Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Public Health
I agree absolutely with Des McNulty's point. I can assure him that my colleagues throughout the Executive are considering how all the resources that we put to work across Scotland can be used to tackle deprivation effectively. Of course, I have a particular responsibility to e...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
14 Dec 2000
Health Plan
This statement marks the publication of "Our National Health: A plan for action, a plan for change". It sets out a radical plan to improve the health of the people of Scotland and to rebuild and renew our national health service. It is not just another Government policy docume...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
01 Sep 1999
Public Health
That was not quite such a brief intervention as I had hoped for. However, I was happy to join Dennis at Falkirk royal infirmary and was pleased that he was there to help me to pull the curtains off the wall while I was unveiling a plaque. It is for health boards to consider ho...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
14 Nov 2001
Mental Health Law
I am pleased to speak to the motion and proud to lead a debate on such an important issue.This afternoon we are debating the Executive's proposals for renewing mental health law. Those proposals were set out in full in a policy statement published on 18 October. Legislation in...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
03 May 2001
Child Health
We have discussed at some length in the chamber the importance of exercise for young people. I echo the view of other ministers who share an interest: physical education is an important area for us to continue to work in. However, in that area, as in others, we must recognise ...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Arbuthnott Report<br />(NHS Resources)
I am pleased to have the opportunity to make what I believe is a very important announcement. I realise that we are competing with a number of other important events around the country, but I am grateful for the interest that many members have shown in the issue.My statement s...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
22 Mar 2000
National Health Service
Presiding Officer, I am grateful for the opportunity to make this statement. I will take your words to heart, as I had intended to. I also apologise to Opposition colleagues for the late delivery of my statement this afternoon, for which I take full responsibility. Today, I wa...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
09 Nov 2000
National Health Service
There are many different views on the structure of the NHS, and I shall comment later on the issue that Andrew Welsh has raised.Since taking up office, I have given that message about the internal market loudly and clearly to the NHS in Scotland. I am pleased that many local N...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Public Health
We are awaiting a ruling from the European Court of Justice on that matter, and I will make a full statement once we have received the ruling. We remain committed to moving forward with the banning of tobacco advertising as soon as possible.In the couple of minutes that I have...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Committee
27 Oct 1999
Arbuthnott Report
I am very pleased that the committee has responded so positively to our request to look at the Arbuthnott review fully and carefully. We consider the review to be an important development. In a moment, I will say more from the Executive's point of view about the background to ...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Public Health
There is a clear connection between this debate and the previous discussion, and I hope that we will build on some of the points that were raised in that discussion during this debate.I have said before, and I make no apology for repeating it, that there is no greater challeng...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
29 Jun 2000
Question Time · Children's Health
The £9 million that I mentioned is part of a total of £15 million, which the Executive is allocating to four national health demonstration projects. The essence of those health demonstration projects is that they involve a multi-agency approach, bringing together health boards...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Chamber
18 Sep 2003
Improving Scotland's Health
In this world of short-lived controversies and shiny new initiatives, we often forget how we got to where we are now. I begin my remarks by taking a brief look back at history—as far back as the last century. The big step change in policy and health improvement in Scotland did...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
10 May 2000
Budget Process
Indeed.The coalition played a part in helping to establish national consensus. The media contributed to the process by raising awareness about health improvement messages. Schools and employers have become actively involved in promoting occupational health. Cultural and attitu...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
27 Oct 1999
Meningococcal C Immunisation
I am grateful to have the opportunity to inform Parliament of the arrangements in Scotland for the introduction of a new vaccine to protect our children against meningitis C. The new vaccine programme is good news for parents and children across Scotland and is a huge step tow...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
01 Mar 2001
Primary Care
White coats, hospital beds, high-tech equipment, intensive care units—those are typically the images that flash up on television screens and in people's minds when we talk about the national health service. However, the reality is that more than 90 per cent of patient contacts...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
29 Jun 2000
Question Time · Children's Health
Child health and the prevention of heart disease are two of our top health priorities. This autumn we will launch major national health demonstration projects in both those areas, backed by a total of £9 million over three years. This week, I announced the creation of a new na...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
20 Sep 2000
Question Time · Family Planning and Sexual Health Services
The development of a sexual health strategy for Scotland, the health demonstration project healthy respect and investment by the Executive directly, and through the Health Education Board for Scotland, to improve and expand information on services have the shared goal of impro...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Committee
07 Dec 2004
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2002/03”
First, I will respond to the two suggestions in the letter, which are to have a briefing on pay modernisation and a briefing on the review of health and care statistics. My view is that, subject to our finding time in our schedule, we should take up the offer of a briefing on ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
10 May 2000
Budget Process
I will endeavour to be crisp in response to that question on an important and complex area.The health improvement targets that have been set are ambitious, but—with the right national effort—they are attainable. They were set after considerable discussion of the health white p...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
25 Oct 2000
