Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
13
Parties on record
2,355,091
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,355,091 contributions. Latest 30 days: 148. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 14 May 2026.
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
25 Mar 2003
Legacy Paper
I think that we have done some pioneering work, especially the videoconference that we had with the president of the Fisheries Committee of the Galician Parliament. Future committees should take part in such activities more frequently.Understanding other people, rather than un...
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2003
International Situation (Contingency Planning)
The First Minister said that contingency plans have been made to prevent extremists from taking advantage of the situation. Will he give us a list, saying who those extremists are and where he expects them to come from?
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2003
International Situation (Contingency Planning)
Question.
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2003
International Situation (Contingency Planning)
Question.
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2003
International Situation (Contingency Planning)
Not when they have been told that they are not allowed in but then that that decision is reversed.
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2003
International Situation (Contingency Planning)
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. If people who want to hear the First Minister's important statement are still queueing to get into the public gallery, would it not be appropriate to allow time for them to enter, given that, although they were told that they would not b...
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2003
International Situation (Contingency Planning)
I suggest that we do not proceed with the business until the matter has been settled, so that the meeting is a genuine public meeting of the Parliament of Scotland.
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2003
International Situation (Contingency Planning)
Further to that point, Presiding Officer, within the past 10 minutes four people have attempted to get tickets for the gallery—which, as you can see, has a considerable number of empty seats—but were told in the Parliament visitor centre that no seats were available for them b...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2003
International Situation (Contingency Planning)
On a point of order, Presiding Officer, I seek your guidance. Several constituents have reported to me that they are being prevented from entering the Parliament's public gallery this afternoon. What reasons are there for preventing ordinary members of the public who are const...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
18 Mar 2003
New Petitions
If members have been to their desks this morning, they will have seen a copy of the report on the first seminar of the consultation on the establishment of a human rights commission, which I attended and to which Mr Slaven referred in his presentation. When they read that repo...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
13 Mar 2003
International Situation
I firmly believe that a war is not inevitable. I say that because our debate on the issue is part of a debate that is raging around the world, which I believe will lead to a peaceful solution. Last Thursday, between 3,000 and 5,000 people demonstrated outside the Parliament; s...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
13 Mar 2003
International Situation
Does John Young agree that it was a Tory Government that, in 1956, led the world to the point of a third world war on the basis of an illegal war in Suez?
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
05 Mar 2003
Food Supplements<br />(European Directive)
What about derogation?
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
05 Mar 2003
Food Supplements<br />(European Directive)
The minister referred to the element of the directive that informs the Executive that it must make law to ban these substances. In that case, there would surely be a responsibility on the Executive to interrupt internet commerce.
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
05 Mar 2003
Food Supplements<br />(European Directive)
Ordinary.
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
05 Mar 2003
Food Supplements<br />(European Directive)
I whole-heartedly agree with what Margo MacDonald just said—in fact it saves my saying it. Little research has been done in this field, particularly for the purposes of those suffering from autism and Asperger's syndrome. This directive has been framed very clearly. I will not...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
05 Mar 2003
Food Supplements<br />(European Directive)
I declare an interest as convener of the cross-party group on autism and as a member of the European Committee. I will confine my remarks principally to people with autism and their parents and carers.Many developing therapies that are based primarily on vitamin and mineral su...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
05 Mar 2003
Subordinate Legislation
Does the member agree that the time has come for the UK Government to seek the same status for the Scottish fishing industry and Scottish fishing waters as Spain negotiated for the Canary Islands?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Scottish Executive (Scrutiny)
Page 6.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Scottish Executive (Scrutiny)
