Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 40 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
31 Jan 2023
Youth Vaping
I congratulate Siobhian Brown on securing time for this really important debate, and I thank all those who have been campaigning on the issue, particularly Less Waste Laura, ASH Scotland and Asthma + Lung UK. The explosion in the use and popularity of single-use vapes, espec...
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
14 Sep 2023
Single-use Vapes (Environmental Impact)
I recognise the strength of feeling on the issue in the Parliament and I thank everyone who will contribute today. The fact that we are so tight on time is heartening and points to how seriously the Parliament takes the issue. I know that work is going on in many offices acro...
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
25 Jun 2024
Circular Economy (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I acknowledge the work that the Scottish Government has done to date to highlight the health and environmental harms of single-use vapes and the commitment to work on a four-nations basis on a ban. I lodged the amendment to place a ban on single-use vapes in the bill. I am res...
Gillian Mackay Green Chamber
25 Jun 2024
Circular Economy (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
In the local authority where I live, Falkirk, the easiest places to take single-use vapes to are local waste centres or tips around the area. A lot of the time, people need a car to be able to get there, so that initially puts them off going. Taking vapes back to the shop that...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
21 May 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
Price is also a major issue that we have heard many concerns about with regard to the accessibility of the disposable vapes to young people. Some of your members are selling vapes with 20mg of nicotine in them for as low as £4.99—that is about the price of a Tesco meal deal; i...
Gillian Mackay Green Chamber
19 Jan 2023
General Question Time · Vapes (Impact on Public Health)
There are many issues with vapes, including in relation to flavours and advertising, that we should be tackling, and I hope that the cabinet secretary would support that. As well as being an issue for public health, vapes are an issue for the environment. That is covered in t...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
12 Sep 2023
Programme for Government 2023-24
Is work under way on putting vapes behind covers, as currently happens with cigarettes? One of the biggest concerns that we are hearing from parents is about the pervasiveness of the products, especially in shops. They can be reached by toddlers, because they are on the ends o...
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Committee
14 Nov 2023
Vaping (Public Health Impact)
I want to build on what we have just heard from Professor Banks. I have hosted a couple of round-table discussions on vaping, at which parents and professionals have raised concerns about flavours, price promotions and the fact that vapes are being marketed to children, and ho...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
14 Nov 2023
Vaping (Public Health Impact)
The pervasiveness of marketing and product placement has also been raised. The Advertising Standards Authority website says that “ads for nicotine-containing e-cigarettes that are not licensed as medicines ... are prohibited” on “On-demand television” as well as newspapers...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
21 May 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
If no one is actually taking up the guidance that you are issuing, you will forgive us for feeling that that aspiration rings hollow. On top of that, you said that you are concerned about vapes coming in from China in particular. One member of your organisation is a medical b...
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Committee
12 Sep 2023
Programme for Government 2023-24
It is being reported in the press this morning that the UK Government is likely to announce a ban on disposable vapes in the coming weeks. I welcome the Scottish Government’s commitment to a consultation on banning them. However, harm is still occurring while that work is unde...
Gillian Mackay Green Chamber
14 Sep 2023
Single-use Vapes (Environmental Impact)
The paediatrician who we heard from at the round table on Monday raised the concern that we are trading two health-harming products off against each other, rather than recognising the health-harming nature of vapes. Does the member agree that we need to recognise this health-h...
Gillian Mackay Green Chamber
07 Mar 2024
General Question Time · Vaping (Action to Minimise Harm)
Organisations are concerned about how disposable or single-use vapes are defined. They are concerned that manufacturers might try to add a USB port to a disposable vape to get around potential regulation, as well as about the potential scope of exemptions in the regulations. W...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
17 Dec 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
There are various provisions in the bill. Some are about the sale of vapes, but some are about smoke-free environments. We are supposed to have smoke-free environments outside hospitals, for example, but from my inbox as well as my experience, I know that that is not necessari...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
06 May 2025
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
Is there a plan to bring in an official ban on vapes in indoor spaces? Obviously, at the moment, although most shopping centres and other such places will not allow it to happen, there is not a ban in the same way as there is on smoking indoors. Having an official ban in place...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
10 Mar 2026
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
Given the range of powers that are in the bill and how far it will stray into devolved competence, and given that, so far, nothing has been done to tackle vapes on a cross-UK basis, what room will the bill leave for Scotland to be able to take targeted measures, rather than ne...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
10 Mar 2026
Public Health Scotland
That was really helpful—thank you.Would the panel support moves to tackle certain social determinants of health? For example, vapes could be put under covers and treated in the same way as tobacco products in order to prevent what we have at the moment: massive shop fronts ful...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
10 Mar 2026
Public Health Scotland
My next question is for the councillors. When it comes to tackling the social determinants of health, a lot of what we need to do, in making the public environment better, lies with local authorities. Greater numbers of licences are granted for takeaways and pubs in areas of h...
7. Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
19 Jan 2023
