Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,355,091
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,355,091 contributions. Latest 30 days: 148. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 14 May 2026.
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
12 Apr 2021
Motion of Condolence
Presiding Officer, “Grief is the price we pay for love”. Quoting Colin Murray Parkes, the Queen was speaking on behalf of the nation when she said those words 20 years ago. I cannot imagine what it is like to be married to someone for 73 years. I cannot imagine what it is li...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
24 Mar 2021
Motion of Thanks
Presiding Officer, I put on record my support and that of the Scottish Conservatives for the First Minister’s motion and wish you well as you retire from Holyrood. While I am not a class of ’99er like the Presiding Officer or the First Minister, I have been here for more than...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
24 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Education (Attainment)
Nicola Sturgeon described closing the attainment gap as her “sacred responsibility”, but the Audit Scotland report is clear that the attainment gap that was meant to be closed is just as wide as ever. Who is to blame on that vital issue? Why, it cannot be the party that has be...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
24 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Education (Attainment)
Gallant but not required, Presiding Officer. The First Minister turns a good line on this: “My aim—to put it very bluntly—is to close that attainment gap. Not by a bit, but to close that attainment gap completely.” That was said more than five years ago; as a promise, it ha...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
24 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Education (Attainment)
A bit of contrition from the First Minister might be in order, after the failures of her Government have been exposed, rather than a lack of honour or indeed any contrition. I do not know how the Deputy First Minister can say that he is concerned about the words “catch up”, be...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
24 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Education (Attainment)
I add my condolences to those of the First Minister, for all those who have died, and I thank all those who are helping in the health and vaccine effort as we tackle Covid across the country. Three major publications have been released this week. On the first two of those, qu...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
23 Mar 2021
Motion of No Confidence
Yesterday, we publicly accepted the Hamilton report. For days, others have rejected the committee’s report. We note that Hamilton was crystal clear that the basis of the vote of no confidence, which is whether the First Minister misled the Parliament, is a decision for the Par...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
23 Mar 2021
Motion of No Confidence
They are the members who are sitting behind the First Minister and who are now catcalling from a sedentary position. Interruption.
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
23 Mar 2021
Motion of No Confidence
We are here today because a former First Minister was accused of sexually harassing members of staff in a Government that he was there not only to lead but to serve. We are here because the hastily changed policy that was designed to protect staff from such actions was not fit...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
23 Mar 2021
Covid-19 (Reflections and Next Steps)
Presiding Officer, I was proud to join you and the other party leaders for the day of reflection and the minute’s silence at noon today, as we remembered all those who have lost their life to Covid. However, I was struck beforehand when I read of a man who wanted his son remem...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
18 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Court Proceedings (Legal Documents)
Day by day, week by week, and drip by drip, more evidence comes to light over how the matter has been mishandled by the First Minister and her Government. There have been allegations of legal documents being deliberately concealed, and the lawyers who acted for the Scottish Go...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
18 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Court Proceedings (Legal Documents)
The First Minister says that there is no cover-up, but six weeks after the note that I read out, her own lawyers said that the Government had not complied with what the court told it to do. We know that the First Minister attended a meeting on 13 November 2018 with legal couns...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
18 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Court Proceedings (Legal Documents)
I do not deal in conspiracies. I deal in facts—Interruption. It is a fact that her own lawyers said that it was “unexplained, and frankly inexplicable” that information had been kept from them. Although that is ground that we have tread before, there is something that she ha...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
18 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Court Proceedings (Legal Documents)
I add my condolences to the loved ones of those who have died. This week, we have heard more allegations about the scandal engulfing Nicola Sturgeon’s Government. At her press conference yesterday, the First Minister refused to address their substance, but claimed to refute...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
16 Mar 2021
Covid-19
Today’s update, as briefed, has started to give some clarity on when various sectors can reopen. Frankly, they were calling for and expecting that clarity three weeks ago, when the First Minister said that she would reveal her road map out of the restrictions. Notwithstanding ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
