committee
29 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I would like to follow up on those points, on which we have heard from a number of witnesses. For example, David Williamson from the Scotch Whisky Association, said that “Obtaining detailed and accurate Scottish export statistics has been a challenge”. Scottish Engineering’s...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
29 Nov 2016
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
Will the research be peculiar to Scotland, or will it be based on the ONS research?
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Chamber
23 Feb 2017
Budget (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
The budget delivers on the promises that the Government was elected on. It was created in Scotland for Scotland, not dictated to us by Westminster. Scotland’s finances are still being strangled by the UK Tory Government, but we will not bend to its plan of total austerity. We ...
Gil Paterson SNP Chamber
28 Feb 2017
Economic Impact of Leaving the European Union
I will come on to that, but I think that those quotes are about direct exports. The uncertainty on the issue is damaging to individual companies and to the industries that benefit from their skills. I own a business, which my son runs and which has millions of pounds in turno...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Committee
19 Sep 2017
Economic Data
One of the biggest things about GERS that sticks out for me is that billions of pounds that are raised in tax in Scotland are spent furth of Scotland, which has impacts. The first whammy is that that money is spent outwith the Scottish economy. The second whammy is that that m...
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
The Royal Statistical Society’s submission says that the 2017 act will not provide devolved Administrations with direct access. That is quite straightforward. It also says that those administrations “should” be able to get access; maybe that should be changed to “will”, so tha...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
Does anyone else have an opinion on whether access should be statutory?
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
I do not think that anyone questions the quality of the data.
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
I would have thought that in Scotland the problem would be about the quantity of the stats, because they are so low in number as to be meaningless. 10:00
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
How relevant will the process be to Scotland? Could you say more about the benefits that we hope will flow from it?
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
Thank you.
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
Yes. What are the key gaps in coverage in Scotland and what are your priorities in filling them?
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
Yes.
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
So there are perhaps three options open to us. First, the Parliament could push for a totally devolved system such as the one in Northern Ireland; secondly, we could have some kind of statutory involvement with the ONS to ensure that the data comes automatically; or, thirdly, ...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
I suppose that, like running a business, it is a chicken-and-egg thing. If you looked at the statistics, you would not be able to run a business.
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
26 Sep 2017
Economic Data
Instead, I would analyse how I was performing and make my decision. Do we not need quality stats—although in Scotland the stats might need to be quantitative rather than qualitative—before we make our move, or can we do it in a different way?
Gil Paterson (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP) SNP Committee
03 Oct 2017
Economic Data
There has been a lot of talk about exports, and there are certainly questions in relation to that. Putting my business hat on, particularly with Brexit, however, we do not have very much information on imports. Our agencies that are charged with improving the Scottish econom...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
03 Oct 2017
Economic Data
I agree with you. From experience, I understand the amount of goods that land in England and are held in warehouses before being shipped. We are the Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee, and it is very important for the Scottish economy that we understand that issue. We are a...
Gil Paterson SNP Committee
03 Oct 2017
Economic Data
The Royal Statistical Society has pointed out: “The DEA will not provide devolved administrations with direct access to these data sources but they should be able to access them through ONS”. Is that not a bit of weakness in that legislation? Does it not take us back to wher...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 23 February 2017

23 Feb 2017 · S5 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Budget (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
Paterson, Gil SNP Clydebank and Milngavie Watch on SPTV

That might well be the case, but the point is that, locally, Labour councillors and Jackie Baillie in particular have berated the freezing of the council tax, yet Labour has continued that freeze. That is what we are talking about.

We have the business bonus, but we also have the social bonus of free further education, free prescriptions and free bus passes, among other benefits that are exclusive to Scotland. I am sad that the Tories are demanding a tax reduction for the highest paid. Should we not maintain the principle that the more a person earns, the more they contribute? There are many higher earners who will gladly contribute their fair share, and I thank them for that.

The Scottish budget protects Scottish services. We have invested in education, and I welcome the new funds that are set to be given to schools. Most of the schools in my constituency will benefit from that funding. More important, more funding will go through the mechanism to underprivileged pupils. That will help to improve the life chances of many young people, and it will also help to reduce the attainment gap, as the Government has vowed to do.

The funding increase for universities and colleges is excellent news and, as I have said, free education will continue. If the Tories had their way, everyone would have to pay the huge fees that apply down south. Every person, no matter what their background is, should get the chance to have a great education if they so choose. The SNP is delivering on its promises.

Poverty scars Scotland. The problem is historical, but we are tackling it. Many of my constituents will benefit from the Scottish Government continuing to mitigate the impact of the hated bedroom tax. Many in my constituency will also benefit from the Scottish welfare fund, which will clear up the mess that the UK Government’s punitive welfare programme has left. The wheels are in motion for a new Scottish social security system. With the powers that we have, we will run welfare with dignity and respect.

Economic growth is the key to Scotland’s prosperity. With the few tools that we have, we are still driving economic growth. We have invested £4 billion in our infrastructure. Most of us will have seen the amazing developments that are taking place, such as the motorway projects on the M8 and the M74 and the stunning Queensferry crossing. Many more projects are progressing across the country. They are all drivers of economic growth and will improve the lives of millions.

