Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
14
Parties on record
2,095,827
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,095,827 contributions. Latest 30 days: 3,357. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 10 Jun 2026.
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
27 Mar 2003
Motion of Thanks
I find it a great privilege to be speaking on behalf of the SPCB in this tribute to David Steel. He has been a giant in British politics; indeed, his influence and fame has spread far beyond these shores. He has been used by people overseas in a number of different ways, and t...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
27 Mar 2003
Closing the Opportunity Gap for Older People
A couple of weeks ago, my six-and-a-half-year-old granddaughter asked me, "Have you ever met Queen Victoria?" I sort of looked at her and asked, "Do you not mean the Queen?" She said, "No, Queen Victoria." I must admit that I think that she was put up to it.One important thing...
John Young: Con Chamber
26 Mar 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill
I agree with Alasdair Morgan—indeed, having been a councillor in Glasgow for 35 years and having served on the planning committee, I agree with him even more. I am not being anti-Edinburgh when I say that by any means. However, the restrictions in the 1991 act must be consider...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
26 Mar 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill
We have had an interesting debate this afternoon. It is unusual in this Parliament not to have disagreement—or even violent disagreement—at some point. There is general agreement across the political spectrum that, in future, we must protect Princes Street gardens. However, th...
John Young: Con Chamber
26 Mar 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Final Stage
The National Galleries of Scotland are working on the Playfair project, which involves the restoration of the Royal Scottish Academy building and various other improvements. As has been said before, the connecting underground link between the two galleries plus the other facil...
John Young: Con Chamber
26 Mar 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Final Stage
I take it that you do not want me to start again, Presiding Officer.
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
26 Mar 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Final Stage
At the outset, I thank the convener of the National Galleries of Scotland Bill Committee, Rhona Brankin, for her handling of this matter, as well as the members, the clerks and the legal advisers. The bill could have been highly contentious, because, quite rightly, the citizen...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
20 Mar 2003
Question Time · Red Squirrels (Parapox Virus)
The minister may not be aware that the cross-party animal welfare group was last night discussing the health of hedgehogs, particularly those that are to be transported. Does he think that the convener and members of the cross-party group should put red squirrels on their next...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
13 Mar 2003
Dog Fouling (Scotland) Bill
A problem will arise—which I have experienced when I have had dogs—because of not enough poop scoops being on sale. I am serious about that point. I went to three shops in which I thought I would find poop scoops, but I could not get one. I wonder whether local authorities and...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
13 Mar 2003
Dog Fouling (Scotland) Bill:<br />Stage 3
Peter Peacock mentioned procurators fiscal, which brings to mind an event in Paisley some years ago. A retired police inspector from that area told me that, when he was a constable, various pieces of legislation on litter were introduced. One of the first cases to go to the co...
John Young: Con Chamber
13 Mar 2003
International Situation
I do not think that the outcome that could have resulted from Suez is comparable to the Korean war. Tensions have risen in the European Union, as we know from news reports over the past few weeks. In turn, that could cause a drastic decline in that organisation. As George Reid...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
13 Mar 2003
International Situation
In my lifetime, this country has been involved in 15 wars. I examined the list last night. Of course, one of them was the major war of all time, the second world war. Then we had the Korean war, which could have made a massive international impact if it had gone on. The rest w...
John Young: Con Chamber
27 Feb 2003
Question Time · Census 2001
Could the Deputy First Minister assist me on that question, please?
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
27 Feb 2003
Question Time · Census 2001
Is the Deputy First Minister aware that in "Scotland's Census 2001: The Registrar General's Report to the Scottish Parliament" there are seven different categories of person set out on page 10? One category that does not appear to be included is potential asylum seekers who ha...
John Young: Con Chamber
27 Feb 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
That was probably the longest intervention in the Parliament so far.I am not the only former Glasgow councillor in the chamber—indeed, Trish Godman was a prominent Glasgow councillor. One cannot equate Glasgow to places such as Edinburgh, as Glasgow city centre's geography is ...
John Young: Con Chamber
27 Feb 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Margo MacDonald may well have spoken to a number of the women. Does she find that those women themselves are happy about that arrangement? Are they concerned about being uplifted by a client and taken elsewhere?
John Young: Con Chamber
27 Feb 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I do not know how it works, but perhaps Margo MacDonald will be able to answer my question.
