Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129

Current MSPs

415

MSPs ever elected

13

Parties on record

2,354,908

Hansard contributions

1999–2026

Coverage span

Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,354,908 contributions. Latest 30 days: 0. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 25 Mar 2026.

Hanzala Malik Lab Chamber

Portfolio Question Time · “Establishing a Stronger Summer Safety Net: Promoting how we can raise retention in post 16 education”

Although summer support is an ambition for students, recent figures released by the Scottish funding council have revealed a £2.4 million shortfall in the term-time bursary funds available for college students. What is the cabinet secretary doing to address that shortfall in s...

4. Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Portfolio Question Time · “Establishing a Stronger Summer Safety Net: Promoting how we can raise retention in post 16 education”

To ask the Scottish Government what its position is on the Students Association of the University of the West of Scotland’s report, “Establishing a Stronger Summer Safety Net: Promoting how we can raise retention in post 16 education”. (S4O-05659)

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Electric Car Rapid Charge Points

I thank Dave Thompson for bringing the debate to the chamber. The expansion of electric vehicle charging networks across the UK in recent years is a welcome contribution to reducing CO2 emissions. The more convenient and cost effective it is for people to have electric or hyb...

Hanzala Malik Lab Chamber

Portfolio Question Time · Aye Write! Festival

Glasgow City Council is very proud to hold the Aye Write! book festival as it has done for the past 11 years. It has been observed that the festival has a low level of participation by people from ethnic minority communities—as participants and contributors. I know of several...

7. Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Portfolio Question Time · Aye Write! Festival

To ask the Scottish Government whether the Cabinet Secretary for Culture, Europe and External Affairs will be attending any events in the Aye Write! festival in Glasgow. (S4O-05632)

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Presidency of the Council of the European Union (Priorities)

I feel reassured. Thank you so much for that.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Presidency of the Council of the European Union (Priorities)

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Committee

Presidency of the Council of the European Union (Priorities)

Good morning and welcome to sunny Scotland. You have been candid about TTIP—how it is progressing, what we can and cannot say and what we can and cannot do. In Scotland in particular, the biggest concern is our national health service. We are very protective of it and we want...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

It is not unreasonable for the petitioner to ask for a review. There has been a lot of misunderstanding of the legislation, and a lot of constituents have said to me that the bill is not having the effect that it was supposed to—or was designed to—have. The fact that people ar...

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

Dr Kohli made a very gallant case for why the decision was made, but I failed to grasp why it was made when all the witnesses agreed that the patients were happy with the service that they received. To me, that overturns any other consideration. Health boards are there to prov...

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Caring in Craigmillar

Good evening, Presiding Officer. I congratulate Kenny MacAskill on securing this debate about Caring in Craigmillar. Kezia Dugdale MSP sends her apologies for not being able to join us and wishes the organisation the very best. She recognises the good work that it does. I join...

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Social Security

It is an honour to speak on social security in Scotland. The new powers that the Scottish Parliament now has present a huge opportunity for us to build a fairer Scotland. A new list of historic decisions will be made for the people of Scotland. However, the complexity of ben...

Hanzala Malik Lab Chamber

Portfolio Question Time · Local Government Finance Settlement

The Scottish Government has added to the Tory cuts and has squeezed local councils further. Glasgow City Council is facing a real-terms cut of £64 million. I have already had several elderly minority ethnic constituents and minority ethnic organisations raise concerns about th...

3. Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Portfolio Question Time · Local Government Finance Settlement

To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of how the reduction in the local government budget settlement could impact on the economy and inequality. (S4O-05536)

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I, too, am very disappointed. There are countries that some would argue do not even have a navy but that still have their own flag, and yet that is not the case in Scotland. Shipping and boating people—particularly those who do it as a hobby—who would be proud to fly their own...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

If you send me all the details, I will do that. Thank you.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

Could I suggest that we add a small paragraph to the letter that we write to the petitioner to say that, if he wishes to engage with the armed forces to find out whether they are willing to engage with the Government to take forward his case, that might be an avenue and a diff...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

As a compromise, could I suggest that we write to the petitioner to say that he might want to engage with the armed forces to see whether—

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I do not see what damage it would do if we took one final opportunity to write to the Government to find out whether it would be prepared to speak to the armed forces to establish whether they would be willing to come on board and engage with it to take forward the proposal. I...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I take on board what very experienced members are saying, but I feel quite strongly about the issue. I suggest that the Government might want to speak to the armed forces to see whether their charities want to engage with it to take the petition forward. I think that there is ...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

At the moment, yes.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

No, convener. I am asking for something totally different. I want the Government to ask the transport providers to provide a service free of charge. I am not asking the Government to make a payment.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

Convener, we tend to underestimate the sacrifices that our armed forces make around the world, and we are demanding more and more.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I am quite happy to die in a ditch.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I am not asking for that at all. I am asking the Government to ask the transport providers to consider it. I do not think that that option has been considered. Many off-peak buses are half empty. There is no harm in asking the companies to consider adopting the policy, and I w...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

With all due respect, I do not think that we have specifically asked the Government to consider the angle that I have raised. I think that it is worth giving it another shot to see whether the Government takes up that opportunity. If it says no, that is fine, but the fact rema...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

We do not know what it has considered.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I wish to support the petition on the ground that it is an important one. We recognise the physical and mental contribution that armed forces personnel make to this country. It is a good petition. However, I am not sure how far we can take it at this point. The Government mig...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

With all respect, we have done a lot. We have gone out of our way with this petition. I recall supporting it on at least two occasions when I thought that it would be the last time that it came before us. The matter seems to be dragging on without our achieving anything other ...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I think that I have made my point, convener.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

Assessing whether the decisions that were made were wise, whether the patients benefited from the service and whether the service represented value for money is possible only if we have figures to substantiate what is being said about the end result of the delivery of the serv...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

A fuller assessment of the failure or success of a change to any service would determine whether the patient was benefiting from the steps that the authority has taken. In the absence of that, it is difficult to assess whether what the board decided was prudent from the point ...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

Dr Kohli, I do not want you to think that I am targeting you, because I am not doing so. Your responses have been clear and I respect the board’s decision in the context of it having to deal with a lot of other issues. I am not looking for Catriona Renfrew to get business from...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

For how many patients there are, how many benefit from the service, how much information is available to GPs and whether the service is being delivered successfully. At the end of the day, this has to be measured. Everything must be measurable. If it is not measurable, we cann...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I am happy to do that in a bid to help. I have already indicated that we do not have Scottish figures.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

Shall I respond to that, convener?

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I accept what you say and I am sure that you will try to ensure that the guidelines are fit for purpose, but I have been pressing you on the matter—I will stop after this, which is my third attempt. I am looking for some sort of timeframe for when you hope to achieve that beca...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

You are stepping around the issue and you are still not giving me a clear guide on how you are focusing on it. How will we assess the success of the advertising campaign? Surely you will be looking for facts and figures on that. What are the timescales in which you are looking...

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Committee

Continued Petitions

I accept what the minister said about the figures in the survey report being UK based, which means that the true picture in Scotland is not clear. Perhaps she will consider doing a report of her own to determine the figures in Scotland. Making doctors aware is important. I am...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

You referred to the armed forces and what happens in that regard. Do you have an opinion from the point of view of European human rights or so-called British human rights about the clandestine flights from Scotland carrying passengers to countries where we know that their huma...

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Committee

I am the deputy convener.

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Abusive Behaviour and Sexual Harm (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

It is with interest that I speak about the Abusive Behaviour and Sexual Harm (Scotland) Bill, which aims to bring Scottish law up to date with changes in society’s view of domestic abuse and with technological changes, to reflect our improved understanding of the issues. Memb...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

That might be helpful.