The SNP Government is building our economy. My Clydebank constituency boasts one of the finest heart surgery hospitals in the world. The Golden Jubilee national hospital is to receive a multimillion-pound expansion and 700 new jobs, which are not being transferred—they are brand-new jobs in the local economy. I also note that health and social care partnerships help some of my most vulnerable constituents.

The budget is about economic growth, investment in our public services and social justice. It is about protecting our most vulnerable from the class war that is waged by the Tories, making Scotland’s economy prosper and investing in and protecting public services. I call on all MSPs to back the budget tonight.

15:58  

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Ken Macintosh) NPA
The first item of business this afternoon is a debate on motion S5M-04168, in the name of Derek Mackay, on the Budget (Scotland) Bill. 14:31
The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Constitution (Derek Mackay) SNP
I am delighted to lead this debate on the budget bill for 2017-18. First, I confirm that I responded formally to the Finance and Constitution Committee repo...
Mike Rumbles (North East Scotland) (LD) LD
Will the minister consider reopening the closing date for submissions to the Barclay review of business rates so that, as a result of what has happened recen...
Derek Mackay SNP
I am staggered. I have never heard Mike Rumbles make such a contribution—a constructive suggestion—in the chamber before. In that spirit, it is absolutely ri...
Ross Thomson (North East Scotland) (Con) Con
I refer to my register of interests. I am an Aberdeen City Council councillor. If the Scottish National Party had been paying attention, it would know that ...
Derek Mackay SNP
What hypocrisy from Ross Thomson and the Conservatives. In Aberdeenshire Council, which is led by the SNP, the Conservatives opposed the local rates relief p...
Murdo Fraser (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con
In the stage 1 debate three weeks ago, I said that the finance secretary was a lucky man. He was lucky because he had more resources than any of his predeces...
Stewart Stevenson (Banffshire and Buchan Coast) (SNP) SNP
Will the Tories be voting against the budget tonight and denying businesses across Scotland access to the £44.5 million to which Murdo Fraser just referred? ...
Murdo Fraser Con
If Mr Stevenson asked the business community in Scotland for its view on the budget, it would give a clear response that would not be the one that he is look...
Derek Mackay SNP
I hate to inform members that Murdo Fraser is wrong. I have spoken to the SNP leader of Perth and Kinross Council, who said that the council is building an a...
Murdo Fraser Con
What a change there has been since yesterday afternoon. I have no doubt that Mr Swinney has been on the phone to the council to tell it to sort out its act i...
Gillian Martin (Aberdeenshire East) (SNP) SNP
Will the member take an intervention?
Murdo Fraser Con
No, I am sorry—I have no time. In the long run, it will be the Scottish public finances that suffer. If our economy does not grow, our tax revenue will not ...
Kezia Dugdale (Lothian) (Lab) Lab
Stronger for Scotland: that is what we were told that the SNP would be. “Vote for us,” SNP members said, “and we will be stronger for Scotland.” Those of us ...
The Minister for Parliamentary Business (Joe FitzPatrick) SNP
What about the small business bonus?
Kezia Dugdale Lab
The SNP’s shambolic U-turn on business rates, which I point out to Mr FitzPatrick is for a specific group of firms, is welcome. However, our public services ...
Derek Mackay SNP
Kezia Dugdale has mentioned cuts a number of times and has tried to make the case local. Just to take one example, in the City of Edinburgh Council—which she...
Daniel Johnson (Edinburgh Southern) (Lab) Lab
It is a £27 million cut.
Kezia Dugdale Lab
I do not accept the cabinet secretary’s figure. He can hear from my colleague, who represents Edinburgh Southern, that the figure is in fact a £27 million cu...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green
Much like the debate in this chamber earlier this week on the rate resolution and non-domestic rates, it is pretty much inevitable that this afternoon’s deba...
Neil Findlay (Lothian) (Lab) Lab
Mr Harvie’s party had the SNP over a barrel in the budget negotiations. Which high environmental or tax justice principles did the Green Party advance when i...
Patrick Harvie Green
I am grateful to Mr Findlay for giving me an opportunity to talk about local government, because that is precisely where the Green approach to the budget has...
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Christine Grahame) SNP
I would like to hear what Mr Harvie has to say, please.
Patrick Harvie Green
We were most focused on the cuts to the non-ring-fenced core local government allocation. What we secured is not just an additional allocation and the first ...
Patrick Harvie Green
I have never said that this budget is perfect and I will not do so today, but this is the biggest budget concession that any Administration has given any Opp...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
Please sit down, Mr Johnson.
Patrick Harvie Green
The concession will make a difference in every local government area, including the one that Mr Johnson represents.
Daniel Johnson Lab
Does the member recognise that that difference is still a £170 million cut to local government, whatever way he dresses it up?
Patrick Harvie Green
I note that Mr Johnson ended his intervention by saying “whatever way it’s dressed up.” It will always be possible to produce a different interpretation of t...
Anas Sarwar (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab
Will the member take an intervention?