Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
26 Mar 2003
Scottish Economy
I hope that Alex Neil will have achieved retirement in 40 years' time.As someone who has been a member of the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee for the whole parliamentary session, I am proud of the contribution that the Parliament has made to shaping a skilled Scotti...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
21 May 2008
Enterprise Network Reform
You probably heard me refer earlier to the sum of £50 million, or around £50 million—£45 million is quite near £50 million. We now know where that figure came from.The cabinet secretary talked about the relocation to local authorities. He said:"Currently, Scottish Enterprise i...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Chamber
21 Nov 2007
Economic Strategy
No. My party clearly set out its commitment on further and higher education. I will not be drawn into that argument—we made our position clear. I agree with the cabinet secretary that we must achieve balanced growth throughout Scotland, whether that is at national, regional or...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Chamber
28 Jan 2009
Budget (Scotland) (No 2) Bill: Stage 3
I say to Tricia Marwick that if I vote against the budget this evening, it is because I want the best for that area. I will make the decision that I think will support my communities, and I will explain why.I want to concentrate on two important issues. It will come as no surp...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
10 Jan 2002
Scotland's Economy
Thank you, Presiding Officer. I will try very hard to stick to time.As others have said, the global economic backdrop of 2001 has been difficult and the terrible events of 11 September considerably heightened those difficulties. The performance of the Scottish economy must be ...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
12 Sep 2002
Scottish Economy
Our Executive is committed to the creation of a strong, diverse and thriving economy. We have enjoyed the benefits of working in partnership with Westminster, which has achieved economic growth and, important for May, a reduction in unemployment, coupled with a strong labour m...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
08 Oct 2008
Budget Process 2009-10
I want to pick up on John McLaren's point on higher education. Some of us on the committee have argued that it was a mistake to remove higher education from the committee's remit, because of the links between higher education and economic success. I worked in further and highe...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
15 Nov 2007
Abolition of Bridge Tolls (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I thank the Presiding Officer for giving me the opportunity to participate in the debate. It will come as no surprise to the Parliament that I will speak in support of the removal of tolls from the Forth and Tay road bridges.There is no doubt that both bridges are essential to...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
20 Mar 2002
Local Economic Forums
My first question to the witnesses will be the same as the first question that I put to the representatives of Glasgow local economic forum. The committee intends to make recommendations on how local economic forums should be developed. What one or two recommendations would yo...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
28 Oct 2009
Draft Budget Scrutiny 2010-11
My colleague Wendy Alexander has explored the national figures, but I want to explore what impact the changes have had on local areas. In my Fife constituency, the loss of the local enterprise company has—although we were assured otherwise—definitely had an adverse effect on b...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
27 Jun 2007
Work Programme
Good morning, minister. I have a number of questions on the skills agenda, because I have not heard you mention it so far. If we are to achieve the economic growth to which we all aspire, we cannot separate the skills and enterprise agendas. This committee must surely take a m...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab) Lab Chamber
03 Mar 2010
Regeneration
I am pleased that the minister has acknowledged the continuing need for the regeneration of communities across Scotland, and that he recognises the number of stakeholders that need to be involved in ensuring its success. However, when he is making his winding-up speech this ev...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
28 Nov 2007
Budget Process 2008-09
I have some specific questions on the transfer of budgets to the skills agency and local government. The minister has made announcements about decentralisation and how the landscape will be decluttered, but a lot of us on the ground are not seeing that and are not convinced th...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
01 May 2002
Local Economic Forums
Your comments on "A Smart, Successful Scotland" and allowing localities to develop it for their areas answer Annabel Goldie's point about local flavour and flexibility. As you know—I have said it to you before—that is the big worry. Local economic forums told us that although ...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
01 Nov 2001
Teaching and Research Funding (Scottish Higher Education Funding Council Review)
I thank the convener of the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee for his speech on behalf of the committee. He covered many points that are pertinent to the report. The committee's members believe that the debate and the minister's response are immensely significant not ...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
27 Nov 2002
Lifelong Learning
To close the debate on the committee's behalf gives me great pleasure. I thank Alex Neil and Annabel Goldie for asking me to take on the role. It shows the co-operation in the committee.I welcome all those in the public gallery from a wide range of lifelong learning sectors an...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
12 Jun 2002
Local Economic Forums
The committee will not be surprised to hear that I totally disagree with David Mundell—perhaps for the first time. The Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee recommended that local economic forums be set up. I realise that some forums are working better than others, but th...
Marilyn Livingstone Lab Committee
19 Jan 2011
Enterprise Network Inquiry
Okay. It would be good to have the details of that.Your submission says that, since the restructuring of Scottish Enterprise and the move of local economic development and local regeneration to councils, it is difficult and“unrealistic to draw a specific comparison between cur...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
18 Sep 2008
Tourism
I am pleased to be able to contribute to the debate, and welcome the Scottish Government's remarks on the professionalism of the committee's work. I thank the clerking team, the committee adviser, fellow members of the committee—I should say past and present members—and, of co...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
07 Nov 2007
Enterprise Networks and VisitScotland (Reform)
I thought you might.I will concentrate on two areas: local economic development and—you will not be surprised to hear—skills. I would support you on a move away from a centralist agenda towards more local economic development by staff in my local enterprise office in Fife. It ...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
