Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
16 Dec 1999
Health Service
It is precisely because I am determined that the NHS should give the best possible service to elderly people—and all the people of Scotland—that I want us to make progress in developing in our hospitals and in our communities the patient-centred health service that the people ...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
14 Dec 2000
Health Plan
This statement marks the publication of "Our National Health: A plan for action, a plan for change". It sets out a radical plan to improve the health of the people of Scotland and to rebuild and renew our national health service. It is not just another Government policy docume...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
06 Jul 2000
National Health Service
To drive forward this formidable programme of work, we need to have the people and processes in place. Yesterday, the first meeting of the new NHS Modernisation Board for Scotland took place. The board will help drive forward our modernisation programme. It will also build on ...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Arbuthnott Report<br />(NHS Resources)
I am pleased to have the opportunity to make what I believe is a very important announcement. I realise that we are competing with a number of other important events around the country, but I am grateful for the interest that many members have shown in the issue.My statement s...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
12 Jan 2000
Influenza and NHS Winter Planning
Thank you, Presiding Officer. I am grateful for this opportunity to make a statement to Parliament on the flu outbreak that is currently affecting people the length and breadth of the country and on the impact that the outbreak is having on the national health service in Scotl...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
22 Mar 2000
National Health Service
Presiding Officer, I am grateful for the opportunity to make this statement. I will take your words to heart, as I had intended to. I also apologise to Opposition colleagues for the late delivery of my statement this afternoon, for which I take full responsibility. Today, I wa...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
09 Nov 2000
National Health Service
There are many different views on the structure of the NHS, and I shall comment later on the issue that Andrew Welsh has raised.Since taking up office, I have given that message about the internal market loudly and clearly to the NHS in Scotland. I am pleased that many local N...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
09 Nov 2000
National Health Service
I am glad that we have the opportunity to have this important debate in the Parliament this morning.The national health service is our biggest and most important public service. Its founding principles hold good today, as they did when it was created more than 50 years ago. Th...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
01 Mar 2001
Primary Care
White coats, hospital beds, high-tech equipment, intensive care units—those are typically the images that flash up on television screens and in people's minds when we talk about the national health service. However, the reality is that more than 90 per cent of patient contacts...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
20 Sep 2001
Patient Care
I welcome this morning's debate and I have listened with interest to David McLetchie's opening remarks. I welcome his acknowledgement of the complexity and scale of the task of modernising and developing the NHS. I also welcome his desire for a balanced and measured debate abo...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
06 Jul 2000
National Health Service
Too often, still, the way services are delivered owes more to the needs of the service than the needs of patient. That is why the NHS needs modernisation, investment and reform.Since the turn of the year, we have been mapping out our modernisation programme for the NHS in Scot...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
09 Nov 2000
National Health Service
I give an assurance that funding flows have been very much on our minds and will be dealt with in some detail in the health plan. One of the problems with the old internal market system was that it tended to know the price of everything and the value of very little. We want to...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
20 Sep 2000
Question Time · National Health Service
I am glad that Duncan Hamilton shares my commitment to putting patients at the heart of the NHS and I hope that in his contributions to debate, in this chamber and in the Health and Community Care Committee, he will join me in taking that forward. I am pleased to see his resea...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
20 Sep 2001
Patient Care
I am glad that Shona Robison welcomes what I have said. Of course, the difference between our policies and the SNP's policies is that we have some, and we have translated our commitments and aspirations into practice. In a moment I will address private sector involvement, beca...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
27 Apr 2004
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2002/03”
I am keen to pursue the wider contractual issues that have been mentioned. There are three major pillars under pay modernisation—GMS contracts, consultant contracts and the agenda for change—all of which are being implemented on a UK basis.I would like to pursue the Scottish d...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
06 Jul 2000
National Health Service
This Executive wants a Scotland in which fewer people need health care because there is less illness. That is why we held a healthy Scotland convention this week, to bring ministers with different portfolios together with people with skills, expertise and perspectives from rig...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Committee
27 Oct 1999
Arbuthnott Report
I am very pleased that the committee has responded so positively to our request to look at the Arbuthnott review fully and carefully. We consider the review to be an important development. In a moment, I will say more from the Executive's point of view about the background to ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
16 Dec 1999
Health Service
I have taken a number of interventions. Nissen huts, mixed-sex accommodation, drafty corridors, Nightingale wards—that is not a modern NHS. It is not what we want for our families. It is not what we should offer to the Scottish people. As politicians, we owe it to the staff wh...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
03 Feb 2000
National Health Service
As Mr Adam and other members will be aware, there is proper machinery for negotiating pay in the NHS, which has existed for some time. We are reconsidering the way in which that machinery can work most effectively in the future. The non-pay review body staff have an offer on t...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
12 Jan 2000
Influenza and NHS Winter Planning
We have to manage a serious situation that affects families, employers and the NHS in Scotland. In such circumstances, it would be helpful if the Opposition could engage in this debate responsibly and effectively. With regard to many of the points that Mrs Ullrich has raised, ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
14 Sep 2004