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Committee

I get the feeling that there is a strong suggestion of a fait accompli. Is that factual? Were others consulted? We need to clarify whether it is a fait accompli in the sense that the Government did not consult anybody or consulted a limited range of people. Perhaps we should e...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

“Brussels Bulletin”

Okay. Thank you.

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

“Brussels Bulletin”

I go back to Jamie McGrigor’s comments on the bulletin. We had an officer who physically spent days in Brussels and was able to dig into a lot of stuff that is perhaps missing now. I recall that, some time back, a conversation took place on revisiting the matter to see whether...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

European Union Reform and Referendum

Thank you. That is a good example. Butter from Ireland is still cheap, by the way. I have another point. At the moment, Norway and Sweden in particular seem to be under the impression that there is not an issue with minority communities entering their part of the world. I wan...

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Committee

European Union Reform and Referendum

I have two points. First, I am interested in the Irish viewpoint on your independence and interests. You seem to have a very strong opinion that you are more independent than you were before you joined the European Union. Can you give me an example of that?

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Immigration Bill

I thank Christian Allard for bringing the matter to the chamber. The UK Government’s Immigration Bill is problematic on many levels. The right to rent scheme requires landlords to check immigration status documents. In addition, the bill gives landlords powers to evict a tenan...

Hanzala Malik Lab Chamber

Portfolio Question Time · Winter Resilience Plans (Transport Services)

The ScotRail alliance announced on Monday that Lamington viaduct will be closed for at least one month longer than was initially expected, due to the discovery of more damage and high water levels hindering repairs. Does the minister agree that winter resilience plans, which h...

3. Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Portfolio Question Time · Winter Resilience Plans (Transport Services)

To ask the Scottish Government how it will revise its winter resilience plans for transport services in light of the disruption to west coast main line services from storm damage. (S4O-05266)

Hanzala Malik Lab Chamber

Public Petitions Process Review

I want to run something past Mr Torrance, because he has more experience than I have. What about the petitioners who have been unsuccessful? Is there room for their petitions to go through either members’ business or perhaps even through parliamentary motions? That might help ...

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Public Petitions Process Review

It is a pleasure to speak on the review of the public petitions process in the Scottish Parliament. The public petitions system and the Public Petitions Committee are an important element in engaging with the people we serve, to try to shape what the Parliament does for them. ...

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber

Higher Education Governance (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

It is an honour to speak in the debate on the Higher Education Governance (Scotland) Bill. There is widespread agreement in the chamber and outside it that Scotland’s universities punch above their weight. They make a major contribution to our economy directly and indirectly, ...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

I mentioned minority views earlier. Minority views are not balanced on numbers; they are balanced on principles and on rights—on human rights and on legacy rights. Therefore having a review is important, as well as giving the Justice Committee an opportunity to review the act....

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

Thank you for your evidence. You have been put in a difficult position once or twice, but that is sometimes part of life for a minority, I suppose. A number of people have mentioned percentages, but they mean nothing to a minority, for whom they can be different from the run o...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

I know that we are talking about figures and costs, but I do not think that those are relevant or what the committee should be worrying about. If we carried out more tests, the costs would reduce anyway. The more important issue is that we need to pick up people who are vulner...

Hanzala Malik Lab Committee

I do not know what the NHS’s position would be on the matter aside from the fact that there is a financial implication, although I tend to agree that it would be a very small price to pay to make such a huge difference to people’s lives and their quality of life.

Hanzala Malik (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Committee

Thank you for your evidence. The suffering that you and your family have gone through has touched my heart. I just want to make sure that I have picked up correctly the point that you are trying to make. You would like the test to be done automatically, simply because staff me...

← Back to list

Committee

European and External Relations Committee 21 January 2016

21 Jan 2016 · S4 · European and External Relations Committee

Item of business

European Union Reform and Referendum

McKelvie, Christina SNP Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse Watch on SPTV

Thank you very much. I invite questions from members.