21 May 2008
Enterprise Network Reform
I will start by asking about local economic regeneration. In his statement of 26 September 2007, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth referred to the amount of activity that had transferred from Scottish Enterprise to local authorities. Has there been any c...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
21 May 2008
Enterprise Network Reform
In his statement on 26 September, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth said:"Local regeneration activity in the Scottish Enterprise area will also become the responsibility of local authorities. Currently, Scottish Enterprise is engaged in a range of regene...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
28 Oct 2009
Draft Budget Scrutiny 2010-11
I am not critical of Fife Council's local economic development unit. It works well and I have no complaints about it. However, it does not have the budget—that is the point that I am making. It needs the budget and the support.Also, the £12.5 million in the local regeneration ...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
08 Nov 2006
Transition from School to Work
We are all aware that poverty of income and opportunity in childhood is likely to lead to poverty of experience as a young person, which will continue into adulthood. We must, therefore, maintain a strong focus on tackling poverty and disadvantage as young people from challeng...
Marilyn Livingstone Lab Committee
27 Oct 2010
Enterprise Network Inquiry
What has become clear is that, as Jacqui Hepburn said in her evidence, nobody has the budget or the responsibility to go out and engage with companies on the skills agenda. Many witnesses—not just today—have asked us who is in charge of the skills strategy for Scotland. Which ...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab) Lab Chamber
17 Mar 2010
Tourism
As a member of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee and someone who represents a constituency to which tourism is important, I am pleased that the importance of tourism to the Scottish economy is being recognised.According to VisitScotland, the national tourist board, Sco...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab) Lab Chamber
19 Jan 2011
“Report on the public sector’s support for exporters, international trade and the attraction of inward investment”
In November 2007, in one of the new Administration’s first policy documents, the First Minister stated that the purpose of the Scottish Government was to create“a more successful country, with opportunities for all of Scotland to flourish, through increasing sustainable econom...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
05 Dec 2007
Budget Process 2008-09
My second question concerns local economic development, regeneration and decision making in the budget process. As I said in the chamber, I am convinced that you wish to decentralise and declutter the landscape, but I still have great difficulty seeing how the proposed structu...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
24 Oct 2007
Council of Economic Advisers
I accept the point about the economic forum—one question is how you will work with it. The issue is about fair representation. You want to give economic advice, but sectors are missing. We will have to agree to disagree on that.
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
24 Oct 2007
Council of Economic Advisers
What work will the council do on concentrations of economic activity in Scotland? A lot of emphasis has been placed on city regeneration, which is important, but what work will be done on our towns, which are important economic drivers for Scotland? What are your thoughts on t...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
07 Nov 2007
Skills Strategy
I am pleased that the cabinet secretary is here, as the skills agenda is important to the committee. The committee has heard evidence inside and outside the Parliament on concerns about the division between the skills agenda and economic development. How will the cabinet secre...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
05 Nov 2008
Budget Process 2009-10
My first question is for Scottish Enterprise. You stated in your written submission and told us today:"We are monitoring current economic conditions … and we are committed to adjusting our planned spend, where necessary."Can you give us examples of where you plan to increase i...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
15 Sep 1999
Work Programme
I agree that item 4, on co-ordination and performance of economic development services in Scotland, should receive priority. I have no problem with looking at that first, as long as it is recognised that it leads on to what Elaine Thomson said about the need for further educat...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
29 Sep 2004
Spending Review 2004
It gives me great pleasure to contribute to the debate and to close for the Labour Party.I welcome the massive investment for our communities throughout Scotland, the like of which we have never seen before. As the minister stated, a £900 million increase in capital investment...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
01 Mar 2006
Regeneration
The title of today's motion, "Regeneration in Scotland—People and Place", is important because it expresses clearly the approach that we must take to regeneration. That approach is not just about housing, important though that is; it is also about our communities as a whole. I...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
21 Nov 2007
Economic Strategy
The SNP Government states that growing the economy is its top priority. It says that the implementation of its economic strategy"will be driven across the public sector and … supported by the new arrangements within the Scottish Government to provide a clear focus on delivery ...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
16 Dec 2009
Council of Economic Advisers (Annual Report)
Week after week, the committee heard in evidence for its previous inquiry that there were not enough planners and that councils were struggling to get suitably qualified planners. Then we read this two-page article, which says that the decrease in funding will hit town planner...
Marilyn Livingstone Lab Committee
06 Oct 2010
Enterprise Network Inquiry
Some submissions refer to the subject of my final question. It is obvious that we will face a round of cuts. Some nervousness is felt in councils about further cuts to economic development. Because economic development and the recovery are the Government’s priority, it has bee...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
21 May 2008
Enterprise Network Reform
I would appreciate some written information on that because it is important.I come back to the budget. The Sunday Herald stated in March 2008 that £12 million was transferred from Scottish Enterprise to COSLA for the business gateway—I can understand that—and £25 million was t...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
20 Mar 2002
Local Economic Forums
I thank John Gallacher for his evidence. I am one of the original committee members who carried out the investigation. One of the criticisms that was made was that we did not bite the bullet enough and that the forums might be talking shops, as they would not have teeth. What ...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