The provisional agenda for the general affairs and external relations council includes in a session on general affairs the likelihood of the consideration of a paper prepared by the Commission that looks at the recent developments in the convention on the future of Europe. Cou...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Future of Europe
Yes—it has done so very clearly.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Future of Europe
There has been a change of position.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Future of Europe
I want to say something about the thorny issue of access to the European Court of Justice. The final sentence on page 3 of paper EU/03/4/2 refers to the declaration that was signed in Florence on 14 November 2002. It states that"the Executive made clear when signing that it di...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Convener's Report
I attended the first consultation conference on the issue. I think that all committee members would support the proposal for a human rights commission in Scotland based on the Paris principles. Surely the European Committee can express its agreement to something that is based ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Executive Priorities<br />(Greek Presidency)
So it is becoming less complex.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Executive Priorities<br />(Greek Presidency)
Does that mean that it is the voluntary sector that is having difficulties? Given that so much policy is delivered by the voluntary sector, would it not be a cost benefit for the Executive to provide that administrative support for the drawing down of European funding, rather ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Executive Priorities<br />(Greek Presidency)
Does the Executive currently leave the cost-benefit analysis of applying for European funding, given the complexity of the bureaucracy, to the individual organisations or—as the Executive is part of the process—does it influence their decisions on a cost-benefit basis? I find ...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Executive Priorities<br />(Greek Presidency)
It would be quite a step forward if the First Minister of the Scottish Parliament were to be asked by the regions with legislative power to take the chair on a rotational basis. That would bind the Parliament firmly into that structure. It would also mean continuity through el...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Executive Priorities<br />(Greek Presidency)
It is an extremely important question.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Executive Priorities<br />(Greek Presidency)
You mentioned in your opening statement that the First Minister has been asked to become chairperson of REGLEG in 2004. Is that a personal invitation, or are we building an institutional structure in which the First Minister of Scotland will take up that post on a rotational b...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
Executive Priorities<br />(Greek Presidency)
On what you said earlier about building concordats and agreements between Executives, such as your agreement with Tuscany, do you believe that it would be appropriate for the current Executive—or any Executive, given that there will be an election in a couple of months—to unde...
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
04 Mar 2003
“Hospital cleaning”
I appreciate the clarity of the instructions to the health trusts. Given the public concern about HAIs and cleaning standards in hospitals, it is important that the Auditor General has managed to get the NHS trusts to examine the matter correctly. I agree with Sarah Boyack tha...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
18 Feb 2003
“Dealing with offending by young people”
I do not know whether you know the answer to this question—I certainly do not. What is the evaluation process for the groupings? Is there an independent evaluation of their work?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
18 Feb 2003
“Dealing with offending by young people”
What is the impact of the new criminal justice social work groupings of local authorities on work with young offenders?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
18 Feb 2003
“Dealing with offending by young people”
Should national guidelines be used to guarantee the outcomes?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
18 Feb 2003
“Dealing with offending by young people”
What is Mr Connolly's experience of multi-agency working and could such working be improved?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
18 Feb 2003
“Dealing with offending by young people”
Who would be the appropriate individual from health to work with youth justice teams or the ADATs?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
18 Feb 2003
“Dealing with offending by young people”
Does there need to be greater co-ordination—indeed, a specific interface—between youth justice teams and ADATs?
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Committee
18 Feb 2003
“Dealing with offending by young people”
Paragraph 188 of the Auditor General's report says that some youth justice teams do not involve enough senior officials and that some of the important key agencies are not participating. How well are key agencies engaging in multi-agency work, including youth justice teams? Se...
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
12 Feb 2003
Theatre in Scotland
She should not ask rhetorical questions, then.
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
12 Feb 2003
Theatre in Scotland
I will explain if she will give way.
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
12 Feb 2003
Theatre in Scotland
Will the minister give way?
Mr Quinan: SNP Chamber
12 Feb 2003
Theatre in Scotland
Will the minister give way?
