Committee
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee 01 February 2024
01 Feb 2024 · S6 · Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Item of business
National Outcomes
Pete Wishart MP (House of Commons Scottish Affairs Committee)
Watch on SPTV
First of all, thank you ever so much for the kind invitation to speak to the committee about what we consider to be one of our most important pieces of work in the past few years. Our report is on how Scotland is promoted internationally and looks specifically at the diplomatic network and infrastructure that are provided by the United Kingdom, and at how well the Scottish Government has engaged with the UK Government to make sure that they are utilised to best effect. It is important that our committees continue to make such relationships and ties, and I look forward to being here a lot more in the future—just as you will be more than welcome to attend any inquiry that we are doing in the House of Commons. I will now address the convener’s question. We went to New York and Washington to discuss the issues with colleagues who were identified and categorised as the Scottish diaspora. We had useful meetings with them about the range of activities that they are engaged in, their views about the arrangements that we currently have in place, how well they are supported, and the types of things that they feel are required in order to be the voices of Scotland in their host countries—in particular, America. The US—especially because it has tartan week and the events around that—probably has the best-designed and best put together organisations when it comes to the Scottish diaspora. That is mainly because they have the task, in relation to tartan week, of making sure that the events are organised and co-ordinated, and that people are asked to come across to enjoy the events that are taking place. However, there is a real challenge. We felt their real frustration that their value is not particularly well appreciated and that they are not sufficiently resourced to do some of their work. I know that the Scottish Government has generously given a number of grant supports over the years since tartan week has been in place, but people have, nonetheless, a sense that they seem to be doing it all on their own. All of the people are, of course, volunteers. None of them is in a paid position, so it takes a bit of time and commitment to be part of the collection of groups and organisations relating to the diaspora. They feel that further information is required in relation to how they might amplify the work that is happening in Scotland and promote our many attributes, and that further resourcing could assist them in that mission. It is a traditional image of Scotland that they present, which I do not think will be any surprise. That is the type of activity that a lot of the Caledonian societies, in particular, engage in. There is sense that they are asking how much they could do to promote some of the more modern images of Scotland. In our inquiry, we were keen to harvest the usefulness of all the traditional images that Scotland has as a means and a gateway to presenting a more contemporary image of Scotland in the work that we are currently undertaking. I do not know whether that answers your question, but that was certainly our experience when we met people there. We are all very grateful for their time and indulgence when we were in Washington and New York.
In the same item of business
The Convener (Clare Adamson)
SNP
Good morning and welcome to the fourth meeting in 2024 of the Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee. We have received apologies from ...
Pete Wishart MP (House of Commons Scottish Affairs Committee)
First of all, thank you ever so much for the kind invitation to speak to the committee about what we consider to be one of our most important pieces of work ...
The Convener
SNP
Did you engage with the GlobalScot network when you were in New York?
Pete Wishart
We came across people who are associated with the network. We did not sit around the table or have any real in-depth conversations about its work, but we cam...
The Convener
SNP
I will open the meeting to questions from the committee.
Alexander Stewart (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con)
Con
Good morning, Mr Wishart. It is good to see you. I will touch on intergovernmental co-operation. It is good to see that there seem to be positive links. Th...
Pete Wishart
That was a good part of what we looked at in our inquiry. Some of the disputes and fallouts between the Foreign Secretary and the cabinet secretary did, in f...
Alexander Stewart
Con
You make some very valid points about the constructive work that is required and is being done, which is appreciated. As a member of this committee, I have c...
Pete Wishart
That has been a regular feature of our conversations with the Secretary of State. We are fortunate that we have three sessions with him in the parliamentary ...
Kate Forbes (Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch) (SNP)
SNP
Good morning. A number of Scottish Government staff have been before the committee, and we have discussed some of the distinct advantages of promoting Scotla...
Pete Wishart
There is no doubt whatsoever that those arrangements, which now exist in eight of our major embassies across the world, bring added value to Scotland. Most p...
Kate Forbes
SNP
We have talked about the value to the economy in trade terms. However, Scotland faces challenging demographic forecasts and it is somewhat frustrating that w...
Pete Wishart
Unfortunately, we did not look at that. A number of aspects of the oral evidence suggested that that is the case; we know that we have fantastic reach and th...
The Convener
SNP
I will bring in Mr Ruskell.
Mark Ruskell (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green)
Green
The “Promoting Scotland Internationally” report is really interesting, and I want to pick up on a couple of points.
The Convener
SNP
Sorry, but Mr Cameron has a supplementary following Ms Forbes’s question. Can I bring him in and then get back to you, Mr Ruskell?
Mark Ruskell
Green
Yes.
The Convener
SNP
Sorry.
Donald Cameron (Highlands and Islands) (Con)
Con
I do not mind if Mark Ruskell goes ahead, in fact.
The Convener
SNP
Right. On you go, Mr Ruskell.
Mark Ruskell
Green
Thanks. I want to pick up on a couple of points in the report. There is a recommendation that the UK Government should work with the Scottish Government to ...
Pete Wishart
I do not think that we recommend directly that the Governments should work together to create some sort of Scottish brand. In our report we concluded that wo...
Mark Ruskell
Green
Regarding the international offices and the joint working between missions and embassies, we find that there are different programmes of work between, say, t...
Pete Wishart
The approach to Scotland across the whole of the UK embassy network could be categorised as mixed. It seems—we were told this consistently by a number of wit...
Donald Cameron
Con
Good morning, Mr Wishart—it is very good to see you. Thank you for your report, too. I want to ask you about the report’s chapter entitled “Beyond the tartan...
Pete Wishart
First, I point out that the introduction to that chapter was not mine. It was probably not the most elegant phrasing of the themes that we were trying to cap...
Donald Cameron
Con
Thank you for that—I did not intend to make that accusation at all. Your report is very clear about that aspect. 10:00 To move on to the linked question ...
Pete Wishart
Is it the diaspora that you are talking about?
Donald Cameron
Con
Yes—the diaspora in particular.
Pete Wishart
Again, we say in the report that it is a much underutilised resource. We reckon that there are 40 million people worldwide who claim some sort of Scottish he...