Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
14
Parties on record
2,096,497
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,096,497 contributions. Latest 30 days: 3,898. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 16 Jun 2026.
The Presiding Officer (Kenneth Gibson) NPA Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Quality (Scottish Transport Emissions Partnership)
Thank you, colleagues. That concludes general questions. I apologise to those whose supplementary questions were not called due to time constraints.The rest of this Official Report will be published progressively as soon as the text is available.
Stephen Flynn SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Quality (Scottish Transport Emissions Partnership)
I am sympathetic to the campaigners’ arguments—it is very hard not to be. I have asked my officials to engage with those campaigners and to feed back to me as quickly as possible whether any action could be taken that is within the Government’s scope.
Katie Hagmann SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Quality (Scottish Transport Emissions Partnership)
The cabinet secretary will be aware that the A77 trunk road runs through Girvan in my constituency, carrying significant heavy goods vehicle traffic to and from the port of Cairnryan. Local groups, including GoGirvan, which is a community regeneration group, seek support in or...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport (Stephen Flynn) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Quality (Scottish Transport Emissions Partnership)
We all recognise the importance of clean air, particularly those of us who walk around with weans. Unfortunately, the Scottish transport emissions partnership is no longer active, but I advise Katie Hagmann that action is currently driven by the cleaner air for Scotland strategy.
Katie Hagmann (Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley) (SNP) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Quality (Scottish Transport Emissions Partnership)
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on the work carried out by the Scottish transport emissions partnership in relation to local air quality management. (S7O-00067)
Màiri McAllan SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Pupil Support Assistants (Rural Primary Schools)
I can. It is worth noting for a moment where we are now. The latest figures show that, in Scotland, we have 16,908 pupil support assistants, which is the third highest number on record and an increase of nearly 1,645 since 2020. However, in our manifesto, the Government commit...
Colin Beattie (Midlothian North) (SNP) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Pupil Support Assistants (Rural Primary Schools)
Pupil support assistants have an essential role to play in our classrooms. Can the cabinet secretary provide any update on the steps that the Scottish National Party Government is taking to support schools, including in Scotland’s rural areas, to deliver more pupil support staff?
Màiri McAllan SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Pupil Support Assistants (Rural Primary Schools)
I recognise the seriousness of the issue that Andrew Baxter raises. It bears repeating that local authorities are the employers of teachers and that, therefore, any assessment that is done regarding the reduction of hours or the withdrawal of pupil support staff in schools in ...
Andrew Baxter LD Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Pupil Support Assistants (Rural Primary Schools)
I thank the cabinet secretary for recognising the importance of our PSAs. However, every summer, pupils, parents, teachers and pupil support assistants are left wondering what their classrooms will look like after the holidays. One PSA recently told me that they were informed ...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic (Màiri McAllan) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Pupil Support Assistants (Rural Primary Schools)
Pupil support assistants play an absolutely vital role in our classrooms and schools and in our young people’s education. They are essential and valued members of the school learning teams and communities. That is why we continue to provide £15 million each year to help local ...
Andrew Baxter (Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch) (LD) LD Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Pupil Support Assistants (Rural Primary Schools)
I refer to my entry in the register of interests, which shows that I am a sitting councillor on Highland Council. To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of how any reduction in hours or withdrawal of pupil support assistant posts will impact rural primary s...
Màiri McAllan SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Teaching Contracts
On the substance of Meghan Gallacher’s question—setting aside any misquoting of cabinet secretaries—the fact is that, as I put to Colm Merrick, the Government has invested significantly in the retention of teachers and the growth of teacher numbers in Scotland. We understand t...
Meghan Gallacher (Central Scotland and Lothians West) (Con) Con Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Teaching Contracts
The former education secretary and now Deputy First Minister, Jenny Gilruth, said in January this year that teachers would need to relocate to where the jobs are. Mike Corbett from the NASUWT condemned those comments. Does the new cabinet secretary agree with the Deputy First ...
Màiri McAllan SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Teaching Contracts
I recognise, and the Government recognises, that the lack of available jobs after probation has, for some prospective teachers, been a significant concern. The commitment to a teacher job guarantee demonstrates that we have listened to that and are prepared and determined to w...