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2002/03”
I am happy to take the opportunity to do that, although should the Auditor General wish to comment on any of my observations, I would be grateful for those insights.I am struck by a number of points in the response. First, I echo what the Auditor General said in that the respo...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
10 May 2000
Budget Process
Consultation and public information are crucial. Although none of us has absolutely correct answers on how to proceed on the matter, the Executive, the committee and particularly the health service have all been working hard to develop new forms of communicating with and engag...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Budget 2001-02
Hugh Henry's point has been at the core of discussions that have taken place over many months and which will come to fruition with the publication of the Scottish health plan in November. He is right to make the point—I have identified it myself and many people throughout the ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
16 May 2001
Budget Process 2002-03
The other matter that was raised was hospital-acquired infection. I will comment on a couple of matters and Gerry Marr and John Aldridge may also wish to say something on the subject. A great deal of work has been undertaken on hospital-acquired infection by the department and...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
16 Dec 1999
Health Service
It is right and fitting that this, our last parliamentary debate before the turn of the century, should be about the future of our national health service in Scotland. That reflects the priorities of this partnership Executive, and I believe that it reflects the priorities of ...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Committee
07 Dec 2004
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2002/03”
First, I will respond to the two suggestions in the letter, which are to have a briefing on pay modernisation and a briefing on the review of health and care statistics. My view is that, subject to our finding time in our schedule, we should take up the offer of a briefing on ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Jan 2005
“Overview of the financial performance of the NHS in Scotland 2003/04”
Thank you. We may return to wider questions on financial pressures later. However, I have a question about the impact of the costs of pay modernisation on the service. The question specifically relates to two additional releases of resource to boards last year. First, £30 mill...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
10 May 2000
Budget Process
The simple answer to that is that anyone who looks for certainty will always be disappointed. We will not get certainty. There is much uncertainty around and that will inevitably continue. Many of us know from our past political and professional lives that that is the case. Th...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Budget 2001-02
It is always welcome to hear members of the Health and Community Care Committee offering to help the Executive. The key question is how best to do that. What questions do we ask? What information is reported and at what level is it reported? Some of the detail to which Richard...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
07 Sep 2000
Question Time · National Health Service
As ever, John McAllion raises a challenging range of issues, and I will do my best in the couple of minutes that are available to address each of them in turn.First, in the report that was published by the task force that has examined the NHS in Tayside, there were a number of...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Arbuthnott Report<br />(NHS Resources)
I have addressed Duncan Hamilton's last point in some detail this morning. I have set out clearly the work that has been done and the work that is in train to review and revise the performance management, accountability and governance framework within which the NHS in Scotland...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
27 Oct 1999
Arbuthnott Report
I hope that I can be forgiven, convener, for repeating one or two points that I made earlier, although I will try to add other information. I wish to make this crystal clear again—it has been debated in the Parliament—that we have now entered a period of record investment in t...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Public Health
I agree absolutely with Des McNulty's point. I can assure him that my colleagues throughout the Executive are considering how all the resources that we put to work across Scotland can be used to tackle deprivation effectively. Of course, I have a particular responsibility to e...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
27 Apr 2004
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2002/03”
That was just my insurance policy. Often, after we have had these sessions, we need time to reflect. I sense that, from what we have heard, we clearly need to reflect on what we are going to say about the pay modernisation issues.Although I would not want to push the committee...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Consultative Steering Group Inquiry
I am afraid that I continue to have concerns about this section. I apologise that I have not consigned alternative text to writing, but I am willing to do that at the 11th hour. I do not disagree with anything in the section, but I think that it is mealy-mouthed. It is not the...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
23 Jan 2007
“Implementing the NHS consultant contract in Scotland”
Notwithstanding the comments and criticisms that we have all made, it is important for us to make wider comments and not to lose sight of the big picture. There are echoes of discussions that we have had about the McCrone deal and the overarching aims of some of the big pay re...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Arbuthnott Report
Deprivation and the wider agenda of social justice have been addressed since the Executive came into office last year. We have worked hard to put tackling health inequalities at the heart of our policy agenda. I shall give a couple of examples of that. We have targeted the all...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
06 Jul 2000
National Health Service
We live in interesting times. More important, we live in challenging times. Fifty-two years ago this week, the national health service was created. Fifty-two weeks ago, the Scottish Parliament took up its powers. It was new politics, a new system of government and a new opport...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
20 Sep 2000
Question Time · National Health Service
Waiting lists must be a top priority in NHS modernisation. I am very disappointed by the length of waiting lists in some parts of the country—indeed, in the most recently published figures, 67 per cent of the increase in waiting lists was attributed to four NHS trusts and acti...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
12 Jan 2000
Influenza and NHS Winter Planning
Perhaps Mr Gallie should be reminded of history. It was a partnership between a Liberal, William Beveridge, and a Labour MP, Nye Bevan, which built the health service. That same partnership will take the NHS forward in the 21st century. We will engage in issues effectively and...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
25 Oct 2000