General Question Time · Vapes (Impact on Public Health)
To ask the Scottish Government what work is under way to assess the impact of vapes on public health. (S6O-01802)
Gillian Mackay Green Chamber
11 May 2023
First Minister’s Question Time · Disposable Vaping Products
I look forward to the publication of the report that was commissioned by the minister. Vaping has serious environmental and health impacts. That is why campaigners such as Less Waste Laura, the Daily Record and a growing number of councils have highlighted those harms. I than...
Gillian Mackay Green Chamber
17 May 2023
Portfolio Question Time · United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020 (Exemptions)
I have previously welcomed the creation of 140 new jobs in Motherwell as part of the DRS. Those are just some of the hundreds of jobs that are being created across Scotland as a result of the scheme. However, the jobs are now at risk because of the UK Government’s deliberate d...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
12 Sep 2023
Programme for Government 2023-24
Yesterday, I hosted a round-table meeting that was attended by Emma Harper and other colleagues. We heard from paediatricians and parents who are concerned about the addiction that children are currently suffering and the potential long-term health impacts. We have never neede...
Gillian Mackay Green Chamber
14 Sep 2023
Single-use Vapes (Environmental Impact)
Will the member take an intervention?
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
30 Jan 2024
Topical Question Time · Single-use Vapes
I place on record my thanks to the campaigners and organisations involved, and to the Daily Record for working with me and other MSPs in campaigning for the ban. The proposals are a huge victory for them, and I thank the Government for the positive conversations that I have ha...
6. Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
07 Mar 2024
General Question Time · Vaping (Action to Minimise Harm)
To ask the Scottish Government what public health measures are being taken to minimise harm from vaping, prior to the introduction of the proposed ban on single-use vapes. (S6O-03179)
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
26 Mar 2024
Smoking and Vaping
I have been campaigning on this issue alongside parents, young people, clinicians, health charities and the Daily Record. They are all really pleased with the announcement on banning single-use vapes, and I thank them for their support. Before the ban comes into place, we nee...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
21 May 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
Good morning. I am pleased that the committee so far seems to be taking a public health approach to the issues. Mr Dunne, I want to challenge you on a couple of points. You said that your organisation takes the safety of children very seriously. Having had a quick Google of a...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
21 May 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
Forgive me, but my question was specifically framed around children and young people.
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
21 May 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
So, you would acknowledge that price is an issue for children and young people, as we have heard from many parents?
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
21 May 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
How would the witnesses like any potential health benefits to be evaluated once the bill is passed? Obviously, it might take a while for the impact of some of the measures to show up in the population health data, but do the witnesses have any initial thoughts about how to mon...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
21 May 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
There are two sides to data collection. There is the collection of data on smoking and increasing age and, as you said, Dr Reid, acute harms from that will show up relatively quickly. For vaping, however, we could be looking for different data, because we have not seen the lon...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
21 May 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
That is great. Thanks.
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
04 Jun 2024
Health and Social Care
I begin by extending my gratitude to the workers who make up our NHS—those who spend their lives making sure that we get the care we are entitled to when we need it. That includes every single worker who is involved in the running of our services, from nurses and GPs to cleane...
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
04 Jun 2024
Health and Social Care
We should all continue to call for additional efforts and initiatives to support the recruitment and retention of clinicians and other NHS staff. For example, the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh highlights that it would welcome a review of the NHS estate to ensure tha...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
17 Dec 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
Good morning, minister. How would you respond to criticisms that existing restrictions on vaping and tobacco are not being adequately enforced?
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
17 Dec 2024
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
The register is obviously very different to the way that we handle alcohol licensing, for example. As a result of some of the things that are happening through the bill, does the Scottish Government have any plans to put additional restrictions in the register, to bring it in ...
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Chamber
01 May 2025
World Asthma Day 2025
I, too, thank Emma Harper for securing this important debate to recognise world asthma day, which this year takes place on 6 May. I echo the contents of her speech and recognise the importance of the points that she and other members have made. Despite its being considered a ...
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green Committee
06 May 2025
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
My question relates in particular to age verification and the supplementary LCM. There are new forms of identification coming on board—we have challenge 25 at the moment—so how quickly does the Government envisage us being able to skill up the workforce that is selling the aff...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
06 May 2025
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
On the designation of smoking and vaping-free places, there is obviously very good compliance at the moment with the ban on smoking indoors, but there are other spaces—in particular, around hospitals and other such places—where smoke-free zones are not currently working partic...
Gillian Mackay Green Committee
10 Mar 2026
Tobacco and Vapes Bill
Thank you.
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 31 January 2023 [Draft]

