Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129

Current MSPs

415

MSPs ever elected

13

Parties on record

2,354,908

Hansard contributions

1999–2026

Coverage span

Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill

Death is a universal experience, yet it remains a difficult subject. We all approach this debate with a profound desire to live. People who are asking us to support the bill would certainly rather live, but for many of them, that choice has been removed by a terminal diagnosis...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Tackling Child Poverty Delivery Plan

—the SNP will fulfil its promise to Scotland’s children?

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Tackling Child Poverty Delivery Plan

The SNP went into the 2021 election promising universal free school meals for all primary pupils. When in government, the roll-out to all primary 1 to primary 7 children was promised by August 2022, but thousands of children are still waiting, years later. Does the cabinet sec...

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber

First Minister’s Question Time

It feels as though it is a good time to remind the Parliament and Kevin Stewart in particular that the triple threat of climate breakdown, nature loss and pollution is an urgent danger to our people and environment.I thank the First Minister and the Cabinet Secretary for Clima...

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Scottish Parliament (Recall and Removal of Members) Bill: Stage 3

I think that I am finally off mute. I apologise. I could not connect. I would have voted yes.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

That is helpful.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

That has been covered. I am mindful of the time, so could I get just a word or two about the role of NatureScot? We heard from it earlier. Given the new governance structures around this and the four-nations approach, do you see any particular challenges for NatureScot in rela...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

I think that I have been clear in making the point about my intention with the order. From what I have heard, I believe that the Government has failed to look at the issue in a wider sense. The discussions with the justice secretary could have happened earlier in the process. ...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

I hope that I have been clear with the committee and the minister that I will support the order today, because it is the option that is in front of us and to delay action on it would not be the right thing to do. However, for the benefit of the record, I am saying that the Gov...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

I will support the order today, because I recognise the broad aims that the minister has set out. I would have liked to hear more clarity about how the order will work operationally and what criteria will be considered for reviews or appeals. We got there towards the end, but ...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

I think that your official is nodding in agreement with you. That is a clear answer, so I thank you, minister.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Given the serious nature of some of the questions about serious types of crime and antisocial behaviour that have been asked in this meeting, it is regrettable that there has been a lot of mansplaining at the committee today. Two former transport ministers have come to your re...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

I will hand back to the convener, but it is unfortunate that the minister has been extremely vague. We are designing a process that could allow for any number of outcomes. I am asking the minister not to get drawn into individual cases, but whether it is his intention that som...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

As you have designed the instrument, there will be discretion for civil servants to decide that someone who has committed a serious crime and caused harm to others would be able to continue to use the bus with a concessionary travel card.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

This is called scrutiny. In what situation, minister, do you think that it is okay that someone who has seriously harmed a passenger or a bus driver should be allowed to retain their free bus pass or win an appeal to get it back? Please tell me in what circumstance that is okay.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

So, you do have a view. Will you please tell us what it is?

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

I must come back in. I will try to keep my remarks short. I am listening carefully, minister, but every time that you are asked for clarification, you seem to delegate that answer somewhere else. The Parliament will want to know what we are being asked to support, both today a...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

It is not about a personal passion of mine; it is about the perception out there in the country. There are many people, particularly women and girls and marginalised people, who do not feel safe on the bus. What I am getting at with the message of zero tolerance is not about u...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

You are saying “likelihood”. I do not know whether victims and families affected by crimes that have happened on buses feel that the Government fully has their back on this.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Yes, so why are we just talking about antisocial behaviour?

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

It is important to understand the policy intention. If the intention is zero tolerance of crime and—

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Where is the messaging on that? For anyone who is thinking about getting on a bus today or tomorrow and behaving in a way that is beyond the pale, where is the messaging from the Government that that is not acceptable?

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

In order for us to make a judgment on the instrument, we need to fully understand the Government’s intention. What I am not hearing clearly enough—I am giving you an opportunity to put this on the record so that people who are listening understand the Government’s position—is ...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Committees are always curious about ministers’ views. You have had these conversations with young people, and you have said that they are talking about the benefits of the scheme. We are exploring what more could be done in policy terms. Would the sort of extension that I have...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

I will make no such declaration, convener.Minister, I want to pick up on what you said about young people and those in education telling you that the scheme has been a game changer for them and that they really value it. As we know, the scheme is about opening up opportunities...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

It is disappointing that we cannot get clarity on that just now, given that the minister is here with four officials.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

The minister perhaps knows the answer.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

This is an interesting place to start. The £4 million is effectively the cost of running the scheme, so that people can have their concessionary travel cards. Will that cover staffing costs?

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Subordinate Legislation

No—I might have misheard. Is this about the operational costs—the costs of running the scheme?