20 Mar 2002
Local Economic Forums
I represent a Fife constituency, which also has coterminous boundaries. The issues within those boundaries are just the same, and local economic forums have to take those issues on and drive them forward. The issue is not coterminous boundaries; it is how to deal with problems...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
18 Sep 2002
Tourism Inquiry
I represent a Fife constituency where the area tourist board does a very good job. The evidence mentioned considering a more integrated approach. You are talking about security of funding. What are the implications of community planning? How do you think it is all going to fit...
Marilyn Livingstone Lab Committee
12 Jan 2011
Enterprise Network Inquiry
No; I was talking about the removal of the responsibility for local economic development from Scottish Enterprise and the demise of the local enterprise network in Fife and across the country. Those functions were given to local government. What effect has that had on economic...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
16 Jan 2002
Local Economic Forums
As one of the original committee members, I have been listening hard to what has been said, and I want to make a couple of points before I ask my question. Previously, the committee unanimously agreed that there should be local flexibility and that local government, Scottish E...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
21 May 2008
Enterprise Network Reform
It would be good if we could be kept up to date because the outcome will be really important for regeneration.I will put you on the spot now, with a crucial question that I asked Jack Perry. Will that result in a lack of activity in project-based local economic development? If...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
06 Jul 2000
Enterprise Networks
I welcome the minister's statement and the changes to the structure of Scottish Enterprise. I was going to ask a very similar question to that asked by George Lyon about the local economic forums, and the minister's comments about more effective partnerships being welcome. How...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
10 Jan 2002
Strategic Planning (Fife)
I welcome this opportunity to focus on the implications of the "Review of Strategic Planning" consultation document. I thank Iain Smith for securing this debate and for allowing Fife MSPs to voice their opinions publicly.The document's wide-ranging proposals for reforming stra...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Chamber
21 Nov 2007
Economic Strategy
Mr Adam made the point about a minute and a half ago, but I will try to recapture the flavour of it. He said that we are nitpicking. Will local authorities receive appropriate funding and, importantly, responsibility for delivering local business support and regeneration? That...
Marilyn Livingstone Lab Committee
29 Sep 2010
Enterprise Network Inquiry
I would like to explore two areas with you, the first of which is local economic development/regeneration. I represent a Fife constituency, which is probably quite a good example of the extent to which things are working—or rather, failing to work. It is clear what is happenin...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
22 Mar 2000
Local Economic Development
I want to pick up on that last point. Minister, I welcome what you have just said about elevating lifelong learning, as that is what I feel has been missing. My experience, like yours, is in Fife, and I would like to ask you about something that worries me there. Perhaps you c...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
03 Oct 2007
Work Programme
I am taken by the convener's suggestion of a tourism/economy inquiry. A skills strategy and a new strategy for economic development in Scotland have been announced, and I have concerns about both. We have voiced our concerns about the skills strategy, and further concerns were...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
05 Dec 2007
Budget Process 2008-09
I am nervous because, in its evidence, COSLA was not clear how what you describe will be achieved, and when I probed Scottish Enterprise representatives repeatedly on how economic development outwith its main priorities—for example, local economic development in Fife—will be s...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
21 May 2008
Enterprise Network Reform
I have two questions, which I will ask together because I know that the convener is keeping an eye on the time. First, you talked about economic pull and better partnership working. Do you acknowledge that as well as providing education and training, local further and higher e...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
28 Jan 2010
Skills Strategy
We all agree that, if we are to compete successfully in this challenging economic climate and ensure that we are well equipped to take advantage of the opportunities that are presented by economic recovery, Scotland needs an increasingly skilled population. There is no argumen...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab) Lab Chamber
22 Apr 2010
Economy
All of us in the chamber can agree on the need to act urgently to implement effective solutions to support our local and national economies. As convener of the cross-party group on construction, I take this opportunity to highlight the difficulties that continue to be experien...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
24 Oct 2007
Council of Economic Advisers
To follow on from that, I am pleased that you mentioned high-level skills in your introduction and that you have talked about the role of education and skills. What role will your council have with regard to advice on the skills strategy and what input will you have on that? I...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Committee
17 Sep 2008
Energy Inquiry
I have one comment about the end. We must be realistic and have as the end a secure energy supply that gives people confidence that electricity will be available at a reasonable and affordable price.I would like the inquiry to consider support to business and the interventions...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Committee
05 Feb 2003
Social Economy
I found Norman Drummond's presentation to be very interesting, to say the least. Like other members, I am sorry that we cannot fit in a visit before the election, because that would have been very interesting.I have been on the committee since day 1 and, in our various discuss...
Marilyn Livingstone (Kirkcaldy) (Lab): Lab Chamber
01 Dec 1999
Co-operative and Mutual Sector
Like Cathy Jamieson and Johann Lamont, I must declare my interest as a member of the Labour and Co-operative movement. I am proud to be able to say that. The Co-operative movement has been part of my daily life and, like millions of people, I welcome co-operatives in our socie...
Marilyn Livingstone: Lab Chamber
16 Nov 2000
Pre-Budget Statement
Under our policy, £2 billion more will be spent over a four-year period than would have been spent if that link had been restored.The increases in the minimum income guarantee mean that, by 2001, no pensioner will be living on less than £100 a week. The pensions credit is a pi...
← Back to list
Chamber

