Holyrood, made browsable

Hansard

Every contribution to the Official Report — chamber and committee — searchable in one place. Pulled from data.parliament.scot, indexed for full-text search, linked through to every MSP.

129
Current MSPs
415
MSPs ever elected
14
Parties on record
2,096,833
Hansard contributions
1999–2026
Coverage span
Official Report

Search Hansard contributions

Showing 60 of 2,096,833 contributions. Latest 30 days: 2,655. Coverage: 12 May 1999 — 09 Jun 2026.
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
27 Mar 2003
Great Northern Partnership
I am pleased to introduce the debate today, which is almost our last debate.The Great Northern Partnership is one of 48 social inclusion partnerships that were formed to address social exclusion in Scotland. Social inclusion partnerships come in all shapes and sizes; some are ...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
18 Mar 2003
Railways and Transport Safety Bill
I am sure that many people will welcome the bill, which will go a long way towards improving maritime safety. The minister will be well aware of the difficulties with drug and alcohol misuse in some north-east villages and towns. The bill will be helpful in that regard.However...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
06 Mar 2003
Question Time · Drugs and Alcohol Misuse
I have been approached by several constituents who look after their grandchildren on a temporary or permanent basis because the parents have chaotic lifestyles as a result of drug misuse. Sadly, in some cases, the parents have died. What further measures will be considered to ...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
05 Mar 2003
Transport
I welcome the minister's statement. I know that the people of Aberdeen, especially my constituents, are delighted with the commitment to build the western peripheral route as part of Aberdeen's integrated modern transport system. That is a real example of delivery by the Execu...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
05 Mar 2003
Subordinate Legislation
On the way to the Parliament this morning, I spoke to several people who, on hearing that we were debating fishing this morning, all said the same thing: "If there aren't enough fish, we have to cut back on fishing." The statutory instruments that we are debating are harsh. Th...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
05 Mar 2003
Subordinate Legislation
Will Alex Fergusson give way?
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
27 Feb 2003
Prostitution Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Prostitution has been with us for a long time, but that is not to say that we should not acknowledge and tackle some of the underlying causes that lead women to enter prostitution. Those causes are, as Trish Godman eloquently said, physical, sexual and emotional abuse, togethe...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Financial Scrutiny Review
By September or October, committees will be able to see clearly whether the recommendations have been adopted.
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Financial Scrutiny Review
So, in the spending review year, the March/April strategy document would be the primary part of the two-year process and would drive everything else, because it would drive all the discussions.
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Financial Scrutiny Review
I am looking at the proposal for the spending review in paragraph 31 of Arthur Midwinter's paper. Am I right in thinking that you are proposing that, instead of a fairly intensive stage 1 and stage 2 under our three-stage budget process, the bulk of the subject committees' wor...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Cross-cutting Reviews
It would be helpful for us to make recommendations, but it will be up to the new committee to decide what it wants to do.I suggest the economic development option and also potentially the sustainable development one. I have sat on both the Finance Committee and on the Enterpri...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Subordinate Legislation
Article 2(5)(o) shows an increase from £633 million to £816 million. That applies to the finance and central services department.
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Subordinate Legislation
I am pleased to hear that.There is an increase under article 2(5)(g) from £5 million to £250 million. That relates to the Scottish Executive development department.
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Subordinate Legislation
I hope that that will make things more straightforward and easy to follow.
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Subordinate Legislation
I would like some more detail on a number of points. Article 2(5)(b), which applies to the Scottish Executive environment and rural affairs department and relates to schedule 2 to the act, shows an increase from £21.4 million to £431 million, which is obviously very substantia...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Intermediary Technology Institutes
