Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
14
Parties on record
2,096,228
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,096,228 contributions. Latest 30 days: 3,758. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 11 Jun 2026.
Mr Wallace: LD Chamber
22 Mar 2007
Scotland in the United Kingdom
I am concluding.While we examine Scotland's relationship with the rest of the United Kingdom, we should not lose sight of the principle that many of us articulated in the run-up to devolution in 1999—that devolved government does not stop at Edinburgh. The reformed electoral s...
Mr Wallace: LD Chamber
22 Mar 2007
Scotland in the United Kingdom
Of course we take part. I have sat at European Council of Ministers meetings articulating a Scottish case on justice matters.By all means, let us make a case for the union on the grounds of a stronger economy and securing greater influence on foreign policy. Let us not do it b...
Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
22 Mar 2007
Scotland in the United Kingdom
Deputy Speaker, this has been a lively debate—one might think that an election was in the offing.I am delighted to wind up for the Liberal Democrats in support of a motion that expressly encourages me to set out the Liberal Democrat position. I thank Margaret Curran for her ge...
Mr Wallace: LD Chamber
15 Mar 2007
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Scottish Natural Heritage<br />(Single Farm Payment)
The minister will acknowledge that I have been in correspondence with her and her predecessor for some time about this matter. Indeed, we are dealing with farmers whose management agreements are up for review or, in some cases, renewal. They are the very people who were pionee...
3. Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
15 Mar 2007
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Scottish Natural Heritage<br />(Single Farm Payment)
To ask the Scottish Executive what discussions it has had with Scottish Natural Heritage regarding levels of compensation paid under management agreements following the introduction of the single farm payment. (S2O-12396)
Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
15 Mar 2007
First Minister's Question Time · Prime Minister (Meetings)
Does the First Minister agree that, regardless of what view one takes on nuclear weapons, they are a serious issue that should not be reduced to constitutional point scoring?Will the First Minister acknowledge that, in the House of Commons last night, Liberal Democrat MPs vote...
Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
15 Mar 2007
Custodial Sentences and Weapons (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I am grateful to Mr Aitken for explaining the dilemma that he is in with procedures. However, before we vote on the amendments in his name, will he tell us whether he actually believes in them?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Mar 2007
Sift
I was going to give Gordon Jackson a chance. I thank members for their kind words. I also thank you, convener. This is the only committee of the Parliament that I have served on and I therefore have a particular affinity towards it. One of the features of the committee that I ...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Mar 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I agree, and John Home Robertson's point about copying the letter to the sponsoring minister is good. Indeed, were it not for the fact that we are reaching the end of the session, I would be minded to suggest that we ask Ken Collins to appear before the committee to answer our...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Mar 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I am grateful that John Home Robertson did the initial spadework in following up the matter with SEPA. The clerks have helpfully provided an extract from the Official Report of the meeting of 16 January, which confirms my recollection that I asked specifically about road plani...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Mar 2007
Scottish Executive European Union Priorities 2007
I have one final detailed point, and I accept that if the minister cannot answer it, he might pass it on to Mr Finnie. It relates to the anti-dumping measures against Norwegian farmed salmon. There is an indication that the anti-dumping committee undertook a consultation to de...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Mar 2007
Scottish Executive European Union Priorities 2007
I was pleased to hear what the minister had to say about the better regulation agenda and what was agreed at the weekend. The "Implications for Scotland" section of the better regulation agenda dossier says:"the UK Government is concerned that any target is clear and credible,...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Mar 2007
Scottish Executive European Union Priorities 2007
I might ask about specifics later, but I will let others speak first.
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Mar 2007
Scottish Executive European Union Priorities 2007
In your reply to Mr Gallie about energy, you referred to the spring European Council meeting last weekend. Do you have anything to add usefully to the dossiers, which we received before that meeting took place? Will you bring us up to date on energy and on better regulation, t...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Mar 2007
Scottish Executive European Union Priorities 2007
You said in your introduction that seven items that are not in the current list were in the 2006 list. Will you say for the record what they are and explain why they were dropped? Are they no longer seen as pressing priorities because they provide examples of progress on which...
Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Committee
13 Mar 2007
Scottish Executive European Union Priorities 2007
Can you highlight any examples from the dossiers that you have given us as good illustrations of relatively early Scottish input?
Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
01 Mar 2007
Multiple Sclerosis (Tysabri)
Does the minister agree that the United States Food and Drug Administration sets some of the highest tests for drugs to get through? It has unanimously supported the prescription of Tysabri. Does not that add weight to the call for it to be allowed in Scotland?
Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
01 Mar 2007
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Central Intelligence Agency (Rendition Flights)
In December 2005, the Parliament agreed to a motion on the issue, which I think the minister supported and which I seem to recall encouraged more of a joint approach between Scottish ministers and the UK Government. Will the minister give us a flavour of those discussions, and...
Mr Wallace: LD Chamber
01 Mar 2007
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Tobacco (Under-age Purchasers)
It certainly does not seem that the courts are overflowing with prosecutions of this nature. Is that because the current law is being obeyed meticulously the length and breadth of Scotland or, as we suspect, because people are not being caught? Would it not be better to try to...
1. Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
01 Mar 2007
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Tobacco (Under-age Purchasers)
To ask the Scottish Executive how many prosecutions have been brought in respect of selling tobacco to under-age purchasers in each of the last three years. (S2O-12199)
Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
21 Feb 2007
Environment
First, I congratulate the Scottish National Party on bringing this motion before Parliament today and giving us such an early opportunity to welcome the announcement by Nicol Stephen and the Executive of the £13 million investment in marine renewables, much of the activity of ...
Mr Wallace: LD Chamber
15 Feb 2007
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Care of the Elderly (Orkney)
I am sure that at our meeting on 20 December the minister got the full flavour of the challenges and difficulties that the council faces in the context of the islands' fast-rising elderly population. As a result of the meeting, the council agreed to consider seeking the assist...
6. Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
15 Feb 2007
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Care of the Elderly (Orkney)
To ask the Scottish Executive what representations it has received regarding the delivery of care services for elderly people in Orkney. (S2O-12019)
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
He is doing fine.First, I do not necessarily expect an answer from you at the moment, but can you confirm whether infraction proceedings have been brought against the UK Government for its interpretation of the waste incineration directive?Secondly, you will be aware that ther...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Finally, I have two quick questions.
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
It is useful that you referred to the specific examples but, in general, does the Executive monitor how regulatory bodies discharge their enforcement functions?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Is it the Scottish Executive's view that there is a distinction between sewage sludge and road planings?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Are you talking about the same—
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I do not know whether you were here when Mr Home Robertson commented on the matter at the beginning of the meeting. Inquiries to the Public Petitions Committee did not find any petition on road planings. There was a petition on sewage sludge—
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Are you sure about that, minister?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
The minister wrote to me and the letter was included in my report.
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I want to ask about differential enforcement—when enforcement is different in other parts of the United Kingdom or the European Union. Some questions today have reflected concerns about that. Mr Home Robertson mentioned road planings. Small waste burners have been mentioned, t...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
That was a helpful and welcome piece of evidence. For Scottish legislation with no European origin—which has tended to happen when there was a transposition but the Executive added something else in—will the information highlight the fact that what has been done is over and ab...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
That would be helpful. Mr Canavan asked about a correlation table; the other kind of table that we could have is a transposition table. For example, if the Scottish Executive has a set of regulations and, for the sake of argument, paragraph 1 correlates with part of an EU dire...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
You helpfully gave two examples to do with the public procurement directive when, for good reason, we took a different direction, but evidence that we received from the Scottish Trades Union Congress suggested that we missed an opportunity with that directive. Stephen Boyd of ...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I was not asking whether we can do it; I was asking about the practice. I suspect that, more often than not, we do not do it. Are there any reasons why we do not do it in circumstances in which we could do it? I was not doubting the legality of our position.