John Young: Con Chamber
27 Feb 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I thank Margo MacDonald for that information. There is a point that I feel I should make, which may be relevant in some ways but may not be relevant in others. Some years ago, Glasgow City Council had a visit from an Australian woman who was an international expert in the fiel...
John Young: Con Chamber
27 Feb 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I accept a large part of what Tricia Marwick has said, but I still think that responses from the Crown Office and others show that there are legal grey areas. The point was made that prostitution is the oldest profession in the world, and that is probably true. Most of us have...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
27 Feb 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
A very full consultation took place on this matter. Senior police officers were consulted, as were major local authorities, health boards, social work groups, drug addiction teams, and the Deputy Minister for Finance and Local Government. Various responses came in; of particul...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
27 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
How does one follow that? We have heard some brilliant speeches in the past half an hour. I thank everyone who spoke, including the committee's convener who, as usual, gave a lucid presentation.The subsequent speeches were also interesting. We heard Mike Watson telling us wher...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
13 Feb 2003
Question Time · Public Transport (Access for Disabled People)
There are plans to replace existing rolling stock over the next few years. Has there been any consultation on the iniquitous design of many railway carriages, which makes it difficult for normal pedestrians to get on and off the train, irrespective of people who are disabled? ...
John Young: Con Committee
11 Feb 2003
Subordinate Legislation
I presume that the issue is conducted under what we would term English law. I may be wrong in saying this, but I understand that, under Scots law, a child is someone under the age of 16. That was not a question, it was more of an observation.
John Young: Con Committee
11 Feb 2003
Subordinate Legislation
With respect, convener, it must have some bearing. There will be an average time for X number of asylum seekers to go through the process. If a whole lot of them are heading up this way, and if the process might take three days or might take three months, the average time will...
John Young: Con Committee
11 Feb 2003
Subordinate Legislation
I appreciate that the convener said that my question was on a reserved matter. I do not challenge that, but I am sure that although it is a reserved matter, an average indication must be given to the authorities up here and in other parts of the UK. For example, somebody might...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Committee
11 Feb 2003
Subordinate Legislation
Section 1 of annexe A to the special grant report states:"‘asylum seeker' means a person aged 18 years or over whose claim for asylum has not yet been finally determined or abandoned".Do we have any idea what the average process time is in such a situation? I appreciate that i...
John Young: Con Chamber
06 Feb 2003
Proportional Representation (Local Government Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I always thought that Stewart Stevenson was a man of principle. This morning he has confirmed that—in the eyes of some, at least.Only the Tories stick to their beliefs, at some sacrifice. It would be in our interests to support PR, but we have principles. Keith Harding said th...
John Young: Con Chamber
06 Feb 2003
Proportional Representation (Local Government Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I will take an intervention from the member later.In the seconds before the division to which Tricia Marwick referred, I realised that the vote would be tied at 3-3. I wanted to see whether Trish Godman, the Labour convener of the committee, would use her casting vote to suppo...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
06 Feb 2003
Proportional Representation (Local Government Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
An old Glasgow councillor used to say, "Let's cut the crap." That is what should be said this morning—if the word "crap" is acceptable. If not, I will say, "Let's go through the mist and clear it away."Why is the SNP following this line today? SNP members are saying, "If we ca...
John Young: Con Chamber
05 Feb 2003
Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc (Scotland) Bill:<br />Stage 3
The point that I am making is that applicants do not have to declare that aspect.
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
05 Feb 2003
Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc (Scotland) Bill:<br />Stage 3
The member has talked about the political imbalance in some public bodies. In view of that, does he think that all applicants for public posts should publicly declare the name of any political party of which they have been a member?
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
I appreciate the sentiments that you have expressed, for which there is a lot of support. I was curious about the phrase that you used when you said that you would "welcome any action". I do not know the extent of our powers. Perhaps the convener could clarify that.
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
In your joint statement, you say:"We are concerned that a public realm development such as the Playfair project - carried out in the public interest, for and by a public body - may be cited as a precedent for the introduction of private commercial development within the garden...
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
Let me take another tack. Do you think that the bill sets a precedent for any future developments in Princes Street gardens, or do you think that this is a one-off situation?
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
Perhaps I should rephrase that. Can you tell us one or two outstanding objections to it? I am thinking not so much of technical objections as of outstanding concerns.