Primary Dental Care
I will answer the question that I think that Dorothy-Grace Elder is about to ask by saying that a problem arises when there are mixed messages and when unhealthy foods are promoted in schools. We are aware of that problem and are working with the Health Education Board Scotlan...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
14 Dec 2000
Health Plan
We are very concerned to ensure that the NHS at a local level is responsive to local communities. There was a concern that once the Scottish Parliament was established things might shift to the centre. Sometimes truly local issues have been overly elevated as national issues i...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
14 Dec 2000
Health Plan
What will happen over time in the structure of the NHS will be a matter for proper and fair consideration through the review process to which I have alluded. It is crucial that there is effective local accountability, but that and local operational autonomy are not necessarily...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Chamber
12 Dec 2001
National Health Service
I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak in the debate, a year on from publication of the Scottish health plan. Unlike the Opposition, the Scottish health plan focused not only on identifying problems but on coming up with solutions for the short, medium and long term. It...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
03 Feb 2000
National Health Service
I speak to NHS staff week in, week out. The one thing that they do not believe is that life was better under the Tories than it is now. The RCN survey to which Mr Wallace refers shows improvements in many areas, and it shows that there is recognition among nurses that steps ha...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Committee
25 Jan 2005
“Overview of the financial performance of the NHS in Scotland 2003/04”
Good morning. Dr Woods, I feel duty bound to welcome you back to NHS Scotland and I wish you well in the challenges that lie ahead.My first question follows on from Andrew Welsh's question. On page 24 of the financial overview report, a table gives Scottish Executive Health De...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Budget 2001-02
Margaret Jamieson raises several important issues, which she has put to me several times before. I agree with some of her general points and I share some of her frustrations. The Government faces some real issues.The Government is pumping an extra £400 million to £500 million ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
07 Sep 2000
Question Time · National Health Service
Tackling and reducing waiting times at every stage of a patient's experience is an absolute priority for the Scottish Executive and for the NHS in Scotland. I am pleased that the most recent figures show that steady progress is being made in reducing waiting times. An importan...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
14 Sep 2000
Question Time · Health Services (Tayside)
It would be more appropriate for Mr Welsh to welcome the fact that decisions about the future of the health service in Tayside are being made and discussed openly. Increasingly, that is true of decisions that affect the NHS throughout Scotland, and it will continue to be so. I...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
05 Oct 2000
Older People (Care)
In addition to my statement, a detailed written response is being produced today. Members can find further information in that response on some of the issues that have been raised.It has been on our minds, not only in the development of today's announcement, but in our work on...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
11 Jan 2001
Question Time · Acute Services Review (Glasgow)
I am aware of the sensitivities and concerns in many parts of the country, as important changes take place in the national health service. I am particularly aware of some of the issues that I know Ken Macintosh has raised previously and which he has discussed with me. As we pr...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
14 Jun 2001
Question Time · Ayr Hospital
I will visit the Ayrshire and Arran Health Board area next week and will take the opportunity to speak to local NHS leaders and GPs, to discuss the issue further. I am pleased that the sizeable programme of investment and modernisation that the Scottish Executive has developed...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
27 Oct 1999
Arbuthnott Report
I am glad that the voluntary sector was mentioned in that broader context. All too often, we speak of the NHS and social services but forget that the third important element of care is the services that the voluntary sector can provide. In any discussion about funding, several...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
12 Jan 2000
Influenza and NHS Winter Planning
I will deal first with Robert Brown's point about where the service is now. As I said in my statement, the medical and scientific advice suggests that the number of new cases will peak this week but—for the reasons that I gave earlier—there will be high levels of illness and t...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
18 May 2000
Community Care
That is precisely why we have moved forward on so many of the recommendations that were made by the royal commission. That is why we have said time and again in Parliament that the remainder of the royal commission recommendations will form part of our considerations in the fo...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
06 Jul 2000
National Health Service
As I agreed with the service in February, we are now taking forward the development of a national health improvement programme for Scotland to provide a clear strategic framework for the development of the NHS. We are developing a more open and inclusive approach to policy dev...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
20 Sep 2000
Question Time · National Health Service
Our aims in modernising the health service are to ensure that the NHS is patient-centred, so that patients have a positive experience in all their contacts with the NHS; that the NHS is able to demonstrate that it is efficient, effective and responsive; and that the NHS satisf...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
14 Dec 2000
Health Plan
Keith Raffan raises two important points. I agree with what he said about structural reform. I am concerned that Nicola Sturgeon is urging us to implement wider structural reform more quickly. The last thing that the NHS needs at this time is widespread and ill-considered stru...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
03 Feb 2000
National Health Service
I am keen to set out constructively and openly the Executive's actions and policies on the NHS. We are investing more in health, but I have said repeatedly that that is not an end in itself—it is what we do with the money that matters. We must ensure that resources are channel...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Committee
21 Dec 2004
“Overview of the financial performance of the NHS in Scotland 2003/04”
I welcome the change to the format of the report, which is explained in paragraph 14. I found the new format helpful and wanted to say so by way of feedback.Although I have identified a number of points and queries, as the convener said, I do not expect to get answers today. H...
← Back to list
Chamber