Colm Merrick (Glasgow Anniesland) (SNP) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Teaching Contracts
I hope that we can all welcome the Scottish Government’s plans to deliver the reforms that are necessary to provide a teacher job guarantee for a minimum of three years for newly qualified teachers. How does the cabinet secretary anticipate that that measure will support Scotl...
Màiri McAllan SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Teaching Contracts
As we do the careful work that is required to design and, thereafter, implement the conditions for a three-year teacher job guarantee, I will, of course, consider, among many other issues, the points that Katherine Sangster has put to me about the very practical question of ho...
Katherine Sangster Lab Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Teaching Contracts
Teaching unions have raised concerns that the way in which local authorities advertise temporary contracts is making work difficult to access for some teachers, by creating an inequality for those with caring responsibilities and those who are unable to check their phones beca...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic (Màiri McAllan) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Teaching Contracts
Local authorities are responsible for teacher employment practices, as they are the employer of teachers. However, the Government is doing everything possible to maximise the number of teaching jobs that are available, including permanent posts. The 2026-27 budget continues to...
Katherine Sangster (Edinburgh and Lothians East) (Lab) Lab Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Teaching Contracts
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on the progress it has made towards reducing the number of teachers on short-term or temporary contracts. (S7O-00065)
Stephen Flynn SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Road Infrastructure Commitments (North East Scotland)
Of course I can, but I appreciate that members are conscious of time, so I do not want to list them all. I can draw Mr Middleton’s attention to what I drew Mr Kerr’s attention to, which is the Aberdeen western peripheral route. It was a huge investment in the north-east of Sco...
Jack Middleton (Aberdeen Central) (SNP) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Road Infrastructure Commitments (North East Scotland)
Can the cabinet secretary remind the chamber what improvements to road infrastructure the SNP Government has made in the north-east and outline what more it will deliver in the future? Interruption.
Stephen Flynn SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Road Infrastructure Commitments (North East Scotland)
Of course, in order to get to Ellon from the south, people right across Scotland have the opportunity to drive on the Aberdeen western peripheral route—a nearly £1 billion project that was delivered by the SNP Government of the time and which Mr Kerr seems to have forgotten ev...
Liam Kerr Con Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Road Infrastructure Commitments (North East Scotland)
I am grateful to hear that reassurance, because the minister will know the dangers of the A90 north of Ellon, particularly at the Toll of Birness and Cortes junctions, which the Scottish National Party Government has shamefully failed to address. In fact, in 2007, Alex Salmond...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport (Stephen Flynn) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Road Infrastructure Commitments (North East Scotland)
Yes.
Liam Kerr (North East Scotland) (Con) Con Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Road Infrastructure Commitments (North East Scotland)
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will honour, in full, commitments made by previous ministers for transport to upgrade road infrastructure in the north-east of Scotland. (S7O-00064)
Gillian Martin SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Flood Protection (Grangemouth)
I agree with the substantive premise of Graham Simpson’s question. Flood defences are for the Scottish Government to provide, but given the size of the scheme, any contribution would be welcome. Obviously, the UK Government has been working with the Scottish Government on issu...
Graham Simpson (Central Scotland and Lothians West) (Reform) Reform Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Flood Protection (Grangemouth)
That scheme is so big that it is of UK significance, and it has always been my view that the UK Government should help to fund it. Has the cabinet secretary been in any direct discussions with the UK Government about sourcing funding for the scheme?
Gillian Martin SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Flood Protection (Grangemouth)
I thank Martin Day for that important supplementary question. We will continue to work with Falkirk Council, the United Kingdom Government, businesses and investors to secure a long-term sustainable future for the industrial cluster. My officials working on flood policy have b...
Martyn Day SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Flood Protection (Grangemouth)
Falkirk Council deserves credit for the years of work that it has put into managing flood risk. With climate change increasing the risk of flooding around Grangemouth and upstream, plans to protect 6,000 people, 2,760 homes, 1,200 businesses and 23km of roads from a major floo...
The Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Rural Affairs (Gillian Martin) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Flood Protection (Grangemouth)
The Scottish Government is in close contact with Falkirk Council on how to progress the Grangemouth flood protection scheme. In February, we provided £1.6 million to the council, which will be used to support the next stage of the scheme’s development. That is in addition to t...
