Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,355,091
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,355,091 contributions. Latest 30 days: 148. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 14 May 2026.
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Chamber
24 Mar 2021
Dogs (Protection of Livestock) (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill
Like others before me, I would like to thank everyone who has brought us to this point in the bill, and to congratulate Emma Harper, who has worked extremely hard over four years, as we have heard. Success will arrive in a very short time—the bill will achieve the success that...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Chamber
24 Mar 2021
Greensill Capital UK (Administration)
I thank the cabinet secretary for his statement and for the Scottish Government’s active involvement in the smelter; I know that the cabinet secretary knows it well. The cabinet secretary was involved in the launch of a—Inaudible.—about the expansion plans. He is right to say...
John Finnie Green Committee
17 Mar 2021
Digital Connectivity
Thank you for that clarification, minister.
John Finnie Green Committee
17 Mar 2021
Digital Connectivity
It is good that discussions are on-going and that you have good relations with the UK minister. You said that £4.5 million has been provided to the R100 central lot. As a result of that, has the UK Government technically started the roll-out phase of its gigabit programme in S...
John Finnie Green Committee
17 Mar 2021
Digital Connectivity
Mr Lyle touched on what I planned to ask about. The minister says that discussions continue with the UK Government about the gigabit programme’s implications. The figure of £1.2 billion has been mentioned. Will you say a bit more about those discussions? Does a Barnett formula...
John Finnie Green Committee
17 Mar 2021
Digital Connectivity
That is me for now. I have some other questions to ask later on.
John Finnie Green Committee
17 Mar 2021
Digital Connectivity
I have a brief supplementary. Colleagues will know that I am not remotely technical, and I get a bit dizzy with all the terminology. It is frequently said to me that satellite is expensive, but it is an option. Are you able to say in general terms in how many cases vouchers ha...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Committee
17 Mar 2021
Digital Connectivity
Good morning. You have covered a lot of ground already, minister. The word “irony” was used. Oh, the irony of a succession of three Conservative politicians haranguing you! One of them said that there was little certainty about the programme; however, what there is absolute c...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Chamber
17 Mar 2021
Domestic Abuse (Protection) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
At the outset, I declare my membership of the cross-party group on men’s violence against women and children. That is relevant, because I feel a measure of discomfort with what I am about to say. It is the only time that I can recall that I will take a different point of view ...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Chamber
17 Mar 2021
Domestic Abuse (Protection) (Scotland) Bill
My thanks go to all the people who have brought us to this point. As colleagues have said, they are many in number, and their contributions have all been very helpful in shaping the bill, which the Scottish Green Party will support at decision time tonight. One of the early c...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Chamber
17 Mar 2021
Scotland’s Railway
I warmly welcome the cabinet secretary’s statement. We support the full devolution of rail powers. The cabinet secretary said that he would allow the trade unions to make representations. Rather than the trade unions responding to decisions that have already been taken, will h...
John Finnie Green Committee
16 Mar 2021
Justice Sub-Committee on Policing (Report Back)
Many thanks.
John Finnie Green Committee
16 Mar 2021
Justice Sub-Committee on Policing (Report Back)
I will be brief. As ever, I will be happy to take questions. As you have said, convener, on 1 March the sub-committee took evidence from Deputy Chief Constable Will Kerr and Assistant Chief Constable Patrick Campbell on Brexit and policing. That updated the evidence that we h...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Committee
16 Mar 2021
Subordinate Legislation
It is not my intention to prolong procedures on that, but the letter that we have received from the Howard League, which I often find myself aligning with, raises important issues. Prisons and young offenders institutions are unique establishments, and it is right that there i...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
That completes our questioning. It falls on me to thank Mr Evans and Ms Brown for the detailed and often reassuring evidence that they have given today. I wish them the very best in their posts during these challenging times. I thank them for their work to date and for taking ...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
Thank you for those comments. I want to ask about a very topical issue. We have touched on policing arrangements and mutual aid for COP26. The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill, which is presently generating a lot of interest and disquiet south of the border, will not...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
I add that it is about attitudes as well as action, as it is important that attitudes are shaped.
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
Yes.
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
There is a principle, applied not just in this case, of the stamp of “draft” across documents providing public bodies with wriggle room such that, when it suits, they say that it is the policy and, when it does not suit, they say that it is a draft policy. Just to provide some...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
I wonder, Mr Evans, whether this is more about flagging up a piece of equipment with no regard to the cost and saying, “This is what this piece of equipment can do?” Do you feel that the memorandum of understanding that you have put in place would preclude that? You will be s...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