You are probably aware that, as an Aberdeen MSP, I am most interested in the energy ITI. Yesterday, Brian Wilson announced the results of the energy review and made some very significant statements about future United Kingdom energy policy. He talked about moving towards using...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Intermediary Technology Institutes
I have another question about companies' being able to access R and D funding. An issue related to proof-of-concept funding, which has been hugely successful, has been flagged up to me. I understand that proof-of-concept funding can be taken up only by higher education institu...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Intermediary Technology Institutes
Good afternoon, Janet. I am sorry that I missed your presentation, although of course I have had the benefit of hearing it once or twice before.To a certain extent, Adam Ingram has covered the area that I wanted to talk about. A significant investment is being made, which I ho...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
25 Feb 2003
Intermediary Technology Institutes
It is nice to be back in the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee, if only temporarily.
Elaine Thomson: Lab Chamber
19 Feb 2003
Fisheries
No. I am running out of time.The original proposal would have allowed fishing for only eight days a month. It was also made clear yesterday that the European Commission is willing to work with the Scottish Executive and others to modify and make more flexible the days-at-sea r...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Chamber
19 Feb 2003
Fisheries
Both those countries are involved in fishing and, as they are part of the EU, they have a right to be involved in discussions on fishing. The proposals for a complete ban or an 80 per cent cut were opposed by both UK and Scottish ministers because they would undoubtedly guaran...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Chamber
19 Feb 2003
Fisheries
I am just going to move on to what really happened at the European negotiations, which was made clear to Mr Lochhead and others who attended the Rural Development Committee meeting yesterday. Mr Lochhead has accused Scotland and the UK of being unable to win over enough EU cou...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Chamber
19 Feb 2003
Fisheries
No—I am not even out of my first minute yet.Once again, the SNP has come to the chamber with no real answers and the same old arguments about the constitution and who leads the delegation. What is really at stake is the future of the Scottish fishing industry, and that is what...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
19 Feb 2003
Fisheries
The solitary point of agreement between Richard Lochhead and me is that the white-fish industry is undoubtedly facing its greatest crisis for a generation. However, there we part company. It is clear that any decisions that are made now must focus on ensuring that the Scottish...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
19 Feb 2003
Fisheries
Could the member clarify whether the Tory party is proposing an immediate withdrawal from the European Union?
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
18 Feb 2003
Telecoms Developments
It does not sound as though communities located near masts can hold out much hope for their removal.On a completely different topic, some of the witnesses who gave evidence to us two weeks ago suggested that there was a link between the ease of roll-out of mobile and third-gen...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
18 Feb 2003
Telecoms Developments
I would like to pursue that issue. What would happen if some of the equipment became dangerous as well as unsightly? Is there not an obligation on someone—even if it is only the landowner—to ensure that the equipment is safe?
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
18 Feb 2003
Telecoms Developments
My question is about redundant masts. There is a general issue of how the planning system may be used to ensure that when masts reach the end of their useful life they can be replaced. Technology moves on and changes in the style, size and type of masts have an impact. It is l...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
18 Feb 2003
Scottish Fishing Industry
What assistance will be given to the processing sector to see it through this difficult period? Will consideration be given to the levy to sustain the Sea Fish Industry Authority, cuts in rates and assistance with the recruitment and retention of staff?
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
18 Feb 2003
Scottish Fishing Industry
Fish processing is another vital aspect of the overall fishing industry. It supports many thousands of jobs throughout Scotland and a large number in Aberdeen, which I represent. It is vital to the sustainability of our fishing industry that we be able to sustain the fish proc...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
18 Feb 2003
Scottish Fishing Industry
Haddock obviously had a big year class around 1999, but I understand that it has had small year classes since. Will ICES do some extra work to examine the future for haddock?
