Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,354,908
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
24 Jan 2024
Green Economy
I will not take an intervention. I would love to, but I will be talking up Aberdeen and I do not want it talked down. Beyond public investment, so much of what saw Aberdeen establish itself as the oil and gas capital of Europe has left the city very well placed to research, d...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
14 Mar 2023
Net Zero: Local Government and Cross-sectoral Partners
I am pleased to speak in my first committee debate as a member of the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee—I think that this is the first time since I joined the committee that we have had a debate in the chamber. I thank the clerks, my committee colleagues and all those w...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
20 Apr 2023
Climate Change and Just Transition
As a member of the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee, I am pleased to speak in the debate, and I take the opportunity to welcome the Cabinet Secretary for Net Zero and Just Transition and the Minister for Energy to their roles. The SNP Scottish Government has demonstra...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
25 Feb 2025
Budget (Scotland) (No 4) Bill
I am very pleased to support this budget. From speaking with my constituents, I think that it is a budget that they support, too, because it invests in the things that they care most about. It maintains the SNP’s most popular policies and demonstrates our clear ambition to mov...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
04 Mar 2025
Scotland’s Renewable Future
I seem to be speaking a lot about energy recently, and that is not just in the scheduled debates. Energy bills are a pressing concern for folk right across Scotland. Thousands upon thousands of folk are struggling to pay them, and many who would have been comfortable just a fe...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
21 Sep 2021
Net Zero Nation
Taking action on climate change is the biggest challenge that we, as a Parliament, our children and our communities will face for years to come. We must act now to help minimise Scotland’s contribution to climate change. We must restore as much nature and green space as we can...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
02 Sep 2025
Scottish Government Priorities
After a long recess away from Parliament, it is good to be back talking about our priorities and about what matters to my constituents and to folk across Scotland. The Scottish Government has four key priorities: eradicating child poverty; tackling the climate emergency; grow...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
25 Jan 2023
Housing
I was surprised to see the Conservatives lodging the motion for this debate when it is their Government in Westminster that is directly impacting the Scottish Government’s ability to build new homes and tackle inequality. It is the capital spending decisions of the Tory UK Gov...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
19 Jan 2023
Carbon Neutral Islands Project
As a member of the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee, I am happy to speak in this afternoon’s debate. As the member for Aberdeen Donside, I want the innovative work of the carbon neutral islands project because I believe that supporting our island communities on their j...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
26 Sep 2023
Climate Emergency
Humza Yousaf wants the north-east to be the energy capital of Europe and the world. I shall try again. I have had the privilege of visiting a number of businesses in the oil and gas sector, as well as in the supply chain. They are all playing their part in the national journ...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
04 Dec 2024
Powering Futures
First, I congratulate Michael Matheson on securing this members’ business debate on putting young people at the heart of the energy transition. As the former Cabinet Secretary for Net Zero, Energy and Transport, and now as the deputy convener of the Net Zero, Energy and Transp...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
07 Jun 2023
Oil and Gas Industry
It might come as a surprise that I actually agree with some of the Conservative motion. I agree that “the Parliament recognises the vital role that oil and gas plays in Scotland’s energy mix and in supporting tens of thousands of Scottish jobs, particularly in the north east”...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
27 May 2025
Community-owned Energy
I am delighted to take part in today’s debate on growing community-owned energy in Scotland—and to have the chance, once more, to talk up Aberdeen. With “Energy” in the title of today’s debate, let me start, as I do every time that happens, by reminding folk that Aberdeen, par...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
07 Dec 2021
Just Transition
I am sorry. I do not have time. There can be no just transition without our taking the north-east along with us. We are being left behind by the UK Government. The transition away from oil and gas is required in order for us to meet our climate change targets. We have a resp...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
20 Apr 2023
Climate Change and Just Transition
Thank you, Deputy Presiding Officer. I am just fair forfochen—I am sorry; that is a good old-fashioned Doric word for being exhausted—haein tae explain tae Liam Kerr that money is money. I am an Aberdonian, and I will appreciate any money that we can get, but I ask him to ask...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
04 May 2023
Portfolio Question Time · Net Zero Projects (Engagement with United Kingdom Government)
Given that Andrew Bowie, Parliamentary Under-secretary of State for the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, told the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee last week that he “would be overwhelmingly delighted should Acorn be successful through the track 2 process” ...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
10 Oct 2024
Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I am delighted to take part in this debate as a member of the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee and to talk about our stage 1 report on the Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill. First, I thank the clerks for all their hard work in completing the...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
28 May 2024
Climate Change and Environmental Governance
Given that Scotland does much of the heavy lifting when it comes to harnessing the power of our natural capital in order to reach net zero, and that, for the whole of the UK to reach net zero, Scotland must do so by 2045—we have heard that in evidence before—is it not logical ...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
30 Oct 2025