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
You tempt me, convener. I would like to pick up some points on implementation and transposition. Bruce Crawford raised a number of points about the use of differential transposition. Mr Lyon will be aware of the paragraphs in my report to the committee that reflect the advice ...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I did not mean this committee but, for example, the Justice 1 Committee or the Justice 2 Committee.
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Is there any reason why, when an explanatory memorandum is submitted to the UK Parliament, it could not also be made available to the relevant Scottish Parliament subject committee, if there is a Scottish interest? Justice is an obvious subject in which there might be a Scotti...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I have one final question on the pre-legislative stage. The United Kingdom Government produces explanatory memoranda to give to the European Scrutiny Committee in the House of Commons and the European Union Select Committee in the House of Lords. In a previous incarnation, I w...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Would it surprise or disappoint you to hear that some of the stakeholder bodies that have given evidence to the committee believe that there is not as much engagement with the Executive at the pre-legislative stage as they would like? Is there scope for doing better?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
On your final point, the committee has found the minister's presentation of the dossiers at the start of each presidency to be very helpful. What happens to those dossiers after they have been presented to the committee? Are the issues continually monitored? Does it vary from ...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
It has emerged from the work that I have done as the reporter and the work that the committee has done that there are three stages in the process: the pre-legislative stage at the European level, the stage at which a European directive is transposed, and the monitoring and enf...
Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Committee
13 Feb 2007
Decision on Taking Business in Private
I was reasonably relaxed about holding a discussion on our priorities in public. However, taking into account both the nature of the paper and Bruce Crawford's point, I would not go to the stake over it.
Mr Wallace: LD Chamber
25 Jan 2007
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Reliance
As the minister knows, I have written to him raising concerns about a case in Orkney in which a 16-year-old boy appeared before the panel in handcuffs. That may be a separate case from the one that the minister mentioned—I do not know. Does the minister accept that, although w...
2. Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Chamber
25 Jan 2007
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE · Reliance
To ask the Scottish Executive what discussions its Education Department has had with Reliance regarding the security arrangements for young people while attending children's hearings from custody. (S2O-11797)
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
23 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I suppose that it goes without saying that you are all generally supportive of the agenda to cut the European and Scottish administrative burden on businesses by 25 per cent by 2012. How confident are you that that will be achieved?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
23 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
That is the purpose of our inquiry. We started from a similar position of scepticism.Before Mr Bell speaks, I would like to question Mr McLean further on this. I do not know whether you were in post when the original directive was introduced. I—and, I am sure the committee—wou...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
23 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I thank the three witnesses for coming to the meeting.As I have said, there is a period in which European legislation is implemented, prior to which Scotland can influence the legislation as it evolves. The third phase is the enforcement phase. Perhaps we can consider each pha...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
23 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
The Commission proposes that there should be a reduction of 25 per cent in the administrative burden on business by 2012 at both a European and Scottish level. Do the two MEPs have any views on how that will be received and what implications that has?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
23 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Those answers were helpful and almost anticipated my follow-on question, which was about how we can make quality judgments on what should be followed up among the plethora of information. The three MEPs have given us useful guidance on that.It is important that we engage other...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
23 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Thank you, Madam President. First, I thank not only the three witnesses who are before us but all seven MEPs for batting together for Scotland. We are trying to find ways of improving the situation and ensuring that we are all involved.I want to pick up on Elspeth Attwooll's p...
Mr Jim Wallace (Orkney) (LD): LD Committee
23 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
I am Jim Wallace.