11 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Judicial Review (Costs)
At her committee appearance, the First Minister became very forgetful, and she seems determined to forget that it was her Government that failed the women so badly. According to five people now, including a QC and a civil servant, her Government is responsible for leaking a co...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
11 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Judicial Review (Costs)
The new evidence that was withheld from the committee until after Nicola Sturgeon appeared shows that Roddy Dunlop QC wrote back when the First Minister challenged his advice, and we now know what he told her in response. He wrote that there were two options and said: “I doub...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
11 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Judicial Review (Costs)
I asked the First Minister a very specific question. Whatever that was, it was not an answer. We have since learned that, from the moment that Roddy Dunlop wrote that note, on 17 December, to the time when the Government finally conceded, the bill exceeded £100,000—perhaps eve...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
11 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Judicial Review (Costs)
Last week, we asked about legal advice in the Alex Salmond case and the First Minister refused to answer any questions. We were told that every issue had been covered. The next day, after First Minister’s question time and two days after her evidence session, John Swinney rele...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
10 Mar 2021
Motion of No Confidence
Three years ago, two women came forward with allegations of sexual harassment against the former First Minister of Scotland. They were women who worked beside him and who, like anyone believing themselves harassed or abused by a senior colleague, felt the power imbalance keenl...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
09 Mar 2021
Covid-19
I thank the First Minister for advance sight of her statement, and I echo her condolences to the families of those who have lost their lives. I agree with her about the scenes in Glasgow at the weekend. When so many people have done so much over such a prolonged period of tim...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
04 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Judicial Review (Legal Advice)
Because of the legal advice that had to be dragged from the Government under the threat of a vote of no confidence, we know that, for weeks, the Government was definitively and beyond any doubt ignoring legal advice. The case only became unstatable so late because the Governme...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
04 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Judicial Review (Legal Advice)
The First Minister cannot get away from the fact that the chamber is an organ of the Parliament and the chamber saw the legal advice that the chamber voted for four months ago only this week. We have every right to question a First Minister, who is the head of a Government and...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
04 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Judicial Review (Legal Advice)
The First Minister characterises this as “political games”, but I have never forgotten the women at the heart of the inquiry, who were failed. The First Minister cannot get away from the fact that it was her Government that failed them and that questions still require to be an...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
04 Mar 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Judicial Review (Legal Advice)
I want to ask the First Minister about the legal advice in the Salmond inquiry. Despite the Parliament voting for that to be released four months ago, it was only partially revealed this week. Section 2.30 of the ministerial code makes it clear that ministers must act lawfull...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
02 Mar 2021
Covid-19
I thank the First Minister for advance notice of her statement. I also take this first parliamentary opportunity to welcome Anas Sarwar to his new role as Labour leader. It is the fifth time that I have been able to welcome a new Labour leader in my time here. I truly wish him...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Ministerial Code (First Minister’s Evidence)
People can see the First Minister’s deflection for what it is. Just answer the questions. This sorry affair is not just tarnishing the First Minister’s reputation; it is damaging the institutions that it is her responsibility to uphold. Majority votes by members to produce le...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Ministerial Code (First Minister’s Evidence)
Here is why all the redacted parts of Alex Salmond’s evidence are important. They are exactly the parts that expose the First Minister. Twice on the BBC, she claimed not to know of anything about sexual misconduct claims before April 2018. Three separate times, she told the Pa...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
25 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Ministerial Code (First Minister’s Evidence)
On Monday, the First Minister summoned journalists to her office and challenged Alex Salmond to produce his evidence, only for the Crown to then demand that sections be censored. Alex Salmond’s evidence states this: “The First Minister told Parliament ... that she first lear...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
25 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Ministerial Code (First Minister’s Evidence)
Presiding Officer, “I have nothing to hide on this—nothing whatsoever.”—Official Report, 8 October 2020; c 5. That is what Nicola Sturgeon said about the Alex Salmond crisis that is engulfing her Government and this Parliament. If she has nothing to hide, will the First Mini...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
23 Feb 2021
Covid-19