Natural Environment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Sorry, Presiding Officer—I am just following what was said to me. I am equally sure that, should any of those targets be missed, whoever is in government will have their feet held firmly to the fire by whoever is in the chamber between now and 2045. The bill contains headline...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
09 Jan 2024
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee Report: “How Devolution is Changing Post-EU”
I thank the convener, the committee members and the clerks for their work on the report that is before us today. I would rather not be taking part in this debate; I would much rather that Scotland had not been ripped out of the EU against its will and that there would be no n...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
21 Sep 2021
Net Zero Nation
I will finish off, if I can. In our move to net zero, we simply cannot leave anyone behind, whether that be our communities or the industries in which we work. Our journey to net zero must be a just one, taking communities with us, engaging with them—
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Committee
11 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I declare an interest, because I am still a serving councillor on Aberdeen City Council. I thank the witnesses for coming. I will keep my questions brief because I notice that we are getting short for time. I will ask about planning. Do your local authorities use agreements ...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
18 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I am interested in planning obligations and land value capture. Should land value capture be directed and used proactively to achieve net zero? What would a robust and successful system for land value capture look like in practice? I am in your hands as to who is best to answer.
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Committee
25 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Thank you, convener, and good morning, panel. I am aware that we are running over time, so I will just ask one question. We are all saying that net zero will be achieved only if we work together; businesses and local authorities need to work together. As you know, I am still ...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
03 May 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I have one more question. Are there any powers or freedoms to act that local authorities should have to assist in delivering a net zero transport system? That is a quick, if-I-ruled-the-world question. Ewan Wallace, I will ask you, because you kind of brightened up when I aske...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
17 May 2022
Energy Price Rises
Good afternoon, cabinet secretary. In a previous evidence session, we heard from Keith Anderson, the chief executive officer of Scottish Power, who gave compelling evidence. He said: “The more that we invest as a country in the future of wind ... and in solar power, the more ...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
24 May 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I will follow on from what David Rodger and David Hammond said about the consultation process. On the positive side, recent evidence suggests that communities are more motivated than ever to make changes to their lifestyle as we move towards net zero, but I am also conscious t...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Committee
14 Jun 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
We hear a lot that, to get to net zero, the public and private sectors will have to work together. What will be the key challenges in making that partnership happen? I do not know whether that makes sense at all. Niall Robertson, I will come to you first, to cover the broader ...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Committee
21 Jun 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Good morning. With regard to supporting the transition to net zero, ABI has suggested that there are currently not enough investment opportunities and that the process is too complicated to freely use the insurance industry’s investment capacity. I see that you are nodding, Be...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
19 Jan 2023
Carbon Neutral Islands Project
I am an Aberdonian: money is money, as far as I am concerned. As long as it is new money and there are no strings attached, I welcome it. The innovative carbon neutral islands project highlights islands as hubs of innovation in our move towards becoming carbon neutral. The pr...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
14 Mar 2023
Net Zero: Local Government and Cross-sectoral Partners
Well, the UK Government has taken £300 billion from the north-east of Scotland through the Treasury since the 1970s, if you are going to start matching funds, Mr Kerr. I call on the UK Government to play its role in ensuring that we achieve a just transition and to match the ...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
31 Oct 2023
Scottish Water Annual Report and Accounts 2022-23
I will move on from sewage and pollution to questions about your net zero projects. In your annual report, you mention the challenges that you are facing in negotiating access to land for peatland restoration work. Can you expand on what barriers you are facing to gain that ac...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
07 Nov 2023
Ferry Services
As a member of the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee, I am pleased to speak in the debate. I thank the clerks, my committee colleagues past and present and everyone who gave evidence to the committee. Without their input, the inquiry and our recommendations would not ha...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Chamber
10 Oct 2024
Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
That is a question for the Scottish Government, but if only the previous UK Government had given the same amount of money for a just transition, we might be in a better place. It is all well and good to talk about targets, but giving the Acorn project the go-ahead would have ...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
24 Jan 2024
Green Economy
I have the honour and privilege of being one of the MSPs who represents the future net zero capital of the world. We are not there yet, but, although we have a fair bit of work to do to realise that ambition, I am confident that we will make that title our own. That confidence...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
20 Mar 2024
Circular Economy (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
As a member of the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee, looking at the basic principles of the bill has been of great interest to me, so I am pleased to take part in today’s debate. I take this opportunity to record my thanks to the clerks, SPICe, and all the people who ...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
26 Mar 2024
Natural Capital Finance
Good morning, panel. To what extent do we need private investment in natural capital in Scotland? That is an open question to start with.