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
I wonder whether you could give a brief outline of the concerns and objections that were raised at the planning stage of the proposed development.
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
Let me put it another way and convey my personal opinion. If you do not want to answer my question, I will understand. Do you feel that—for want of a better phrase—an iron curtain should be brought down and no further development should take place in Princes Street gardens, as...
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
Do you think the bill sets a precedent for building in Princes Street gardens?
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
There would be the danger of muggers in an underground passage.
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
Thank you very much.
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
I must admit that I am not fully conversant with the provisions of the Edinburgh Improvement Act 1816, which is the earliest legislation in this respect. Does that act make any comment on the matter? I know that we are talking about a long time ago, but the sentiments then mig...
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
I agree with much of what you say. However, is there a real danger that some private developer might try to gain access in future?
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
What impact will the development have on the character and amenity of east Princes Street gardens and the surrounding area?
John Young: Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
In the policy memorandum to the bill, you indicate that there are no alternatives to the bill. How did you reach that conclusion?
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Committee
03 Feb 2003
National Galleries of Scotland Bill: Preliminary Stage
If the bill does not become law, do you have any contingency plans?
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
29 Jan 2003
Firefighters' Dispute
Will the Deputy First Minister state whether the possibility of strike action's being made illegal has entered the discussions? If war with Iraq goes ahead and large numbers of service personnel from this country go to the middle east, there might not be sufficient reserve for...
John Young: Con Committee
21 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I know that it is always difficult to forecast the future, but do you perceive any dangers of that sort coming into play?
John Young: Con Committee
21 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
You know what happened in Melbourne and Amsterdam, especially the former. The Russian mafia seems to have become involved in transporting people.
John Young: Con Committee
21 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Do you think that the life expectancy of tolerance zones would be quite short? Do you think that tolerance zones would eventually fail and that other measures would have to be introduced?
John Young: Con Committee
21 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I echo Iain Smith's words of appreciation for the work that you and your helpers have done. You have taken on a considerable load.Do you perceive Glasgow and the west of Scotland as taking a higher moral stance on this issue? Do some people in Glasgow feel that they are more r...
John Young: Con Committee
21 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
It is obvious that the tolerance zones in the three major cities—if they are tolerance zones—operate differently. Should there be an attempt to tighten up and have more uniform tolerance zones, particularly from the policing point of view?
John Young: Con Committee
21 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I can repeat it if you want, convener.
John Young: Con Committee
21 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
My question was there.
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Committee
21 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Richard Simpson used the phrase "uncontrolled street prostitution". I am not at all certain about tolerance zones because there are variations from city to city. The Women's Support Project (Glasgow) stated in evidence: "violence and crime thrives in tolerance zones, including...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
16 Jan 2003
First Minister's Question Time · Scottish Manufacturing Steering Group
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. Do you have the latitude to extend First Minister's question time for another three minutes, which would allow question 6—a crucial question—to be answered? If the Army and its firefighters go to Iraq and the firemen go on strike, there ...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con Chamber
16 Jan 2003
Question Time · Bus Travel Scheme
My good friend Phil Gallie—who, if my memory serves me correctly, becomes an old age pensioner next year—advises me that about 1 million people in Scotland could qualify under the scheme. Some of those people are very wealthy; in Kenneth Macintosh's Eastwood constituency, we s...
John Young: Con Committee
14 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I appreciate that it is difficult to forecast the future, but what is your view of the French system, which operates state or municipally owned brothels? In the future, might that approach be more effective than tolerance zones, or is there no place for such a system in our so...
John Young: Con Committee
14 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
I first became a councillor in Glasgow Corporation in 1964. That local authority had 111 members, and if the idea of a tolerance zone had been introduced, not one of the 111 councillors would have voted in favour of it, but time moves on and views change.However, have views re...
John Young: Con Committee
14 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
You have outlined a number of ways in which you are trying to help. As you and previous speakers have suggested, the fact that most prostitutes are on drugs—as their predecessors, going way back in time, were addicted to alcohol—creates a catch-22 situation. I wonder whether t...
John Young: Con Committee
14 Jan 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Over the past few weeks, there has been considerable discussion of tolerance zones and, to a lesser extent, the use of industrial zones, which I think could be highly dangerous for women, especially if those industrial zones are situated in isolated areas or are on the outskir...
