Meeting of the Parliament 19 March 2026 [Draft]
The problem with the First Minister’s defence is that it ignores the fact that David Hamilton, the Scottish Information Commissioner, has spent his entire career in the criminal justice system and he probably understands these issues better than anybody else in this chamber. His criticism of the Government is that the excuses that it has given are, in his words, “preposterous and unacceptable”. Surely we should be listening to him. The Government should be complying with his reasonable requests. Otherwise, it gives the impression that this is a Government that is addicted to secrecy.