Primary Dental Care
I recall, as one of my earliest comments as a health minister, in reply to a parliamentary question, giving a commitment to push dental health further up the agenda in the Parliament and in the Government's health priorities. I am pleased that, in the intervening period, that ...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Chamber
14 Jan 2004
Sexual Health and <br />Relationship Strategy
I welcome today's debate and the publication of the draft sexual health strategy, which is an important milestone. Like other members, I welcome the strategy's holistic approach and its emphasis on relationships, values, culture and education, as well as on services. However, ...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Chamber
15 Jun 2005
Sexual Health
I am surprised that the question has been asked why we are having this debate. It is more than five months since the Executive published a major, long-awaited policy document on one of the major public health challenges of our time. It is absolutely right and proper that we ha...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
24 Jan 2001
Long-term Care
It is clear that change on the proposed scale needs to be resourced properly. We have already committed £25 million for the implementation of free nursing care. We will back our plans to extend the provision of free care with additional resources.Next week, Angus MacKay, the M...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
24 Nov 1999
Tobacco Sales
I will start by being unoriginal and congratulating Irene Oldfather on raising this issue. On a lighter note, the image of Ian Jenkins in a rhododendron bush will remain with me for a long time. The discussion has shown that we are agreed on the importance of the issue. In her...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Public Health
I recognise the value of the work that school nurses do and I am pleased to confirm that a review of the public health nursing function is currently under way. That review is specifically examining the role of school nurses as well as that of health visitors and other communit...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
24 Jun 1999
Question Time · Teenage Pregnancies
Fifty million pounds has been allocated to the health demonstration project that I mentioned earlier. However, it is important that we spend the time in this chamber discussing what the Scottish Parliament will do instead of talking about what is going on in other parts of the...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
22 Nov 2001
Question Time · Diet
Margaret Smith is right to highlight the growing problem of childhood obesity. It is in part a product of diet, but also of other lifestyle factors, not least the lack of exercise that many children experience as a consequence of changed habits. The problem is being tackled th...
4. Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Chamber
28 Apr 2005
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · National Health Demonstration Projects
To ask the Scottish Executive how the work of the four national health demonstration projects is being developed to inform practice across Scotland. (S2O-6509)
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
16 May 2001
Budget Process 2002-03
I am making an important point. The initial question was about achieving health improvement targets for cancer and coronary heart disease. We will not achieve our health targets simply by doing more and more in the NHS to treat ill health; we will achieve those targets by tack...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
09 Nov 2000
National Health Service
I give an assurance that funding flows have been very much on our minds and will be dealt with in some detail in the health plan. One of the problems with the old internal market system was that it tended to know the price of everything and the value of very little. We want to...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
03 May 2001
Child Health
Each of us has a personal memory of 1 July 1999, when this Parliament opened. One of the lasting memories for many of us is the procession of children from every constituency in Scotland. They came to Edinburgh to mark the creation of their new Parliament. As the second annive...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Committee
16 May 2006
Teaching Profession
It is interesting that we have touched on the question of balance. The sentence in the report that neatly expresses that balance is:"The Teachers' Agreement has brought about a number of benefits for the profession, but more work is required to demonstrate long-term outcomes a...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
10 May 2000
Budget Process
It is important not to generalise. Significant additional resources are going into a number of the areas Kay Ullrich mentioned. Respite care is an obvious example: funding there has been doubled to support the carer strategy. That said, there are always enormous and growing de...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
01 Sep 1999
Public Health
Thank you, Presiding Officer. Just under two years ago, the Scottish people voted overwhelmingly for this, their first ever democratically elected Scottish Parliament, a Parliament that they wanted to deliver a better quality of life and better opportunities for the people of ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
22 Mar 2000
National Health Service
I am grateful to Margaret Smith for her questions and for focusing on the substance of the issues that I have raised this afternoon. On the first question, the proposal for a public health institute derives from a report published just before Christmas by the chief medical off...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
06 Jul 2000
National Health Service
This Executive wants a Scotland in which fewer people need health care because there is less illness. That is why we held a healthy Scotland convention this week, to bring ministers with different portfolios together with people with skills, expertise and perspectives from rig...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Arbuthnott Report<br />(NHS Resources)
I shall address Margaret Smith's comments on the Health and Community Care Committee first. Like her, I do not think that something that is as positive and generally welcomed as my announcement should have a sour note attached to it. I stress the full part that the Health and ...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Chamber
23 Sep 2004
Breastfeeding etc (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
It is not often that I am given latitude by the Presiding Officer, but I am happy to take it on this occasion.I am pleased to close the debate and I thank Elaine Smith for giving me the opportunity to do so. I pay tribute to her for her work, commitment and sheer tenacity in p...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Chamber
27 Jan 2005
Infertility Services
I join others in congratulating Mary Scanlon on securing this debate. Over the years, she and I have disagreed on many health-related issues, but I genuinely admire her tenacity and consistency in championing a number of issues in the Parliament, infertility being one. Over th...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
10 May 2000
Budget Process