Mr Lloyd Quinan (West of Scotland) (SNP): SNP Chamber
12 Feb 2003
Theatre in Scotland
I need to declare an interest. I was a member of Equity for 20 years. I am the ex-associate director of the Scottish Theatre Company, which was one of the attempts to create a national company in this country. I was also associate director of the Traverse Theatre and the artis...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Convener's Report
In some ways it is probably more important that the petitioners meet the clerks in order to maintain continuity.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Convener's Report
There are major issues for people with Alzheimer's, autism, Asperger's syndrome, hyperactivity attention deficit disorder and other disorders for which it has been discovered that the application of the vitamin B complex and vitamins E and D might help. All those supplements a...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Convener's Report
I accept entirely that we have a limited number of meetings left, but Helen Eadie and I attended a meeting in the city chambers. Primarily, the discussion was about what can be done between now and the final implementation date of 2009. If we cannot have a formal meeting, woul...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Convener's Report
May I ask a brief question? I have had a lot of communication from people who are concerned about the directive on food supplements, with which Helen Eadie is dealing. The last communication I received seemed to refer to having written to you, convener, to ask whether it would...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Employment and Corporate Social Responsibility Inquiry
Would you encourage other structures in Scotland—for example, non-governmental organisations such as Fairbridge, which moves people from homelessness and drugs misuse into work—to become involved in feeding into Whitehall policy, as a part of your strategy to develop, at least...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Employment and Corporate Social Responsibility Inquiry
That leads on to my second question. The Commission feels that the local level has a very important role to play in the European employment strategy. Do you feel that the strategy gives you an opportunity to discuss employment policy within Scotland? What role does the local l...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Employment and Corporate Social Responsibility Inquiry
Yes.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Employment and Corporate Social Responsibility Inquiry
To discuss the European employment strategy and effectively feed into it.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Employment and Corporate Social Responsibility Inquiry
Although you have partly answered this question, I just want to ask whether the European employment strategy gives you the opportunity to discuss policy within Scotland with the UK Government. You have outlined some other mechanisms that you use, such as connections between of...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Representation in the European Union
We could deal with recommendation 17 by lodging a motion before Parliament to provide secretariat support for the Parliament's Committee of the Regions members.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Representation in the European Union
I do not think that there is a problem, either; I am thinking about whether we could action the matter.
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Representation in the European Union
In its response, the Executive seems to be saying, "If you want something to be done about this, lay something before Parliament."
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Representation in the European Union
Paragraph 17 is about securing secretariat support for the Scottish Parliament's Committee of the Regions members. The Executive is saying that that would have to be debated in Parliament and carried by Parliament. I suggest that we could start the ball rolling by having a com...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Representation in the European Union
Could we ask the Executive about that?
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Representation in the European Union
In paragraph 15, the Executive's response is:"Recommendations 14 and 15 are a matter for the Parliament."In paragraph 17, the Executive's response is:"This is a matter for the Parliament."Does that mean that, if the committee presented a recommendation to Parliament, the Execu...
Mr Quinan: SNP Committee
11 Feb 2003
Representation in the European Union
It is good news that the network is being established. Could we ask Andy Kerr, who is the minister with responsibility for local government, whether the Executive will support the network? I agree that the matter is for COSLA and the local authorities. They have taken the step...
← Back to list
Committee

European and External Relations Committee, 25 Mar 2003

25 Mar 2003 · S1 · European and External Relations Committee
Item of business
Legacy Paper
I think that we have done some pioneering work, especially the videoconference that we had with the president of the Fisheries Committee of the Galician Parliament. Future committees should take part in such activities more frequently.Understanding other people, rather than understanding the directives of the European Union, is the way to develop Europe. The quickest and most sensible way for us, as a devolved Parliament, to do that is to interconnect directly with the devolved Parliaments of the other states. The fact that I have seen our papers on the desks of senior political and administration figures in other states is the clearest statement of the effect that we have had beyond these walls. We may be unaware of that or believe that we have had a low profile in this country, but I assure members that our profile in other countries has been far from low.The most pressing issue for the next committee—aside from dealing with straightforward directive issues such as the food supplements issue—is, without doubt, the constitutional convention. If I have one regret, it is that the committee did not regard that as a priority at an earlier stage. I genuinely believe that we have failed to stay on top of the discussion. We have not had discussions on the issue at every meeting, as we should have done from the moment that the convention began to sit, to keep a clear view of the shifting sands of constitutional politics in the rest of the European Union.Given some of the exchanges between convention members over the past couple of weeks, it is clear that a change has occurred as a result of the broader political issues in the world and the conflicts that exist within and between European Union states. It is incumbent on the next committee to engage with the development of a constitution for Europe, which will affect all states, irrespective of whether they are member states or have autonomous Governments. The issues will stay with us for ever and will affect the fundamental law of every country and the fundamental rights of every citizen throughout Europe. Without doubt, the convention is the most important issue on the European stage at present.I have enjoyed my time on the committee enormously and, on behalf of those of us who were on the committee under the previous convener, I thank Hugh Henry, who was a damn good convener—as are you, convener. We had interesting times in the first few months, and I put on record my admiration for the way in which Hugh held the line while he was convener.

In the same item of business