Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
14
Parties on record
2,096,833
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,096,833 contributions. Latest 30 days: 2,655. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 09 Jun 2026.
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
17 Mar 2011
Clydebank Blitz 70th Anniversary
I thank Margaret Curran very much for her intervention. I think that other Glasgow members are well aware that the Luftwaffe lightened its load as it escaped home and was under orders to wait until it was over a heavily populated area before it dropped its spare bombs, which d...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
17 Mar 2011
Clydebank Blitz 70th Anniversary
In the past couple of weeks, we have seen some horrendous images of death and devastation from Japan on our television screens. There is no doubt that the scale of the natural disaster in Japan has been truly ferocious. We would not in any sense want to make a comparison betwe...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
17 Mar 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · St Margaret of Scotland Hospice
Has the cabinet secretary given any indications to the chair of Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board about what she would like to come out of tomorrow’s meeting? We have waited a long time to get that meeting up and running. Does she want to give a sense to the chair of that bo...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
17 Mar 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · St Margaret of Scotland Hospice
11. To ask the Scottish Executive what recent discussions it has had with NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde regarding future funding and co-operation with the St Margaret of Scotland Hospice. (S3O-13357)
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
17 Mar 2011
Bus Services Regulation
A fortnight ago, we had a by-election in Clydebank—in the Duntocher, Faifley and Hardgate ward. The key issue in that by-election was buses, specifically the number 118. First had proposed to withdraw that service, which runs between Duntocher and Gartnavel hospital via Bearsd...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
16 Mar 2011
Higher Education Funding
Answer the question, cabinet secretary.
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
16 Mar 2011
Higher Education Funding
I am pleased that the cabinet secretary now recognises that there is a funding gap as a result of the actions of the Con-Dem Government at Westminster in raising tuition fees to £9,000 and reducing teaching grant. His earlier stance, which was that there might not be a funding...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
10 Mar 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · Schools (Repairs)
Will the minister confirm that £18.8 million in capital funding is still available for Garnock academy? When will that funding be available? The original plan was that it would be available in 2013-14. Is that still the year in which that capital funding will be available?
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
09 Mar 2011
“Teaching Scotland’s Future”
I thank the Scottish Government for providing an advance copy of the minister’s statement although, in truth, there is so little substance in it that Michael Russell would not have been criticised for providing information in advance of the statement had he responded to the qu...
Des McNulty Lab Committee
08 Mar 2011
Current Petitions
I will make a couple of points in conclusion, if I may. It is reasonable to say that it is not for the committee to involve itself in local issues. We never asked it to do that. Bill Butler is right to say that the fact that we do not yet have the information on hospice fundin...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Committee
08 Mar 2011
Current Petitions
I thank the committee for its consideration thus far of the issues around the St Margaret of Scotland hospice. I am also grateful to Marjorie McCance and Jean Anne Mitchell, who are behind the petition.The petition has two strands to it. The first is to do with the funding arr...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
03 Mar 2011
Damages (Scotland) Bill
Like others, I congratulate my neighbour Bill Butler on his outstanding work in introducing the bill. Like me, he has a very strong interest in asbestos issues, on which the Parliament has already passed two bills. The Damages (Scotland) Bill will extend some of the improvemen...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
03 Mar 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · Railway Station Car Parking
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. Is it in order for ministers to give misleading responses to questions? Earlier, I asked a question about Tesco’s appeal. It is quite clearly a ministerial decision to pass any appeal to the inquiry reporters unit. Ministers authorise ex...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
03 Mar 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · Planning Application (Milngavie)
I was in contact with the minister’s predecessor on this particular application, and I confirm for the record that it was a ministerial decision to pass the appeal to the reporter. There was a possibility of not so doing, but the decision to do so was made in the minister’s na...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
03 Mar 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · Planning Application (Milngavie)
6. To ask the Scottish Executive what the estimated cost is to the inquiry reporters unit of the appeal by Tesco against the decision by East Dunbartonshire Council to turn down the planning application for an enlarged store in Woodburn Way, Milngavie, and when a decision on t...
Des McNulty Lab Committee
01 Mar 2011
Current Petitions
For them, but that is a self-selecting group.
Des McNulty Lab Committee
01 Mar 2011
Current Petitions
I think that the point that I have heard you make before, Mr Shaw, which is that we will learn lessons through the process, is very strange. I do not need a lengthy process that costs hundreds of thousands of pounds to tell me that the kinds of things that happened in what we ...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Committee
01 Mar 2011
Current Petitions
I have read the report and listened to what you have said, Mr Shaw. You focused strongly on acknowledgement rather than on accountability—it is obvious that the time to be heard forum focused its attention on that. As you acknowledged, you reached only the tip of the iceberg, ...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
24 Feb 2011
Regeneration
I agree with the minister, and I look forward to reading the document and contributing to the discussion around it. Does the minister agree that regeneration is not something that can be done in an area for a year or two years, as it requires a sustained programme of investmen...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