Plenary, 26 Mar 2003

26 Mar 2003 · S1 · Plenary
Item of business
Scottish Economy
I hope that Alex Neil will have achieved retirement in 40 years' time.

As someone who has been a member of the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee for the whole parliamentary session, I am proud of the contribution that the Parliament has made to shaping a skilled Scottish economy that is capable of coping with the current difficulties in the global economic market and a Scotland that is ready to capitalise on the opportunities for enterprise in the future. I believe that the devolved Parliament has meant that the political contribution to shaping Scotland's economy has been greater than before and more matched to Scotland's needs.

I am pleased that the Scottish Executive has made it clear that it is making economic growth a priority. Scotland already benefits from high employment, but we need to ensure that that contributes to greater economic growth and that we get even more people back into work. Such aims are a far cry from the days of the Tories, who claimed that unemployment was a price worth paying. That was certainly not the case for the people in my area, many of whom, thanks to the Tories, lost their jobs, especially in the coal-mining industry.

Labour has got people back into work. People have been given the pride that comes from sustaining themselves and their families and from raising their aspirations. Labour recognises that our current rate of economic growth is, as the minister said, not good enough and does not match our aspirations for our country. We have put in place infrastructure and investment to change that.

Our partnership with the Labour Government in Westminster has provided us with economic conditions that we could only have dreamed of a decade ago. We have low unemployment, low interest rates and low inflation. Like Bristow Muldoon, I have every faith in the Chancellor of the Exchequer and his economic policies.

I take this opportunity to thank Iain Gray for his recent visit to my constituency to discuss with Fife Council and Scottish Enterprise their action plan for an economic and social strategy for Kirkcaldy and its travel-to-work area. I thank the Executive for agreeing to continue to support that strategy. We need to ensure that the increase in tourism from the Zeebrugge ferry benefits everyone who lives in Fife.

I believe that the Executive has the right strategy to create economic growth, as the strategy invests in enterprise, education and our people. In my constituency as in others, we can now see a learning environment from which young people and those returning to learning are benefiting.

We know that the best way for Scotland to compete is by improving the skills and knowledge of our people. We are capitalising on that by investing in the new technology institutes, which Richard Simpson mentioned. The technology institutes will turn good ideas into good business and they are one of the things that Alex Neil and other members of the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee, including me, have said that we need. That is now being done.

By expanding the modern apprenticeship schemes, we will ensure that our people have the skills that they need for the modern workplace. By rolling out education maintenance allowances, we may be able to do even better than at present by getting more than 50 per cent of our students to continue into education—whether that be further or higher education, academic or vocational.