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
21 Sep 2021
Committee Priorities
Good morning, panel. My question is for Scottish Enterprise. I note in your written submission that you are focused on “stimulating early action” in support of the transition to net zero. What are the early actions and how do you measure their success?
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
05 Oct 2021
Committee Priorities
Finally, what are your expectations of COP26, which is just around the corner? What would you like to see come out of it to achieve the net zero targets?
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
11 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
When it comes to how the section 75 money is used, is the current balance between housing and infrastructure appropriate? I think that that balance is about 60:40 at the moment.
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
11 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I understand that, at the moment, 60 per cent of the section 75 money goes on housing and 40 per cent of it goes on infrastructure. Is that balance appropriate or would you change it if you could?
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
11 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Thank you. I put the same questions to Councillor Aitken.
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
11 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
What are your views on the balance of what section 75 is being used for at present? Is there anything else that you would like to see it being used for?
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
11 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Thank you. Councillor McVey, will you give me your thoughts, please?
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
18 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I totally understand you not being an expert, because I am absolutely no expert, which is why I find these questions interesting. I would be delighted if you got back to us in writing. I am happy to have a written response to my next question, too, if that is more appropriate...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
18 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I am still a serving councillor on Aberdeen City Council and I was there when the case that you referred to happened. That is all that I have got, convener.
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
18 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I thank the witnesses for coming to the meeting. I could not agree more with you when you speak about communities being best placed to tell us what they need with regard to the problems that we face as we move forward. Of course, different communities will have different probl...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
18 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I could not agree more. I will go to Ailsa Raeburn and then to Mark McRitchie. I am sorry—I should have said that before.
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
18 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
That is all I have, convener, so I will pass back to you.
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
25 Jan 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Thank you. Back to you, convener. I just had the one, quick question, as I said.
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Chamber
17 Mar 2022
Active Travel
I am pleased to take part in today’s Scottish Government debate on delivering on active travel commitments and recognising the important investment that our Government is making in our communities and the benefit that it will have to our constituents. It is the Scottish Gove...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Committee
22 Mar 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Good morning, panel. I will follow up on a couple of points that have already been touched on. Jane Tennant has spoken about planning as a career and mentioned that we should try to ensure that school pupils are aware of planning as a career. What more could schools do to ens...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
22 Mar 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
From what you say, we need people in local authority planning departments to step across the corridor and speak to people in the education departments and ask them to plug the planning department. I think that Robbie Calvert talked about skill sets needing to be in the right ...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
22 Mar 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Pam, you spoke about local authorities sharing expertise in best practice. Will you explain briefly what arrangements are in place and what could be done to improve sharing of best practice among local authorities?
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
22 Mar 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I am not sure who would be the best person to answer my last question, so whoever thinks they are best placed should shout out. We saw in the Covid-19 pandemic that decisions were made and things were put in place in super quick time. What lessons can we learn from that as we...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
22 Mar 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Simon Hewitt said that we need to blur the lines of who is responsible for what in education and training. I could not agree more. I said earlier that education on the subject should be started at primary school level. What are local authorities doing to work with you to make ...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
22 Mar 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Chris Brodie mentioned that we need more folk to move back to work and that we need more routes for training, upskilling and retraining. I have a really simple question. What do you mean by retraining? Is it about folk who are already in an industry or folk who are coming into...
Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP) SNP Committee
29 Mar 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Good morning, panel, and thank you for coming along. In previous evidence-taking sessions, the committee has heard about staff retention in local authorities. In response to Monica Lennon, you mentioned planning services and building standards, but have you been made aware of...
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
29 Mar 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
I know that building standards works closely with other departments, which is why I asked whether you had seen anything. Martyn, what about your services?
Jackie Dunbar SNP Committee
29 Mar 2022
Role of Local Government in Delivering Net Zero
Do any of the Ians have an insight into the shortages? I apologise for saying “any of the Ians”—I know how rude that sounds.
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 24 January 2024