For those who are not familiar with the correspondence between the sub-committee and Police Scotland, I point out that there were fundamental issues. The sub-committee understood that there were three drones, but it turned out that there were seven, and they were employed more...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
I have a question about cyberkiosks. The roll-out of the technology was a lesson in how not to do things, and there was a disregard for human rights impacts. The sub-committee has been clear that we want Police Scotland to have the necessary equipment to fulfil its function of...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
Thank you. That is very reassuring.
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
Thank you, Mr Evans. I am conscious of the time. Briefly, different policing approaches have been adopted and many of the attendees at COP26 will be from outwith Scotland. The policing model is very positive, if it is about facilitating the human right to peaceful protest. How...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
For the avoidance of doubt, I say that I was not trying to get you to be critical. I support absolutely the autonomy of police officers and I know that the police service varies under the cold analysis of events when on-the-spot decisions have to be made urgently. There has to...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
Mr Evans, the operational independence of the chief constable is readily understood. The public would expect a question to be asked about last week’s unprecedented scenes in George Square and elsewhere in Glasgow. Police Scotland was required to police unauthorised gatherings ...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
I suspect that I could ask you questions about that all morning, but time precludes it. Ms Brown, to follow on from the chair’s comments, has consideration been given to assessing public confidence in the board’s ability to acknowledge and deal with issues of concern? Is ther...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
I have a couple of questions. The first is on scrutiny and engagement again, and I direct it to you, Mr Evans, given that you have been around a bit longer. A recurring theme of the HMICS inspection was the SPA board’s limited ability to recognise issues of significant public ...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
Yes.
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
Ms Brown’s microphone is muted. Can broadcasting staff help, please?
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
Thank you for that comprehensive opening statement. We have quite a number of questions. Before we move to them, I remind members to indicate who their questions are for, and I remind all attendees to wait just a moment for your microphone to be activated before you speak. Th...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Scottish Police Authority
Agenda item 2, our main item of business, is an evidence session with the newly appointed chair of the Scottish Police Authority and the newly confirmed chief executive. I refer members to paper 1, which is a note by the clerk, and paper 2, which is a private paper. I welcome...
The Convener Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Decision on Taking Business in Private
It is agreed that we will take items 3 and 4 in private.
The Convener (John Finnie) Green Committee
15 Mar 2021
Decision on Taking Business in Private
Madainn mhath, a h-uile duine, agus fàilte. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the Justice Sub-Committee on Policing’s fourth meeting in 2021. We have received apologies from Margaret Mitchell and Rona Mackay. Under agenda item 1, the committee is invited to decide whethe...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Chamber
11 Mar 2021
Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill
I thank everyone who has got us to this point: Lord Bracadale; the cabinet secretary and his team; the convener of the Justice Committee, Adam Tomkins, whose leadership throughout has been helpful in steering us through important issues such as freedom of speech and the thresh...
John Finnie Green Committee
10 Mar 2021
Transport (Update)
I appreciate the challenges, and I know that everyone has public safety at the forefront of their deliberations, but are you able to give us any sort of timeframe? Everyone wants a sustainable permanent solution but, in the best-case scenario, when might we get that?
John Finnie Green Committee
10 Mar 2021
Transport (Update)
I have a question about the Rest and Be Thankful. First, though, I put on record my thanks and the thanks of my constituents for the hard work of the workforce at that site. It is a demanding location and the weather is difficult. Cabinet secretary, can you provide an overvie...
John Finnie Green Committee
10 Mar 2021
Transport (Update)
I note that you are rightly trumpeting the approach that has been taken by Scottish Borders Council. Do you see any irony in the resistance that there was to my colleague Mark Ruskell’s very sensible bill, which focused on the position of Scottish Borders Council? Welcome thou...
John Finnie Green Committee
10 Mar 2021
Transport (Update)
Thank you for that. I appreciate that, looking ahead, there is a significant measure of uncertainty. I will stick with buses. In July last year, the Scottish Government allocated £10 million for coronavirus-related pop-up bus infrastructure. What has been installed using thos...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Committee
10 Mar 2021
Transport (Update)
Good morning, cabinet secretary and officials. Do you anticipate that there will be any further rounds of support for bus, tram and subway services? If so, what form will that support take and how much might be available?
John Finnie Green Chamber
10 Mar 2021
Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
As has been said, amendments 37 and 41 relate to the characteristic of transgender identity and would remove protection from crimes that are targeted at cross-dressing people. That is an existing hate crime, for which the protections have been in place for 10 years. Johann Lam...
John Finnie Green Chamber
10 Mar 2021
Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
