Committee
Public Petitions Committee, 20 Mar 2007
20 Mar 2007 · S2 · Public Petitions Committee
Item of business
Current Petitions
Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route (PE977)
The petitioners said that the minister had said that—we did not get evidence of that. That is my recollection and, as I said, it can be checked. However, I remember the conversation when the suggestion was made, and I was particularly concerned about the impression, if nothing else, that such a meeting had taken place at which a decision was taken to spend £X of taxpayers' money, without any record of the meeting being taken.The petitioners said that they could provide evidence of the meeting, but they have not done so, so it remains an allegation. It is a concerning one, but it will remain only an allegation unless they contact us with something. As I said, they may be able to produce evidence during the consultation, but that is a matter for them. Anyone would consider it a valid matter for the consultation if a decision was taken behind closed doors and not in a proper manner, but the petitioners would have to show that that took place. I think that we have to leave it at that. Are members agreed that we will close consideration of the petition?Members indicated agreement.
In the same item of business
The Convener:
Lab
Our next petition is PE977, from Paddy Imhoff, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to review its proposals for the controve...
Rosie Kane:
SSP
One of the biggest issues that come to the committee is consultation. I would hope that, when it takes place, the consultation will allow full public partici...
The Convener:
Lab
I remember the conversation. If memory serves—we can check this—we asked the petitioners for evidence of the meeting, but it never materialised. I know that ...
Rosie Kane:
SSP
When the minister was asked, he said:"In common with many other similar meetings it was not minuted but actions were agreed to be taken forward by those pres...
The Convener:
Lab
The petitioners said that the minister had said that—we did not get evidence of that. That is my recollection and, as I said, it can be checked. However, I r...