St Margaret of Scotland Hospice
I want to be clear about this. The cabinet secretary has said for the past year and a half that NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde should enter into negotiations with St Margaret’s about a contract for St Margaret’s to make provision available. She now seems to be saying that St Ma...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
St Margaret of Scotland Hospice
I point out that there was no public consultation on the proposal to take the 30 beds away from St Margaret’s. I also point out that, notwithstanding the fact that continuing care has continued at St Margaret’s, it has also continued at Blawarthill for the past three years in ...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
St Margaret of Scotland Hospice
I am worried about the member’s direction of travel. I would not put that past the health board.
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
St Margaret of Scotland Hospice
I have the best will in the world towards Campbell Christie, but we are talking about an absolutely open-and-shut case. We do not need to get into the debate about public sector reform. There is an answer to a question that is begging to be answered, and I hope that the minist...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
St Margaret of Scotland Hospice
No. Let me continue, if I may.Yesterday, the health board put out a press statement that said—surprise, surprise—that Southern Cross Healthcare, which was one of the partners at Blawarthill, is no longer able to provide the service that it had contracted to provide, and the co...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
St Margaret of Scotland Hospice
This is the third members’ business debate that I have had on the St Margaret of Scotland Hospice; the issue has been going on for more than three years. I remember bringing a group from the hospice—many of the same people are in the public gallery tonight—to a debate in Decem...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · Active Schools Co-ordinators
Will the minister work hard with local government to try to ensure that the active schools projects continue? As she said, there are some valuable outcomes in local authority areas right across Scotland as a result of this worthwhile programme. It would be unfortunate if the p...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · Active Schools Co-ordinators
10. To ask the Scottish Executive how many active schools co-ordinators there are and by how many sportscotland estimates this number will have to be reduced as a result of the 2011-12 budget. (S3O-12981)
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · New Housing (West of Scotland)
I invite the minister to be a wee bit more specific. How major is major? Will he put a figure on how much money will come to Clydebank Re-built? I have asked the minister about that before. Can he offer any indication of what funding will be available for housing in West Dunba...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
Early Intervention
I agree with both of those points. Teachers—particularly nursery teachers—make the same point. Intervention is too fragmented and too late. The parents, rather than the children who are brought up in chaotic circumstances, are often seen as the clients of the agency, and the c...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
Early Intervention
I will just make this point.It is important that we talk about the voluntary sector too, because it has a major role to play and it could play a much greater part than it does at present.
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
Early Intervention
It is a way forward, but if we look at the distribution of budgets, we can see that there has been a decline in the numbers in nursery education and a reduction in the budget for care staff. We need to pay attention to that. It is about priorities, and young children should be...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
Early Intervention
I welcome that, but I believe that we need to go further. The review makes some serious criticisms of what has happened to the health visitor service. As Shona Robison said, the guidance has been reissued, but we need to go a bit further.Health support and advice need to be av...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
10 Feb 2011
Early Intervention
I begin by thanking the Conservatives for choosing the topic for debate. It is an extremely important issue, and the debate allows the different parties to put forward their thinking in advance of the election in May. I assure the Parliament that during the election—and therea...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
09 Feb 2011
Budget (Scotland) (No 5) Bill: Stage 3
We absolutely did, and if Margaret Smith was in the debate two weeks ago, she will have heard me make that point.In colleges, people know what the real financial situation is and what the settlement means. In Clydebank College, the grant is being reduced from £11.5 million to ...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
09 Feb 2011
Budget (Scotland) (No 5) Bill: Stage 3
The facts are undeniable: the further and higher education sectors in Scotland have been particularly badly bruised by this SNP budget. While the Liberal Democrats claim a great victory—as I am sure Margaret Smith is keen to do—which they hope will offset the anger at their be...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
09 Feb 2011
Budget (Scotland) (No 5) Bill: Stage 3
I welcome the revisions to the budgets for the urban regeneration companies. I lobbied Mr Neil on that matter on behalf of all the regeneration companies—in particular, Clydebank Re-built—and will be interested to know the detail of the additional money that Mr Swinney has mad...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
03 Feb 2011
Scottish Executive Question Time · Further Education (Student Numbers)
I accept that it is the responsibility of the funding council rather than ministers to decide on funding allocations to individual further education institutions, but has the funding council gathered information about the implications for jobs and course provision of the Gover...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
03 Feb 2011
First Minister’s Question Time · New National Examinations
Scotland’s schools have more than 3,000 fewer teachers now than they had in 2007. Officials worry that we could lose 900 more next year, which would bring the total of teachers’ jobs lost under the Scottish National Party to 4,000.On the curriculum for excellence, the issue is...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
03 Feb 2011
First Minister’s Question Time · New National Examinations
5. To ask the First Minister, in light of reported comments from the Educational Institute of Scotland, whether the Scottish Government will delay the introduction of new national exams. (S3F-2892)
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