Martyn Day (Falkirk East and Linlithgow) (SNP) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Flood Protection (Grangemouth)
To ask the Scottish Government what progress has been made regarding funding for the Grangemouth flood protection scheme. (S7O-00063)
Stephen Flynn SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
It is important to place on record the important work that was undertaken by the former constituency member, Ms Hyslop, and by Mr Fairlie in his ministerial role. I look forward to working with the new constituency member to take forward the matter, and I am sure that we will ...
Pauline Stafford (Bathgate) (SNP) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
I refer members to my entry in the register of members’ interests, as I am an elected member of West Lothian Council.I welcome the Scottish Government’s clear commitment to delivering a Winchburgh station, including reference to it in this year’s budget statement and in the Sc...
Stephen Flynn SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
I would love to be in a position to do that here today. It is important to recognise that it is for West Lothian Council and Winchburgh Developments to take forward construction of a new station, but we are willing to engage with them in that process. They have already been in...
Jenny Young Lab Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
Currently, it takes more than an hour to get the bus from Winchburgh to central Edinburgh. That is a journey of under 15 miles. The train to Waverley would take around 15 minutes.Last week, the cabinet secretary opened a debate on growing Scotland’s economy, which I know is a ...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport (Stephen Flynn) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
The member knows that the Government is committing to ensuring that there is a new train station at Winchburgh. We are continuing to work with West Lothian Council and Winchburgh Developments in that regard. I hope that I will be able to update the chamber in the not-too-dista...
Jenny Young (Central Scotland and Lothians West) (Lab) Lab Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on when construction work on Winchburgh train station will begin. (S7O-00062)
Gillian Martin SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
Mark Ruskell is absolutely right, and 2026 is a key year in that regard. Proposals for a long-term air quality policy framework will succeed the cleaner air for Scotland 2 strategy when it expires at the end of this year. We are developing those proposals, including assessing ...
Mark Ruskell (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green) Green Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
The science shows that even modest improvements in air quality result in significant improvements in health, particularly in disadvantaged communities. Will the Scottish Government be revising the current out-of-date air quality standards that we have in Scotland to reflect th...
Gillian Martin SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
I would welcome anything that the council decides to do in relation to where it puts its monitors and any pilot that it might want to go forward with. Improving air quality to protect the health of Scotland’s population, particularly children and young people, is a key priorit...
Heather Anderson SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
—in 30 of our primary schools, we do not know how safe our children are from damaging air pollution. Would the cabinet secretary welcome Dundee City Council piloting an air monitoring project at primary schools in our city?
The Presiding Officer NPA Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
Ask a question, please.
Heather Anderson SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
We know that there is a correlation between areas of high deprivation and poor air quality for children and adults, which exacerbates pre-existing health inequalities. We also know that children are among the most susceptible to harm from air pollution. In Dundee, we are lucky...
The Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Rural Affairs (Gillian Martin) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
The placement of air quality monitors is prioritised to cover potential air pollution hotspots. Additionally, over time, local authorities have progressively adapted their monitoring strategies to address specific local air quality issues. That approach ensures that any areas ...
Heather Anderson (Dundee City West) (SNP) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
I refer to my entry in the register of members’ interests and declare that I am a serving councillor on Dundee City Council.To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to calls from the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh for a national pilot programme to monitor ...
Màiri McAllan SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Queen’s Park Glasshouses
I restate that I understand the connection that is felt to the Queen’s park glasshouses. Anecdotally, they provided an important day out for my own family in the south side of Glasgow, and we want to see them continue to do so. I have set out my willingness to have discussions...
Paul Sweeney (Glasgow) (Lab) Lab Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Queen’s Park Glasshouses
The cabinet secretary outlined an array of funding options. Capital funding is certainly one aspect, but the challenge in the immediate term is ongoing revenue funding. That issue is a direct result of the Scottish Government’s disproportionate cuts to Glasgow City Council’s c...
The Presiding Officer (Kenneth Gibson) NPA Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Queen’s Park Glasshouses
Before I take a supplementary question from Paul Sweeney, I remind members that you should press your request-to-speak button only when you come to your question or wish to ask a supplementary question to someone else’s question. There are members who have pressed their button...
Màiri McAllan SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Queen’s Park Glasshouses
Holly Bruce will know that the Government understands the importance of those matters, which is demonstrated not least by the investment that we are committed to making in the People’s Palace in Glasgow. My colleague Tom Arthur will shortly update the Parliament on those plans...
