Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
14
Parties on record
2,096,833
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,096,833 contributions. Latest 30 days: 2,655. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 09 Jun 2026.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2026
Wealth Taxation for Public Services
I regret that, like his colleague Mr Cole-Hamilton, Mr Rennie has perhaps not been listening to what I have said. To clarify on the record, I note that those are not the comments that I have made today.We need to look at other, broader opportunities to raise revenue in Scotlan...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2026
Wealth Taxation for Public Services
I am happy to do so for Mr Rennie.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2026
Wealth Taxation for Public Services
Okay. I would like to come back to Mr Marra in greater detail on that. I met the Scottish Fiscal Commission earlier today and we will continue that engagement. However, we are looking at a range of ways in which we can better engage with businesses. Mr Marra might be aware of ...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2026
Wealth Taxation for Public Services
I think that Mr Marra is referring to the Scottish Fiscal Commission.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2026
Wealth Taxation for Public Services
I will take Mr Marra, but I am conscious of the time.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2026
Wealth Taxation for Public Services
Mr Flynn has provided me with an analogy with the Laffer curve: it went up and then it fell back down. I am not sure whether Mr Kerr would agree with that analogy. I am more than happy to have a discussion with him and, of course, with Mr McKee, the Cabinet Secretary for Publi...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2026
Wealth Taxation for Public Services
As Mr McKee is whispering in my ear, the economy is growing faster in Scotland than in other parts of the United Kingdom. In part, that is a result of our approach to a progressive taxation system, which I will go on to talk about, because it benefits our society. I know that ...
The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
04 Jun 2026
Wealth Taxation for Public Services
I am conscious that the Minister for Public Finance, Hannah Mary Goodlad, will give her first speech in closing the debate. Hannah Mary’s victory in Shetland was one of the biggest highlights in the Scottish National Party’s recent election victory. Colleagues will have observ...
The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
02 Jun 2026
Decision Time
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. My app would not connect. I would have voted yes.
The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
02 Jun 2026
Decision Time
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. My app would not connect. I would have voted yes.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
26 May 2026
Independence Referendum
I am certainly happy to take away that ask from the member this afternoon.Julie MacDougall also made her initial speech in the chamber today. Going back to the kingdom of Fife, I note that she is the daughter of the former Labour MP for Glenrothes and that her father is fondly...
The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
26 May 2026
Independence Referendum
This is my first contribution in Parliament since the election, so I begin by placing on record my gratitude to the people of the Mid Fife and Glenrothes constituency for re-electing me to serve them in our national Parliament. It is a privilege for all of us to serve here, an...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
26 May 2026
Independence Referendum
I am certainly happy to take away that ask from the member this afternoon.Julie MacDougall also made her initial speech in the chamber today. Going back to the kingdom of Fife, I note that she is the daughter of the former Labour MP for Glenrothes and that her father is fondly...
The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
26 May 2026
Independence Referendum
This is my first contribution in Parliament since the election, so I begin by placing on record my gratitude to the people of the Mid Fife and Glenrothes constituency for re-electing me to serve them in our national Parliament. It is a privilege for all of us to serve here, an...
Jenny Gilruth (Mid Fife and Glenrothes) (SNP) SNP Chamber
14 May 2026
Oaths and Affirmations
I, Jennifer Madeleine Gilruth, do solemnly, sincerely and truly declare and affirm, that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law.
Jenny Gilruth (Mid Fife and Glenrothes) (SNP) SNP Chamber
14 May 2026
Oaths and Affirmations
I, Jennifer Madeleine Gilruth, do solemnly, sincerely and truly declare and affirm, that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law.
Jenny Gilruth (Mid Fife and Glenrothes) (SNP) SNP Chamber
14 May 2026
Oaths and Affirmations
I, Jennifer Madeleine Gilruth, do solemnly, sincerely and truly declare and affirm, that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
25 Mar 2026
Mobile Phone Use in Schools (Ban)
I apologise. However, I want to pay tribute to you, too, for your service to the people of Cowdenbeath. Laughter. I shared Mr Rennie’s smile as you advocated for Lochgelly health centre. You were always very supportive towards me when I was first elected 10 years ago, and you ...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
25 Mar 2026
Mobile Phone Use in Schools (Ban)
I remind Pam Gosal that the foreword from me at the front of the national guidance document makes it very clear that any headteacher will have my backing as cabinet secretary should they see fit to implement a ban but that, ultimately, the decision as to whether to do so is at...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
25 Mar 2026
Mobile Phone Use in Schools (Ban)
I very much recognise Mr Cole-Hamilton’s point, which is reflective of a growing ask from Parliament for more national direction. We saw that only yesterday with stage 3 of Mr Johnson’s Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill. On that topic, the Government had publi...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
25 Mar 2026
Mobile Phone Use in Schools (Ban)
I thank Pam Gosal for bringing this debate to Parliament and for sponsoring the recent round-table discussion on the topic, which I was pleased to attend, along with colleagues from across the Parliament.There is now a growing consensus on the issue. We all share concerns abou...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
24 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I start by making it absolutely clear that all of Scotland’s children deserve and have the right to feel safe in our schools. They should not be restrained or secluded. The only occasions on which that should be considered are when there is an immediate risk of injury to the c...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