26 Jan 2011
Budget (Scotland) (No 5) Bill: Stage 1
There are some things in the budget that I welcome. For example, I welcome the retention of the education maintenance allowance but, as the National Union of Students has pointed out, there is a real problem with college bursaries that affects our poorest students, and which w...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
26 Jan 2011
Budget (Scotland) (No 5) Bill: Stage 1
A service that should deliver national priorities has become a postcode lottery, while the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning, who is notionally in charge, devotes his time to usurping the responsibilities of the retiring member for Argyll and Bute. Every ti...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
26 Jan 2011
Budget (Scotland) (No 5) Bill: Stage 1
Our schools are under pressure, education is already suffering and we can count the number of teachers who are no longer employed in the system, but the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning has never been more bullish. It is sometimes difficult to gauge from t...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
26 Jan 2011
Budget (Scotland) (No 5) Bill: Stage 1
In the brave new world that—according to the SNP—arrived in 2007, we were promised across-the-board reductions in class sizes, the abolition of student debt, the maintenance of teacher numbers, additional support for child care and physical education, free music instruction, a...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
20 Jan 2011
Historic Environment (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I lead for Labour in the debate as a substitute for my colleague Pauline McNeill, who unfortunately is ill and sends her apologies. I also apologise, because I cannot stay for the whole debate, as I previously arranged another engagement. I apologise to the Presiding Officer a...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
13 Jan 2011
Education
Will the minister confirm that the previously announced capital allocations for Garnock academy and Wick high school will still be handed to the respective authorities?
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
13 Jan 2011
Education
Will the member ask the cabinet secretary why he is withdrawing capital allocations from new schools that are on the list and replacing them with revenue support?
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
13 Jan 2011
Education
Why has West Lothian Council written to people on its supply list to say that they will have to be reinterviewed for that list and that there will be very few jobs in the coming year?
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
13 Jan 2011
Education
Will the minister give way?
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
13 Jan 2011
Education
I am very happy to do so. I will make the point again in a moment.The SNP inherited from the previous Administration a legacy of sustained improvement and trashed it. Had the SNP kept teacher numbers at the level that Labour and the Liberal Democrats achieved in 2007, there wo...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
13 Jan 2011
Education
Over the past year, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning has tried his best to convince parents, teachers and the wider Scottish public that his Government is delivering on education. His amendment today is a litany of deceit. It is intended to obscure the...
Des McNulty Lab Chamber
12 Jan 2011
Proposed School Closures (Argyll)
Finally, will the cabinet secretary provide details of ministerial and parliamentary resources used to arrange and deliver the meetings?
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
12 Jan 2011
Proposed School Closures (Argyll)
I thank the cabinet secretary for advance sight of his statement. I have three specific questions and a number of requests for further information.Will the cabinet secretary name the eight or nine schools in Argyll and Bute that he apparently considers could have been closed w...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
23 Dec 2010
Scottish Executive Question Time · Business Support (West Dunbartonshire)
Will the minister intervene to ensure that Scottish Enterprise honours the agreement between the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and the Scottish Government with regard to funding for the urban regeneration companies such as Clydebank Re-built? Will he or the Cabinet ...
Des McNulty Lab Committee
21 Dec 2010
Current Petitions
It is not for me to intervene in the committee’s consideration of how it handles matters, but a point of clarification arises from Bill Butler’s comments. It would not be a good idea for the consultation that Fergus Ewing mentioned to be delayed until the committee has time to...
Des McNulty Lab Committee
21 Dec 2010
Current Petitions
Yes; it is about the letter from Duncan Wilson of the SHRC. He said:“Upon completion of the pilot forum and the publication of the report by Tom Shaw and the other Time to be Heard Commissioners”and presumably the consultation document to which the Minister for Community Safet...
Des McNulty Lab Committee
21 Dec 2010
Current Petitions
I have a final question, convener. I am grateful to the committee for its indulgence and I thank the minister for that clarification.I am highly conscious of the minister’s remarks about the court not being the most appropriate or available route to some kind of reparation or ...
Des McNulty Lab Committee
21 Dec 2010
Current Petitions
I welcome the minister’s remarks. I would be grateful if he would confirm that, in that context, the Government might take a similar view in relation to the Scottish Law Commission’s formal position on the cases as it took in relation to double jeopardy—in other words, that it...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Committee
21 Dec 2010
Current Petitions
The problem that I want to highlight is that the prescription and time-bar legislation coupled with how the courts are interpreting the Scottish Law Commission’s report mean that access to redress through civil procedures is virtually impossible. A more or less blanket ruling ...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
16 Dec 2010
Higher Education
Last weekend, sources close to the First Minister told several newspapers that the Scottish National Party wants to make free higher education the cornerstone of its election campaign in May. Neither Mike Russell nor John Swinney believe that higher education can be sustained ...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab Chamber
15 Dec 2010
Damages (Scotland) Bill:Stage 1
Like other members, I congratulate Bill Butler on taking the bill to this stage. I hope that it goes further and becomes law in due course.In 2006 I considered introducing a bill to amend the Damages (Scotland) Act 1976, prompted by the particular circumstances of sufferers of...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 17 March 2011