← Back to list
Chamber

Plenary, 27 Mar 2003

27 Mar 2003 · S1 · Plenary
Item of business
Motion of Thanks
Young, John Con West of Scotland Watch on SPTV
I find it a great privilege to be speaking on behalf of the SPCB in this tribute to David Steel. He has been a giant in British politics; indeed, his influence and fame has spread far beyond these shores. He has been used by people overseas in a number of different ways, and that is a tremendous tribute to him. The First Minister covered David's political career in some detail—in fact I was tearing up pages of my speech as the other speakers went on ahead of me.

However, one thing that they did not touch on was an election that I am glad David Steel did not win. In the 1980s, he suddenly decided to stand for the European Parliament. He chose the unusual seat of the central region of Italy. The mind boggles to imagine where David would be today if he had won that election. He would probably eat spaghetti every lunch time, have a lovely villa in Tuscany, speak fluent Italian—and no doubt, end up as the speaker of the Italian Parliament in Rome. He may think that this is a tough mob here, but it ain't nothing compared with that! If he had become the speaker of the Italian Parliament in Rome, I suspect that he would have brought the members under control in the calm manner that he employs all the time.

David has often been criticised in his four years as Presiding Officer. He has seen it in the press and people have been after him about this, that and everything else. We in the corporate body were in a unique position from which to observe his reactions to that criticism. He was always calm and he never lost his temper. His blood pressure might have gone up slightly, but never once can I recall him losing his temper. In fact, he would be a great man to have in the United Nations. During his illness he obviously suffered a great deal, yet he insisted on coming to the corporate body to chair it. All of us greatly admired his bravery and courage during that time—it cannot have been easy.

Not all members will be aware that there has been an interim setting up of an association of former MSPs, of which I am the interim chairman—and I hasten to add the word interim. Sir David Steel has agreed to be the honorary president of that organisation and I am pleased to say that that outstanding politician for Scotland, Winnie Ewing, has agreed to be the honorary vice-president. With those calming influences, it will be a very effective body indeed once it is fully set up.

I wish David, Judy and the family well. I know that David has written at least 12 books on a variety of subjects, and I am quite sure that he will produce many more. The book that I will stand in a queue to buy, even if the price is 30 guineas a time, is the one that tells the inside story of the Scottish Parliament's first four years and the corporate body. I wish you the best of luck, David.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Mr George Reid): SNP
The next item of business is a debate on motion S1M-4063, in the name of the First Minister, on the Presiding Officer.
The First Minister (Mr Jack McConnell): Lab
This is an important occasion. As the proceedings of this four-year session draw to a close, I am delighted to have the honour of moving a motion to pay trib...
Mr John Swinney (North Tayside) (SNP): SNP
It is my pleasure to support the motion that has been moved by the First Minister and to recognise the historic event that we are witnessing today. We are a ...
David McLetchie (Lothians) (Con): Con
On occasions such as this there is the temptation to say, "Oh, for goodness' sake give him the watch and crack open the sherry." Laughter. However, that woul...
The Deputy First Minister and Minister for Justice (Mr Jim Wallace): LD
Sir David Steel will be pleased and reassured to know that, following debate and discussion at our group meeting on Tuesday evening, the Liberal Democrat gro...
John Young (West of Scotland) (Con): Con
I find it a great privilege to be speaking on behalf of the SPCB in this tribute to David Steel. He has been a giant in British politics; indeed, his influen...
The Minister for Parliamentary Business (Patricia Ferguson): Lab
On behalf of the members of the Parliamentary Bureau, both past and present, I have great pleasure in taking the opportunity to say a few words before you go...
The Deputy Presiding Officer: SNP
It is with real pleasure, Sir David, that I ask you to reply to the debate.
The Presiding Officer (Sir David Steel): NPA
I see that I have less than two minutes in which to do so, Deputy Presiding Officer.It is especially pleasing to listen to all those kind words when I reckon...
The Deputy Presiding Officer: SNP
The question is, that motion S1M-4063, in the name of the First Minister, on the Presiding Officer, be agreed to.
Motion agreed to.
That the Parliament expresses its gratitude to Sir David Steel for his service to the Parliament and recognises the important and historic role he has carrie...
The Deputy Presiding Officer: SNP
The motion is agreed to unanimously. For the last time, I hand back the chair to Sir David Steel.