After a year when all our lives have been put on pause, there is finally a growing sense that it might be over soon. Although it is too early to declare anything like victory, we are starting to win the race between the vaccine roll-out and the spread of the virus, and we are ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
17 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Pandemic Preparedness
I will read directly from Audit Scotland’s report so that there can be no “mischaracterisation”. The First Minister mentioned the guidance that was issued to care homes. Page 21 of the report says that “Flu pandemic guidance published in 2012, designed for health and social c...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
17 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Pandemic Preparedness
The First Minister stands there telling us that there was no issue with PPE last year. Perhaps she wants to tell that to Scotland’s nurses, half of whom told the Royal College of Nursing that they had been forced to reuse single-use protection. Tragically, Scotland’s care hom...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
17 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Pandemic Preparedness
It was no surprise that the First Minister did not want to give a number for how many of the 52 recommendations have been implemented, because the Audit Scotland report highlights a catalogue of missed opportunities on the part of the Scottish Government, including failure to ...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
17 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Pandemic Preparedness
Over the past 10 months and even before that, Governments across the world made mistakes in their planning for and handling of the pandemic, but today’s report by Audit Scotland identifies a lack of preparedness, on the part of the Scottish Government, stretching back more tha...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
16 Feb 2021
Covid-19
I thank the First Minister for advance notice of her statement. We have come to the chamber many times to call for the pace of the vaccine roll-out to pick up; we are delighted that it has happened. Scotland and the United Kingdom now lead the whole of Europe and much of the r...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
10 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Committee on the Scottish Government Handling of Harassment Complaints (Evidence)
The women were failed—they were failed by system that was set up by the First Minister’s Government. While they were being failed, the First Minister knew exactly what she was meeting Alex Salmond about. She chose not to tell her officials in advance and she chose not to keep ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
10 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Committee on the Scottish Government Handling of Harassment Complaints (Evidence)
If we pick our way through that answer, it sounds like the First Minister only informed the permanent secretary after the meeting and the phone call. Let us get the story straight. In everyone else’s mind—including Peter Murrell’s—this was always a Government matter. However, ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
10 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Committee on the Scottish Government Handling of Harassment Complaints (Evidence)
The First Minister said that Peter Murrell told the truth, but the SNP chief executive’s evidence conflicts with the First Minister’s, and only one of them can be right. There is a pattern here: a ruling party of government acting as though it is beyond reproach, a chief exec...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
10 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Committee on the Scottish Government Handling of Harassment Complaints (Evidence)
The Scottish National Party’s chief executive, Peter Murrell, might have committed perjury by changing his story under oath to an inquiry of a committee of this Parliament. However, he has been clear about one thing: Nicola Sturgeon did not discuss the Alex Salmond meetings wi...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
03 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccination Programme
I thank the First Minister for that answer, but it would be good to hear when the six sites are projected to reach 20,000 vaccinations per week, as was promised. Yesterday, I asked the First Minister whether she would accept further help from the armed forces, which has been ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
03 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccination Programme
I thank the First Minister for agreeing to publish daily the data by health board area, which I asked for four weeks ago. That will help us to track exactly where the hold-ups are in the country. Looking at the issue nationally, I think that the whole country will have been d...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
03 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccination Programme
We have also heard from the health secretary that there is evidence that some parts of the country are getting the vaccine faster than others. A month ago, we raised concerns that a postcode lottery was possible, unless local data was published to help to identify and address ...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
03 Feb 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccination Programme
I associate myself and my party with the sentiments that the First Minister expressed regarding the death of Captain Sir Tom Moore. The word “hero” is overused, but he definitely was one, and our thoughts are with his family. The Government has finally accepted that Scotland’...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
02 Feb 2021
Covid-19
A return date for nurseries and early primary and for part-time schooling for older year groups is welcome and it will allow parents across the country to plan. However, it is clear that heavy restrictions will remain in place until enough Covid-19 vaccine is delivered to enou...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
