Committee
Public Petitions Committee 24 March 2021
24 Mar 2021 · S5 · Public Petitions Committee
Item of business
Continued Petitions
A77 (Upgrade) (PE1657)
The next continued petitions are PE1610, on upgrading the A75, by Matt Halliday, and PE1657, on upgrading the A77, by Donald McHarrie on behalf of the A77 Action Group. We welcome Finlay Carson MSP, who is in attendance for the petitions. John Scott MSP will sit in on this part of the meeting as well, and I will call him if he wants to make a contribution at a later stage. PE1610 calls on the Scottish Government to upgrade the A75 Euro route to dual carriageway for its entirety as soon as possible. PE1657 calls on the Scottish Government to dual the A77 from Ayr, at Whitletts roundabout, south to the two ferry ports that are located at Cairnryan, including the point at which the A77 connects with the A75. The committee previously agreed to consider the petitions together. Members may remember that, at the Conveners Group meeting with the First Minister on 13 November 2019, I raised the two petitions with the First Minister. The First Minister advised that she would respond to the committee in writing. Despite repeated requests for that information since December 2019, including in a letter sent to the First Minister in January 2021, no response has been received. Since our last consideration, we have received submissions from the North Channel partnership, Allan Dorans MP, Dual the A75, Councillor Willie Scobie and Catherine Branson, as well as four submissions from the A77 Action Group. They are summarised in the clerk’s note. I found the submissions interesting. My reflection, as ever, is that this is very much a cross-cutting issue—it is about transport, the environment, tourism and the economy. The information that we received from the North Channel partnership about the implications and impact of not having an efficient system of getting into the port was particularly interesting. The committee had planned to visit the affected communities, but we were unable to do that because Covid arrived and we all went virtual. I have always been interested in the issue. It is not just about the roads; it is about the implications of getting the right approach. We have to think about how best we can take forward the petition and whether we have gone as far as we can at this point. I ask Finlay Carson to speak first and then committee members. If John Scott wants to comment, we can hear from him after that.
In the same item of business
The Convener
Lab
The next continued petitions are PE1610, on upgrading the A75, by Matt Halliday, and PE1657, on upgrading the A77, by Donald McHarrie on behalf of the A77 Ac...
Finlay Carson (Galloway and West Dumfries) (Con)
Con
I first want to thank you, convener, for the way in which you have convened the committee over the years and for making it a friendly and welcoming forum for...
The Convener
Lab
Thank you for those comments and for your kind words, Finlay.
Maurice Corry
Con
I thank Finlay Carson for that summary and I am glad that John Scott is going to speak later. I concur with what Finlay Carson has said. We should keep the p...
David Torrance
SNP
I do not have anything to add to that, because my colleagues have covered it all. We will just have to wait and see what the strategic transport projects rev...
Tom Mason
Con
I agree with Finlay Carson and other members. We are short of the information that we asked for and we should not close the petitions until we get that infor...
Gail Ross
SNP
I do not have much to add, and I bow to the knowledge of the local members. I wish that there was an unlimited pot of money that we could use to upgrade all ...
The Convener
Lab
John Scott, do you want to say anything?
John Scott
Con
Yes, please, convener, and thank you for letting me speak. I pay tribute to Finlay Carson and Brian Whittle for the work that they have done on the issue. T...
The Convener
Lab
Thank you. I think that the committee agrees that we want to continue our consideration of the petitions. People will always make an argument for an individu...