The existing bill language—“persons of a different sex”—is consistent with other Scottish legislation over the past decade, including the Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Act 2014 and the Civil Partnership (Scotland) Act 2020. As I said at stage 2, I was a member of w...
John Finnie Green Chamber
10 Mar 2021
Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I thank Adam Tomkins. I am a member of the Justice Committee, and Mr Tomkins gave a very accurate résumé of the progress—yes, the progress—that has been made on the bill. I am sure that he will confirm that absolutely no one has been in touch to say that they were not in favou...
John Finnie Green Chamber
10 Mar 2021
Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I will try to be brief. It is important to say that the extension of the existing offence of stirring up racial hatred to cover other characteristics is to be welcomed. It seems to me that it does not matter how mildly Mr Kerr wants to revisit the matter, the idea—particularly...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Chamber
10 Mar 2021
Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
This is an important debate and I do not wish to silence anyone’s voices. There are important issues at stake here and it is right that that is reflected in the debate. Like many men—I know that people would say that that is a privileged position—I have frequently spoken abou...
John Finnie Green Committee
03 Mar 2021
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
I thank the minister and Mr Wilcock. I think that the issue of RET would require a whole session of its own, so that is maybe for another day.
John Finnie Green Committee
03 Mar 2021
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
Indeed. A number of the matters that I wanted to ask about have been covered by the minister. Could you say a bit more about the islands connectivity plan and how it relates to fares policy? You briefly alluded to that, but could you outline for the committee how wide ranging...
John Finnie Green Committee
03 Mar 2021
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
There are lots of questions that I would like to ask, but I appreciate the restraints of time, so I will hand back to you, convener.
John Finnie Green Committee
03 Mar 2021
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
I will make this brief. Will changes in state aid rules as a result of leaving the EU influence the Scottish Government’s approach to vessel procurement? Do you intend to do competitive tendering for such contracts? I hope not. My preferred option would be the direct award of ...
John Finnie Green Committee
03 Mar 2021
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
I would not want to give the impression as a representative of the Highlands and Islands—as the convener is—that we are not delighted to hear about new vessels. What about the notion that this is a very timely distraction for CMAL? We should have a rolling programme of replac...
John Finnie Green Committee
03 Mar 2021
Construction and Procurement of Ferry Vessels
Can you explain why CMAL has launched the small vessel replacement programme before the publication of the islands connectivity plan or the next vessels replacement and deployment plan? Does that not potentially limit the scope of the new plans, pre-empt the results of public ...
John Finnie Green Committee
03 Mar 2021
Agriculture and Fisheries (Update)
Thank you, cabinet secretary.
John Finnie Green Committee
03 Mar 2021
Agriculture and Fisheries (Update)
Early in the parliamentary session, the Scottish Government undertook to bring in new inshore fisheries legislation. Could you please comment on the status of that, specifically with regards to three points? Our sister committee, the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Committee
03 Mar 2021
Agriculture and Fisheries (Update)
Good morning, cabinet secretary and officials. We are no longer under the common fisheries policy. Can you outline, please, what progress has been made on producing a joint fisheries statement, and what is the timeline for when a draft statement might be shared with the four U...
John Finnie Green Committee
02 Mar 2021
Subordinate Legislation
I note the Law Society of Scotland’s comments in relation to the instrument. I have a general comment. Almost every week, we seem to refer to legal aid and the challenges around it. For a number of years, the Law Society has consistently expressed concerns about the diminution...
John Finnie Green Committee
02 Mar 2021
Petitions
I will follow on from the convener’s comments about the separation of powers. Of course, in any liberal democracy, it is absolutely right that we have an independent justiciary. I accept that. However, we are talking about one individual—the Lord President. I do not know that...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Committee
02 Mar 2021
Petitions
Thank you, convener; you have correctly laid out the position on the petition. I have been on the Justice Committee since 2011 and I think that I am the only member who has been on the committee throughout the time that the petition has been referred to the committee. We would...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Chamber
02 Mar 2021
Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Bill
It is appropriate that I join others in thanking those who have brought us to this point. We have heard that every one of the Scottish Law Commission’s substantive recommendations was progressed. The Justice Committee met the commission. I thank it for its work, not just on th...
John Finnie Green Chamber
02 Mar 2021
Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
Mr MacGregor mentioned the Open Rights Group, much of whose work I commend. Indeed, it was via that route that I was lobbied by a constituent who was concerned that “As things stood you were guilty until proven innocent.” I commend the words that they went on to say about Mr...
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green Chamber
02 Mar 2021
Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I wish to speak in support of my colleague Andy Wightman’s comments. At the outset, Mr Wightman said that he had reviewed his position. That is a strength, not a weakness, and it has caused me to review my approach. Mr Wightman has talked about the scrutiny that went on at sta...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament (Hybrid) 24 March 2021