Holly Bruce Green Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Queen’s Park Glasshouses
As the cabinet secretary knows, Glasgow faces a unique responsibility with its array of listed heritage buildings in council ownership, coupled with an acute lack of capital infrastructure funding. In Glasgow Southside, we are already navigating the devastating prolonged closu...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic (Màiri McAllan) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Queen’s Park Glasshouses
The Government appreciates the historic and community value of the Queen’s park glasshouses. Responsibility for their operation rests with Glasgow City Council. However, I am happy to engage with the council and with partners. Such discussions can include help to facilitate ac...
Stephen Flynn SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
It is important to place on record the important work that was undertaken by the former constituency member, Ms Hyslop, and by Mr Fairlie in his ministerial role. I look forward to working with the new constituency member to take forward the matter, and I am sure that we will ...
Pauline Stafford (Bathgate) (SNP) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
I refer members to my entry in the register of members’ interests, as I am an elected member of West Lothian Council.I welcome the Scottish Government’s clear commitment to delivering a Winchburgh station, including reference to it in this year’s budget statement and in the Sc...
Stephen Flynn SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
I would love to be in a position to do that here today. It is important to recognise that it is for West Lothian Council and Winchburgh Developments to take forward construction of a new station, but we are willing to engage with them in that process. They have already been in...
Jenny Young Lab Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
Currently, it takes more than an hour to get the bus from Winchburgh to central Edinburgh. That is a journey of under 15 miles. The train to Waverley would take around 15 minutes.Last week, the cabinet secretary opened a debate on growing Scotland’s economy, which I know is a ...
The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport (Stephen Flynn) SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
The member knows that the Government is committing to ensuring that there is a new train station at Winchburgh. We are continuing to work with West Lothian Council and Winchburgh Developments in that regard. I hope that I will be able to update the chamber in the not-too-dista...
Jenny Young (Central Scotland and Lothians West) (Lab) Lab Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Winchburgh Train Station
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on when construction work on Winchburgh train station will begin. (S7O-00062)
Gillian Martin SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
Mark Ruskell is absolutely right, and 2026 is a key year in that regard. Proposals for a long-term air quality policy framework will succeed the cleaner air for Scotland 2 strategy when it expires at the end of this year. We are developing those proposals, including assessing ...
Mark Ruskell (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green) Green Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
The science shows that even modest improvements in air quality result in significant improvements in health, particularly in disadvantaged communities. Will the Scottish Government be revising the current out-of-date air quality standards that we have in Scotland to reflect th...
Gillian Martin SNP Chamber
16 Jun 2026
General Question Time · Air Pollution Monitoring (City Primary Schools)
I would welcome anything that the council decides to do in relation to where it puts its monitors and any pilot that it might want to go forward with. Improving air quality to protect the health of Scotland’s population, particularly children and young people, is a key priorit...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament (Hybrid) 17 September 2020

17 Sep 2020 · S5 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Employment Support

I speak to my leader all the time, but I say to the minister that he is providing £60 million for 100,000 young people who are about to become unemployed. That is not enough; it is not the scale of the ambition that this country and our young people require.

In summary, I want the furlough scheme to be extended—of course I do—but I also want the Scottish Government to do three things. First, I want it to work with the Welsh Government and the regions and cities across the UK in the Alliance for Full Employment. Secondly, I want the scale of the Scottish Government’s response to be sufficient to meet the scale of the challenge that we face. It needs to set out how many young people will be helped, when, and the cost of that. Thirdly, there is huge urgency, but we have not seen the detail yet. How will young people apply? When will the scheme be open? Who will deliver on the ground? Will it be councils, Skills Development Scotland or private training providers? I hope that it will be all of them. When will we know the detail? Young people are unemployed now and many more will follow.

We are in a crisis that is about to get a whole lot worse. It is politically easy to blame the UK Government, but it is harder for the Scottish Government to do something itself. However, if we do not act quickly and at scale, we will let down a whole generation of young people.

I move amendment S5M-22731.1, to insert at end:

“; calls on the Scottish Government to act quickly to put in place a range of measures to support employment that are coherent and targeted at businesses at risk and those who find themselves out of work, in particular young people, women, disabled people and ethnic minorities; recognises the existing fragility and inequality in Scotland’s labour market, and calls on the Scottish Government to produce an industrial strategy that lays out increased investment in housebuilding, green energy and transport, to put Scotland back on track and ensure fairer, greener and sustainable jobs for all.”