As the minister said, there is no quick fix. Only last week, we showed our long-term vision to create a strong economy in Scotland through encouraging enterprise education in our schools. Last week, the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee heard at first hand from primary school children who showed their enthusiasm for the project. The programme is working. As we have heard, the Executive has announced that it is working with entrepreneurs, including Tom Farmer, on our enterprise programme so that education for work and enterprise will be embedded in every school in Scotland from primary 1 to secondary 6.

Our commitment to investment in skills, in our people and in enterprise is a sharp contrast to the approach of the Tories and the SNP. They would cut investment in training and enterprise schemes for the short-term electoral benefit of cutting business rates. That is not the way in which to build long-term prosperity for Scotland and it is not a responsible way in which to meet the challenges that we face. It is typical of the Opposition's opportunism.

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Sir David Steel): NPA
Our main item of business today is a debate on motion S1M-4057, in the name of Iain Gray, on the Scottish economy.
The Minister for Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning (Iain Gray): Lab
It is right that one of the last debates in this session of the Parliament allows us to focus on the Scottish economy, which is the issue that underpins all ...
Phil Gallie (South of Scotland) (Con): Con
Does the minister believe that Scotland's economy will benefit from the block grant, given the current balance of trade deficit, which was induced by the nat...
Iain Gray: Lab
When we want to look forward, we must look back and judge the handling of the economy on the record of the current UK Government. We all know about the recor...
Miss Annabel Goldie (West of Scotland) (Con): Con
Will the change in culture extend to political thinking? Does the minister recognise that bureaucrats do not deliver business start-ups and that the business...
Iain Gray: Lab
Of course the change in culture has to extend to politics. That is why, as I am about to say in a moment, we have made a political decision to invest unprece...
Alex Neil (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP
Can the minister update members on the current state of the accessing telecoms links across Scotland project in relation to broadband and tell us whether the...
Iain Gray: Lab
As Mr Neil probably knows, the first stage of project ATLAS came online early, and the second stage is still on time. Nevertheless, Scottish Enterprise has p...
Alasdair Morgan (Galloway and Upper Nithsdale) (SNP): SNP
Even if one were to accept that taking the electronics sector out of the minister's GDP figures was a valid exercise, how does he explain the fact that for t...
Iain Gray: Lab
The question posed is extremely interesting, because we know that for 25 to 30 years Scotland's GDP growth has lagged behind the UK's. One aspect of consider...
Phil Gallie: Con
Does the minister agree that between 1989 and 1996 the Scottish economy grew at a rate that placed it either in the third or fourth position in the UK charts?
Iain Gray: Lab
Nonetheless, the fact is that for 25 or 30 years—for a generation—Scotland's growth rate has lagged behind the UK's. However, we also know and understand—I w...
Andrew Wilson (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP
No, we would not.
Iain Gray: Lab
An SNP document says that as a first step, the SNP"will use savings from the reform of the local enterprise network to reduce business rates to a level lower...
Miss Goldie: Con
Will the minister give way?
Iain Gray: Lab
I am finishing.As we look forward to a new parliamentary session, it is time for the Scottish Parliament to choose investment in Scotland's future, in Scotla...
Andrew Wilson (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP
Iain Gray nearly got going at the end of his speech. We almost got into a debate, and then he had to sit down. My throat is failing me at this early stage in...
Iain Gray rose— Lab
Andrew Wilson: SNP
I will take Iain Gray if he can tell us why a number of those in the advert said that they had not been contacted by Labour and so their support had been mad...
Iain Gray: Lab
I have this to say about it: one chooses who to ask to pass judgment on one's success. I choose not a single Labour activist who expressed a view with which ...
Andrew Wilson: SNP
That is terrific. If the minister is complacent and thinks that things are fine, why did his predecessor resign saying that she could not get the economy to ...
Ms Wendy Alexander (Paisley North) (Lab): Lab
Will Andrew Wilson give way?
Andrew Wilson: SNP
No, thanks. Why have 55 of Labour's business supporters said that they will not support Labour in the election? Why did 30 of them go bust?
Ms Alexander: Lab
Will Andrew Wilson give way?
Andrew Wilson: SNP
I will not.The reality is that some of those people have even said that the Labour party did not contact them. It was making up support that did not exist.
Ms Alexander: Lab
Will Andrew Wilson give way?
Andrew Wilson: SNP
How can we possibly trust a party that has made up supporters and spun the truth when most of those who backed it previously will not back it now? Why should...
Ms Alexander: Lab
I challenge Andrew Wilson now because I have heard him repeat his false allegation so often. I challenge him to provide a sourced quotation from anywhere tha...
Andrew Wilson: SNP
I have to rely for my sources on Alf Young in The Herald, who reported Wendy Alexander as having said it. If it is not true, I am sure that she will have wri...
Iain Gray rose— Lab