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
16 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
You stress the importance of transposition tables, which would be useful from a parliamentary perspective. However, when I was in Brussels I discussed with you or others the reluctance on the part of Governments to produce them, because doing so might flag up opportunities for...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
16 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
The Commission proposes a 25 per cent cut in the administrative burden by 2021. The cut would be made jointly with member states. It is yet to be formally adopted, but how would it work in practice? What sort of things is the Commission looking for?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
16 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
At the other extreme, we heard evidence from the Food Standards Agency Scotland that, for food hygiene, there is now a tendency to produce a regulation rather than a directive, to try to ensure some degree of conformity. Do you see that extending to other areas?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
16 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
One of the suggestions was that a directive could sometimes be implemented by guidance or codes of practice. Would I be right in thinking that there is an increasing tendency for the Commission to look to more formal legislation, be it primary or subordinate legislation, or is...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
16 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Another point that was made by the NFUS was that the starting point should be whether a particular directive addresses an issue that is relevant in Scotland. The suggestion was that solutions are often applied even when there is no problem. Taking the nitrates directive as an ...
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
16 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
There is a rich diversity of sub-national or sub-member-state Administrations in Europe. Do you have experience of, for example, German Länder or Spanish provinces being involved in that process at present?
Mr Wallace: LD Committee
16 Jan 2007
Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry
Therefore, as far as the Commission is concerned, there is no barrier to prevent the Scottish ministers or their officials from providing a direct input.
← Back to list
Chamber

Plenary, 22 Mar 2007

22 Mar 2007 · S2 · Plenary
Item of business
Scotland in the United Kingdom
I am concluding.

While we examine Scotland's relationship with the rest of the United Kingdom, we should not lose sight of the principle that many of us articulated in the run-up to devolution in 1999—that devolved government does not stop at Edinburgh. The reformed electoral system offers a fresh opportunity to build the parity of esteem between the Scottish Parliament and our councils that we talked about back in 1999. In the next session, the Parliament should resist any unnecessary tendency to centralise; rather, it should seek positive opportunities to decentralise.

That is a particularly important issue from the perspective of my islands constituency. As Alasdair Morrison said, the devolved Parliament has recognised many of our island communities' challenges. On the key issue of transport, Orkney has a new generation of ferries with supporting infrastructure, concessionary fares for pensioners who use the ferries, reduced freight charges and an instrument landing system for the airport. Furthermore, air fares have been reduced by 40 per cent. Undoubtedly there are challenges ahead for my constituency—not least as a result of its increasing elderly population—but there have been regular increases in funding for public services. Looking to the future, the Executive has made significant investment, not least in Orkney, to establish Scotland as a powerhouse for renewable energy.

The Scottish constitutional convention recognised that our island communities "warranted distinctive constitutional consideration". Already, our standing orders require bill promoters to indicate the impact of the proposals on island areas. In the next session the Parliament may wish to consider how that provision could be beefed up. In addition, I hope that members in the next session will support a Liberal Democrat proposal to encourage and support island areas that choose to move forward on establishing single public service authorities that will harness the advantages of distinctive communities, promote the more efficient use of resources and more effectively act against centralisation.

In conclusion, I thank colleagues in all parties for the friendship and courtesy that they have shown me in the past eight years. Over 24 years in one Parliament or another, it has been my experience that politicians are, with rare exceptions, motivated by a strong sense of public service and that they pursue their careers according to their sincerely held political beliefs. That is too rarely acknowledged and reported.

It goes without saying that many of us could not do the job that we do without the support of our families. In that context, I acknowledge the great support and encouragement that I have received from Rosie, Helen and Clare. However, above all, I want to express my gratitude to my constituents in the northern isles. The past 24 years in the House of Commons and in the Scottish Parliament, in which I have been Deputy First Minister, acting First Minister and, not least, a back bencher—for the first time—in the past two years, have been a rich experience, none of which would have been possible without the support of my constituents. They accorded me the privilege of electing me to represent their interests six times, for which I shall be eternally grateful. [Applause.]

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Mr George Reid): NPA
Good morning. Our first item of business is a debate on motion S2M-5779, in the name of Margaret Curran, on Scotland in the United Kingdom.