24 Mar 2021 · S5 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Dogs (Protection of Livestock) (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill
Finnie, John Green Highlands and Islands Watch on SPTV

Like others before me, I would like to thank everyone who has brought us to this point in the bill, and to congratulate Emma Harper, who has worked extremely hard over four years, as we have heard. Success will arrive in a very short time—the bill will achieve the success that it deserves.

Within the past fortnight, in Sutherland, just north of me here, there was a serious incident in which five sheep were killed and other beasts traumatised, as would be the owners, the neighbours and the police who are investigating the incident. As a young police officer in the 1980s, I was called to a scene of carnage, in which many sheep were killed and numerous others were injured and required to be humanely destroyed. At the request of the dogs’ owners—good folk, whom I knew—I assisted the good vet, whom I knew, to put down dogs that I knew, so I am acutely aware of the wider implications of an incident like that in a rural community.

As has been said, legislation on its own will not stop livestock worrying, but this enhanced legislation, which includes new protection for my dear friends the camelids—I am a big alpaca fan—is needed and will help. Education is the key, so I welcome the recent Scottish Government social media campaign that the minister alluded to. This is entirely about responsible ownership. Scottish Greens will support the bill at decision time tonight.

I hope that the Presiding Officer will indulge me, as she did Mr Rumbles before me. Tha mi às na Cluainean, baile beag snog air taobh Loch Lòchaidh faisg air a’ Ghearsdan. For that reason, it has been a real honour to represent the Highlands and Islands in the Parliament. I thank the constituents for the privilege to do so.

The day after I was elected in 2011, I arrived at the Parliament building for the very first time with my former colleague Dave Thompson MSP. We were greeted with a smile by the security officer and we immediately met Paul Grice, the chief executive, and had a blether. From that day to this, that is the way that engagement has been with the parliamentary staff. I take this opportunity to thank the present chief executive, David McGill, and each and every one of the parliamentary staff for their courtesy and assistance, and likewise the Scottish Government officials.