24 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I thank Daniel Johnson for his commitment in bringing forward the legislation on restraint and seclusion that is before us today. I applaud his approach to working with the Government and I encourage more such good behaviour in the coming parliamentary session.The bill has bro...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2026
Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill: Stage 3
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. My app did not connect. I would have voted yes.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I have nothing further to add.Amendment 4 agreed to.Amendment 5 moved—Jenny Gilruth—and agreed to.Section 6—InterpretationAmendment 6 moved—Jenny Gilruth—and agreed to.Section 6B—Ancillary provisionAmendment 7 moved—Jenny Gilruth—and agreed to.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
Amendment 4 removes a provision that is now unnecessary because the same provision was made in another amendment that was agreed to at stage 2.Amendments 5 and 7 add a power to modify enactments to two of the regulation-making powers in the bill where that is necessary to ensu...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I have nothing further to add.Amendment 2 agreed to.Section 3—Duty to inform parents of use of restraint or seclusionAmendment 3 moved—Jenny Gilruth—agreed to.Section 4—Duty to record and report on use of restraint and seclusion
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
Amendment 2 is a minor amendment to allow consultation on the first set of statutory guidance to begin before relevant sections in the bill are brought into force. It provides ministers with flexibility on that matter and will benefit the Government’s engagement with stakehold...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
This morning, I met the EIS and AHDS, as well as the other teaching trade unions, and I talked to some of their concerns in this area. It is the case that, through the statutory guidance that will be in place, there will require to be a level of consultation with the trade uni...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
I thank John Mason for lodging amendment 1. The regulation-making power will be used by ministers only where they consider it necessary to ensure that the definitions capture only actions that carry a significant risk of harm. Further safeguards are provided, in that ministers...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2026
General Question Time · Pupil Support Assistants (Additional Support for Learning)
Mr Balfour raises a hugely important point. He is absolutely correct to say that additional support needs in our schools have grown in recent years. That has been driven, in part, by greater identification, but it has also been driven by increasing complexity in the support ne...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
19 Mar 2026
General Question Time · Pupil Support Assistants (Additional Support for Learning)
All children and young people should get the support that they need to reach their full potential. The latest figures show that there are 17,046 full-time-equivalent pupil support assistants in Scotland. That is the second-highest level on record and an increase of nearly 1,80...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
17 Mar 2026
Decision Time
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. My app would not connect. I would have voted yes.
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
17 Mar 2026
Non-surgical Procedures and Functions of Medical Reviewers (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. My app would not connect. I would have voted no.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
12 Mar 2026
Portfolio Question Time · Schools (Violent and Disruptive Incidents)
When we talk about behaviour in schools, we need to be careful, as we are not seeking to demonise the next generation. The majority of children and young people in Scotland’s schools are well behaved; the behaviour in Scottish schools research documented that. However, it also...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
12 Mar 2026
Portfolio Question Time · Schools (Violent and Disruptive Incidents)
I thank Mr Kerr for his question and for his general interest in the topic during the current parliamentary session, which led to some of the work that I detailed in my original answer.The member raises an important point in relation to the use of data in Scottish education. W...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
12 Mar 2026
Portfolio Question Time · Schools (Violent and Disruptive Incidents)
There is no place for violence and abuse in Scotland’s schools. We continue to implement our relationships and behaviour in schools action plan, working with partners including the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and the teaching trade unions, and I will shortly publi...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
12 Mar 2026
Portfolio Question Time · School Provision and Safe Travel Routes (Robroyston)
It seems that there is an issue that is localised to Robroyston. I can ask officials to engage with Glasgow City Council. I place on record that the statutory responsibility rests with the local authority and that ministers are extremely limited in the actions that we can take...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
12 Mar 2026
Portfolio Question Time · School Provision and Safe Travel Routes (Robroyston)
The Scottish Government recognises the strength of community concern about the provision of school places and the safety of walking routes in Robroyston. Responsibility for managing the school estate and for assessing the safety of walking routes rests with Glasgow City Counci...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
12 Mar 2026
Portfolio Question Time · School Investment Programmes (Cumbernauld and Kilsyth)
I very much agree with what Jamie Hepburn said about the difference that this Government’s investment has made in his constituency at Cumbernauld academy and Greenfaulds high school, and about the importance of having high-quality, well-ventilated learning environments across ...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
12 Mar 2026
Portfolio Question Time · School Investment Programmes (Cumbernauld and Kilsyth)
Through the Scotland’s schools for the future programme, we awarded North Lanarkshire Council significant funding of £42 million towards the Cumbernauld academy and Greenfaulds high school projects in the Cumbernauld and Kilsyth constituency. In North Lanarkshire more widely, ...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
05 Mar 2026
General Question Time · Secondary School Leavers (Positive Destinations)
