Meeting of the Parliament 11 June 2025
I acknowledge that we all share a common goal: to manage our marine environment in a way that is responsible, non-polluting and forward looking. The aquaculture sector is an important part of Scotland’s economy, particularly in rural and coastal communities, and I support its development—but only when that is evidence led and environmentally sound.
I have serious reservations about approving this SSI today. Although I understand that the intention behind it is to clarify consenting powers, we cannot ignore its wider implications. This is a significant geographical and regulatory shift that risks getting ahead of the science and the processes that we need to support it, and it raises more questions than answers.
The Rural Affairs and Islands Committee was clear that any relocation of farms to more exposed or offshore locations must be based on a full understanding of environmental, animal welfare and social impacts. Concerns were raised about stronger tidal conditions, colder waters and more extreme weather, all of which could harm fish welfare and increase the risk of escapes. The committee called on the Scottish Government to commission new research and consider the development of dedicated research pens before taking such a step. I believe that the SSI moves ahead of any of the evidence on that. That is why I called for a pause to allow proper research, strategic planning and safeguards to catch up before further expansion proceeds.