28 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccination Roll-out
We all want the vaccination programme to work as quickly and efficiently as possible so that restrictions can be lifted, but there is genuine concern across Scotland about the pace of the roll-out. We know that more mass vaccination centres, which have already been set up else...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
28 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccination Roll-out
The problem for the First Minister is that those examples are not isolated incidents. She insists that everything is going well, but let as look at what GPs on the ground are telling us. Earlier this week, a family doctor in Glasgow bluntly said: “The bottleneck is not peopl...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
28 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccination Roll-out
Without further action, supplies that get to GPs too slowly will continue to be an issue, but we have not heard an answer to the question whether they will be allowed to order themselves. One north-east GP has told us that they “have the ability to vaccinate about 500 patient...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
28 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccination Roll-out
The GPs are right, however. Vaccinating in care homes and vaccinating in the community are two different systems, and we are able to do both quickly and at the same time, so there is no excuse for falling behind. The Scottish National Party has fallen behind, however much the ...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
20 Jan 2021
Drugs Policy
Drug deaths have been a growing national tragedy for more than a decade, but, in the past few years, they have become Scotland’s worst shame. We are now known as Europe’s drug death capital. Our problem is more acute and heartbreaking than in the rest of the continent and most...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
20 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccine Roll-out
There we have it, Presiding Officer: it is not a slip, it is a refinement. Problems have been building for some time and the Scottish Government continues to stand by and furiously repeat that everything is fine, but GPs and the BMA are sounding the alarm and raising the red f...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
20 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccine Roll-out
But the health minister said the end of January and the First Minister cannot get away from that. The First Minister just said that the figures speak for themselves. She is right, because the numbers here are pretty straightforward. As the Deputy First Minister has accepted, ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
20 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccine Roll-out
Prioritising care homes, as the Scottish Conservatives have always argued that we should, does not explain why GP surgeries, which should have doses of vaccine sitting in their fridges, do not have those. The problem is the insistence from the First Minister that all is on tra...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
20 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Vaccine Roll-out
Yesterday, the First Minister was asked a series of serious questions about why hundreds of thousands of doses of vaccine were not reaching general practitioners quickly enough. The questions asked were based on evidence—the testimony of GPs, the GP chair of the British Medica...
Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
19 Jan 2021
Covid-19
Parents, pupils and teachers all expected today’s news. Indeed, it was almost pushing credibility to tell parents that schools would be closed until 1 February, reopen for a week and then shut again for the half-term break seven days later. All that they asked was for the Gove...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
13 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Covid-19 (Restrictions on Businesses)
The First Minister has responded to me by listing announcements. I welcome those—everyone does—and the Scottish Government is great at making them, but this is about getting money delivered into people’s pockets, and the money is not getting there. The First Minister’s inbox ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
13 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Covid-19 (Restrictions on Businesses)
The Government also has a responsibility not to let viable businesses fall. Here is where we are. Leaked documents show that only seven of 30 business funds have launched. The Federation of Small Businesses Scotland says that funding is trapped in an “administrative logjam”. ...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
13 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Covid-19 (Restrictions on Businesses)
The decision is the latest in which businesses do not feel involved or consulted by the Government. They feel like an afterthought—and no wonder. We called months ago for a Covid business council, and the First Minister said that she would take the proposal forward, but such a...
1. Ruth Davidson (Edinburgh Central) (Con) Con Chamber
13 Jan 2021
First Minister’s Question Time · Covid-19 (Restrictions on Businesses)
I thank the First Minister for advance notice of her statement. The announcement of new restrictions today to both takeaway and click-and-collect services, while understandable, will be a further disappointment to businesses. Business groups have said that the evidence for th...
Ruth Davidson Con Chamber
04 Jan 2021
Covid-19
Today’s announcement raises immediate practical questions, and one of the primary ones concerns the legal requirement for people to work from home where they can. That raises all sorts of issues, including who is a key worker and what constitutes essential labour in a workplac...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament (Hybrid) 12 April 2021