31 Jan 2023 · S6 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Youth Vaping
Mackay, Gillian Green Central Scotland Watch on SPTV

I congratulate Siobhian Brown on securing time for this really important debate, and I thank all those who have been campaigning on the issue, particularly Less Waste Laura, ASH Scotland and Asthma + Lung UK.

The explosion in the use and popularity of single-use vapes, especially among young people, is multifaceted and difficult to tackle. I was pleased that, in response to my question, the Scottish Government committed to exploring a ban on single-use vapes. I share the concerns that Siobhian Brown and others have raised around such age-restricted products being marketed and sold to children. As the Asthma + Lung UK lung health champion for young people, I believe that we need to involve young people in such conversations, and I hope that, in the coming months, I will be able to work with the Scottish Youth Parliament and others to get their views.

Dundee City Council recently reported that 62 per cent of sites visited sold vapes to a test purchaser who was under 18. That is a real issue for councils, but I should stress that it is not restricted to Dundee. Those who repeatedly flout the rules could be banned from selling vapes and tobacco for up to 24 months, and I know that some of my councillors have raised the issue of how to deal with the large number of retailers selling vapes and the compliance issues that that causes.

In addition, if any of us wanted to, right now, we could order—via Just Eat, Uber Eats or other, similar platforms—vapes directly to this building. The people who deliver the product are supposed to check age on delivery, but how many are doing so? Although test purchasing from stores is a well-trodden path, it is an even more difficult area for councils to gauge.

The flavours of vapes that are available is an issue of concern to many parents, who believe that they are being targeted at children. We are hearing anecdotally that large numbers of children and young people are taking up vaping who probably would not have smoked. That is partly due to the appeal of the flavours, the disposable nature of vapes and the ease of getting them. We must ensure that their advertising to children is restricted.

Some of the ways in which children may be exposed to vapes, as with some issues relating to alcohol, are a reserved matter, but I hope that the UK Government will take action on the issue and ensure that children do not have age-restricted products advertised to them. I believe that the ban on such advertising should extend to stores, and I am pleased that so many members across the chamber believe that, too.

Just before Christmas, I wrote to some major retailers to ask them to treat vaping products in the same way as cigarettes are treated. I was disappointed by the responses that I received; indeed, sometimes, I did not receive a response at all. Many of those retailers were very proud when they removed sweets and other less healthy products from till lines, which they did mainly to improve the health of the population. I do not understand why that does not extend to the prominent placement of other health-harming products in stores, some of which are not only in prominent places but could be reached and picked up by children. I hope that, in the coming weeks, we will see a change of heart by the big supermarkets and other major chain retailers, and that they will put such products behind cover.

The strength of some vapes, as we have heard, is astounding, with some single-use vapes containing as much nicotine as 40 cigarettes. People who vape are being exposed to far higher levels of nicotine than they may realise.

The environmental issues are important, too. As I am sure that many in the chamber are aware, the number of vapes that litter our streets and parks is growing. Siobhian Brown highlighted that some children are picking them up to see what they have left in them, which is undoubtedly a public health concern. We have heard about how difficult they are to dispose of, let alone recycle. The lithium batteries in them present a risk of explosion if disposed of incorrectly. As Clare Adamson said, retailers who sell such products should be taking them back. We need to make people more aware of the appropriate ways to dispose of them and make sure that they are banned in the long term.