I have enjoyed my parliamentary work and particularly helping constituents. To that end, I could not have been better served than by Linda Wilson in my constituency office throughout both sessions. Linda’s courteous and engaging manner has been invaluable in our helping countless constituents, and she can be very proud of the support that she has given the communities of the Highlands and Islands. Thanks, too, to past employees Richard, Pauline and Gary, and to Kevin and more recently Liam, both real wordsmiths, who have been of great help to me.

My long-suffering office manager, Steven Dehn, has been with me since the start in 2011 and has tirelessly kept me on course with all things parliamentary. Steven was pivotal in the progression of the Children (Equal Protection from Assault) (Scotland) Bill into law and we are both very proud of being part of the big team behind the bill. I value my staff and will be for ever in their debt.

I value our Parliament, too. In the relatively short time for which it has been in place, it has brought great progress to our country. I always want to be forward looking and positive. However, I must say that I have been dismayed and indeed angered by those, particularly of late, who have sought to undermine our Parliament and our institutions for their own shabby ends.

Fortunately, session 5 of the Parliament will be remembered not for their wrecking crew’s activities but for progressive legislation such as the Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Act 2018, the Redress for Survivors (Historical Child Abuse in Care) (Scotland) Bill, the Period Products (Free Provision) (Scotland) Act 2021 and many other pieces of legislation including—dare I say it?—my bill that became the Children (Equal Protection from Assault) (Scotland) Act 2019, without which the historic United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Bill would not have been possible.

Soon, I hope, our Parliament will have to raise its horizons even further, our magnificent chamber resonating to new voices and wider issues, with debates about Scotland’s foreign policy, Scotland’s defence policy and all the powers that are in the meantime held elsewhere. I believe that it is a matter of when, rather than if, Scotland takes its place at the United Nations as an independent nation and rejoins our European friends.

Like many, I have spent the past year working entirely from home. I thank my wife of 45 years, Bernadette, for her endless support and forbearance. Perhaps there will be one final debrief for her after today’s events, following which I promise that there will be no more running commentaries on the political business of the day.

In a year like no other, I thank all those who have helped our communities in whatever capacity, and I pay tribute to the Presiding Officer, Ken Macintosh; the Deputy Presiding Officers; the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport, Jeane Freeman; and our First Minister for their leadership.

I thank my dear Green colleagues and our super Green staff. Indeed, I thank colleagues across the chamber, past and present, for their camaraderie. I wish those who are standing down healthy and less-demanding days ahead. New members are coming, and I am delighted that our Parliament will welcome more women. I hope that my successor as lead candidate, the talented Ariane Burgess, my dear friend Gillian Mackay, and indeed my daughter Ruth Maguire, of whom I am very proud, will be among that growing number.