Plenary, 16 Dec 1999

16 Dec 1999 · S1 · Plenary
Item of business
Health Service
Deacon, Susan Lab Edinburgh East and Musselburgh Watch on SPTV
It is precisely because I am determined that the NHS should give the best possible service to elderly people—and all the people of Scotland—that I want us to make progress in developing in our hospitals and in our communities the patient-centred health service that the people of Scotland need.

The Executive is determined to do that. We want to build on the foundation that we inherited from the previous Labour Administration, which drew a line under the madness of the internal market, ended the inequity of GP fundholding and so began the process of healing the health service. No one should underestimate the damage that was done by the divisiveness of the internal market and by policies that put political ideology before the needs of patients.

We have begun the process of renewal, but I am determined that we will see it through to fruition. First, we must ensure that the NHS of the future is based truly on collaboration, not on competition. I want us to increase the pace of collaboration and partnership in the NHS in Scotland, not just between trust and health board or trust and trust, but between manager and clinician, doctor and nurse and carer and cleaner. There must be a new mobilisation of all the staff who deliver our NHS services.

Through the Scottish partnership forum, we have put that philosophy into practice. We have brought together NHS staff, trade unions, management and Government, not across the table, but around it. We have worked together to deliver real improvements: the first ever education, training and lifelong learning strategy for the NHS in Scotland, the soon-to-be-launched occupational health and safety strategy for NHS staff and other products of partnership working, such as the millennium pay deal and action to reduce junior doctors' working hours. Those are real improvements for NHS employees, which in turn deliver real improvements to NHS patients.