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
18 Feb 2003
Scottish Fishing Industry
I have one final little question.
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
18 Feb 2003
Scottish Fishing Industry
On the final decision, we moved from an initial recommendation that there be a complete ban to one that there be a 65 per cent reduction in fishing mortality. That decision must present a much higher risk that cod stocks and some of the other associated white-fish stocks might...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
18 Feb 2003
Scottish Fishing Industry
As a visiting member, I thank the convener for allowing me to ask a question. Given that I am not an expert, members will have to forgive me if my questions come across as being fairly simplistic. I want to expand on some of the points that Rhoda Grant made about the advice th...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
13 Feb 2003
Question Time · Rail Services (Aberdeen and the North-east)
How does the minister see the proposed Aberdeen crossrail scheme complementing the western peripheral route, to which the First Minister made a very welcome commitment when he was in Aberdeen recently? Both are part of the modern transport system that is being developed for Ab...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
11 Feb 2003
Holyrood Project
Do the builders move out at the end of November? Does the management of the building then move away to a large extent from the project management team that is building it? The management will then fall to you, because it is beginning to be run as the parliamentary complex.
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
11 Feb 2003
Budget Documents 2003-04
I agree that although, increasingly, we have large documents with lots of numbers in them, sometimes the information they contain is not particularly accessible, especially to the wider public. Originally, we tried to produce a short, snappy view of the Scottish budget. I know...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
05 Feb 2003
Telecoms Developments
You said that there is slightly less investment going on across Europe than there is in the UK. If that is maintained, and if more investment is encouraged in Scotland, that could give the UK a slight advantage in the use of 3G technology when things pick up again.
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
05 Feb 2003
Telecoms Developments
If I understand you correctly, you are saying that, because the regulatory regimes in Scotland and England differ, if only slightly, we are at a disadvantage in a scarce market for investment. Even the fact that companies have to submit planning applications appears to put the...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
30 Jan 2003
Budget (Scotland) (No 4) Bill: Stage 1
This year there is record growth in the Scottish budget, which is continuing to deliver the required investment in public services that benefit everyone in Scotland. As Wendy Alexander and George Lyon said, we are seeing the highest real-terms sustained growth in the Scottish ...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
30 Jan 2003
Budget (Scotland) (No 4) Bill: Stage 1
Will the member admit that some of the Scottish Executive's policies, such as education maintenance allowances, have been introduced precisely to address the concerns that he raises? Does he welcome such measures?
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
28 Jan 2003
Invitation
It is important that the committee be represented. If the convener is able to take up the invitation, he should attend.
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
28 Jan 2003
Budget Setting and Financial Scrutiny
As the convener says, the report is interesting. Longer planning horizons have been discussed on and off over the past three or four years. Are you suggesting that in order to fit in with the spending review, which has undoubtedly caused a number of difficulties in scrutiny of...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
22 Jan 2003
Subordinate Legislation
I want to ask about the implementation of the directive in Scotland compared with implementation in the rest of the UK. Are we using different criteria or cut-off levels? Some people seem to be suggesting that the implementation of the directive in Scotland is weaker than it i...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
22 Jan 2003
Subordinate Legislation
As Bruce Crawford said, no committee member disagrees with protecting land and ensuring that anything that will suffer from nitrate pollution is dealt with. However, the process for designating an area that is at risk must be clear. People must be able to say that if the level...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
22 Jan 2003
Subordinate Legislation
Bruce Crawford has asked questions about matters that I wanted to discuss. I wonder whether the witnesses agree that openness, transparency and a level playing field are important in applying European directives and that it is important that, if there is a scientific process, ...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Chamber