I thank Mr Whittle for his warm welcome for Scottish apprenticeship week. I am sure that he was out visiting a local business in his area, as I was in my area, and supporting the important work of apprentices in our communities.The Government’s budget, which Mr Whittle was not...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
05 Mar 2026
General Question Time · Secondary School Leavers (Positive Destinations)
Last week’s data publication showed that the percentage of school leavers in a positive destination three months after the end of the school year was 95.7 per cent, which is the second-highest figure on record. Our most recent Scottish Qualifications Authority exam results sho...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Mar 2026
Education
I accept that the debate is about the Government’s record on education. I listened to some of Roz McCall’s points on outcomes, but it is important to record that the recent statistics on outcomes for our primary pupils show that the proportion of pupils who achieve expected cu...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Mar 2026
Education
I am happy to do so.
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Mar 2026
Education
In this debate, I was keen to praise the positive behaviour of children. If everything is framed through a negative lens, all that it does is risk demoralising parents, pupils and teachers. Karen Adam was absolutely right about that. We need to be mindful of how we characteris...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Mar 2026
Education
I very much recognise that point, and I know that Mr Cole-Hamilton recently raised it at First Minister’s question time. To give him some assurance, I note that we have convened a national working group on the issue, involving the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, the ...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
04 Mar 2026
Education
I will come to the points that Mr Rennie has addressed in his motion, but I have more praise for him first, which it is important for him to hear.I am also grateful to Willie Rennie for his collegiate contributions to the cross-party review of additional support needs, particu...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Chamber
04 Mar 2026
Education
In what is all but guaranteed to be the last education debate in this session of Parliament, I begin by paying tribute to Scotland’s children and young people.This is the generation who experienced their education in the teeth of a global pandemic. The upset caused by Covid an...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Committee
04 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
:As drafted, section 5 would require ministers to maintain and publish a list of approved training providers and the details of their courses. However, there are already well-recognised and established national frameworks and training standards in place, including the Restrain...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Committee
04 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
:Amendments 19 and 20 make simple but important changes to the reporting arrangements in section 4. Under the bill as introduced, independent and grant-aided schools would be required to submit their data on restraint and seclusion incidents to the education authority in whose...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Committee
04 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
:I thank Daniel Johnson for these pragmatic amendments. Amendments 29 and 30 are standard provisions, ensuring that the bill works as intended in the light of changes made by other amendments. I am happy to support them.I am also pleased that, having discussed the question of ...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Committee
04 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
:I welcome the amendments in the group, which strengthen the notification requirements in section 3, which were discussed during stage 1. They ensure that there are clear and robust timelines for reporting of incidents. At present, the bill requires schools to notify parents o...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Committee
04 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
:Amendment 10 is an important amendment that adds children and young people to the list of statutory consultees with whom ministers must engage before issuing or revising guidance under section 2. The bill already requires consultation with education providers, parents’ repres...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Committee
04 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
:These amendments are technical in nature, but they carry meaningful implications, by guaranteeing that all pupils are afforded the same protections by the bill. The issue was raised with Daniel Johnson by the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, as has been ment...
The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Jenny Gilruth) SNP Committee
04 Mar 2026
Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
I thank Daniel Johnson for working with me to lodge a package of amendments that will strengthen the bill. The amendments on the definition of restraint were requested by the committee and by stakeholders because the original one that was used in the bill was considered to be ...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
25 Feb 2026
Protecting Children from Harm
I recognise the challenge in the points that Mr Mason raises. He will recognise, too, the limitations that are put on the Government by the Inquiries Act 2005 in relation to costs and stipulating timescales. However, to give assurance, I have discussed those matters with Alexi...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
25 Feb 2026
Protecting Children from Harm
As Audrey Nicoll knows, Police Scotland has a well-established specialist capability in that area, including officers and staff who are specifically trained in child protection, sexual abuse investigations and trauma-informed engagement.The Government recognises the scale and ...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
25 Feb 2026
Protecting Children from Harm
I hope that Meghan Gallacher welcomes the announcement today. I agree with her sentiment that any inquiry needs to be fearless and transparent and to have victims at its heart—that is exactly the approach that I have taken throughout the process.The member mentioned the Citize...
Jenny Gilruth SNP Chamber
25 Feb 2026
Protecting Children from Harm
I very much agree with the sentiment behind Ms Harper’s question. The timescales for an independent statutory inquiry rightly require dialogue with the independent chair, which has to take into account the draft terms of reference and the Inquiries Act 2005. From my discussion...
← Back to list
Chamber