15:55  
References in this contribution

Motions, questions or amendments mentioned by their reference code.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
The next item of business is a debate on S5M-22731, in the name of Jamie Hepburn, on employment support. I invite members who wish to speak in the debate to ...
The Minister for Business, Fair Work and Skills (Jamie Hepburn) SNP
Back in April, the Scottish Government welcomed the introduction of the United Kingdom’s job retention scheme. The furlough scheme has maintained the viabili...
Murdo Fraser (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con) Con
Will the member take an intervention?
Jamie Hepburn SNP
If Murdo Fraser can explain why that is a sensible thing to do, I will happily give way.
Murdo Fraser Con
I am grateful to the minister for giving way so early in his speech. At this early stage, I wanted him to set out on the record that the UK furlough scheme h...
Jamie Hepburn SNP
I am happy to concede that the UK furlough scheme has been an excellent initiative. That might be why I am here urging the UK Government to extend such a sen...
Willie Rennie (North East Fife) (LD) LD
I support the motion and the minister’s contribution so far. Back in June, the Parliament agreed to set out in financial terms the total sum of what the bene...
Jamie Hepburn SNP
Just yesterday, as I have alluded to, the chief economic adviser published a full assessment of the benefits of the introduction of the furlough scheme. I re...
Willie Rennie LD
Will the minister gave way?
Jamie Hepburn SNP
I am afraid not, Mr Rennie. I am happy to give way in closing. In calling for the UK Government to extend the furlough scheme, I recognise the role that thi...
Jackie Baillie (Dumbarton) (Lab) Lab
How many young people will the £60 million youth guarantee scheme provide for?
Jamie Hepburn SNP
The fundamental principle of the scheme is to guarantee every young person in Scotland the chance to get employment, education or training. I am not suggesti...
Maurice Golden (West Scotland) (Con) Con
No one should be under the illusion that we face anything less than a full-blown jobs crisis. The latest figures show that Scotland now has the highest unemp...
George Adam (Paisley) (SNP) SNP
I thank Maurice Golden for taking an intervention. I have just one point to make. Last week, in a debate in the House of Commons, the Chief Secretary to the ...
Maurice Golden Con
I thank George Adam for that intervention. If we listen to the SNP, the Scottish Government paper “COVID-19: Analysis of Extending the Coronavirus Job Reten...
Jamie Hepburn SNP
Will the member give way?
Maurice Golden Con
I am developing the theme. Spending more increases debt, potentially decreases the credit rating of the UK, will increase the cost of borrowing and risk stag...
Jamie Hepburn SNP
Maurice Golden recognises that we are not calling for the scheme to be extended for time without end, but are asking for a sensible extension to support peop...
Maurice Golden Con
The minister should understand the wider economic impact and—as I have mentioned—with regard to increasing borrowing, the risk to the overall deficit. Those ...
Maurice Golden Con
I am going to make progress. I also respect the minister’s and the cabinet secretary’s views on the furlough scheme. If they had listened to SNP back benche...
Keith Brown (Clackmannanshire and Dunblane) (SNP) SNP
Will the member take an intervention?
Maurice Golden Con
I take it that I do not have extra time, Presiding Officer.
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
I will give you extra time for interventions
Keith Brown SNP
I thank Maurice Golden for giving way. Does he agree with the Resolution Foundation, which has said that the job retention bonus “will not make a major diff...
Maurice Golden Con
Keith Brown, who during his tenure as minister presided over a disastrous economic strategy for Scotland, has a hard neck to try to lecture me on economics. ...
The Deputy Presiding Officer SNP
Do you wish to give way, Mr Golden?
Maurice Golden Con
No, I am going to make progress. More than 2,600 firms have received support worth almost £600 million from the coronavirus business interruption loan schem...
Jackie Baillie (Dumbarton) (Lab) Lab
I welcome the opportunity to discuss the support that is needed to help employers retain jobs across the UK and, where that is not possible, to help people w...
Jamie Hepburn SNP
If people approach us and let us know about things, we might consider co-operating with them.
Jackie Baillie Lab
I look forward—