17 Mar 2011 · S3 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Clydebank Blitz 70th Anniversary
McNulty, Des Lab Clydebank and Milngavie Watch on SPTV
I thank Margaret Curran very much for her intervention. I think that other Glasgow members are well aware that the Luftwaffe lightened its load as it escaped home and was under orders to wait until it was over a heavily populated area before it dropped its spare bombs, which destroyed Glasgow tenements in various places, from the west end of the city to the east. It was not just Clydebank that was affected. However, Clydebank was the target, and Clydebank went up in flames, not just from the bombing but from the incendiary devices that lit up the town so that the bombs could subsequently fall. As well as the death and destruction that the bombs caused, there were horrendous fires, in Singer’s wood yard for example.

For many people in Clydebank, the memory of the blitz and the evacuations and what happened to them and their relatives is present. At the 70th anniversary service in Kilbowie St Andrew’s church at the weekend, I talked to people who, as young children, experienced being bombed or their relatives being injured and, in a couple of cases, being killed in the bombing. This is probably the last big anniversary at which we will have people alive who lived through the blitz, so it is important that their memories and records are not lost.

I pay tribute to West Dunbartonshire Council, which has done a terrific job over the years, particularly on the 60th and 70th anniversaries, to ensure that appropriate and dignified ceremonies have been held to commemorate what happened in the blitz and, to some extent, to ensure that the events were not just for Clydebank but for Scotland.