16 Jan 2003
Question Time · Quality-of-life Issues
Is the minister aware of the innovative scheme in Middlefield in my constituency of Aberdeen North, which the Minister for Social Justice visited this week? The scheme involves community wardens who help to clean up the streets by speeding up the removal of abandoned cars and ...
5. Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
16 Jan 2003
Question Time · Quality-of-life Issues
To ask the Scottish Executive what progress it has made in tackling issues that affect the quality of people's lives such as litter and abandoned cars. (S1O-6254)
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
16 Jan 2003
Question Time · Sports Facilities (Winter Use)
Is the minister aware of the situation that will face curlers in my constituency and elsewhere in the north-east following the closure of the only curling rink in the region? Will he, perhaps with sportscotland, examine in more detail the options that were presented by the Abe...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
15 Jan 2003
Rail Industry
I joined the Transport and the Environment Committee only recently, so I was not a member during its deliberations on the rail industry. However, the committee has clearly made a number of useful recommendations on the future of rail in Scotland, for which it is to be commende...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
09 Jan 2003
Question Time · Fishing Communities (Aid)
The minister will be aware of the concerns of the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea about the poor recruitment to haddock stocks since 1999, which was the last good year, and about the possibility that that will lead to a sudden collapse of haddock stocks ne...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
08 Jan 2003
Fisheries
It is very clear that this year's negotiations have been exceptionally difficult. The UK Parliament and Scottish Executive ministers have fought hard to get what they could out of the negotiations and there have been some achievements, particularly in relation to CFP reform.Ho...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Committee
08 Jan 2003
Building (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
I support amendment 107. Following a fire in Aberdeen, the Poundstretcher building in Union Street was left in a dangerous condition. Although the owners of the property collected insurance money, they failed to carry out repairs to return the building to a safe condition, wit...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Chamber
19 Dec 2002
Question Time · Intermediate Technology Institutes
All in Aberdeen and the north-east are delighted that the new energy institute will be located in Aberdeen and will benefit from being close to the oil and gas industry there. The institute will also be able to build on the emerging work on renewables. Will the minister assure...
16. Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
19 Dec 2002
Question Time · Intermediate Technology Institutes
To ask the Scottish Executive what role the new intermediate technology institutes will have in encouraging new businesses and high-quality jobs. (S1O-6140)
Elaine Thomson: Lab Chamber
19 Dec 2002
Budget Process 2003-04: Stage 2
I think that I touched on cumulative accounting earlier, and the matter has been discussed fully this morning. I am sure that we will continue to discuss the best methods of presenting financial figures over time.Despite having reservations in certain areas, the Finance Commit...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
19 Dec 2002
Budget Process 2003-04: Stage 2
The debate brings us to the end of stage 2 of this year's budget process. It has been an interesting morning. Thoughtful contributions have been made by many members—even those who were out late last night.This is the third full year of the complete budget cycle. The cycle con...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab Chamber
19 Dec 2002
Budget Process 2003-04: Stage 2
I am always keen to talk about Aberdeen transport issues. David Davidson said that the Aberdeen crossrail project would be a good thing. Do the Tories recognise that it is one project, among many, that the Scottish Executive has got absolutely right?
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
17 Dec 2002
Commissioner for Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill
I accept your points about the independence of the commissioner and the need to be child friendly, which demands colourful and imaginative materials to attract children's attention. Nevertheless, there are a number of back-office functions such as HR and IT support, to which t...
Elaine Thomson: Lab Committee
17 Dec 2002
Commissioner for Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill
Given that we are talking about a parliamentary appointment, the funding will come out of the SPCB's budget. I wonder whether there are opportunities for the Parliament to supply some of the services that the new body will require. We have mentioned the recruitment costs. Do o...
← Back to list
Chamber