12 Apr 2021 · S5 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Motion of Condolence
Davidson, Ruth Con Edinburgh Central Watch on SPTV

Presiding Officer,

“Grief is the price we pay for love”.

Quoting Colin Murray Parkes, the Queen was speaking on behalf of the nation when she said those words 20 years ago. I cannot imagine what it is like to be married to someone for 73 years. I cannot imagine what it is like to have to get up and face every future day without that person, or what that absence feels like. The recognition of the enormity of such a loss is what has led many people over the past few days to look past the titles and the 41-gun salutes and have a sense of feeling on a human level for Her Majesty.

For most of us in the chamber, and for most people outside it, our picture of His Royal Highness the Duke of Edinburgh is of an elderly man. He was active, vigorous, gruff, witty and still able to stand ramrod straight, but, by the very fact of reaching the age of 99, a person has been of pensionable age for decades. Therefore, for my generation and those coming after, that dashing young naval officer in his 20s, the husband made consort at 30 and the palace moderniser intent on propelling post-war Britain to the front ranks in science, research, industry and technology exists only in Pathé news footage. Here was a man who was born before the discovery of penicillin, the creation of the United Nations and the invention of the television and jet engine but who was a moderniser in life as well as in work. How many men in the 1950s gave up their job for their wife’s career? How many headed the household, making the decisions and smoothing the way? How many walked behind their spouse or accepted that their children would never take their surname? As Barack Obama wrote,

“Prince Philip showed the world what it meant to be a supportive husband to a powerful woman.”

If all that he had done had been to undertake his vow at the coronation to be her

“liege man of life and limb”,

that would have been enough to have recorded his place in history, but it is clear that not only was he a man of huge practical ability—a decorated and talented naval officer, a qualified pilot and a natural sailor and horseman—but he had interests, passions and issues that he wanted to use his position to drive forward, and he focused on engineering, research, youth, the outdoors and conservation. In a life that could so easily have been about one shallow wave, a ribbon cut and a couple of public remarks before moving on to the next engagement, he demonstrated huge commitment to the organisations that he championed.

He served 64 years as the captain general of the Royal Marines; 61 years heading the Duke of Edinburgh’s award scheme, which he created for young people; and 20 years as the president of WWF UK, which he helped to found, with a further 15 years as the international president of WWF. Here, in this city and in my constituency, he served 57 years as the chancellor of the University of Edinburgh. As former principal Timothy O’Shea remembers, although the duke was a huge supporter of the university’s academic excellence and was involved in opening buildings and conferring degrees, he was a particular supporter of the sometimes wild celebrations surrounding the installation of any new rector, giving Prof O’Shea into trouble when one such installation was too sedate for his liking.

His association with the city of Edinburgh stretched to patronage of more than 30 organisations including the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh, the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland, the National Galleries of Scotland and the Royal British Legion. Of course, he was no stranger to Holyrood—both the palace and the Parliament—and he hosted numerous representatives from the latter in the former. At a reception for Pope Benedict’s visit, on seeing Iain Gray sporting a tie in the papal tartan, the duke turned to Tory leader Annabel Goldie to ask whether she had a pair of knickers made out of that. Quite properly, Annabel retorted, “I couldn’t possibly comment, and, even if I did, I couldn’t possibly exhibit them.” It is no wonder that, when asked to sum up his grandparents’ connection, Prince William said simply, “He makes her laugh.”

There has been tension in the coverage of the duke’s death—a sense of grappling with the positions that he held and the narrative of someone who could be irascible and could say the wrong thing—much of it coloured by people’s views on the institution of the monarchy. However, anyone who, in their life, fought in the second world war, set up an organisation to help young people build resilience and change the course of their lives for the better, helped to found the world’s largest conservation charity to save endangered species, gave of his time to help 800 individual charities and was still working well into his 90s deserves to have that life recognised.

As the Queen remarked on her golden wedding anniversary,

“he is someone who doesn’t take easily to compliments”,

so he would probably hate all the fuss. However, to have achieved all of that while undertaking his greatest job and duty of being partner, friend and confidant to the monarch for 73 years, always just two steps behind, supporting the Queen and being her strength and stay for all those years, reflects a life of remarkable public service. As an exiled prince, he came to Scotland as a boy, and his time here shaped the man that he would become. His relationship with Scotland endured and was woven into the service that he gave on behalf of the whole United Kingdom and the Commonwealth.

On behalf of my party, I support the motion of condolence on the life of service of His Royal Highness Prince Philip, the Duke of Edinburgh, and I offer our sincere condolences to his children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren, and to Her Majesty the Queen.

11:14  

In the same item of business