The moderator of the Church of Scotland gave the sermon at the service. His sermon was excellent. He said that he had spoken to a person in Edinburgh who had lived in Clydebank at the time of the blitz and had helped to rescue people. That person had met a man who had lost his young daughter and had said to him, “I hope we’re not going to do this to other people’s weans.”

The sense in Clydebank of a lack of rancour towards the German people, as well as solidarity with the Polish people who were in Clydebank at the time and helped not just to minimise the effect of the bombing on naval targets but to rescue people from houses, has continued. At the service, I sat next to the German consul and behind the Polish consul, and there were representatives from the Polish navy in the audience. After the ceremony we went to the monument that is a memorial to the crew of the ship, Piorun, which was berthed in Clydebank at the time. The sailors helped greatly to deal with the consequences of the bombing.

The survival of Clydebank after the blitz is a story of a long, slow process of regeneration. Clydebank was picked as a target because it was such an industrial centre. Singer’s was there, the shipyards were there and engineering factories were there. It was an important centre of munitions production for the war effort. That is why it was a target. The destruction of factories and workplaces had a profound and long-term effect on the town’s economy and the destruction of the houses had a profound effect on its social fabric.

It probably took 20 years for Clydebank to recover and to be physically rebuilt, and after that it was affected by the Thatcher recession of the 1980s. Probably only in the past 10 years has Clydebank been in a position to begin to recover from the economic destruction that it has suffered. That is why Clydebank wants not only to remember what happened in the blitz but to look forward to a positive future. Scotland should help Clydebank to achieve that.

17:15

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Trish Godman) Lab
The final item of business today is a members’ business debate on motion S3M-7738, in the name of Des McNulty, on the 70th anniversary of the Clydebank blitz...
Des McNulty (Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab) Lab
In the past couple of weeks, we have seen some horrendous images of death and devastation from Japan on our television screens. There is no doubt that the sc...
Margaret Curran (Glasgow Baillieston) (Lab) Lab
I absolutely accept the point that Des McNulty is making, but on behalf of people in the east end of Glasgow, I ask him to convey to the people of Clydebank ...
Des McNulty Lab
I thank Margaret Curran very much for her intervention. I think that other Glasgow members are well aware that the Luftwaffe lightened its load as it escaped...
Gil Paterson (West of Scotland) (SNP) SNP
I pay tribute to Des McNulty for bringing this debate to the chamber and I congratulate him on a fine speech. I associate myself with every word in his excel...
Bill Aitken (Glasgow) (Con) Con
I congratulate Des McNulty on bringing the matter before the Parliament. I speak as a member of a fairly blessed generation. Born post-war, I did not have to...
Patricia Ferguson (Glasgow Maryhill) (Lab) Lab
Like other members, I congratulate my colleague Des McNulty on securing the debate. As his motion makes clear, it is 70 years since Clydebank was bombed. As ...
The Minister for Housing and Communities (Alex Neil) SNP
I, too, congratulate Des McNulty on securing the debate and on his gracious and informative speech.Before addressing the issue, I pay tribute to Bill Aitken,...