Plenary, 27 Mar 2003

27 Mar 2003 · S1 · Plenary
Item of business
Great Northern Partnership
I am pleased to introduce the debate today, which is almost our last debate.

The Great Northern Partnership is one of 48 social inclusion partnerships that were formed to address social exclusion in Scotland. Social inclusion partnerships come in all shapes and sizes; some are based on geographical areas and some are thematic. The GNP is a geographic SIP and is unusual because it is in an archipelago that is made up of four islands that are all in the northern part of Aberdeen. The four areas comprise: Middlefield; Printfield; Alexander and Hayton; and Ferrier and Sandilands. However, all share the same problems of social exclusion and a combination of high unemployment, poor skills, low incomes, poor housing, high crime, poor health and high rates of family breakdown. That combination of disadvantage not only causes deprivation but has an impact on the ability of communities to exercise their full citizenship rights and to participate fully in wider society.

Aberdeen is a city with almost the lowest unemployment rate in Scotland, and it has higher than average incomes. Compared to many areas of Scotland it also has better health. Therefore the situation of those communities that do not share that prosperity is made all the more difficult. In Middlefield, which is the largest of the areas and which is in my constituency, the health statistics are sharply different from those for the rest of the city. Those statistics put that area in the worst 10 per cent in Scotland.

Characteristics of the GNP areas are a high number of children and young people and a higher-than-average number of single parents. Some 53 per cent of children in Middlefield are living in households with benefit-dependent parents—that is double the percentage of families with children living on income support in the rest of Aberdeen.

However, over the past four years the GNP has begun to address many of those issues. It has very high levels of community involvement in each of the four areas that make up the partnership. The aims of the GNP are to work to improve the social, economic and physical environment of those areas and to bring together effectively all the different agencies and organisations that can help to change them. Crucial to everything is ensuring that those who live in the GNP areas are involved—that communities are consulted and listened to—so that people in those communities are empowered through participation and training to take on leadership roles. It is important to ensure that they play a central part in identifying priorities and developing strategies for the many different types of work that the GNP undertakes. The aim is to restore and promote people's sense of citizenship and pride in where they live.

A high proportion of community representatives are involved at all levels of the GNP. Sixteen out of 28 board members—55 per cent of the total membership—are community representatives, four from each area. All but one of the sub-groups of the GNP are chaired by community representatives. I acknowledge the immense amount of work that people from those communities have contributed to the GNP, and I acknowledge the work of others, including local councillors such as Councillor Gordon Graham, the current vice-chair of the GNP, who stood in as chair before the new chair, Dawn Galashin, was appointed.

When I asked what difference the GNP makes, Dawn said that it

"Makes it better for local folk to make decisions and the ability to challenge agencies providing services within the area. We also have the ability to make funding decisions at a local level".

There are many different areas in which the GNP and all the other agencies involved are beginning to make a difference—for example, in tackling drug misuse. The level of drug misuse is high throughout Aberdeen, but it is higher than average in the GNP areas. The GNP set up a people's jury to consider how the quality of life for individuals and families in communities that are affected by drugs can be improved, which led to a specific GNP drugs plan. The GNP is now a member of the Aberdeen drug action team, ensuring that projects and strategies reflect accurately the particular issues that GNP communities face. There are projects such as "Give Kids a Chance", a community referral scheme that aims to divert young people away from drug and alcohol misuse.

The GNP is also working with other organisations, such as Aberdeen Drugs Action, to provide an outreach service. This weekend, a group will travel to Preston to see an innovative needle-exchange programme.

The activities of the GNP reach out into many different areas, such as health and providing support for parents and young children. Middlefield is well known for possessing a "healthy hoose", which is staffed by nurse practitioners who provide advice and help on a range of issues, from healthy eating to encouraging breast feeding and providing better local access to general practitioners. That is complemented by other projects such as Healthy Roots, which aims to turn disused allotment land into community gardens. The project has recently got its lease and it will move on to a new phase.

Early intervention is seen as vital; the GNP works to reduce teenage pregnancies and cases of low-birth-weight babies. The "baby, think it over" project uses realistic baby models with microchips to bring home the reality of the responsibilities of early parenthood. Addressing the needs of children with special needs is also important, as is working to close the opportunity gap that exists for so many children.

The important new community schools work with many of the GNP projects. Some exist at primary level and others, at primary and secondary level, will be rebuilt or refurbished over the next few years.

The disparity in opportunity between areas cannot be overemphasised. The rate of pupils moving on to higher and further education varies from just over 10 per cent in some areas to over 90 per cent in others. That makes the presence of the University of Aberdeen and of communities and children working to encourage higher rates of participation all the more important. Also in Middlefield is the learning house, run by Scottish Enterprise, which is complemented by learning projects elsewhere. It provides access to learning for families, and is building the confidence of people who have often had negative experiences of school.

