Hansard

The Presiding Officer (Alex Fergusson): NPA

Good morning. The first item of business this morning is a debate on motion S3M-2667, in the name of Duncan McNeil, on behalf of the Local Government and Com...

Duncan McNeil (Greenock and Inverclyde) (Lab): Lab

Let me start by thanking the committee members, the clerks, the officers and the Scottish Parliament information centre for all their hard work and patience ...

The Minister for Parliamentary Business (Bruce Crawford): SNP

I wrote to the convener of the committee on 1 August to respond formally to the committee's report. I said that I was grateful for the committee's detailed c...

David Whitton (Strathkelvin and Bearsden) (Lab): Lab

We are here to consider the report into the circumstances surrounding the elections for the Scottish Parliament and Scottish local authorities that the Parli...

David McLetchie (Edinburgh Pentlands) (Con): Con

Much rhetorical hot air has been expended on the debacle of the elections to the Scottish Parliament and Scotland's councils on 3 May last year when, as we k...

Alison McInnes (North East Scotland) (LD): LD

It has been said that, in a democracy, the most important office is that of citizen. Sadly, it is clear from the analysis of last year's electoral process th...

Bruce Crawford: SNP

I have read carefully what was said by the Electoral Commission, which has made a useful contribution to the debate. However, I find it difficult to understa...

Alison McInnes: LD

As I said, the suggestion is worthy of further consideration. Before we come to conclusions, we should explore it further. We need something that refines the...

The Presiding Officer: NPA

We come to speeches in the open debate. Members have a tight 6 minutes.

Bob Doris (Glasgow) (SNP): SNP

In looking at the Gould report and considering its recommendations and their impact on the local government elections, it became apparent to members of the L...

Andy Kerr (East Kilbride) (Lab): Lab

Mr Gould also said to the committee:"We do not need to bring responsibility for all elections to the Scottish Parliament in order to get clarity."—Official R...

Bob Doris: SNP

He said that, but he also said that responsibility should go to the Scottish Parliament because that would be the logical choice.I had hoped that today's deb...

Duncan McNeil: Lab

Does the member think that it was remiss of the committee—albeit that I suggested it—that we did not seek to broaden the remit of our inquiry to look at Scot...

Bob Doris: SNP

The committee convener makes a good point, but if legislative responsibility were to be brought to this chamber that would happen quite naturally.Yesterday, ...

Michael McMahon (Hamilton North and Bellshill) (Lab): Lab

We should welcome the fact that the Local Government and Communities Committee's report on the 2007 election has once more given us the chance to debate an i...

Bob Doris: SNP

Would it not have been advisable and courteous for the Secretary of State for Scotland to await the outcome of today's debate first?

Michael McMahon: Lab

I do not think that that would have mattered, given that he was restating a 10-year-old policy that the Government has no intention of changing. I could have...

John Wilson (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP

Every member who stood for election last year has their own experiences of the May 2007 Scottish Parliament and local government elections; David Whitton des...

James Kelly (Glasgow Rutherglen) (Lab): Lab

I welcome the opportunity to take part in the debate and I commend the committee for its work in producing its comprehensive report.There is no doubt that al...

Nicol Stephen (Aberdeen South) (LD): LD

The May 2007 election debacle was a dark day for democracy in Scotland. More than 85,000 votes were rejected in the constituency ballots and more than 60,000...

Andy Kerr: Lab

For clarity, will the member remind the Parliament of his party's position on the ballot paper and on decoupling the elections?

Nicol Stephen: LD

I will come on to those points. I do not believe that we should tinker with the system; fundamental change is needed.The debacle in May 2007 was a serious fa...

Gavin Brown (Lothians) (Con): Con

Does the member regret the trebling in the failure of voting at council level in 2007, as compared with 2003 and 1999?

Nicol Stephen: LD

I regret any spoiled ballot. However, it is important to emphasise that the dramatic shift was in the failure of voting under the Scottish Parliament voting ...

Jamie Hepburn (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP

Today's debate is welcome, although much of the ground covered in the Local Government and Communities Committee's report is not exactly new. Scotland's expe...

Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab): Lab

The opening speakers all emphasised the importance of putting voters first when designing electoral systems. That is important, and it is the right thing to ...

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Alasdair Morgan): SNP

Order. The member must withdraw that remark.

Des McNulty: Lab

I withdraw that remark. There is an issue around voter fatigue. Not next year, but in future we will end up with voters being asked to vote every year, wheth...

Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): Green

How infuriating that Des McNulty ended that speech with something—fixed terms—that I agree with him on.I thank the Local Government and Communities Committee...

Sandra White (Glasgow) (SNP): SNP

I, too, thank the Local Government and Communities Committee for its report on what I would call the chaotic 2007 elections; I also thank all who gave eviden...