The partnership approach is now being developed at local level and, over the months ahead, I want to ensure that partnership working becomes a reality across the NHS in Scotland. There is no one better placed to help shape the future of the NHS than the people who work in it. I want them to be at the heart of the decision- making process.

Alongside that, I will be working to bring about a step change in the way in which the NHS—locally and nationally—communicates and engages with the wider public. The NHS belongs to the people of Scotland. They must feel that it does.

It will not be easy to achieve that change in culture. It will take years, not months, to make it happen, but happen it must. Local communities and local elected representatives have a right to know who takes decisions and why they are taken and must have the opportunity to contribute to the decision-making process.

The remote and faceless NHS boardroom of the internal market must become a thing of the past. Next month, I plan to meet all NHS board and trust chairmen to discuss with them how that change can be achieved. Over the coming months, I will be taking steps to attract a far wider pool of people into NHS boardrooms.

As a first step, I am writing to every MSP of every political hue to ask them to identify people in their local communities who could make a contribution in NHS boardrooms. That new sprit of openness, accountability and inclusion must extend to patients. A patient-centred NHS must be more than just a slogan—it must become a way of life.

That is why, in our programme for government, we committed ourselves to developing the patients project, which will aim fundamentally to change and improve the way in which the NHS communicates with patients through every stage in their journey: from GP surgery to out-patient clinic, from hospital to home. That work, which will draw widely on the views and experiences of patients themselves, will start in earnest early in the new year.

As well as keeping patients informed, we must work to reduce delays throughout the system. No single issue dominates my mailbag more than that. Such delays provoke a fear of the unknown: patients and their relatives wait and worry, not knowing what will happen next or when or where it will happen.

Our investment in a modern telecommunications system, linking up all GPs and hospitals in Scotland, will mean that, by 2002, patients will be able to leave their GP practice knowing when and where their out-patient appointment will be. Early next year, we will launch the first pilots of Scottish

NHS Direct, designed here in Scotland with the active participation of GPs and nurses. It will provide high-quality expert nursing advice via the telephone, 24 hours a day.

Our work does not end there. In our programme for government, we committed ourselves to set targets for speeding up treatment and shortening waiting times. Over the past few months, an expert support force has been working with the NHS across Scotland to explore how best we can do that.

Doctors, nurses and patients' representatives have told us that we have to tackle the inequalities in waiting times across Scotland, and that we have to address all the stages of a patient's journey through the NHS, not just one part of it. They have told us to redesign that journey so that it is not only faster but better planned, with realistic timetables that are met day in, day out, so that patients can have confidence that promises will be kept. I intend to heed their advice.

That is why I can announce today that, over the coming months, we will be working with the NHS to establish national maximum waiting times to be met by March 2001 in the key clinical priorities of heart disease, cancer and, for the first time, mental illness.

Much of that work will be achieved through the redesign of existing services. It can be done. We know that because, in many cases, it has been done. For example, the cataract redesign project in Ayrshire has resulted in the waiting time being reduced from 12 months to six weeks. Think of the difference that that makes for an elderly person waiting for a cataract operation. I want that approach to be rolled out across the country. That is why we will double the number of one-stop clinics and why we will work with NHS staff to support staff in the modernisation and redesign of services.

There will be a new alliance for patients, in which the Executive will work together with staff to deliver a new type of patient-centred care where services are made to fit people, not the other way about.

To achieve such changes and to deliver services in Scotland that can be the envy of the world, we must change the way in which the NHS delivers care. We must build on success, using innovative service design, our leading-edge work in clinical standards and our new approaches to multidisciplinary working. However, that process of modernisation and improvement also requires us to tear down some of the relics of the NHS of the past, including the outdated ways of working and, sometimes, the outdated buildings and shells that house them.

That will require hard decisions: a new way of

doing things; a new alliance of interests—an alliance for patients; a modernisation of people and priorities rather than just of technology and terrain. The NHS is not just about bricks and mortar—it is about the people who provide care and the quality of care that people receive, in hospital or increasingly in their community or home.

Fifty years ago, when most of our hospitals were built, they were the home of services because there was no other way of delivering them. Today, they are a hub for many services because so much more can now be delivered away from a hospital setting—in GP surgeries, community health centres and at home, with the support of health visitors and other community-based health care professionals.

