Chamber
Meeting of the Parliament 26 February 2014
26 Feb 2014 · S4 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Scotland’s Children
I am grateful for the opportunity to pause to remember why we are doing what we are doing in CFE and to reflect on the positive progress that has been made for our learners, parents and teachers. As I have said, vital as it is for us to listen to teachers during the process—we will listen to them—it is important to reflect on why we are doing the work, which is for the benefit of young people.
I have visited schools regularly in my job for almost three years and can testify to the excellent work that is going on. It is particularly inspiring to hear young people enthusing about their learning. At yesterday’s Education and Culture Committee, I said that we all share the vision of Scotland’s being the best place in the world to go to school. Nothing has changed my view on that, and nothing has changed the recognition that we have a broad consensus in the chamber on the principles of curriculum for excellence—a policy that was begun under the previous Labour-Liberal Democrat coalition and which has been continued by this Government. Putting in place the last pieces of the CFE jigsaw is a prize that all parties have played a part in—or, as the EIS put it more trenchantly yesterday, it is a prize in which all parties are “complicit”.
I cannot emphasise enough that this Government recognises and appreciates teachers’ hard work, commitment and dedication. Much of the basis of curriculum for excellence is the intention to free teachers to use their professional judgment, so everything that we do nationally and locally must support that.
We hear reports that some teachers are anxious as we move to the new qualifications. That is a reflection of our teachers’ deep commitment to doing their absolute best for young people. However, we take very seriously the points that are raised around support and workload issues. I have never tried to shy away from the reality that this level of change in any education system implies a great deal of hard work. To that end, the Scottish Government, Education Scotland and the SQA have worked closely with local authorities, teachers, and parents in order to ensure that effective support is available; indeed, unprecedented levels of support have been provided. Much of that has been long planned and agreed, and all national support has been provided on or before schedule.
We have also always been willing to listen to calls for further support and to put that in place. Last Friday, I announced a package of £5 million further assistance, which the unions and others have welcomed. I take issue with Mr Bibby’s assertion that that is somehow the Government’s first meaningful response to what teachers have told us. Since 2012, we have in total provided more than £10 million of additional funding, three extra in-service days, including a further day for higher in 2014-15, full course materials for each of the 95 national 4 and 5 courses, and we will provide higher materials by April, and subject-specific and other events for thousands of teachers.
I have visited schools regularly in my job for almost three years and can testify to the excellent work that is going on. It is particularly inspiring to hear young people enthusing about their learning. At yesterday’s Education and Culture Committee, I said that we all share the vision of Scotland’s being the best place in the world to go to school. Nothing has changed my view on that, and nothing has changed the recognition that we have a broad consensus in the chamber on the principles of curriculum for excellence—a policy that was begun under the previous Labour-Liberal Democrat coalition and which has been continued by this Government. Putting in place the last pieces of the CFE jigsaw is a prize that all parties have played a part in—or, as the EIS put it more trenchantly yesterday, it is a prize in which all parties are “complicit”.
I cannot emphasise enough that this Government recognises and appreciates teachers’ hard work, commitment and dedication. Much of the basis of curriculum for excellence is the intention to free teachers to use their professional judgment, so everything that we do nationally and locally must support that.
We hear reports that some teachers are anxious as we move to the new qualifications. That is a reflection of our teachers’ deep commitment to doing their absolute best for young people. However, we take very seriously the points that are raised around support and workload issues. I have never tried to shy away from the reality that this level of change in any education system implies a great deal of hard work. To that end, the Scottish Government, Education Scotland and the SQA have worked closely with local authorities, teachers, and parents in order to ensure that effective support is available; indeed, unprecedented levels of support have been provided. Much of that has been long planned and agreed, and all national support has been provided on or before schedule.
We have also always been willing to listen to calls for further support and to put that in place. Last Friday, I announced a package of £5 million further assistance, which the unions and others have welcomed. I take issue with Mr Bibby’s assertion that that is somehow the Government’s first meaningful response to what teachers have told us. Since 2012, we have in total provided more than £10 million of additional funding, three extra in-service days, including a further day for higher in 2014-15, full course materials for each of the 95 national 4 and 5 courses, and we will provide higher materials by April, and subject-specific and other events for thousands of teachers.
