Committee
Justice Committee 15 March 2011
15 Mar 2011 · S3 · Justice Committee
Item of business
Subordinate Legislation
Criminal Legal Assistance (Duty Solicitors) (Scotland) Regulations 2011 (SSI 2011/163)
The PDSO was established prior to the current Administration coming into office. Since then, I have said that I will expand the PDSO only where there are clear gaps or public contingencies, and preferably with the consent of the profession. I understand that about 80 per cent of cases will be dealt with by the solicitor of choice, which will not be the PDSO. As I say, discussions are on-going with the Scottish Legal Aid Board and the criminal legal aid committee of the Law Society. The duty plan is not due out until July, so at the moment we are talking about subordinate legislation laying out the framework for duty plans. The matter is on-going and I appreciate the concern that has been raised.Some currently enshrined aspects of the solicitor of choice require to be changed. Olly Adair and others have advised me that, at the moment, if an accused says that their agent is to be Robert Brown, for example, the police are duty bound by that and cannot pass the accused on to somebody in another firm. We must introduce some flexibility to enable somebody else to see that individual, although, equally, they will remain the client of their solicitor of choice. It is about providing flexibility. It involves the PDSO, but it also involves changing fundamentally how the Law Society views the matter. With the Cadder judgment resulting in more call-outs to police stations, there is a desire among a lot of lawyers not to have to deal with every one of those call-outs. When they have a social and family life, they want to ensure that they are not called out every night.
In the same item of business
The Convener
Con
We have a bit of time left with the cabinet secretary so, if he does not mind, we will move on to the Criminal Legal Assistance (Duty Solicitors) (Scotland) ...
James Kelly
Lab
I want to allow the cabinet secretary to get his responses on the record. The regulations appear to move us away from appointed solicitors and towards appoin...
Kenny MacAskill
SNP
I appreciate that the matter is on the agenda. The regulations put the duty to make solicitors available in Cadder cases on to the Scottish Legal Aid board. ...
Robert Brown
LD
My question is not so much on the regulations per se as on the operation of the system. Cabinet secretary, you are probably aware that one of the Glasgow Bar...
Kenny MacAskill
SNP
The PDSO was established prior to the current Administration coming into office. Since then, I have said that I will expand the PDSO only where there are cle...
Robert Brown
LD
I am grateful, cabinet secretary, for your emphasis on flexibility, which is important, but I am trying to get to the principle that underlies the changes. C...
Kenny MacAskill
SNP
That is fundamentally a matter for the Scottish Legal Aid Board. There may be consequent increases in costs, but, if you are asking whether there is a grand ...
The Convener
Con
As there are no other questions for the cabinet secretary, I thank him and his colleagues for their time this morning. It has been very helpful.I suspend the...