I could mention many other aspects of the work of the GNP. However, the role of the great northern partnership and other SIPs is vital in promoting social inclusion. I am delighted that it will share in the £60 million that the Scottish Executive has committed to social inclusion partnerships this year. That will involve communities, ensure that all the different agencies in the public and voluntary sector work together in a holistic and cohesive way, improve life and widen opportunity in Scotland's less advantaged communities. I commend the contribution that the GNP has made and continues to make.

In the same item of business

The Presiding Officer (Sir David Steel): NPA
Our final item of business this morning is the members' business debate on motion S1M-4020, in the name of Elaine Thomson, on the Great Northern Partnership ...
Motion debated,
That the Parliament commends the work done by the Great Northern Partnership (GNP) in Aberdeen; notes that the GNP plays an important role in improving quali...
Elaine Thomson (Aberdeen North) (Lab): Lab
I am pleased to introduce the debate today, which is almost our last debate.The Great Northern Partnership is one of 48 social inclusion partnerships that we...
Brian Adam (North-East Scotland) (SNP): SNP
I lodged an amendment to the motion and I am delighted that, in her speech, Elaine Thomson referred to the role of the community representatives within the G...
The Presiding Officer: NPA
Please move to a close.
Brian Adam: SNP
I am just about to do so, Presiding Officer.Rather than duplicate the administrative functions of other public and voluntary sector agencies, we could better...
Mr Tom McCabe (Hamilton South) (Lab): Lab
I welcome the motion and I congratulate Elaine Thomson on securing a debate on SIPs as the first session of our Scottish Parliament draws to a close. It is d...
Richard Lochhead (North-East Scotland) (SNP): SNP
What a joy it is to follow Tom McCabe's positive contribution. However, it is a pleasure to speak in today's debate. The first members' business debate in th...
Mr McCabe: Lab
The member seems to be making an argument for refining social inclusion partnership funding, yet the SNP's policy is to abolish such partnerships. Which is t...
Richard Lochhead: SNP
Brian Adam has outlined the SNP's position. My point is that organisations such as the GNP cannot even get access to the funding that is currently available ...
Sarah Boyack (Edinburgh Central) (Lab): Lab
I am happy to congratulate Elaine Thomson on securing the debate. I think that I replied to the first members' business debate in the Parliament so it is pro...
Brian Adam: SNP
Will the member take an intervention?
Sarah Boyack: Lab
I will when I get into my discussion.Many communities in my constituency in Edinburgh, which is one of the most prosperous cities in the United Kingdom, expe...
Brian Adam: SNP
We probably agree on the analysis of the source of the problem but we disagree about the solution. Will Sarah Boyack comment on the proportion of the funding...
Sarah Boyack: Lab
I think Brian Adam misunderstands the purpose of SIPs and the way in which they operate. I have yet to be lobbied on that issue, although voluntary organisat...
The Deputy Minister for Social Justice (Des McNulty): Lab
One of the number of points that Brian Adam got wrong in his speech was his claim that this is the last debate. I understand that there will be a further deb...
The Presiding Officer: NPA
Modesty prevents me from commenting on that.
Des McNulty: Lab
I begin by pointing out that this is the final members' business debate. I know that the Presiding Officer and Tom McCabe were very much involved in setting ...
Brian Adam: SNP
I readily acknowledge that that is the intention. In as much as success has been achieved, the SIP programme has been a success. However, will the minister d...
Des McNulty: Lab
I will deal later with that issue, which is important in considering the transition that lies ahead as SIPs move towards community planning.It is important t...
Brian Adam: SNP
Will the minister give way?
Des McNulty: Lab
I will finish my point.
The Presiding Officer: NPA
Technically, the minister is in his last minute.
Des McNulty: Lab
We are progressing links so that the experience and skills that have been gained through the way in which the SIP has worked can be shared. We want to develo...
The Presiding Officer: NPA
I close the last members' business debate of this Parliament.
Meeting suspended until 14:30.
On resuming—