Chamber
Meeting of the Parliament 23 February 2011
23 Feb 2011 · S3 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Public Petitions Committee
I have been privileged to have been a member of the Public Petitions Committee for almost two and a half years. I record my thanks to its exemplary clerking team, led by the incomparable Fergus Cochrane. During my time as a member of the committee, I have, along with colleagues, witnessed first hand the way in which the public petitions process allows members of the public to become directly involved in the Parliament’s work and the development of policies that seek to better the lives of citizens throughout Scotland.
The committee’s decision to undertake a series of external meetings in 2009-10 has been one of the many ways by which the committee has sought to involve as many people as possible in communities throughout our nation. The committee’s external meetings in places from Alness to Arran have been successful in that they have allowed people to see the committee’s work in their own locality and encouraged many people to become directly involved in that work as petitioners. I hope that the successor committee in the next diet of the Parliament continues that practice, as I believe that it chimes with the Parliament’s founding principles.
In the brief time that has been allotted to me, I want to mention two petitions out of many that exemplify the ability of citizens to make a difference in policy areas that affect the day-to-day lives of people in Scotland. Petition PE1108, by Tina McGeever, on behalf of Mike Gray, called on
“The Scottish Parliament to urge the...Government to consider the provision, on the NHS, of cancer treatment drugs, in particular cetuximals, to ensure equity”
in
“the availability of such treatments.”
The work on that petition is an excellent example of collaborative working with the Scottish Government, and the process has shown the way in which co-operative working involving a petitioner, the committee and the Government can change a situation for the better. Tina McGeever has proved a most effective campaigner. She fought alongside and on behalf of her late husband to ensure that important changes were made in the process for accessing cancer treatment drugs at the local NHS board level in order to reduce the likelihood of postcode prescribing. Sadly, Mike Gray had to grapple with an unacceptable funding situation even as he fought the cancer that would eventually prove fatal to him.
Both Tina and Mike believed that no one who had fallen victim to cancer should also be the victim of an inflexible and inequitable prescription system. Both the committee and the Government believed that their cause was just, and they have continued to work with Tina to reform the system. The changes that have been made to the process for accessing cancer treatment drugs have led to greater consistency and greater clarity, and there is an improved process for exceptional prescribing. That is to the credit of the petitioners and the Parliament’s petitions system.
If I had more time, I would go into detail about a second petition that is a nationwide success story: PE1259, by Ryan McLaughlin, a young constituent of mine from Drumchapel who, because of his mum’s experience as a multiple sclerosis sufferer, urged
“the Scottish Government to produce new guidelines on vitamin D supplementation for children and pregnant women”
and thus lessen the impact of MS on future generations. That collaborative working with the Government has proved positive, and progress has been made. It is another striking example of how the public petitions process continues to make a difference to the lives of people in our country.
The petitions process can help to change lives and make Scotland a better place in which to live. We should be proud of it and we should treasure it. We should see it not as peripheral but as central to the work of this place. I commend the motion to the chamber.
15:25
The committee’s decision to undertake a series of external meetings in 2009-10 has been one of the many ways by which the committee has sought to involve as many people as possible in communities throughout our nation. The committee’s external meetings in places from Alness to Arran have been successful in that they have allowed people to see the committee’s work in their own locality and encouraged many people to become directly involved in that work as petitioners. I hope that the successor committee in the next diet of the Parliament continues that practice, as I believe that it chimes with the Parliament’s founding principles.
In the brief time that has been allotted to me, I want to mention two petitions out of many that exemplify the ability of citizens to make a difference in policy areas that affect the day-to-day lives of people in Scotland. Petition PE1108, by Tina McGeever, on behalf of Mike Gray, called on
“The Scottish Parliament to urge the...Government to consider the provision, on the NHS, of cancer treatment drugs, in particular cetuximals, to ensure equity”
in
“the availability of such treatments.”
The work on that petition is an excellent example of collaborative working with the Scottish Government, and the process has shown the way in which co-operative working involving a petitioner, the committee and the Government can change a situation for the better. Tina McGeever has proved a most effective campaigner. She fought alongside and on behalf of her late husband to ensure that important changes were made in the process for accessing cancer treatment drugs at the local NHS board level in order to reduce the likelihood of postcode prescribing. Sadly, Mike Gray had to grapple with an unacceptable funding situation even as he fought the cancer that would eventually prove fatal to him.
