Chamber
Plenary, 01 Oct 2008
01 Oct 2008 · S3 · Plenary
Item of business
Action on Thrombosis
Yes, of course. I will say a bit more about that.
The other risks for DVT include pregnancy, age, underlying cancer, being on the pill or hormone replacement therapy and immobility. However, in most people's minds, as Trish Godman said, DVT is associated with long-distance travel. Inherited abnormalities of blood clotting can also predispose people to DVT. I will return to that later.
One of the ombudsman's main recommendations was that we should develop a standard information leaflet about DVT. NHS Quality Improvement Scotland therefore identified what it considered to be the best existing leaflet. An adapted version of it was issued to all NHS boards in January by the chief medical officer and the chairman of NHS QIS. A letter was sent to the chief executives of the boards, asking them to provide information on how they intended to adopt the standard leaflet, because it was clear from the boards' returns that the matter was a work in progress. NHS QIS is carrying out a follow-up exercise in November, as Margaret Curran said, and it will then provide another report to the chief medical officer. I am happy to keep members informed of progress in that regard.
We also commissioned Lifeblood to develop an information leaflet on DVT, which was mentioned earlier. That has been distributed to every GP practice in Scotland and I am happy to follow up some of the concerns that have been raised about whether that leaflet is being used in all practices. One of the main messages in both leaflets is that there is no definitive test for DVT. If people are in doubt, they are advised to go back to their local DVT clinic or accident and emergency department.
All that work has been undertaken on an interim basis, until SIGN completes its revision of its guideline 62, on the prevention of venous thromboembolism, or VTE. That work is well under way, and I am pleased that SIGN has included Gordon McPherson as a member of the guideline development group.
The motion refers to the possibility of establishing a screening regime. The United Kingdom National Screening Committee advises all four United Kingdom health departments and has considered proposals for the introduction of a population screening programme for thrombophilia. The discussion centres on a genetic abnormality called factor V Leiden, which has been shown to increase susceptibility to DVT and affects about 5 per cent of the population. However, it is important to realise that a positive test for that gene does not mean that a person will go on to develop VTE, and doctors would not offer any preventive treatment in those circumstances.
We have therefore accepted the national screening committee's advice that it would be inappropriate to introduce population screening for VTE. That has nothing to do with cost; it reflects a lack of evidence to justify introducing such a programme. Government action has to be evidence based.
The other risks for DVT include pregnancy, age, underlying cancer, being on the pill or hormone replacement therapy and immobility. However, in most people's minds, as Trish Godman said, DVT is associated with long-distance travel. Inherited abnormalities of blood clotting can also predispose people to DVT. I will return to that later.
One of the ombudsman's main recommendations was that we should develop a standard information leaflet about DVT. NHS Quality Improvement Scotland therefore identified what it considered to be the best existing leaflet. An adapted version of it was issued to all NHS boards in January by the chief medical officer and the chairman of NHS QIS. A letter was sent to the chief executives of the boards, asking them to provide information on how they intended to adopt the standard leaflet, because it was clear from the boards' returns that the matter was a work in progress. NHS QIS is carrying out a follow-up exercise in November, as Margaret Curran said, and it will then provide another report to the chief medical officer. I am happy to keep members informed of progress in that regard.
We also commissioned Lifeblood to develop an information leaflet on DVT, which was mentioned earlier. That has been distributed to every GP practice in Scotland and I am happy to follow up some of the concerns that have been raised about whether that leaflet is being used in all practices. One of the main messages in both leaflets is that there is no definitive test for DVT. If people are in doubt, they are advised to go back to their local DVT clinic or accident and emergency department.
All that work has been undertaken on an interim basis, until SIGN completes its revision of its guideline 62, on the prevention of venous thromboembolism, or VTE. That work is well under way, and I am pleased that SIGN has included Gordon McPherson as a member of the guideline development group.
The motion refers to the possibility of establishing a screening regime. The United Kingdom National Screening Committee advises all four United Kingdom health departments and has considered proposals for the introduction of a population screening programme for thrombophilia. The discussion centres on a genetic abnormality called factor V Leiden, which has been shown to increase susceptibility to DVT and affects about 5 per cent of the population. However, it is important to realise that a positive test for that gene does not mean that a person will go on to develop VTE, and doctors would not offer any preventive treatment in those circumstances.
We have therefore accepted the national screening committee's advice that it would be inappropriate to introduce population screening for VTE. That has nothing to do with cost; it reflects a lack of evidence to justify introducing such a programme. Government action has to be evidence based.
In the same item of business
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Alasdair Morgan):
SNP
The final item of business today is a members' business debate on motion S3M-2482, in the name of Trish Godman, on action on thrombosis. The debate will be c...
Motion debated,
That the Parliament notes with concern that, according to provisional figures from the Scottish Government, the total number of deaths from thrombosis in 200...
Trish Godman (West Renfrewshire) (Lab):
Lab
Katie was 23 years old when she died of deep vein thrombosis. She had tried three times to get treatment, in two hospitals and from her general practitioner....
Ian McKee (Lothians) (SNP):
SNP
I congratulate Trish Godman on initiating this important members' debate, and I join her in extending my condolences to Katie McPherson's family. We need to ...
Trish Godman:
Lab
I hear what the member is saying, but because there are so many questions about DVT—he is asking them himself—we need money so that we can research whether t...
Ian McKee:
SNP
I agree that research should be done, and that not enough has been done into the causes of DVT and its treatment. However, I still hold that it is wrong to e...
Jackson Carlaw (West of Scotland) (Con):
Con
Once again, Trish Godman has brought to members' business an important and substantial issue. Seven months ago, the issue was the human rights of wheelchair ...
Dr Richard Simpson (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Lab):
Lab
I add my congratulations to those of other members on Trish Godman securing this debate and on the way in which she graphically illustrated the tragic early ...
Margaret Curran (Glasgow Baillieston) (Lab):
Lab
I, too, thank Trish Godman for securing tonight's debate. As others have acknowledged, she has made a significant contribution to raising awareness of thromb...
The Minister for Public Health (Shona Robison):
SNP
I add my thanks to Trish Godman for securing a debate on this important but complex issue. Her motion mentions the death of Katie McPherson, and the first th...
Ian McKee:
SNP
Does the minister not agree that cigarette smoking is also a lifestyle choice that leads to an increased risk of DVT?
Shona Robison:
SNP
Yes, of course. I will say a bit more about that.The other risks for DVT include pregnancy, age, underlying cancer, being on the pill or hormone replacement ...
Trish Godman:
Lab
You are saying that screening would be done in some circumstances. It seems to me that Katie McPherson's family should have some support and screening, but t...
Shona Robison:
SNP
I am just about to deal with that issue. We agree that high-risk groups should be tested, and we are clear that the adult relatives of someone with factor V ...
Meeting closed at 17:35.