Committee
Equal Opportunities Committee, 20 Jun 2000
20 Jun 2000 · S1 · Equal Opportunities Committee
Item of business
“Towards an Equality Strategy”
The next item on the agenda is evidence on "Towards an Equality Strategy". Everybody has had a copy of the report on the responses. The annexe includes a list of respondents. We are being offered the opportunity to examine the responses, of which there are a number. Today, we will hear from Yvonne Strachan, Esther Breitenbach and Kate Bilton from the Scottish Executive. As I said, Jackie Baillie is coming on 4 July to talk to the committee about the report.
Yvonne Strachan will lead. The committee will then have the opportunity ask questions.
Yvonne Strachan will lead. The committee will then have the opportunity ask questions.
In the same item of business
The Convener:
Lab
The next item on the agenda is evidence on "Towards an Equality Strategy". Everybody has had a copy of the report on the responses. The annexe includes a lis...
Yvonne Strachan (Scottish Executive Equality Unit):
I will make a couple of brief introductory remarks and then invite Esther Breitenbach, who is the research consultant for the equality unit, to give a little...
Esther Breitenbach (Scottish Executive Equality Unit):
I want to do three things in introducing the report. First, I want to talk about distribution and how we got the report out to people. Secondly, I want to ta...
Esther Breitenbach (Scottish Executive Equality Unit):
Committee members might have been confused by a small technical matter: although the tables in the early part of the report indicate clearly that there were ...
The Convener:
Lab
You said that 4,000 copies were distributed. Were they distributed in accessible formats such as Braille, audiotape and languages that are minority languages...
Esther Breitenbach:
I do not have all the details to hand. The document was translated into community languages and certainly would have been available in a big-print version. I...
Yvonne Strachan:
We received one request for the document in Hindi and one request for it in Braille. Copies in those formats were made available.
The Convener:
Lab
Obviously, as you accepted late submissions, people were not disadvantaged because they had to request the document in an accessible format.Will the 185 resp...
Yvonne Strachan:
The report on the consultation will be sent to everybody who responded to the consultation. We hope that they will see that not only their views but the view...
Mr McMahon:
Lab
I have a similar question to yours, convener. It is about the on-going involvement that the report highlights. Does that pose problems for the Executive and ...
Yvonne Strachan:
The issue of communication and networking was a significant part of the consultation and the responses. The Executive's task is to consider the best way to r...
Mr McMahon:
Lab
An obvious implication of doing that will be resources. Has the Scottish Executive indicated that there will be adequate resources to continue the involvemen...
Yvonne Strachan:
Several issues arise from the question of whether there are resources to develop communication and networking. Developing appropriate consultative networks i...
Esther Breitenbach:
There is already a well-established framework for women's organisations through the database and the women in Scotland consultative forum, which has met regu...
Irene McGugan (North-East Scotland) (SNP):
SNP
You acknowledged that the consultation was different, in that it did not focus on specific proposals but took a more general approach. A major criticism of t...
Yvonne Strachan:
We welcome open and frank opinion. It is good to hear points that are constructive, whether they are negative or positive. As Esther Breitenbach said in her ...
Irene McGugan:
SNP
How do you plan to develop the strategy in the light of the responses that you have received, and what time scale are you working to?
Yvonne Strachan:
Jackie Baillie will be at the Equal Opportunities Committee on 4 July, and we see that as an important part of the process. We are currently discussing how w...
Malcolm Chisholm:
Lab
I am interested in the definitional aspects of this matter. I read an interesting submission from the Scottish Poverty Information Unit, whose main concern w...
Yvonne Strachan:
How the equality strategy will move forward in the light of the consultation has to be considered further. The relationship between social inclusion, particu...
Malcolm Chisholm:
Lab
You will not be here for item 4 on the agenda, but I can make this question relevant by saying that part of the strategy is to get work done on specific poli...
Esther Breitenbach:
The final version of the report on women and transport will be finished soon. The purpose of that research was to examine women's transport needs, as it was ...
Johann Lamont:
Lab
I want to cover more about how successful this consultation process has been. Would the level of responses received be considered to be within the normal ran...
Esther Breitenbach:
I will answer the general question first, then I will ask Kate Bilton to answer the specific questions.It is not easy to say whether the response rates were ...
Johann Lamont:
Lab
An equality strategy is probably as broad a consultation process as we could get. Would you have expected more than 185 responses? In your organisation, is t...
Esther Breitenbach:
We do not know the answer to that. We would have to take some soundings and to re-examine who responded. We might ask some of the people whom we might have e...
Kate Bilton (Scottish Executive Equality Unit):
There will be organisations that cover interests that are outwith their main purpose. A local authority will certainly cover issues concerning women, black a...
Johann Lamont:
Lab
On women's issues, it would be interesting to know whether the voluntary sector is saying something different from statutory organisations, or whether women'...
Kate Bilton:
Further analysis could be done on that, if it were deemed appropriate.
Esther Breitenbach:
A number of responses covered a range of equality areas, whereas others focused very specifically on one interest. There were women's organisations that talk...