Both Tina and Mike believed that no one who had fallen victim to cancer should also be the victim of an inflexible and inequitable prescription system. Both the committee and the Government believed that their cause was just, and they have continued to work with Tina to reform the system. The changes that have been made to the process for accessing cancer treatment drugs have led to greater consistency and greater clarity, and there is an improved process for exceptional prescribing. That is to the credit of the petitioners and the Parliament’s petitions system.
If I had more time, I would go into detail about a second petition that is a nationwide success story: PE1259, by Ryan McLaughlin, a young constituent of mine from Drumchapel who, because of his mum’s experience as a multiple sclerosis sufferer, urged
“the Scottish Government to produce new guidelines on vitamin D supplementation for children and pregnant women”
and thus lessen the impact of MS on future generations. That collaborative working with the Government has proved positive, and progress has been made. It is another striking example of how the public petitions process continues to make a difference to the lives of people in our country.
The petitions process can help to change lives and make Scotland a better place in which to live. We should be proud of it and we should treasure it. We should see it not as peripheral but as central to the work of this place. I commend the motion to the chamber.
15:25
In the same item of business
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Trish Godman)
Lab
The next item of business is a debate on motion S3M-7968, in the name of Rhona Brankin, on the work of the Public Petitions Committee.14:50
Rhona Brankin (Midlothian) (Lab)
Lab
It is with pleasure that I open this debate on behalf of the committee, which will allow us to highlight some of the important petitions that we have discuss...
The Minister for Parliamentary Business (Bruce Crawford)
SNP
I thank the convener for her opening remarks and for the opportunity to contribute to this afternoon’s debate on the work of the Public Petitions Committee.F...
Paul Martin (Glasgow Springburn) (Lab)
Lab
I commend, as others have, the work of the Public Petitions Committee not only this session but since 1999. A number of members have already illustrated the ...
Nanette Milne (North East Scotland) (Con)
Con
Having been a member of the Public Petitions Committee throughout the third session of Parliament, I can honestly say that it has been the most rewarding and...
Mike Rumbles (West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD)
LD
As others have said, the Scottish Parliament’s public petitions system is a real success story. Nanette Milne identified some of those successes.There has be...
Anne McLaughlin (Glasgow) (SNP)
SNP
Those of us who are on the Public Petitions Committee are rather fortunate to be there. As Nanette Milne said, it is a varied committee, so it is never borin...
Bill Butler (Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab)
Lab
I have been privileged to have been a member of the Public Petitions Committee for almost two and a half years. I record my thanks to its exemplary clerking ...
Bob Doris (Glasgow) (SNP)
SNP
I start by thanking the current convener, the previous one, Frank McAveety, and all members of the committee for providing a positive and constructive forum ...
Cathie Craigie (Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab)
Lab
Like other members, I welcome the opportunity to speak in this debate on the importance and uniqueness of our Parliament’s petitions system.I am proud that o...
John Wilson (Central Scotland) (SNP)
SNP
Members in the chamber—committee members and the many members who have come through the doors on a Tuesday afternoon to support petitions from constituents a...
Robin Harper (Lothians) (Green)
Green
In the first session of Parliament, I was on the Transport and the Environment Committee, in which we were concerned with making legislation. I was on the Au...
Nigel Don (North East Scotland) (SNP)
SNP
Members will perhaps not be surprised that, in the brief time available, I will not consider the substance of what the committee has done—other members have ...
Jim Hume (South of Scotland) (LD)
LD
We have had an interesting debate this afternoon that has highlighted the importance of the Public Petitions Committee. The Scottish Constitutional Conventio...
Nanette Milne
Con
Like other members, I pay tribute to the committee clerks, led by Fergus Cochrane, who have made an immense contribution to the success of the committee. The...
Paul Martin
Lab
Like other members, I note that the committee’s convener, its deputy convener and Robin Harper are stepping down at the next election, so what they said soun...
Bruce Crawford
SNP
I thank the committee members for their contributions. Listening to the different perspectives of members across the chamber has been interesting. I am sure ...
John Farquhar Munro (Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD)
LD
It is with enormous pleasure that I close this debate on behalf of the Public Petitions Committee. Those who follow our work will know that we are very much ...
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Alasdair Morgan)
SNP
You have about a minute left, Mr Munro.
John Farquhar Munro
LD
Thank you.Most petitions are lodged on the back of personal experience, sometimes tragic, as in the case of John Muir. When we hosted the knife crime summit ...