There could be significant improvements in how expenditure that is related to public health and health promotion is shown in the document. For example, the spending of the Health Education Board for Scotland is shown, but it is not broken down. A great deal of health promotion...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Arbuthnott Report
Deprivation and the wider agenda of social justice have been addressed since the Executive came into office last year. We have worked hard to put tackling health inequalities at the heart of our policy agenda. I shall give a couple of examples of that. We have targeted the all...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Arbuthnott Report
Let me correct a point that Mary Scanlon makes. It is important to point out that the Arbuthnott report is not my report. The report was produced by the Arbuthnott committee and an independent review group, following widespread consultation, and the Executive has chosen to acc...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Budget 2001-02
Hugh Henry's point has been at the core of discussions that have taken place over many months and which will come to fruition with the publication of the Scottish health plan in November. He is right to make the point—I have identified it myself and many people throughout the ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Budget 2001-02
I shall answer the point about voluntary organisations first. I share the view that the voluntary sector will have an immense role to play in the delivery of effective health and community care services in future. The tragedy is that, all too often, insecurity and uncertainty ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
01 Sep 1999
Public Health
We will give the Conservatives a second chance. They did not do it in government; they can do it now. Across the Scottish Executive, we are taking action to make real improvements to people's lives through better job prospects, better housing and better education. We will work...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Chamber
09 Nov 2000
National Health Service
I am glad that we have the opportunity to have this important debate in the Parliament this morning.The national health service is our biggest and most important public service. Its founding principles hold good today, as they did when it was created more than 50 years ago. Th...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
14 Dec 2000
Health Plan
There is no quick answer that does justice to that question. I will simply say that tackling health inequalities is one of the key priorities not only in health policy, but across the Scottish Executive's work. Narrowing the health gap between rich and poor must be a priority ...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Chamber
12 Dec 2001
National Health Service
I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak in the debate, a year on from publication of the Scottish health plan. Unlike the Opposition, the Scottish health plan focused not only on identifying problems but on coming up with solutions for the short, medium and long term. It...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
27 Apr 2004
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2002/03”
I appreciate the substance of Trevor Jones's answer to Margaret Jamieson's question about what is happening with regard to health improvement and the timescale that is involved, and I acknowledge that what will deliver results is action across Government and not just within th...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab Committee
07 Sep 1999
Food Protection (Emergency Prohibitions) (Amnesic Shellfish Poisoning) (West Coast) (Scotland) Order 1999 (SSI 1999/26) <br />Food Protection (Emergency Prohibitions) (Amnesic Shellfish Poisoning) (Orkney) (Scotland) Order 1999 (SSI 1999/27)
I am pleased to be here on my first visit to the Health and Community Care Committee. I am sure that the convener is right to say that this will be the first of many visits, many of which I hope will be pleasant and all of which I hope will be searching. We are here for a spec...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Budget 2001-02
We have talked about monitoring and performance measurement today. Those subjects are dear to my heart and we have spent a lot of time working on them in the department. Ultimately, however, I am interested in results. I do not want to spend so long measuring and monitoring, o...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
16 May 2001
Budget Process 2002-03
The other matter that was raised was hospital-acquired infection. I will comment on a couple of matters and Gerry Marr and John Aldridge may also wish to say something on the subject. A great deal of work has been undertaken on hospital-acquired infection by the department and...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
16 Dec 1999
Health Service
It is precisely because I am determined that the NHS should give the best possible service to elderly people—and all the people of Scotland—that I want us to make progress in developing in our hospitals and in our communities the patient-centred health service that the people ...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
21 Sep 2000
Arbuthnott Report<br />(NHS Resources)
I am pleased that Kay Ullrich welcomes the Arbuthnott report and our decision to implement it. I am also pleased that she has joined me in acknowledging the link between poverty and ill health. I am always pleased to find areas of common ground where we can move forward togeth...
Susan Deacon: Lab Chamber
20 Sep 2001
Patient Care
I am glad that Shona Robison welcomes what I have said. Of course, the difference between our policies and the SNP's policies is that we have some, and we have translated our commitments and aspirations into practice. In a moment I will address private sector involvement, beca...
Susan Deacon (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab): Lab Chamber
22 Apr 2004
Multiple Sclerosis Awareness Week
I congratulate Tricia Marwick on securing this important debate. During her recap of our previous consideration of the issue, she certainly brought to life in my mind several memories of that debate and the many discussions that took place at that time. I take this opportunity...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
14 Sep 2004
“Overview of the National Health Service in Scotland 2002/03”
I am happy to take the opportunity to do that, although should the Auditor General wish to comment on any of my observations, I would be grateful for those insights.I am struck by a number of points in the response. First, I echo what the Auditor General said in that the respo...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
25 Oct 2000
Budget 2001-02
It is always welcome to hear members of the Health and Community Care Committee offering to help the Executive. The key question is how best to do that. What questions do we ask? What information is reported and at what level is it reported? Some of the detail to which Richard...
Susan Deacon: Lab Committee
16 May 2001
Budget Process 2002-03
I wonder whether I should go into the issue of burger bars.The point that Dorothy-Grace Elder began with is important: we are running a health service, not a burger bar. Although I am not the first person here to invoke the memory of Margaret Thatcher, perhaps I can be the sec...
← Back to list
Chamber