24 Jan 2024 · S6 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Green Economy

I will not take an intervention. I would love to, but I will be talking up Aberdeen and I do not want it talked down.

Beyond public investment, so much of what saw Aberdeen establish itself as the oil and gas capital of Europe has left the city very well placed to research, develop and pioneer the new technologies that will be needed to reach net zero. On top of that, we still have oil and gas companies that are based in Aberdeen and that recognise that their own long-term future relies on their being able to deliver more sustainable forms of energy.

However, the most important reason why I am confident that Aberdeen will be the net zero capital of the world is the people we have in Aberdeen, who are some of the most talented and innovative workers from across the world. There is a line from Jimmy Reid’s rat race speech that I keep hearing from a colleague:

“The untapped resources of the North Sea are as nothing compared to the untapped resources of our people.”

That line needs to underpin Aberdeen’s approach to the just transition and our investment in a green economy. That we have oil and gas in the North Sea was key when it came to establishing Aberdeen as an energy capital. When it comes to renewables, although we rightly recognise the potential that our land and sea offer, I do not think that we talk up our folk enough. I will never tire of talking up Aberdeen and its folk.

Over the years, Aberdeen has amassed a workforce that includes many of the brightest and best in the industries that are key to making our economy green. Some of those workers were trained here; others have come from far and wide and have chosen to work here. Having such a skilled workforce means, however, that it is in demand around the world. The investment that we are seeing in the foundations of a green economy today will give those workers opportunities to move across to our green industries. It will help to keep them here and ensure that we retain our greatest asset in the move to net zero—our people.

I will use the rest of my speech to talk up a few examples of some of the amazing folk, businesses and organisations across Aberdeen that are key to growing our green economy today and that will help us to become a global net zero capital in the future.

Last week, I had the great privilege of visiting Verlume, a company in my constituency that specialises in intelligent energy management and storage technologies. It was not the first time that I had visited the company, but the word about its work seems to have gotten out, because this time it was also being visited by the chief executive of Scottish Enterprise, the cabinet secretary and our First Minister. During the visit, the First Minister spoke of wanting us to have a fair, green and growing economy. I think that Verlume’s operations facility in Dyce, where it does the work that has made it a front runner in the energy transition, was the perfect backdrop for that.

Another business that has received Scottish Enterprise’s backing, and which I am looking forward to meeting soon, is Kionnali Living Systems, which is headquartered in the Bridge of Don area of my constituency. Avriel and Corinn, who founded the company, are re-imagining what housing will look like in years to come, and I look forward to seeing what the future will bring for them and the role that they will play in making that future more sustainable.

As we look to the future, I was pleased to meet Bryan Snelling, the chief executive of Aberdeen Science Centre, just last Friday, to hear about the work that it is doing to bring science, technology, engineering and maths learning about wind farms and engineering into communities and schools across the north-east of Scotland. The staff and volunteers at Aberdeen Science Centre have, for decades, especially with their outreach work, captured the imagination of our youngsters and encouraged many who are in the green economy today to study and work in STEM.

As we look to realise the untapped resources of our folk, whether through outreach work, support for start-ups, investment in growing opportunities, the just transition fund or creating green jobs, I am hopeful for a future that will see Aberdeen established as the net zero capital of the world and a Scotland that is fairer, greener and wealthier.