Meeting of the Parliament 04 June 2026 [Draft]

04 Jun 2026 · S7 · Meeting of the Parliament
Item of business
Wealth Taxation for Public Services
Gilruth, Jenny SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes Watch on SPTV

I regret that, like his colleague Mr Cole-Hamilton, Mr Rennie has perhaps not been listening to what I have said. To clarify on the record, I note that those are not the comments that I have made today.

We need to look at other, broader opportunities to raise revenue in Scotland. There is a significant fiscal challenge ahead of the Government; the Opposition is well aware of that. I have seen Mr Rennie’s amendment to the motion, which is very critical of where we are currently. However, we exist in a Parliament of minorities, so we have to work together to address the budget gap. That is why Mr McKee’s role is so pivotal in terms of the efficiencies and reform that he will have to drive.

More broadly, the Government believes that those who enjoy the privilege of travelling on private jets should make a fairer contribution to the public finances, but we want to go further, which is why we are seeking the devolution of further powers to address the issue of private jet ghost flights. When a private jet completes a one-way trip, it often flies on to its next location with no passengers. Air departure tax is a tax on the carriage of passengers, so such flights would be exempt from it. However, those flights still produce emissions and support the activity of the super-wealthy. With estimates suggesting that up to 41 per cent of private jet flights take off without passengers, it is only right that we explore every possible opportunity to bring that activity into the scope of our progressive taxation system, and we call on the UK Government to devolve the powers to allow us to do so.

We are improving fairness at the top end of the council tax system, which is allowing us to raise additional funding to support our public services. Currently, some high-value properties face council tax bills that are not materially different from those for far more modest homes. From April 2028, we will introduce new council tax bands for properties that are worth more than £1 million.

In our tax strategy, we have committed to exploring the reforms that are needed to continue to deliver more sustainable and growing tax revenues in the future. That includes considering the balance of taxes across labour, income and wealth that I alluded to previously.

To shape those next steps, we are opening up a broad, evidence-based conversation on how Scotland can tax wealth more effectively, bringing together experts and stakeholders from across the country. That work will look at new approaches to wealth taxation and at the opportunities and challenges for a fairer and more sustainable tax system. I extend an invitation to the Opposition to work with the Government on that and to be part of the broader discussion, so that we can find consensus as a Parliament on those matters.

We know that meaningful reform of wealth taxation in Scotland would need significant co-operation from the UK Government and a fundamental change in relation to where the powers sit. Indeed, as the Scottish Green Party acknowledged in its manifesto, the prospect of a Scottish wealth tax would be feasible only with independence—or at least with the agreement of the UK Government to further devolve those powers. Of course, the Scottish Government would far rather that those tax powers were devolved back to Scotland, because an independent Scotland would give us the power to redesign—with the people and businesses of Scotland—our wealth taxation and other far-outdated taxes to work more effectively.

The pressures on our public finances are real, and the constraints on what we can currently achieve are significant. I ask parties to engage constructively and openly with the Government about what further steps we can take to consider the right balance of taxation for Scotland. The Government is committed to ambitious reform to reduce costs while increasing the effectiveness of our public services and achieving better outcomes for our citizens.

What I am asking the Parliament to do today is to empower us to continue to implement a progressive taxation system—a system that asks the wealthiest to pay their fair share while helping the poorest to make ends meet, which supports our businesses to drive the economic growth that is needed and which allows us to deliver better public services for our people while supporting those who are most in need.

I move,

That the Parliament believes in fair, progressive and sustainable taxation to support the delivery of public services; welcomes the progress made towards the creation of a private jet tax and a mansion tax; supports actions to go further and seek the powers necessary to take action on so-called ghost flights of private planes; recognises that Scotland’s current powers limit the scope for additional wealth taxation, and endorses the Scottish Government’s plans to explore what further steps could be taken either within the current system or with full fiscal powers.