In the same item of business

The Convener SNP

We move swiftly on to our first agenda item, which is the continuation of our inquiry into European Union reform and the EU referendum. Today we are looking ...

Niels Engelschiøn (Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs)

First of all, thank you very much for inviting us to Edinburgh. We are very pleased to be here. It is the first time for me, and it is a great pleasure to se...

Professor Dr Andreas Auer (Universities of Zurich and Geneva)

I, too, thank the committee very much for inviting me to this beautiful city so that I can inform members about the relationship between Switzerland and the ...

The Convener SNP

Thank you very much indeed. Dáithí, do you want to go next?

Dáithí O’Ceallaigh (Institute of International and European Affairs)

Thank you very much. I join my colleagues in thanking you for inviting me. About a year ago, the Institute of International and European Affairs, which is b...

The Convener SNP

Thank you very much. I invite questions from members.

Jamie McGrigor (Highlands and Islands) (Con) Con

I should say at the outset that I am not a Eurosceptic. I agree with the idea that the UK should stay in the EU. I find it interesting that, in Norway, some...

The Convener SNP

Who is that question for?

Jamie McGrigor Con

It is for the Norwegian witnesses primarily, but it is also for the Swiss representative.

Niels Engelschiøn

It is not entirely correct to say that the political establishment in Norway is pro-EU, because several parties in Parliament are against Norwegian membershi...

Jamie McGrigor Con

What is putting the population off Norway’s becoming a full member of the EU instead of its being, in a way, a member without having the ability to influence...

Niels Engelschiøn

I have mentioned fisheries, agriculture and the sovereignty issue. There is no precise answer—this is just speculation—but the Norwegian economy and the work...

Jamie McGrigor Con

Is there nothing that you can put your finger on and say, “They don’t like that”?

Niels Engelschiøn

No, it is difficult to say. However, given the difficult economic situation that many European countries—particularly those in the eurozone—have faced since ...

Jamie McGrigor Con

Do you think that Norwegians are particularly against joining the euro?

Niels Engelschiøn

It is about the whole thing. Eighty per cent of Norwegians would say no to EU membership because they know what they have and they do not know what membershi...

The Convener SNP

Do you want to put the same question to Professor Auer?

Jamie McGrigor Con

Yes, please. I do not want to hog the discussion, but I would like to hear the Swiss perspective.

Professor Auer

I would never consider the Swiss situation as being a solution for anyone—not even for Switzerland, which is currently in a very difficult position. Let me e...

Jamie McGrigor Con

The Convener SNP

Dáithí O’Ceallaigh, you have done some analysis of the other models. You mentioned both the Swiss and Norwegian models, but you also mentioned the Turkish mo...

Dáithí O’Ceallaigh

Throughout the European Union, there is an increasing general dissatisfaction with Brussels. Within all our populations, there is a feeling that the politica...

Jamie McGrigor Con

Was monetary union a bridge too far?

Dáithí O’Ceallaigh

No. The regulation of the monetary union was there without a bridge, because the individual treasuries and finance ministries were not prepared to give up th...

Willie Coffey (Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley) (SNP) SNP

I will pick up Mr O’Ceallaigh’s point about the four unions. You said that the Norwegian, Swiss and Turkish models would not lend themselves to being a UK so...

Dáithí O’Ceallaigh

I honestly think that, were the UK negotiating on its own, its position would be much weaker than it would be were the UK to remain negotiating on the inside...

Willie Coffey SNP

Partially. I would love to ask Professor Auer for his view. Professor, you have already said that the Swiss relationship is not a particularly good one for ...

Professor Auer

I am sorry, but I did not understand the question.

Willie Coffey SNP

You have said that the arrangement that Switzerland has is not a particularly good one. What relationship do you think that the UK would have with the EU if ...

Professor Auer

I am sorry, but that is a very difficult question for me to answer. I am convinced that, because it is a strong and important country, the UK could negotiate...