Plenary, 21 Sep 2000

21 Sep 2000 · S1 · Plenary
Item of business
Public Health
Deacon, Susan Lab Edinburgh East and Musselburgh Watch on SPTV
I agree absolutely with Des McNulty's point. I can assure him that my colleagues throughout the Executive are considering how all the resources that we put to work across Scotland can be used to tackle deprivation effectively. Of course, I have a particular responsibility to ensure that that is done effectively within the NHS. However, the NHS's capacity to work effectively in partnership with local authorities, voluntary organisations, social inclusion partnerships and many others will determine how effective they in turn can be.

At a national level, we have demonstrated our commitment to that area. Indeed, we have given increased impetus to it by fulfilling our pledge to create a health improvement fund. It is significant that although that fund is NHS money that is being channelled through local health boards, much of it will be targeted towards multi-agency projects and work that will be done jointly by the NHS and other bodies. An unprecedented £26 million package of investment is being funded from the entire Scottish allocation of revenues from the tax on tobacco.

On top of that package, we are investing £15 million in our major national health demonstration projects, which will provide test beds for action for the whole country. Again, those projects have been developed on a holistic, multi-agency basis and will consider how action can be taken to improve health on all fronts. I am pleased to say that the Have a Heart Paisley project, which is devoted to preventing coronary heart disease across a broad range of fronts, will be launched next week—in Paisley, as members might guess. The demonstration projects on children's health and sexual health will follow soon.

We are working on more initiatives, such as the new national physical activity task force, which will be launched early in the new year. Arrangements are also in hand for the appointment a national co-ordinator to drive forward work on improving the nation's diet.

Partnership is the key to success of all of our efforts: partnership within government; partnership between organisations such as the NHS, local authorities, schools and voluntary organisations; partnership with communities; and partnership with the Scottish people themselves.