In the same item of business

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Katy Clark) Lab
The next item of business is a debate on motion S7M-00249, in the name of Jenny Gilruth, on wealth taxation for public services. I invite members who wish to...
The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government (Jenny Gilruth) SNP
I am conscious that the Minister for Public Finance, Hannah Mary Goodlad, will give her first speech in closing the debate. Hannah Mary’s victory in Shetland...
Craig Hoy (Dumfriesshire) (Con) Con
I welcome the minister to her new role. How does she explain Scotland’s economic performance gap?
Jenny Gilruth SNP
As Mr McKee is whispering in my ear, the economy is growing faster in Scotland than in other parts of the United Kingdom. In part, that is a result of our ap...
Liam Kerr (North East Scotland) (Con) Con
One of the minister’s predecessors was famously completely unaware of the principles of the Laffer curve. What is her view on that theory and whether it impa...
Jenny Gilruth SNP
Mr Flynn has provided me with an analogy with the Laffer curve: it went up and then it fell back down. I am not sure whether Mr Kerr would agree with that an...
Michael Marra (North East Scotland) (Lab) Lab
Will the Deputy First Minister take an intervention?
Jenny Gilruth SNP
I will take Mr Marra, but I am conscious of the time.
Michael Marra Lab
I appreciate that the Deputy First Minister has given way. In these matters, she and her predecessors have taken advice from a tax advisory group. Can she up...
Jenny Gilruth SNP
I think that Mr Marra is referring to the Scottish Fiscal Commission.
Michael Marra Lab
No—the tax advisory group.
Jenny Gilruth SNP
Okay. I would like to come back to Mr Marra in greater detail on that. I met the Scottish Fiscal Commission earlier today and we will continue that engagemen...
Willie Rennie (Fife North East) (LD) LD
Will the cabinet secretary give way?
Jenny Gilruth SNP
I am happy to do so for Mr Rennie.
Willie Rennie LD
I have been listening carefully to the cabinet secretary’s contribution. She has, in passing, referenced the challenging fiscal set-up, but most of what she ...
Jenny Gilruth SNP
I regret that, like his colleague Mr Cole-Hamilton, Mr Rennie has perhaps not been listening to what I have said. To clarify on the record, I note that those...
The Deputy Presiding Officer (Katy Clark) Lab
I remind colleagues that there should be no interventions or interruptions during a first speech. I call Kim Schmulian to speak to and move amendment S7M-002...
Kim Schmulian (Glasgow) (Reform) Reform
Thank you, Deputy Presiding Officer. I join other members in welcoming you and your colleagues to your new roles.I congratulate those members who have been r...
Michael Marra (North East Scotland) (Lab) Lab
Labour welcomes the early opportunity to debate the scale of the fiscal challenge that the SNP has created for Scotland. The £4.7 billion gap between the spe...
The Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform (Ivan McKee) SNP
Will the member take an intervention?
Michael Marra Lab
No, thank you. I am just getting started.We might all wish that the process would involve addressing the drug deaths crisis, which is the worst in the develo...
Ivan McKee SNP
Mr Marra said that the fiscal gap is a consequence of the Government’s spending plans and that we have no plan for addressing it. I think that he is wrong on...
Michael Marra Lab
I would certainly have to differ with Mr McKee on some of the analysis. The demand on our public services is recognised. It is clear from many reports by the...
Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green) Green
This is my first opportunity on the record to congratulate the new Deputy First Minister on her appointment. I am pleased that she has chosen to debate this ...
Craig Hoy Con
Would Patrick Harvie concede the point that the very wealthy are also likely to be the most mobile and that they can therefore take their wealth and their as...
Patrick Harvie Green
If the member reads the briefing that I have just mentioned, he will see that the vast majority of millionaires who were canvassed by that organisation are m...
Craig Hoy (Dumfriesshire) (Con) Con
I think that we all know why this debate is taking place: the SNP Government and John Swinney are in hock to the Scottish Green Party. A party that does not ...
Patrick Harvie Green
I am grateful to the member for taking my intervention. Does he agree in principle that abolishing poverty is a legitimate reason to impose taxation on those...
Craig Hoy Con
Growing the economy is the legitimate way of eradicating poverty. If we grew the economy, we would not need the burgeoning benefits bill that the SNP has pre...
Daniel Johnson (Edinburgh Southern) (Lab) Lab
Will the member take an intervention?