I again congratulate Siobhian Brown on securing time to debate the issue, and I hope that members across the chamber can work together to tackle it.

18:07  

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Annabelle Ewing) SNP
The final item of business is a members’ business debate on motion S6M-07290, in the name of Siobhian Brown, on concern regarding youth vaping. The debate wi...
Siobhian Brown (Ayr) (SNP) SNP
I thank everybody who has supported the motion and those who are taking part in the debate. I am really looking forward to all contributions. I lodged the m...
Rona Mackay (Strathkelvin and Bearsden) (SNP) SNP
I am pleased to speak in this very important debate. I thank my friend and colleague Siobhian Brown for bringing it to the chamber and for her very informati...
Alexander Stewart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con
I am pleased to be able to contribute, and I thank Siobhian Brown for bringing this important debate to the chamber. As Asthma + Lung UK Scotland’s parliamen...
Emma Harper (South Scotland) (SNP) SNP
The member mentioned flavours that are approved for food but, just because something is approved for food does not mean that it is okay to go into people’s l...
Alexander Stewart Con
I completely concur with that. As I said, they are not there for that specific use or to be ingested in that way; they are there for the food impact. I ment...
Clare Adamson (Motherwell and Wishaw) (SNP) SNP
I thank Siobhian Brown for securing the debate, which is on an issue of increasing urgency. According to the BBC Radio 4 programme “All Consuming”, the globa...
Paul Sweeney (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab
I congratulate the member for Ayr on securing this members’ business debate, which ensures that this topic is given the prominence that it deserves in this c...
Kenneth Gibson (Cunninghame North) (SNP) SNP
I, too, congratulate my colleague Siobhian Brown on securing debating time on this important matter. With sweet flavours, colourful packaging and low prices...
Gillian Mackay (Central Scotland) (Green) Green
I congratulate Siobhian Brown on securing time for this really important debate, and I thank all those who have been campaigning on the issue, particularly L...
Stephanie Callaghan (Uddingston and Bellshill) (SNP) SNP
I thank Siobhian Brown for bringing the debate to the chamber and for all the work that she has been doing on the issue for quite some time. There have been...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
Before I call the next speaker, I advise members that, due to the high number of members who wish to speak in the debate, I am minded to accept a motion with...
Brian Whittle (South Scotland) (Con) Con
I thank Siobhian Brown for bringing the debate to the chamber. Given the length of the debate and the number of people who want to speak in it, it is clear t...
Pauline McNeill (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab
I thank Siobhian Brown for an excellent speech. It is the speech that I wanted to hear, because I did not disagree with a single word of it or any of the exc...
Emma Harper (South Scotland) (SNP) SNP
I congratulate my colleague Siobhian Brown on securing the debate. I know that she is doing much work on youth vaping. She laid out perfectly the issues arou...
Brian Whittle Con
I know that there has not been enough research into it, but is it not logical that inhaling foreign bodies into your lungs has to be harmful?
Emma Harper SNP
There is just a one-word answer to that and that is yes. We should absolutely be doing research into and paying attention to substances that people are takin...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab
Thank you to Siobhian Brown for lodging her motion for debate, providing a timely opportunity to discuss the phenomenal growth in vaping that has left behind...
The Minister for Public Health, Women’s Health and Sport (Maree Todd) SNP
I thank Siobhian Brown for lodging the motion and offer my thanks to all the members across the chamber who have taken part in discussing what we can all agr...
Brian Whittle Con
Surely what we should be looking to do here is make it as difficult as possible for our youth to get hold of these products and to punish those who supply to...
Maree Todd SNP
We are working very closely with Trading Standards Scotland to understand what key improvements could be made in Scotland to stamp out illegal sales. I also ...
Gillian Mackay Green
I thank the minister for taking an intervention. She recognised the impact that the tobacco industry has. Will she join the calls that I have made to retaile...
Maree Todd SNP
Yes, absolutely. We are considering all these things. We have started to take action. Last year we consulted on restrictions on the advertising and promotion...
Brian Whittle Con
I thank the minister very much for indulging me again. Should we not be organising a marketing counter strategy that takes a pride in Scotland approach, in t...
Maree Todd SNP
We need to consider all aspects of how to get to the crux of this problem, but we need to remember that it is a highly addictive product that is being market...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
That concludes the debate. Meeting closed at 18:36.