15:38  

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Annabelle Ewing) SNP
The next item of business is a debate on motion S6M-11945, in the name of Neil Gray, on investing in Scotland’s green economy. I invite members who wish to s...
The Cabinet Secretary for Wellbeing Economy, Fair Work and Energy (Neil Gray) SNP
The transition to net zero will transform the global economy. For us, in Scotland, it presents enormous economic opportunities together with benefits for our...
Fergus Ewing (Inverness and Nairn) (SNP) SNP
I agree with all that the cabinet secretary has said. Does he agree that, in order to maximise the efficacy of the opportunities in the green economy, we mus...
Neil Gray SNP
I agree with much of that. The traditional oil and gas energy companies will be putting private investment, which we need, into the renewables sector. I abso...
Douglas Lumsden (North East Scotland) (Con) Con
Will the cabinet secretary give way?
Neil Gray SNP
I am mindful of the time, but I will take one further intervention.
Douglas Lumsden Con
Does the cabinet secretary agree that cutting the just transition fund by 75 per cent is detrimental to reaching net zero?
Neil Gray SNP
The investments and the choices that we have had to make in the budget are a direct consequence of the choices and underinvestment that have come from UK Gov...
Brian Whittle (South Scotland) (Con) Con
Will the cabinet secretary take an intervention?
Neil Gray SNP
I will come back to Mr Whittle later if time allows. That strategic public investment in offshore wind will catalyse private investment in the infrastructur...
Michelle Thomson (Falkirk East) (SNP) SNP
Will the cabinet secretary take an intervention on that point?
Neil Gray SNP
I will come back to the member later if time allows. We need urgent action from the UK Government to buy in to meeting our net zero targets and securing the...
Douglas Lumsden (North East Scotland) (Con) Con
This is an important debate to shine a light on our move towards a more green economy and on how the Scottish Government should be doing more to support the ...
The Minister for Zero Carbon Buildings, Active Travel and Tenants’ Rights (Patrick Harvie) Green
Douglas Lumsden knows—or at least he should do—that Greens, like the whole Scottish Government, are extremely enthusiastic about the potential for green hydr...
Douglas Lumsden Con
I will come back later in my speech to the commitment on hydrogen and to how much the Scottish Government is cutting that. Regarding nuclear, the costs have...
Jim Fairlie (Perthshire South and Kinross-shire) (SNP) SNP
Will Douglas Lumsden take an intervention?
Douglas Lumsden Con
I will make some progress first. Cuts are being made to vital industries that are leading in the areas of green economic growth, and the budget also makes S...
Neil Gray SNP
Will Douglas Lumsden give way?
Douglas Lumsden Con
I will continue a little further. Those cuts will affect our ability to grow the economy and make the transition to a greener future more difficult because,...
Michelle Thomson SNP
Will Douglas Lumsden take an intervention?
Douglas Lumsden Con
I will give way to Michelle Thomson.
Michelle Thomson SNP
I remind Douglas Lumsden that, with regard to capital expenditure, the Scottish Fiscal Commission projects a 20 per cent cut from the UK Government to the Sc...
Douglas Lumsden Con
Let us look at the budget that Michelle Thomson is asking me about. If we look at the Scottish Parliament information centre report, which is available for ...
Neil Gray SNP
Absolute nonsense.
Douglas Lumsden Con
I hear “nonsense” from the cabinet secretary, but today’s issue of The Press and Journal reported that “Big names” are due to join the “North Sea exodus thi...
Sarah Boyack (Lothian) (Lab) Lab
I wanted to be constructive when crafting my amendment, but then I saw a news article this morning that summarised the attacks on Labour that the cabinet sec...
Neil Gray SNP
Sarah Boyack says, quite rightly, that we need clarity and confidence. I was heavily critical of the current UK Government in its flip-flopping and reneging ...
Sarah Boyack Lab
I felt that it might not be appropriate to ask members to vote Labour, so I thought that it would be better to ask them to note our policy, then I would go t...
Neil Gray SNP
Will the member take an intervention?
Sarah Boyack Lab
No, I will not. There has been a 48.5 per cent cut to the climate change budget; a 75 per cent cut to the just transition fund; a nearly 40 per cent cut to ...