Some important steps towards partnership were set out in the "Review of the Public Health Function in Scotland", which was led by Sir David Carter and published in December. The document laid the groundwork for significant changes and suggested new approaches, which we are introducing, such as building health boards into public health organisations, creating managed public health networks along the lines of managed clinical networks, reviewing the role of public health nurses and establishing the public health institute.

Backed by £1 million from the health improvement fund, the new institute will bring focus and drive to the many strands of public health activity. As I said in July when we committed ourselves to establishing the institute, its task is to make Scotland an example of what can be done. Scotland will be a case study in what needs to be done no longer. I am pleased to confirm that the new director will be appointed shortly and I look forward to the institute getting down to work at an early date.

As I have said before, as well as doing more and spending more to improve health, we must constantly strive to do better. We must act on the best evidence, make the most effective interventions, learn from others and share what we have learned.

I am pleased that Scotland has played a leading part in the joint ministerial committee on health, which brings together the devolved Administrations and the UK Government.

We are making important contacts further afield. I visited Finland earlier in the year and on Monday I met the European Community health commissioner, David Byrne, in Brussels. We had a useful and constructive discussion on how Scotland could contribute to and benefit from collaborative efforts to improve health on the European stage. This week I also met a range of non-governmental organisations and health experts from France and Finland. As well as learning from them, I was also pleased to be able to set out some of the groundbreaking work that is under way in Scotland.

These are two-way contacts and I am particularly pleased that a leading Finnish health expert, Erkki Vartianinen, will come to Scotland soon on a visiting fellowship. He will work with Scottish researchers and health boards on ways of tackling heart disease. As many members know, Finland has been highly successful in that area.

We held our first ever Healthy Scotland convention in July, which will be an annual event that brings together the full range of people who are working to improve our health. Side by side with Government, health and education professionals will sit alongside employers and trade unions, voluntary organisations and charities. They will come together to address a common goal, because that is as it must be if we are to be effective.

Closer to home, the Executive is taking action too. We have restructured the health department to integrate public health and the management of the NHS in Scotland, and we are forging closer working, policy development and spending plans across the Executive to improve health together.

We are creating the structures and the networks and we must continue to build on that work at a local level. I will give an example of how that is happening on the ground. The health care professionals who work in the new local health care co-operatives are the people for whom all the statistics that I have quoted become the daily, often heartbreaking, reality.

It is understandable that we talk a great deal about what goes on in Scotland's hospitals during our debates on the health service. However, we must remember that 90 per cent of contacts with the health service begin and end in primary care settings, with general practitioners, health visitors, midwives, pharmacists, community physiotherapists and occupational therapists, social workers and many others who work day in, day out to deliver better health and better health care in our communities.

The new LHCCs are crucial to the NHS's contribution to improved health at local level. LHCCs give us a local focus for primary health care, involving local authority services, voluntary groups and, most important, the community itself. That new way of working is enabling and empowering people to come together, not just to deliver services, but to assess and address the needs of the community itself.

We can learn lessons from such working patterns and apply them more widely. People can come together across traditional institutional boundaries to deliver services now and to play a key joint role in determining how resources should be invested in the future.

To deliver action and results on the ground we must help everyone into health, from children and young people through to adults during their working lives and as they get older. We need to help them not just in hospitals and clinics, but where they spend their lives: at home, in classrooms, in the community and in the workplace. Health starts at birth and even before. Children must get the best start in life, and I want us to reduce the numbers of low birth-weight children born in Scotland.

We are increasing support for health in the early years and will continue to do so. The health improvement fund is already being put to work, providing practical measures to make a difference. It is providing fresh fruit to infants to improve their diet, a new educational media campaign to promote better child and family health, and expanded health service support through sure start Scotland.

As children and young people develop, they need support that is shaped to meet their needs. We are investing to provide that support, through a major expansion of school breakfast clubs, starting with schools in deprived areas. We are providing more fruit and salad bars in schools, building on work in new community schools. We are introducing measures to reduce suicide among young people, particularly young men. We will also be creating a sexual health strategy and providing more support for advice services for young people, together with our national demonstration project Healthy Respect.