In the same item of business
The Deputy Presiding Officer (John Scott)
Con
The next item of business is a debate on motion S4M-09140, in the name of Neil Bibby, on Scotland’s children. I invite members who wish to speak in the debat...
Neil Bibby (West Scotland) (Lab)
Lab
Like all parties in the chamber, the Scottish Labour Party continues to support curriculum for excellence. We want it to work, and that is why Scottish Labou...
The Minister for Learning, Science and Scotland’s Languages (Dr Alasdair Allan)
SNP
Will the member give way?
Neil Bibby
Lab
I am happy to give way to the minister, who I hope will respond to the concerns of those teachers.
Dr Allan
SNP
I am grateful to the member for raising these issues. As I have indicated throughout the process, the Government is keen to hear from teachers. It is importa...
Neil Bibby
Lab
Teachers can complain about the situation because it is completely unacceptable. We need a review for the very reasons that the minister has just outlined. I...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning (Michael Russell)
SNP
The member has just asserted that“so many pupils will not be studying the new highers next year”.Can he benefit the chamber by telling me how many? What prec...
Neil Bibby
Lab
Forgive me, Presiding Officer, but I did not know that I had assumed the position of Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning. If I was the cabi...
Michael Russell
SNP
He does not know.
Neil Bibby
Lab
Mr Russell does not know, and that is concerning. Instead of leadership, we have seen complete complacency—Interruption.
The Deputy Presiding Officer
Con
Can we have a bit of order, please? Interruption. Order!
Neil Bibby
Lab
It has fallen to local authorities such as Fife Council to give the leadership that has been lacking from the cabinet secretary’s actions. Such is its commit...
The Deputy Presiding Officer
Con
I ask the member to move his motion as he draws to a close.
Neil Bibby
Lab
It is vital that lessons are learned, so that we can prevent such a situation from happening again.The situation is unacceptable and the Government has been ...
The Minister for Learning, Science and Scotland’s Languages (Dr Alasdair Allan)
SNP
I am grateful for the opportunity to pause to remember why we are doing what we are doing in CFE and to reflect on the positive progress that has been made f...
Neil Bibby
Lab
Pupils, parents and teachers all need to feel confident before exams take place. Will the minister help to alleviate concerns by ensuring as a matter of urge...
Dr Allan
SNP
I am glad that Neil Bibby has asked that, because it was one of the interesting issues that was raised at yesterday’s meeting of the Education and Culture Co...
Neil Bibby
Lab
Will the minister clarify how many specimen higher papers will be published? He will be aware that concerns have been raised about the lack of resources for ...
Dr Allan
SNP
On the last question, the Government recently made an extra £1 million available to assist local authorities with textbooks, and we remain open to schools’ a...
Neil Bibby
Lab
It was about the number of specimen papers that will be published.
Dr Allan
SNP
In the next few days, a specimen paper will be made available for all the new higher courses.On the subject of highers, it is also worth saying—
The Deputy Presiding Officer
Con
You should draw to a close.
Dr Allan
SNP
The Government is listening—not only to parents and schools, but to teachers. We want to do what we can to ensure that confidence is not undermined at this c...
Liz Smith (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con)
Con
I thank the Labour Party for selecting the topic for debate at what is clearly an extremely important time for the curriculum for excellence and the new qual...
Michael Russell
SNP
Will Liz Smith give way?
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Elaine Smith)
Lab
The member is concluding, cabinet secretary. You must be very brief.
Michael Russell
SNP
The SQA has made it clear that local authorities take the ultimate responsibility, but I thank Liz Smith for raising the issue in the way that she has raised...
The Deputy Presiding Officer
Lab
You must conclude now, Ms Smith.
Liz Smith
Con
I very much appreciate the cabinet secretary’s comments because the issue is certainly worrying parents.I agree with Labour that, whether we are talking abou...
The Deputy Presiding Officer
Lab
I am afraid that you really must finish, Ms Smith.