The Minister for Parliamentary Business (Ms Margaret Curran): Lab
I am delighted to be back in the chamber to open this morning's important debate. On the eve of the election, let us address the fundamental question that wi...
Mr John Swinney (North Tayside) (SNP): SNP
Can the Executive get its motion right?
Ms Curran: Lab
From a sedentary position, Mr Swinney is trying to provoke me.
Mr Swinney: SNP
It has worked so many times in the past.
Ms Curran: Lab
I was about to say that that is not a difficult thing to do. However, although the SNP talks about the words of the motion, Labour members are happier talkin...
Ms Sandra White (Glasgow) (SNP): SNP
Can the member clarify for the chamber which version of the motion she will discuss?
Ms Curran: Lab
We will focus on the substantial issues that face the Scottish electorate, not the words of a motion. It is clear that the road to separation will be costly,...
Alex Neil (Central Scotland) (SNP): SNP
Will the minister take an intervention?
Ms Curran: Lab
No. Scotland's separatists argue that our partnership in the United Kingdom has failed Scotland; apparently, we have been held back and undermined for many y...
Phil Gallie (South of Scotland) (Con): Con
I want to support the minister today, but I am not sure that her going through the Executive's record is the best way of getting me to do that. Where do her ...
Ms Curran: Lab
Phil Gallie's timing is perfect. I was about to say that we have tackled the tough issues—in the face of much resistance. We recognised, as the Tories did no...
Mr Swinney: SNP
Will the minister give an accurate statement to the Parliament by acknowledging that the SNP's commitment is to abolishing the despised council tax, which ha...
Ms Curran: Lab
Mr Swinney is easily provoked, too. I think that he is so animated because we have exposed the real consequences of SNP policy, which would mean not only a 3...
Margo MacDonald (Lothians) (Ind): Ind
Is the minister arguing that the SNP's economic policies would bring penury or that independence, if the Scots chose that, would impoverish us?
Ms Curran: Lab
It is sad that the SNP never gave Margo MacDonald the opportunity to advocate her policy for independence. The policies of the SNP will be disastrous for Sco...
Christine May (Central Fife) (Lab): Lab
Does the minister recognise that many of my constituents who receive pensions from Westminster are very worried about what might happen to those pensions und...
Ms Curran: Lab
That is a very good point, and it was very well put. That is an example of exactly the kind of issue and detail that we need to think through. This is the ke...
Alex Neil: SNP
Where is Jack?
Ms Curran: Lab
I have one fundamental question: where is Alex? I am not sure why the Scottish Parliament was not good enough for Alex Salmond before, and I am not sure why ...
The Minister for Education and Young People (Hugh Henry): Lab
With three jobs.
Ms Curran: Lab
Yes, with three jobs.This debate illustrates the real choices before the Scottish people: tax and turmoil or prosperity and progress; improving education or ...
Alasdair Morgan (South of Scotland) (SNP): SNP
I will move the only amendment in my name. Behind this debate is the question whether a constitutional arrangement devised three centuries ago, in questionab...
Bristow Muldoon (Livingston) (Lab): Lab
Will the member give way?
Alasdair Morgan: SNP
It is a bit early in my speech. I hope that I have said something controversial already.
Bristow Muldoon: Lab
Does Mr Morgan not recognise that Scotland has a new constitutional settlement that is only 10 years old, not 300 years old? Is it not time to allow that con...
Alasdair Morgan: SNP
That is one of the questions that I will address in my speech. It is interesting that Bristow Muldoon's coalition partners do not seem to agree with him on t...
The Minister for Health and Community Care (Mr Andy Kerr) rose— Lab
Alasdair Morgan: SNP
I am glad to give way on that point.
Mr Kerr: Lab
The member does not focus on the substance. Geoff Hoon pointed out that House of Commons library research says that if Scotland were independent, referendums...