Committee
Public Petitions Committee 08 March 2011
08 Mar 2011 · S3 · Public Petitions Committee
Item of business
Current Petitions
Silicone Breast Implants (PE1378)
I had some concerns about the information that the committee was given following the most recent meeting on the matter. The committee was informed that there was only one report of an adverse incident. That is obviously a big issue, as such incidents are in fact a lot more common than that. I do not know whether general practitioners are involved in reporting adverse incidents, or how that happens. If a patient goes back to a private clinic to report an adverse incident, for instance, is that clinic bound under health service rules and guidelines to report it? It would be useful for the committee to pursue that point.I understand that there is a three-year time limit for complaints regarding health procedures. Given that symptoms can sometimes take 10 to 15 years to appear, that time limit also requires to be examined.There is a further concern. The Scottish Government did not know what I meant about treatment time and the treatment that is available. I meant that if the condition is not recognised and if the science is not there to prove the symptoms, the treatments that might alleviate the symptoms are not available on the NHS, as they are not viewed as forming a care pathway. More research needs to be done into what treatments are available to treat the symptoms instead of removing the silicone. A number of issues regarding the petition still give concern.We are obviously coming to the end of the parliamentary session, and the committee will be trying to close off petitions or decide what otherwise to do with them. Perhaps the Public Petitions Committee will wish to put this petition in its legacy report, referring it to the next session’s health committee, so that it may carry out an inquiry into the issue. A lot of the work that has been carried out on the subject seems inadequate and there is not enough information available to allow people to help others who are suffering from this type of illness.
In the same item of business
The Convener
Lab
PE1378, by Mairi Johnston, is on silicone breast implants—rupture awareness. I seek committee members’ views on the issue.I welcome Rhoda Grant MSP to the co...
Rhoda Grant (Highlands and Islands) (Lab)
Lab
Yes, thank you, convener. I feel like I am almost a member of the committee, because I pop in so often.
The Convener
Lab
You and Dr Simpson.17:15
Rhoda Grant
Lab
I had some concerns about the information that the committee was given following the most recent meeting on the matter. The committee was informed that there...
The Convener
Lab
I seek the views of the committee.
Cathie Craigie
Lab
In view of the information that Rhoda Grant has brought to the committee this afternoon—noting the response that we received from the Government and the othe...
Nigel Don
SNP
I wonder if it is appropriate, in our legacy paper, to suggest to our successors that they might wish to refer the matter to the health committee in the next...
The Convener
Lab
Is that the view of the committee?Members indicated agreement.
The Convener
Lab
It is agreed that we will include the petition in our legacy paper, on the ground that there seem to be some disputed statistics that the next committee migh...