Meeting of the Parliament 11 February 2026 [Draft]
I will take an intervention in one minute when I finish this point.
However, section 170 was written not as a work of fiction by Joseph Heller but as a provision by the United Kingdom legislature in 1995. To proceed with his malicious prosecution action, Mr Hirst would have had to have said to Sheriff Paterson, “Please find me guilty and send me to jail, because otherwise I can’t pursue a case for malicious prosecution.” That is plainly absurd. Justice was served and done by his acquittal, but justice was also then denied because of his acquittal.
The right to a free trial is a cornerstone of democracy. It is what protects the citizen against the knock on the door in the middle of the night. It is what protects people from unlawful detention. It is what protects people from the jackboot of totalitarianism. Democracy is based on personal freedom, and where there is no fair trial, freedom does not exist.
I will take the intervention from Mr Kerr.