However, no matter how the next Parliament is configured, I wish everyone well in discharging their sworn duty of public service. Presiding Officer, one last time, mòran taing a-h-uile duine agus tioraidh.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Lewis Macdonald) Lab
The next item of business is a stage 3 debate on motion S5M-24270, in the name of Emma Harper, on the Dogs (Protection of Livestock) (Amendment) (Scotland) B...
Emma Harper (South Scotland) (SNP) SNP
I am weel chuffed to open the stage 3 debate on my Dogs (Protection of Livestock) (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill. I am pleased that the bill, which I have worke...
The Minister for Rural Affairs and the Natural Environment (Ben Macpherson) SNP
I am pleased to speak for the Scottish Government in support of this important legislation, which will do much to protect livestock all across Scotland. I t...
Jamie Halcro Johnston (Highlands and Islands) (Con) Con
I draw members’ attention to my entry in the register of members’ interests as a partner in a farming business and a member of NFU Scotland. I am pleased, o...
Colin Smyth (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab
The bill represents a positive step for Scotland’s agriculture sector and our animal welfare standards, so Scottish Labour is happy to support it. I thank Em...
The Deputy Presiding Officer Lab
I call Mike Rumbles, who will be making his final speech in the Parliament. 16:49
Mike Rumbles (North East Scotland) (LD) LD
I, too, congratulate Emma Harper on introducing the bill. It will be good to get it passed before the session ends. It will be at the last minute, but that w...
The Deputy Presiding Officer Lab
Thank you, Mr Rumbles. I call John Finnie, who is also making his final speech in Parliament. 16:52
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green) Green
Like others before me, I would like to thank everyone who has brought us to this point in the bill, and to congratulate Emma Harper, who has worked extremely...
The Deputy Presiding Officer Lab
Mòran taing, Maighstir Finnie. We move to the open debate. I ask for three-minute speeches, please. 16:58
Christine Grahame (Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale) (SNP) SNP
I can see people around the chamber timing me before I even start. Laughter. I wish John Finnie and Mike Rumbles well, and I particularly thank the cabinet s...
The Deputy Presiding Officer Lab
That was a very timely contribution. 17:02
Claudia Beamish (South Scotland) (Lab) Lab
I have been frantically trying to cut my speech from four to three minutes, Presiding Officer; I will do my best. I thank Emma Harper for introducing the Do...
Clare Adamson (Motherwell and Wishaw) (SNP) SNP
On their final day, I offer congratulations to all members who are leaving and to Mike Rumbles and John Finnie in particular for their contributions. I offer...
The Deputy Presiding Officer Lab
John Scott will make a brief contribution before we move to closing speeches. 17:08
John Scott (Ayr) (Con) Con
Thank you for your indulgence, Presiding Officer. I have very little to say except to welcome the passage of the bill and declare an interest—Interruption. I...
Rhoda Grant (Highlands and Islands) (Lab) Lab
Like others, I congratulate Emma Harper on introducing the bill. I pay tribute to Mike Rumbles and John Finnie on their final speeches, and to you, Presiding...
The Deputy Presiding Officer Lab
I call Peter Chapman, who is also making his final speech. 17:13
Peter Chapman (North East Scotland) (Con) Con
Let me remind the chamber for the last time that my entry in the register of interests states that I am a member of a farming partnership. As you say, Presid...
The Deputy Presiding Officer Lab
I will stop you, Mr Chapman. There is a little disorder in the chamber. I encourage you to confine your remarks to the usual finishing remarks in a final spe...
Peter Chapman Con
I hear what you say, Presiding Officer, but—as I said—some of these issues are, to my mind, very important, so I wish to make the points, as I have stated I ...
The Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform (Roseanna Cunningham) SNP
On the last day of the current parliamentary session, it seems fitting that we are considering a member’s bill that has strong cross-party support and addres...
The Deputy Presiding Officer Lab
I call Emma Harper to respond to the debate and to wind up. 17:26
Emma Harper SNP
In closing, I have additional people to thank. More than 600 people responded to my consultation in full, and I appreciate the time and input from members of...
Gail Ross (Caithness, Sutherland and Ross) (SNP) SNP
Will the member take an intervention?
Emma Harper SNP
Of course I will.
Gail Ross SNP
It would be remiss of me not to personally thank Emma Harper for all the hard work that she has put into the bill. It is a fitting end to our parliamentary s...
Emma Harper SNP
I thank Gail Ross for that. It is very fitting that she mentions Sally Crowe and Joyce Campbell. I know that they will be keen to hear that we are—as I hope—...
The Presiding Officer (Ken Macintosh) NPA
We will move to the vote on the bill. Before that, however, I suspend the meeting for a technical break to allow members to access the voting app. 17:31 Mee...
The Presiding Officer NPA
We will go straight to the vote. The question is, that motion S5M-24270, in the name of Emma Harper, on the Dogs (Protection of Livestock) (Amendment) (Scotl...