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Sir David Steel): NPA
We move to the debate on public health on motion S1M-1196, in the name of Susan Deacon, and the two amendments to that motion. I invite those who wish to spe...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Susan Deacon): Lab
There is a clear connection between this debate and the previous discussion, and I hope that we will build on some of the points that were raised in that dis...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab): Lab
I very much agree with the minister on the need to take account of deprivation in the process of allocating health resources. However, if we are to achieve s...
Susan Deacon: Lab
I agree absolutely with Des McNulty's point. I can assure him that my colleagues throughout the Executive are considering how all the resources that we put t...
Fiona McLeod (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP
Although the minister is describing the support that will be made available to young people at the places where they need that support, can she confirm that ...
Susan Deacon: Lab
I recognise the value of the work that school nurses do and I am pleased to confirm that a review of the public health nursing function is currently under wa...
Mr Duncan Hamilton (Highlands and Islands) (SNP): SNP
I want to pick up on the point that the minister was making about preventing people from smoking. What is the latest legal advice that she has on the possibi...
Susan Deacon: Lab
We are awaiting a ruling from the European Court of Justice on that matter, and I will make a full statement once we have received the ruling. We remain comm...
Kay Ullrich (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP
Members will recall that, when we last debated public health just over a year ago, the SNP did not lodge an amendment to the Executive motion. I felt then, a...
Mr Mike Rumbles (West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD): LD
Does Kay Ullrich recognise and welcome Jack McConnell's announcement yesterday that there will be a 10.5 per cent increase in local authority funding, over a...
Kay Ullrich: SNP
Local authorities have been cash-strapped for three years. We welcome any additional money, but it will take a long time for them to get back to the position...
Mrs Margaret Smith (Edinburgh West) (LD): LD
Keep going.
Kay Ullrich: SNP
Thank you, Margaret.I want to give an example of how initiatives can be undermined. The Minister for Health and Community Care announced a scheme to give fre...
Des McNulty: Lab
Will the member give way?
Kay Ullrich: SNP
No, I want to make this point.The machines are there because they can earn about £400 to £500 a week for cash-strapped schools.
Des McNulty: Lab
Will the member give way?
Kay Ullrich: SNP
No, I will not take an intervention.We are talking about schools, so the minister should pay attention. Incidentally, I am sure that she is tired of people a...
Susan Deacon: Lab
I will take the opportunity to make a factual correction to Mrs Ullrich's comments. The scheme is for all children under the age of 12 months. The age varies...
Kay Ullrich: SNP
I thank the minister. She obviously has a closer knowledge of babies and teeth than I do—my babies are somewhat large, but they do still have all their own t...
Mary Scanlon (Highlands and Islands) (Con): Con
Like Kay Ullrich, I am pleased that the Minister for Health and Community Care has toned down her usual self-congratulatory motion to a form of wording that ...
Margaret Jamieson (Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (Lab): Lab
I speak as someone who has recently been prescribed Zyban and has yet to feel its full effects. Mary Scanlon describes an isolated case. My experience has be...
Mary Scanlon: Con
I would like to think that the case was isolated. I have read two newspaper articles about it. Bristow Muldoon asked yesterday about Zyban and counselling, a...
Mrs Margaret Smith (Edinburgh West) (LD): LD
I welcome the tone of this debate—it is probably one of the most good-humoured health debates that we have had in the chamber. As everyone knows, we in the H...
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Patricia Ferguson): Lab
We now move to the open part of the debate. Because of the additional time allowed for the statement, we have less time than we had hoped for each speaker. I...
Dr Richard Simpson (Ochil) (Lab): Lab
It is impossible to do justice to this subject in four minutes, but I will start by considering Arbuthnott and this morning's statement. I welcome that state...
Mr Hamilton: SNP
Although that is undoubtedly correct, let us consider the new formula. Our whole point is that, if the new formula is right on the basis of the new allocatio...
Dr Simpson: Lab
I would like to have a think about that and come back to the member.I welcome the new money that has been announced, especially the funds for GP premises and...
Dorothy-Grace Elder (Glasgow) (SNP): SNP
I draw the minister's attention to the point that several members have made today—that Arbuthnott has moved only 1 to 2 per cent of the total budget more eve...
Margaret Jamieson: Lab
Shameful.
Dorothy-Grace Elder: SNP
That is true, Margaret. It is tragic. He was a fine man.I urge the health ministers to look into chronic pain as urgently as they can. The problem has been n...