Of course, we need new facilities. That is why there will be nearly £500 million of new hospital developments between now and 2002. That is why we are developing a new generation of walk-inwalk- out hospitals that harness new technologies and the benefits of day surgery.

Throughout Scotland, a process of reviewing local facilities is now taking place, to give people the best possible quality of care. That process will draw the blueprint of a new NHS. Our aim is to deliver local, convenient services wherever possible. It will be an NHS that will not shirk from the need to provide first-class treatment of the highest quality, because quality matters.

The reviews will propose changes to services. They will be changes for the better. Let me set another challenge to members.

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Sir David Steel): NPA
We now move to the debate on motion S1M-383, in the name of Susan Deacon, and the amendments to it. Before the debate starts, it is only fair to tell members...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab
It is right and fitting that this, our last parliamentary debate before the turn of the century, should be about the future of our national health service in...
Christine Grahame (South of Scotland) (SNP): SNP
Will the minister give way?
Susan Deacon: Lab
I will take an intervention later; I want to move a little further into my speech. We are often asked about how we will address such challenges. For example,...
Mr David Davidson (North-East Scotland) (Con): Con
Is the minister aware that, in the past few days, there has been much publicity about the inability of health boards and trusts to fund their activities with...
Susan Deacon: Lab
Let me repeat my previous point. We are putting record levels of investment into the NHS in Scotland; we are not squandering resources on a divisive and bure...
Brian Adam (North-East Scotland) (SNP): SNP
We are not talking about isolated incidents. Almost every acute hospital trust in Scotland has a significant cash crisis that is leading to bed closures and ...
Susan Deacon: Lab
I will give members a choice: we can have another sterile exchange of numbers or a real discussion on the issues facing the health service. I have already an...
Mr Duncan Hamilton (Highlands and Islands) (SNP): SNP
Will the minister give way?
Susan Deacon: Lab
I am not taking another intervention, and I suggest that the Opposition listens to the point that I am about to make. We will not move forward if the NHS is ...
Mr Hamilton: SNP
If the minister concentrates on doing her job, we will concentrate on doing ours the way that we want. Her comment that Opposition criticism somehow leads to...
Susan Deacon: Lab
I do not mind if Duncan Hamilton or any other member of his party criticises me every day from now until kingdom come; what I find offensive is that he refus...
Roseanna Cunningham (Perth) (SNP): SNP
Will the minister give way?
Susan Deacon: Lab
If I may, Presiding Officer, I will continue, because I know that my time is limited. Rent-a-quote politics—which is what we are talking about—may generate c...
Christine Grahame: SNP
Will the minister give way?
Susan Deacon: Lab
I will take one further intervention.
Christine Grahame: SNP
I do not want to make a party political point. I am sure that the minister is aware of the Age Concern publication, "Turning your back on us"—it is a joint A...
Susan Deacon: Lab
It is precisely because I am determined that the NHS should give the best possible service to elderly people—and all the people of Scotland—that I want us to...
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Mr George Reid): SNP
Briefly, minister.
Susan Deacon: Lab
As members examine the NHS in their areas and question local health authorities about their plans for change—as I hope that they will—they should demand the ...
Roseanna Cunningham: SNP
Will the minister give way on that point?
Susan Deacon: Lab
I have no time.
Roseanna Cunningham: SNP
It is on that point.
The Deputy Presiding Officer: SNP
The minister is not giving way.
Susan Deacon: Lab
I have taken a number of interventions. Nissen huts, mixed-sex accommodation, drafty corridors, Nightingale wards—that is not a modern NHS. It is not what we...
The Deputy Presiding Officer: SNP
That was a substantial overrun, which I allowed because the minister was so open in taking interventions. It means, however, that one speaker will drop out. ...
Kay Ullrich (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP
I am disappointed that the Minister for Health and Community Care did not see fit to use the time today to address the real problems that currently face the ...
Susan Deacon: Lab
Absolutely.
Kay Ullrich: SNP
Okay, once again—I am glad that the minister gave me a chance to put it right— reality is being completely ignored in favour of rhetoric. The minister is wor...
Bristow Muldoon (Livingston) (Lab): Lab
Will the member give way?