Chamber
Meeting of the Parliament 17 March 2011
17 Mar 2011 · S3 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Scottish Executive Question Time
Forests (Grant Recipients)
General Questions
The European Court of Justice has made a judgment that the European Commission’s regulation on the matter imposed excessive requirements on the publication of data for individual beneficiaries—that is, natural persons—which meant that all member states were in breach by publishing payment details of natural persons. It is not technically feasible for many member states, including the United Kingdom, to separate individual beneficiaries from businesses.
Following Scottish Government legal advice, the decision was taken temporarily to suspend publication of the payments of all 22,000 beneficiaries on the Government website until a solution can be found that allows us to publish payment details of those beneficiaries that are not deemed to be natural persons. The rural payments and inspections directorate of the Scottish Government will still release information in response to individual freedom of information requests where it is possible to identify that a business is not a natural person.
Following Scottish Government legal advice, the decision was taken temporarily to suspend publication of the payments of all 22,000 beneficiaries on the Government website until a solution can be found that allows us to publish payment details of those beneficiaries that are not deemed to be natural persons. The rural payments and inspections directorate of the Scottish Government will still release information in response to individual freedom of information requests where it is possible to identify that a business is not a natural person.
In the same item of business
George Foulkes (Lothians) (Lab)
Lab
1. To ask the Scottish Executive for what reason, in response to freedom of information requests, it has chosen not to reveal the names of recipients of gran...
The Minister for the Environment and Climate Change (Roseanna Cunningham)
SNP
The European Court of Justice has made a judgment that the European Commission’s regulation on the matter imposed excessive requirements on the publication o...
George Foulkes
Lab
With respect, that is a load of rubbish. I keep getting lectures that our freedom of information regime in Scotland is better than it is in the rest of the U...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning (Michael Russell)
SNP
That is a disgrace.
The Presiding Officer (Alex Fergusson)
NPA
Order. A question, please, Lord Foulkes.
George Foulkes
Lab
I would hesitate to suggest such a thing. Let us have the real reason, then. Why are the names being withheld?
Roseanna Cunningham
SNP
I thought that I gave a clear, calm explanation of the current position in respect of the legal advice that the Government received. I do not know whether La...