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

That is encouraging. Thank you.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

I strongly agree that we need a joined-up approach.I am watching the clock; the convener is sitting right there. I just have one more question, convener, about the progress that we need to make on the 30 by 30 target. What progress has NatureScot made in assessing potential ar...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

Yes, it does. Thank you, Pete. Some of the earlier comments from Nick were obviously important for us to hear today, and they are now on record for the next Parliament to pick up the baton. It is clear what the ambition is and what the milestones are, but there are a number of...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

I want to briefly ask something that is supplementary to the deputy convener’s question. Nick, in your opening comments, you talked about the complexity of your organisation’s work but also said that, at times, it can be contentious. It is important that we see in writing some...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

Is that change likely to be part of a broader shift to strategic biodiversity compensation approaches? What are your views?

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

There is that long-term approach. Pete, do you want to comment?

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

That is helpful. I am just trying to understand the role of NatureScot in all of this, because it sounds as though there might be some joint working and a need for good communication, record keeping and data.

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

Do you anticipate that decisions will be made at a ministerial level, whether by UK ministers or Scottish ministers? Will that impact on local planning authorities?

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Committee

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

On the same theme, I want to drill down into the governance arrangements and what you anticipate the role of NatureScot will be.You have said that it is complex and that sites in England and other areas outwith Scotland are not within your jurisdiction. Let us say that an offs...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Ecocide (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

I have great faith in Edward Mountain, even though he might be talking himself down today. As convener, he expertly chairs the committee every Tuesday morning.As I look around at the colleagues who are in the chamber, I know that we can do this. As Douglas Lumsden said—I think...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Ecocide (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

As a socialist, I always have a glass that is half full, and I believe that we can get this done—I will move mountains to get this done.

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Ecocide (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

I thank all colleagues for their contributions to the debate. It is clear that members have put a lot of thought into the points that they wanted to make. I will repeat what I said at the beginning of the debate: I take the committee’s report seriously, I am grateful for its w...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Ecocide (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

I declare an interest as a fellow member of the committee, although I was recused from scrutiny of the bill.I recognise that, like other committees, the committee has a high workload. However, does the member feel reassured by me and the cabinet secretary that work on the amen...

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Ecocide (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

I begin by declaring a financial interest, which is listed in my entry in the register of interests: I have received in-kind support from Stop Ecocide International.Today, we have a historic opportunity to join a global movement and take the first step towards introducing ecoc...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Royal Burgh of Rutherglen (900th Anniversary)

Another fantastic organisation has come to mind: Classrooms for Malawi, which is also based in Rutherglen. Over the years, we have joined forces on the issue of period dignity, and I know that it appreciates the cross-party work in the Parliament that led to the Period Product...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Royal Burgh of Rutherglen (900th Anniversary)

As dance partners.

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Royal Burgh of Rutherglen (900th Anniversary)

Contemporary dance.

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Royal Burgh of Rutherglen (900th Anniversary)

Absolutely, and if I had stuck to my speaking notes, Councillor Robert Brown would have been one of the first people I would have mentioned. When I became a South Lanarkshire councillor in 2012, Robert Brown was the first person to say hello and greet me as a fellow councillor...

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Royal Burgh of Rutherglen (900th Anniversary)

I congratulate Clare Haughey on securing the debate. It has been lovely to hear the contributions so far. Everyone has been so enthusiastic about Rutherglen and the many things that it is famous for. The longer you sit here, the more likely you are to think of something else t...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Living with Phenylketonuria

I am encouraged by the minister’s remarks so far. Does she agree that it is important that we get it right for every single PKU patient, including those who have other health conditions or who may be neurodivergent? One of my constituents has been in touch about her children w...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Living with Phenylketonuria

Will the minister take an intervention?

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Living with Phenylketonuria

I thank Fulton MacGregor for securing the debate, and I thank the colleagues who have taken part. It is important that the voices of the PKU community are heard in the Scottish Parliament. As we have heard, PKU is a rare inherited metabolic condition that demands an extraord...

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Scotland’s firefighters are demanding urgent funding to end the SNP’s decade of dangerous underinvestment, which has cut one in six firefighters since 2013—that is 1,250 posts—and delivered a real-terms reduction of £84 million in the fire and rescue resource budget. Will the ...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Non-fatal Strangulation Laws and Intimate Partner Homicides

I am grateful to the cabinet secretary for taking my intervention before she moves on to the next point. I appreciate the efforts that are being made, and the NHS Inform website is always worth a visit, but I am not sure that a huge number of 16, 17 and 18-year-olds are going ...

Monica Lennon Lab Chamber

Non-fatal Strangulation Laws and Intimate Partner Homicides

Will the cabinet secretary take an intervention?

Monica Lennon (Central Scotland) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Non-fatal Strangulation Laws and Intimate Partner Homicides

I thank Claire Baker for securing this important debate and I thank all colleagues for their contributions—in particular, Tess White and Michelle Thomson, who have worked on a cross-party basis to combat violence against women and girls, a subject that is close to my own heart...

