Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,355,091
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Clear
Showing 0 of 2,355,091 contributions in session S6, 16 Apr 2026 – 16 May 2026. Latest 30 days: 148. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 14 May 2026.

No contributions match those filters.

← Back to list
Committee

Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee 27 May 2025

27 May 2025 · S6 · Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Item of business
Subordinate Legislation
Deposit and Return Scheme for Scotland (Designation of Scheme Administrator) Order 2025 [Draft]
Martin, Gillian SNP Aberdeenshire East Watch on SPTV

I will hand over to one of my officials, Haydn Thomas, in a minute, as he has been in the weeds of all this. Obviously, we have been having a great deal of discussion with stakeholders on all of this. When it comes to signing up to the principles of these regulations, we have been having a continuing dialogue with producers and, indeed, vendors.

One of the things that the smaller producers were very keen to see was that there was no mandatory take-back system. To my knowledge, there is no other scheme in operation that has such a system; in fact, I remember that, when the regulations for the original DRS were being taken through the Scottish Parliament, microbreweries and so on expressed concerns in that respect, as such a move would have put an overhead cost on them that they were not really able to meet. Because it is now voluntary, I think that we have bottomed out a lot of those concerns.

It is fair to say that the Scottish Grocers Federation, which I met last week to discuss the issue, still has some questions about what the scheme administrator will do about handling fees. We have made it absolutely clear that we want handling fees associated with DRS to be proportionate, and we have discussed the issue with and had that assurance from the UK Government. However, the Scottish Grocers Federation is asking for more assurances from the scheme administrator, which, once in place, will obviously be able to answer quite a lot of the concerns. Of course, its board members will represent a great many of the stakeholders involved.

I will hand over to Haydn Thomas, who will be able to detail the discussions that we have been having with stakeholders over the past year or so.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Convener SNP
Item 3 is consideration of two draft statutory instruments. The Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee raised points in relation to both instruments. In r...
Gillian Martin SNP
Thank you, convener, for the opportunity to discuss these two instruments, both of which were laid in Parliament on 2 May. The Government has been committed ...
The Deputy Convener SNP
Thank you, cabinet secretary. We move to questions, and I will start us off. What substantive changes have been made to the Deposit and Return Scheme for Sco...
Gillian Martin SNP
I am happy to answer that, convener. I will take you through the substantive changes to the current regulations for Scotland. The first thing, crucially, is ...
The Deputy Convener SNP
Those are quite significant changes. What impact will they have on the outcomes that will be achieved compared with what was proposed under the Scottish DRS,...
Gillian Martin SNP
The most substantive change is the removal of glass. We want recycling rates for glass to accelerate and improve. The Scottish Government, as has been well d...
The Deputy Convener SNP
The changes have quite a substantial impact on the overall benefit of the original deposit return scheme, given the exclusion of glass from the new scheme.
Sarah Boyack Lab
Why have we not had a consultation on these changes? How is the Scottish Government engaging and ensuring that the feedback from key sectors and stakeholders...
Gillian Martin SNP
I will hand over to one of my officials, Haydn Thomas, in a minute, as he has been in the weeds of all this. Obviously, we have been having a great deal of d...
Haydn Thomas (Scottish Government)
I am happy to take that one. First of all, we can look at the consultation issue in a few ways. We consulted on the principle and design of Scotland’s DRS i...
Gillian Martin SNP
It might also be helpful to outline what is required of the scheme administrator with regard to consulting and working with affected stakeholders. The draft ...
Sarah Boyack Lab
I welcome those answers, because the issue of small producers and retailers is huge and one that I certainly raised in the first instance. You did not clari...
Gillian Martin SNP
We have been engaging with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities on this, and indeed did so ahead of signing up to the principles in, I think, April l...
Sarah Boyack Lab
Thanks. I will come back later to ask about some of the changes that have been made.
The Deputy Convener SNP
I call Douglas Lumsden.
Douglas Lumsden Con
Cabinet secretary, I want to look at the regulations for return points, the proposals for which are a bit different from what was proposed before. The regula...
Gillian Martin SNP
The scheme administrator would decide that.
Douglas Lumsden Con
Would there be any appeal against that?
Gillian Martin SNP
Yes. That is one of the changes that have been made. In terms of the associated fees or a review of whether there should be an exemption, there would be grou...
Douglas Lumsden Con
But there would still be an appeal process—it just needs to be ironed out. Is that right?
Gillian Martin SNP
Yes. I think that it is one of the ways in which these regulations strengthen things: vendors can ask for a review of decisions that the scheme administrator...
Ailsa Heine (Scottish Government)
I just wanted to clarify that there is a right of review to the scheme administrator for these decisions. It is set out in the designation order.
Douglas Lumsden Con
But the matter will still go to the scheme administrator.
Ailsa Heine
Yes.
Douglas Lumsden Con
Okay. Cabinet secretary, how do the regulations ensure that there is a good distribution of return points, especially in rural areas and on the islands?
Gillian Martin SNP
That is a good point, and it is something that the scheme administrator will take into account. You have rightly pointed to rural areas, where there might be...
Douglas Lumsden Con
So, will people get money back or, as you just mentioned, a voucher?
Gillian Martin SNP
The scheme administrator will bottom all that out. That is for it to decide.
Douglas Lumsden Con
We do not know that yet.
Gillian Martin SNP
No, it will be for the scheme administrator to decide.