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Draft Climate Change Plan

Is that me out of time?

Monica Lennon Lab Committee

Draft Climate Change Plan

I will take one from Gary. 12:30

← Back to list

Committee

Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee 17 February 2026 [Draft]

17 Feb 2026 · S6 · Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee

Item of business

NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities)

Nick Halfhide Watch on SPTV

I will say little about the economic side of things and then invite Pete Higgins to say more about health and social wellbeing.The week before last, I spoke at the NFU Scotland annual general meeting in Glasgow and made a point that I make wherever I go, which is that the businesses that rely on the natural assets that we seek to protect absolutely understand that their lives are difficult and that they have to be profitable. Our job is to help them to do that so that they can run their businesses profitably, but in a way that is sustainable in the long term and protects the assets on which their businesses are based.We have many examples of where that has worked, which I would be happy to send information to the committee about. I am thinking particularly of a farm that we have been working with in Sutherland, where we have done more than 900 hectares of extensive peatland restoration with the farmer. We have also worked on other changes on the farm, which mean that the farmer is running a more profitable business and has far fewer losses to her flock. There are many examples of where we are working to help people to run their businesses in a way that supports nature. That is just one example in farming. Pete, would you like to say a bit more about the work that we are doing on the social or health side?

In the same item of business

The Convener Con

The second item of business is an evidence session with NatureScot. This is a general check-in with the body about its annual report and corporate plan and s...

Nick Halfhide (NatureScot)

Good morning. Thank you very much for inviting us along. On behalf of my chairman, I offer his apologies. He had very much hoped to be with us today but, unf...

The Convener Con

Thank you, Nick. I will give you an easy question to start with. You have developed a new corporate strategy to take you through to 2030 and you have told us...

Nick Halfhide

We are focusing on five areas of work for the next four years and I will run through those if I may. They are all important and must be done together if we a...

The Convener Con

What are the key challenges to all of that? You have spoken a lot about the environment and ecosystems, but will you talk also about the thing that is someti...

Nick Halfhide

I will say little about the economic side of things and then invite Pete Higgins to say more about health and social wellbeing.The week before last, I spoke ...

Professor Pete Higgins (NatureScot)

I have been an observer of the work that NatureScot has been doing for a considerable time. Over the past 15 or 20 years, I have noticed that the trajectory ...

The Convener Con

We are going to move on to other questions. I know that committee members get bored when I say this but, for the record, because you have mentioned farming a...

Mark Ruskell (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green) Green

Staying on the theme of people, you are Scotland’s national access agency and yet, looking at your corporate plan for 2026 to 2030, I do not see a focus on e...

Nick Halfhide

As we were developing the corporate plan, we included references to access, so it is in there, but you are right that it is not our top priority. Our statuto...

Mark Ruskell Green

Would you accept, though, that you are Scotland’s national access agency? If it is not you, who is it that maintains the strategic overview of access rights,...

Nick Halfhide

We absolutely do that, and that is one of our many different functions. The point that I was perhaps not expressing very well was that we will be doing that,...

Mark Ruskell Green

I thought that you had a corporate priority around the public, public access to nature and that side of things. Education and engagement are really important...

Nick Halfhide

Mark Ruskell Green

Do you see things through that lens?

Nick Halfhide

I will bring in Pete Higgins in a minute, as this is his area of expertise. We absolutely do see that as important, although we are only one of many actors i...

Mark Ruskell Green

So, you are not taking a lead on public access.I turn to the subject of species licensing. It would be good to know exactly where you are with the species li...

Nick Halfhide

We have submitted the species licensing review to ministers. It rests with them at the moment.

Mark Ruskell Green

What are the headlines?

Nick Halfhide

The headlines are that we feel that we should be doing some charging for it. That is one aspect. Our advice was clear: we think that we are following the var...

Mark Ruskell Green

Have you assessed the compliance of species licensing with international law and international conventions? I will give you an example of that. It did not ge...

Nick Halfhide

I do not know the answer to that. Determining whether something is legally compliant is a role for the courts. In our implementation of the law, we will seek...

Mark Ruskell Green

Let us use that example again, then. Would that practice be compliant with the Bern convention?

Nick Halfhide

I do not know. I would have to seek legal advice.

Mark Ruskell Green

Okay. It just seems odd. You are Scotland’s national nature agency as well as Scotland’s national access agency. If you do not assess compliance with interna...

Nick Halfhide

As I have said, we will seek legal advice on those things, just as the Scottish Government will do when it is proposing amendments. I am perhaps missing the ...

Mark Ruskell Green

Let me ask you a straight question. When you were doing the species licensing review, did you review whether species licences that are currently issued by Na...

Nick Halfhide

I will need to check. I assume that we did, but I do not have that detail to mind.

Mark Ruskell Green

Okay.I will move on. A key performance analysis in your annual report concerns the condition of protected areas. We know that woodlands are in serious declin...